Plagiarism
Udit Batra
Since we are on the topic of plagiarism these days, I would like to add
my two cents worth. I can remember at least two movies that have been
cogged from oldies. 'angoor' from 'do duni char' originally from
Shakespeare's 'Comedy of Errors' and 'Dil hai ke manta nahin' from
'Chori Chori'.
In addition to the oldies being pretty good movies, the recent versions
were also very entertaining. Thus the question arises: 'Is it OK to
cog if the new work is as entertaining as the old one?' It is also
granted that a large fraction of us would not have been entertained by
these stories if it were not for the new version of the oldies. Or can
this be considered cogging at all, since most pieces of art if left in
public domain for a long enough time (20 or so yrs) become public
property (you know what I mean).
Can any of you think of any other old Hindi movies that have been
reproduced?
Regards
Udit
--
Udit Batra
Chemical Engineering, Princeton University
"Insaaf tere saath hai ilzaam utha le,
apne pe bharosa hai to yeh dauv laga le"
Yashesh Bhatia
|> 5)Chori chori Seven days and seven nights
--------------------------------
I think the movie is It happend one night.
Anyway the others that I can think of are
Inaam Dus Hazzaar (Sanjay Dutt) North by Northwest.
Andhi Toofan (Hema Malini) Sholay.
Hatya (Govinda) Eyewitness to murder.
--
- Yashesh Bhatia y...@cs.brown.edu
ajo...@ac.dal.ca
> Hi:
> Since we are on the topic of plagiarism these days, I would like to add
> my two cents worth. I can remember at least two movies that have been
> cogged from oldies. 'angoor' from 'do duni char' originally from
> Shakespeare's 'Comedy of Errors' and 'Dil hai ke manta nahin' from
> 'Chori Chori'.
> In addition to the oldies being pretty good movies, the recent versions
> were also very entertaining. Thus the question arises: 'Is it OK to
> cog if the new work is as entertaining as the old one?' It is also
> granted that a large fraction of us would not have been entertained by
> these stories if it were not for the new version of the oldies. Or can
> this be considered cogging at all, since most pieces of art if left in
> public domain for a long enough time (20 or so yrs) become public
> property (you know what I mean).
>
> Can any of you think of any other old Hindi movies that have been
> reproduced?
>
> Regards
>
> Udit
>
film that starred Mithun C. and Dimple Kapadia. It was a 'modernized' version
of the classic, 'Aan' the first Indian movie that was in colour.
-Samir Siddiqui
rskedia
> Since we are on the topic of plagiarism these days, I would like to add
> my two cents worth. I can remember at least two movies that have been
> cogged from oldies. 'angoor' from 'do duni char' originally from
> Shakespeare's 'Comedy of Errors' and 'Dil hai ke manta nahin' from
> 'Chori Chori'.
'Chori Chori' was cogged from an english movie too.I think it was "Seven days and seven
nights" starring Clark Gable(of 'Gone with the Wind" fame)
rskedia
since on the topic of plagarism, how about a list of movies copied from other
languages
1)Karz (rishi,tina) The reincarnation of peter proud
2)ek ladka ek ladki(salmaan,nelam) Overboard(goldie hawn, kurt russell)
3) Khoj (rishi,kimi,nasir) To chase a crooked shadow
4)Aitbaar(dimple,raj babbar) Dial m for murder
5)Chori chori Seven days and seven nights
6)Manpasand My fair lady
7)Avinaash(Mithun) Bourne Identity(TV Movie)
8)khudgarz Kane and Abel
9)Kaash traces of "the champ"
10)Jurm..something(Shotgun sinha,kumar gaurav) Untouchables
11)Dayavaan Naiyakan
12)Ishwar Swathi Muthayam(?)
13)Appu raja
14)Pushpak pushpaka vimana
These are all i can think of at the moment.Please add more to the list.
Rajiv
amit agarwal
Satte Pe Satta : Seven Brides For Seven Brothers
Insaaf Ka Tarazu : Lipstick
Amit
rskedia
>
>
> |> 5)Chori chori Seven days and seven nights
> --------------------------------
> I think the movie is It happend one night.
>
> Anyway the others that I can think of are
>
> Inaam Dus Hazzaar (Sanjay Dutt) North by Northwest.
> Andhi Toofan (Hema Malini) Sholay.
> Hatya (Govinda) Eyewitness to murder.
>
>
>
> --
> - Yashesh Bhatia y...@cs.brown.edu
>
Another one: Main Azaad Hu Meet John Doe
Rajiv
SHAH RITESH
15) Khoon Bhari Maang (Rekha, Kabir Bedi) Return to Eden
This one was exactly the same, directed by Rakesh Roshan. It also had a copied
song from the ever-classic "Chariots of Fire" (Main teri hoon jaanam)
Ritesh Shah
University of Toronto
--
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Ritesh Shah
E-Mail: sh...@ecf.toronto.edu
University of Toronto
rskedia
Tarzan(kimi) Tarzan the ape man(Bo)
Jungle ki beti Daughter of the jungle
Teri baahon mein Blue lagoon
Rajiv
Satish Subramanian
* Dil Hain KI Manta Nahi - It Happened One Night
* Junoon (Rahul Roy) - ??
* ?? (Rahul Roy ) - Ghost
bye
satish
>
>Rajiv
Kumara Thirumalai
>Hi:
>Since we are on the topic of plagiarism these days, I would like to add
>my two cents worth. I can remember at least two movies that have been
>cogged from oldies. 'angoor' from 'do duni char' originally from
>Shakespeare's 'Comedy of Errors' and 'Dil hai ke manta nahin' from
>'Chori Chori'.
>
>Regards
>
>Udit
>
>
Dear Udit :
Chori Chori was based on the Capra Classic - It happenned one Night
Starring Clark Gable and Paulette Goddard. It was also remade (ok Copied)
in Tamil as Chandrodhayam *ing MGR and Jayalalitha.
There are many other old movies that have based their stories on
Eng movies, I'll post a detailed list when I find time.
>"Insaaf tere saath hai ilzaam utha le,
> apne pe bharosa hai to yeh dauv laga le"
--
FROM : BALAJI THIRUMALAI KUMARA # 1 fan of Krishnamachari Srikkanth.
Dept. of Electrical
Engineering # 1 fan of Kamalahasan
SUNY at StonyBrook
NY 11790. # 1 fan of Illayaraja
OR : I 1129 A Chapin Apts.
700 E Loop Road # 1 fan of S.Ve.Sekar.
StonyBrook, NY 11790.
" I once shot an elephant in my pajamas but I dont know how it got there "
- Groucho Marx. # 1 fan of the Marx Brothers.
rskedia
Rajeev Kumar Ranjan
I think "Hatya" is the copy of "Witness" and not "Eyewitness
......"
-rajeev
Ajay Divakaran
Parichay -------------- The sound of music?
ajay
Surender Mohan
>In article <C3r02...@news.cis.umn.edu>, subr...@myria.cs.umn.edu (Satish Subramanian) writes:
>> >13)Appu raja
>> >14)Pushpak pushpaka vimana
These two movies were just dubbed in hindi(and telugu etc.) so this can
not be classified as plagiarism. And "Phushpak Vimanam" was a anyway(s)
a silent movie, and was released with just the change in titles(i.e.
the name of the movie and some credits were put in hindi instead of
Kannada(I think it was originally in Kannada, but I am not sure).
>> * ?? (Rahul Roy ) - Ghost
This was "Pyaar Kaa Saaya".
Hope this helps,
-Surender.
PVR Narasimha Rao
In article <1993Mar11....@Princeton.EDU>, hari...@phoenix.Princeton.EDU (Ramesh Hariharan) writes:
|> How do u call Pushpak a Hindi movie... it was a silent movie with Kamalahasan
|> and Amala ..
Well, it has some Hindi words _spoken_ in it!
Though the characters don't speak in the movie, there is background
music [and human voices as well (not of characters)]. So it's not a
"silent" movie in a strict sense.
In one of the early scenes, you can hear something from radio (some
bhajan, some news etc). The bhajan and news pieces depend on whether
you are watching the Hindi version or the Telugu version or ...
Also, in the middle, when Kamalahasan goes out with Amala, they go
to a theater. There is a scene in the movie where the hero of the
movie (presumably) says something like "mother, I'll take revenge on
them for ..." blah blah blah. Those exact sentences again depend on
which language version you are watching.
Other than these 2 things, I don't think there's any difference (in
audio as well as in video) in all the language versions (excepting,
of course, the titles!). But, they decided to have the Kannada
version "Pushpaka Vimana" as the the "original". However, I don't
think this can be listed under "plagiorism".
PVR
Prince Kohli
|> hi there,
|>
|> since on the topic of plagarism, how about a list of movies copied from other
|> languages
|>
|>
|> 1)Karz (rishi,tina) The reincarnation of peter proud
|> 2)ek ladka ek ladki(salmaan,nelam) Overboard(goldie hawn, kurt russell)
|> 3) Khoj (rishi,kimi,nasir) To chase a crooked shadow
|> 4)Aitbaar(dimple,raj babbar) Dial m for murder
|> 5)Chori chori Seven days and seven nights
|> 6)Manpasand My fair lady
|> 7)Avinaash(Mithun) Bourne Identity(TV Movie)
|> 8)khudgarz Kane and Abel
|> 9)Kaash traces of "the champ"
|> 10)Jurm..something(Shotgun sinha,kumar gaurav) Untouchables
|> 11)Dayavaan Naiyakan
|> 12)Ishwar Swathi Muthayam(?)
|> 13)Appu raja
|> 14)Pushpak pushpaka vimana
15) Main Azad hoon Meet John Doe
16) Inaam das Hazaar North By Northwest
17) Chandi-sona Mackenna's gold (??)
18) Manoranjan Irma La Duce
Any more?
Cheers,
-Prince
--
pko...@cc.gatech.edu | "What's so unpleasant about getting drunk?"
Distributed Systems Group,| "Ask a glass of water." Hitchhikers'....
College of Computing, Georgia Tech.
Prince Kohli
|> |> 1)Karz (rishi,tina) The reincarnation of peter proud
|> |> 2)ek ladka ek ladki(salmaan,nelam) Overboard(goldie hawn, kurt russell)
|> |> 3) Khoj (rishi,kimi,nasir) To chase a crooked shadow
|> |> 4)Aitbaar(dimple,raj babbar) Dial m for murder
|> |> 5)Chori chori Seven days and seven nights
|> |> 6)Manpasand My fair lady
|> |> 7)Avinaash(Mithun) Bourne Identity(TV Movie)
|> |> 8)khudgarz Kane and Abel
|> |> 9)Kaash traces of "the champ"
|> |> 10)Jurm..something(Shotgun sinha,kumar gaurav) Untouchables
|> |> 11)Dayavaan Naiyakan
|> |> 12)Ishwar Swathi Muthayam(?)
|> |> 13)Appu raja
|> |> 14)Pushpak pushpaka vimana
|>
|> 15) Main Azad hoon Meet John Doe
|> 16) Inaam das Hazaar North By Northwest
|> 17) Chandi-sona Mackenna's gold (??)
|> 18) Manoranjan Irma La Duce
Following up on myself :), there are at least two hindi movies
that are copies of "Come September," starring Gina Lolobriginida
and some famous guy (Rock Hudson? Cary Grant?). One of them had
Om Prakash. They were not exactly copies but had the same idea
running thru them - the owner of the house does not live there
during the summer (winter) and hence this other guy uses it.
See if you can recall the name.
Keyush Shah
of "some one to watch over me" and "witness".
keyush shah
SAMIUDDIN MOHAMMED
>Hi:
>Since we are on the topic of plagiarism these days, I would like to add
>my two cents worth. I can remember at least two movies that have been
>cogged from oldies. 'angoor' from 'do duni char' originally from
>Shakespeare's 'Comedy of Errors' and 'Dil hai ke manta nahin' from
>'Chori Chori'.
Dil hai ke manta nahin a copy of Chori Chori ? I did'nt know that! I recently
say a Clark Gable movie on TNT: It Happened One Night. I realized that Dil hai
ke....... is a exact copy (to the last detail) of Gable's movie. It even has
the same dialogues and also the scene in which Aamir Khan teaches Dixit how to
get a ride on the highway. Well, if Dil.....=It happened...... and
Dil.....=Chori Chori, then Chori Chori must've been a copy of It Happened one
night.
>
>Can any of you think of any other old Hindi movies that have been
>reproduced?
>
I think Mehboob remade one of his old films (Aurat ??) as Mother India.
>Regards
>
>Udit
>
Sami Mohammed (A Naushad fan)...... who loved the songs in Mother India
--
_______________________________________________________________________________
|
Sami Mohammed |
Emulsion Polymers Institute | I polymerize,
Dept. of Chemical Engineering | Therefore, I AM
Lehigh University |
_______________________________|________________________________________________
rskedia
> In article <1993Mar11.2...@cc.gatech.edu>, pko...@cc.gatech.edu (Prince Kohli) writes:
>
pushpaka vimana
> |>
> |> 15) Main Azad hoon Meet John Doe
> |> 16) Inaam das Hazaar North By Northwest
> |> 17) Chandi-sona Mackenna's gold (??)
> |> 18) Manoranjan Irma La Duce
>
> Following up on myself :), there are at least two hindi movies
> that are copies of "Come September," starring Gina Lolobriginida
> and some famous guy (Rock Hudson? Cary Grant?). One of them had
> Om Prakash. They were not exactly copies but had the same idea
> running thru them - the owner of the house does not live there
> during the summer (winter) and hence this other guy uses it.
> See if you can recall the name.
>
The movie having Om prakash and Ashok Kumar was called, "Kalidasa".was
based on the same lines as come september(yes it had rock Hudson).
a couple of more copied movies along with some others posted before.
19)Jalwa Beverly Hills Cop
20)Masoom Man Woman and Child
21)Tarzan(kimi's debut) Tazan the ape man
22) Teri bahom meim(Ayesha dutt) blue lagoon
23)jungle ki beti daughter of the jungle
24) khel Dirty rotten scoundrels
two movies had most of their songs taken from two previously released
independent albums.
one was Don II had all the songs from "Hawa Hawa" by hasan jahaangir
the other was a raj kiran and divya rana starrer,having all the songs from
a Pankaj udhas album (including chandi jaisaa rang, ghoonghru toot gaye)
as for pushpak, DAYA PUBLIC. I STAND CORRECTED. IT WAS not A PLAGIARISED MOVIE.
RAJIV
Kavita R. Sheth
amit agarwal
1. Twelve Angry Men ( Henry Fonda ) : 12 jurors are locked in a room to decide
the fate of a young boy who is accused
of killing his father.
The Hindi TV movie (Name ?) had Pankaj Kapoor, KK Raina etc.
2. Cocoon : 3 Old men are rejuvenated after taking bath in some special water.
"Namkeen" had Om Prakash etc.
3. Some Like it Hot : Jack Lemmon and Tony Curtis dress up as girls to join
Marilyn Monroe in a music band.
The Hindi version had Rishi Kapoor and Paintal dressing up as
girls to go after Neetu Singh.
Surender Mohan
>Some more movies :
>
>1. Twelve Angry Men ( Henry Fonda ) : 12 jurors are locked in a room to decide
> the fate of a young boy who is accused
> of killing his father.
>
> The Hindi TV movie (Name ?) had Pankaj Kapoor, KK Raina etc.
****** " Ek Ruka Hua Faisla "
>3. Some Like it Hot : Jack Lemmon and Tony Curtis dress up as girls to join
> Marilyn Monroe in a music band.
>
> The Hindi version had Rishi Kapoor and Paintal dressing up as
> girls to go after Neetu Singh.
***** "Rafoochakkar".
Enjoy,
Surender Mohan.
Makarand Gadre
>
> since on the topic of plagarism, how about a list of movies copied from other
> languages
>
>
>1)Karz (rishi,tina) The reincarnation of peter proud
>2)ek ladka ek ladki(salmaan,nelam) Overboard(goldie hawn, kurt russell)
>3) Khoj (rishi,kimi,nasir) To chase a crooked shadow
>4)Aitbaar(dimple,raj babbar) Dial m for murder
>5)Chori chori Seven days and seven nights
>6)Manpasand My fair lady
>7)Avinaash(Mithun) Bourne Identity(TV Movie)
>8)khudgarz Kane and Abel
>9)Kaash traces of "the champ"
>10)Jurm..something(Shotgun sinha,kumar gaurav) Untouchables
>11)Dayavaan Naiyakan
>12)Ishwar Swathi Muthayam(?)
>13)Appu raja
>14)Pushpak pushpaka vimana
15) The movie Angoor (Sanjeev Kumar, Deven Verma) was a copy of the movie
"Do Dooni Char" (Anup Kumar, Asit Sen(?)) which was a remake of a
classic english play "The comedy of Errors" or something like that
Does any literature guy know more about this play "The comedy of errors (?)".
Makarand.....
Yashesh Bhatia
|> Some more movies :
|>
|> 1. Twelve Angry Men ( Henry Fonda ) : 12 jurors are locked in a room to decide
|> the fate of a young boy who is accused
|> of killing his father.
|>
|> The Hindi TV movie (Name ?) had Pankaj Kapoor, KK Raina etc.
Shital Ambuj Bhatt
Hi !!
Can somebody post the lyrics of the title song of the TV serial "Chunauti" ...The TV serial was on college life..
Thanks in Advance,
Shital Bhatt.
ajo...@ac.dal.ca
Khel - Dirty Rotten Scoundrels
-Samir Siddiqui
ajo...@ac.dal.ca
King Uncle - Annie
Pyaar ke Naam Qurban - Aan
Game - The Godfather
Atishbaaz - Scarface
Pyaar Ka Sayaa - Ghostasya - Ghost
Malamaal - Brewster's Millions
Sholay - The Magnificent Seven (Not sure about this one)
Sadak - A Few scenes from 'Cyborg'
Junoon - Cat People
Jurrat - The Untouchablesa
Khal Nayak (soon to be release) - Cape Fear
Khalnayikka (in the making) - The Hand That Rocks the Cradle
Shaan - Some scenes 'inspired' by Dr. No
Kroadh - 'Inspired' by Deewar, plus countless other 'Deewar' clones (ie:Shakti
, etc.)
Chaalbaaz - Rita aur Sita
Bond 007 - James Bond Films
Masoom - (don't know the name of the English movie)
Beta - A South Indian film I don't know the name of.
Jamai Raja - same as above
Vaansh - same as above
Inspector Dhanush, Police Officer, Dav Pech, etc. - Don
Surender Mohan
Off late we have been witnessing lot of articles which merely repeat the
information which has already been provided by some other netter. It gets
very annoying to read such articles. I understand that we get very enthu-
siastic to reply once we see some query which we can answer, but before
doing we "F" we can just see all the articles on the subject and confirm
that we are not duplicating the information. Yes you can second somebody's
point if he/she is not sure or if you are in disagreement, there is nothing
wrong in that as the network is for information exchange. But we should avoid
posting the same information without any addition/modification.
This will save our time as well as the bandwidth. Now the question will be
how can we do that. Though I am not very knowledged about this but I can tell
you one way to do that. If you are using "rn" to read the news, you can press
"=" to see the subject of all the articles. Then you can go thru all the
articles on the same subject by typing those particular article numbers eg :
3330 Re : XYZ
Suppose you are at article #3330 (on subject XYZ), and you want to follow it
up. Pick up a pen and paper and press "=", you will get an output like -
3331 Re : Plagiarism
3332 Re : Plagiarism
3333 Re : XYZ
3334 Re : Plagiarism
3335 Re : XYZ
Now if you want to read all the articles on XYZ (before following up or other-
wise), you can type "3333" instead of "n" at the end of the article. Once you
are done till the end of the list i.e. 3335, then you can retype 3330(article
that you wanted to follow up), which will take you back to 3330, and NOW you
can press "F" to provide us with your contribution which very valuable to all
of us, becuase success of the news group depends on our articles and their
quality.
I hope some other friend can provide us with some other way to avoid duplicate
information(and specially for some other programs like "tin"etc.). This
very be very helpful for some the friends who are not wizards at using these
packages.
Take it easy, and nobody should take it personally I also used to make the
same mistakes in the begining (and sometimes I do that even now, specially
when I feel lazy to go through this or when I am near the end of the newsgroup).
And yes if you post such an article by mistake you can go and and cancel your
article by using "c" command, for more info. type "h" in "rn".
Hope this helps,
- Surender Mohan.
P.S. : Was slightly disgusted at re-re-repitition of the same information on
some subjects like
Plagiarism, Amitabh Movies etc.
But I can understand this is because many of us do not know of all these
ettiquettes(sp?).
C.S. Sudarshana Bhat
>
>
>Hi !!
>
>Can somebody post the lyrics of the title song of the TV serial "Chunauti" ...The TV serial was on college life..
Someone had sent this to me a long time ago, and I can't trust my memory;
anyway, this is all I recall of it ...
man ... ik seepi hai, aasha motee hai,
har pal jeevan kaa, ek chunautee hai
sone na de aag seene kee,
kar le agan se tu pyaar,
aavaaz de kar bulaa le too,
tere liye hai bahaar,
jo (jyot?) ban jaata hai,
phool raahoN kee,
uskee deevaanee,
manzil hotee hai ...
Ciao.
Porky!
Kumara Thirumalai
Beta - Enga Chinna Rasa (TAMIL)
Vansh - Agni Nakshatram (TAMIL)
Raju Bangaya Gentleman - Mr. Deeds goes to Town
Jalwa - Beverly Hills Cop
Akeyla - Dirty Harry Movies
Mayor Saab - Indrudu Chandrudu (TELUGU) which was based on
the Richard Dreyfuss starrer Moon Over Parador.
Anjali - Inspired by ET
DayaVan - Based on Nayagan - Godfather
Kasak - Mouna Raagam (Tamil)
100 Days - Eyes of Laura Mars
Boxer - Rocky Movies
Time Machine (in the making) - Back to the Future
Some Vinod Khanna- Meenakshi- Sangita Bijlani Starrer- Fatal Atraction
The Salman Khan- Neelam Starre Based on Overboard (Goldie and Kurt Russel)
^^^^^^^^^^^ What was that HIndi film in which Neelam has Amnesia.
Aitbaar - Dial M for Murder
Manoranjjan - Irma La Douce
and many more..................
rskedia
just a followup on mohan's article on duplication of same info. it would be much easier if
the reader is using the "tin" command to read news. Here all the replies to an article are
automatically grouped together and the reader just has to press the space bar to scroll
through all the articles. So you dont have to hunt for articles with the same subject header.
Of course if someone posts on the same subject with a new subject header, then it wont be
grouped with the rest.
hope this helps.
Rajiv
Chandrashekar Ramanathan
>Here is my 2cents worth added to the list :
>
>The Salman Khan- Neelam Starre Based on Overboard (Goldie and Kurt Russel)
> ^^^^^^^^^^^ What was that HIndi film in which Neelam has Amnesia.
********* Ek ladka Ek ladki *********
>Aitbaar - Dial M for Murder
>Manoranjjan - Irma La Douce
>
>and many more..................
>--
>FROM : BALAJI THIRUMALAI KUMARA # 1 fan of Krishnamachari Srikkanth.
> Dept. of Electrical
> Engineering # 1 fan of Kamalahasan
> SUNY at StonyBrook
> NY 11790. # 1 fan of Illayaraja
>OR : I 1129 A Chapin Apts.
> 700 E Loop Road # 1 fan of S.Ve.Sekar.
> StonyBrook, NY 11790.
> " I once shot an elephant in my pajamas but I dont know how it got there "
> - Groucho Marx. # 1 fan of the Marx Brothers.
-Chandrashekar (she...@cs.msstate.edu)
KS60
of the great Dilip Kumar's Gunga Jumna. The plot of these movies
is that one brother is in the police while the other is a good
guy yet circumstances make him a thief, dacoit, smuggler, etc.
Copies of Gunga Jumna include Amitabh's Deewaar. I know the
truth hurts but we should all accept it.
Peace to all --Shahreyar
>.
Neeran M. Karnik
[explanation for `rn' deleted]
>I hope some other friend can provide us with some other way to avoid duplicate
>information(and specially for some other programs like "tin"etc.). This
>very be very helpful for some the friends who are not wizards at using these
>packages.
You don't really have to be a wizard :-) Here's what `nn' users
can do. When you see an article that you want to followup to,
press `l', which stands for "Leave", rather than the `f' for
"Followup". This will simply take you to the next article to be
read. At the end, when you've read all articles that were
selected, `nn' will ask you "Show left over articles again?".
Press `y' and it will redisplay those articles. By now, you've
seen all the followups to that article you `left', so you can
judge whether your have anything to add or not, and
accordingly, decide whether or not to post a followup.
>And yes if you post such an article by mistake you can go and and cancel your
>article by using "c" command, for more info. type "h" in "rn".
Or the `C' command in `nn' ... For more info, type `?' in `nn' :-)
>Hope this helps,
Ditto!
>- Surender Mohan.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Neeran Karnik ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Dept. of Computer Science, | Email: kar...@cs.umn.edu
University of Minnesota | kar...@staff.tc.umn.edu
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Rajeev Kumar Ranjan
Masoom: Man, Woman and Child (Based on the novel by Eric
Segal)
Sholay: Magnificent Seven (Right)
Chaalbaaz: Sita aur Gita (not Rita aur Gita)
-rajeev
Alka Malik
In article <C3r02...@news.cis.umn.edu> subr...@myria.cs.umn.edu (Satish Subramanian) writes:
[...text deleted]
* ?? (Rahul Roy ) - Ghost
>> Film: Pyar Ka Saaya
bye
satish
Also,
>> Andar Bahaar - 48 hours (I think)
an1...@anon.penet.fi
Jaag Utha Insaan Saptapadi(Telugu)
Saaheb ?? (Assamese/Bengali)
Mashaal Ashroonchi Zhali Phule (Marathi)
Sau Din Saas ke Sasurvasheen (Marathi)
Sadma Moonram Pirai(Tamil)
Subah Umbartha(Marathi)
Katha Sasa ani Kasav(Marathi)
Ek Duje ke Liye Maro Charithra(Telugu)
Chaalbaaz Seeta Aur Geeta (Hindi)
Jalwa Beverly Hill Cop (English)
Main Tulsi Tere Aagan ki Mee Tulas Tujhya Angani (Marathi)
Piya ka Ghar Mumbaicha Jawai (Marathi)
Chemeen Lehren Chemmen(Malayalam)
Bhabi ki Chudiyan Vahinichya Bangdya (Marathi)
?? Witness (English)
Kamla Kamla(Marathi)
Ardha Satya ??
?? Antha(Kannada)
?? Madhuchandra(Marathi)
Mahananda Mahananda(Marathi)
Tere Mere Beech Mein Bot Lavin Tithe Gudgulya (Marathi)
Dayavaan Naayakan(Tamil)
Sur Sangam Shankabharanam(Telugu)
Basera ??
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
To find out more about the anon service, send mail to he...@anon.penet.fi.
Due to the double-blind system, any replies to this message will be anonymized,
and an anonymous id will be allocated automatically. You have been warned.
Please report any problems, inappropriate use etc. to ad...@anon.penet.fi.
*IMPORTANT server security update*, mail to upd...@anon.penet.fi for details.
ajo...@ac.dal.ca
Dil Hi Hai - Coming to America
Bechain (a VERY VERY bad movie) - Double Impact
Dil Aashiana Hai - Steel Magnolias (not sure about this one.)
Jigar - 'Inspired' by Bloodsport
-Samir
Ramesh Hariharan
Anyone have any info on the film `careers' of any of the Chunauti
serial...I always found it to be pretty interesting serial to follow ...
they really freaked out drug addiction I recall... surely scarred my
parents... :-)
--
******************************************************************************
Ramesh Hariharan, Chem. Engg., Princeton Univ.
*****************************************************************************
Hemal Pandya
to be based on The Cat People ( Nastasia Kinski and others ) .
This one stars rahul roy and a tiger and others; horrible it is.
Hemal
--
First He created computers, but they could not make mistakes ,
so He created programmers. Hemal Pandya ( he...@kailash.cse.iitb.ernet.in )
Aniruddha B. Deglurkar
>Few more copies/remakes
***********************************************************
Mera Saaya------------------>>>>>>>> Paathlaag.(Marathi)
*******************************************************
Aniruddha.
--
To know recursion, you should first, know recursion.
: - )
Sandip Sanghvi
>>hi there,
>>
>> since on the topic of plagarism, how about a list of movies copied from other
>> languages
>>
>>
>>1)Karz (rishi,tina) The reincarnation of peter proud
>>2)ek ladka ek ladki(salmaan,nelam) Overboard(goldie hawn, kurt russell)
>>3) Khoj (rishi,kimi,nasir) To chase a crooked shadow
>>4)Aitbaar(dimple,raj babbar) Dial m for murder
>>5)Chori chori Seven days and seven nights
>>6)Manpasand My fair lady
>>7)Avinaash(Mithun) Bourne Identity(TV Movie)
>>8)khudgarz Kane and Abel
>>9)Kaash traces of "the champ"
>>10)Jurm..something(Shotgun sinha,kumar gaurav) Untouchables
>>11)Dayavaan Naiyakan
>>12)Ishwar Swathi Muthayam(?)
>>13)Appu raja
>>14)Pushpak pushpaka vimana
>>
>>
>>These are all i can think of at the moment.Please add more to the list.
>>
>
>* Junoon (Rahul Roy) - ??
>* ?? (Rahul Roy ) - Ghost
Pyar Ka Saya
Jigar (?? Devagan, Karishma Kapoor) -one of Van Damme movie
(???? )
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
C Ya,
Sandip
>
>bye
>satish
>
>>
>>Rajiv
Sandip Sanghvi
>
>In article <C3r02...@news.cis.umn.edu> subr...@myria.cs.umn.edu (Satish Subramanian) writes:
>
> [...text deleted]
>
> >> Andar Bahaar - 48 hours (I think)
I think Andar Bahaar was relased way before 48 hrs. Andar Bahaar
was released in '85 or something.
Sandip.
Preetham Gopalaswamy
|> > In article <1993Mar11.2...@mtu.edu>, rsk...@mtu.edu (rskedia)
|> > writes:
|> >> hi there,
|> >>
|> >> since on the topic of plagarism, how about a list of movies copied from
|> >> other languages
|> >
|> >
|>
I had this distinct misfortune of seeing this film. It is a remake of "Lace",
not "Steel Magnolias". I flinched so many times while seeing this film at the
bad direction, the miserable acting (it was amazing how Hema Malini managed to
get the worst out of all the actors/actresses) that after a while, I had to just
laugh at the film and not try to evaluate it at all. I normally do not go on a
tirade against a film, but this was particularly bad. They tried to Indianize
the original storyline and landed up just making it stupid. God it feels good to
get that off of my chest in public :-) :-) but the bad was bad enough to merit it
IMHO of course. Anybody else feel similarly ???
Preetham
MALLAPRAGADA, SRINIV
>Some more movies :
>
>1. Twelve Angry Men ( Henry Fonda ) : 12 jurors are locked in a room to decide
> the fate of a young boy who is accused
> of killing his father.
>
> The Hindi TV movie (Name ?) had Pankaj Kapoor, KK Raina etc.
>
***** The name of this movie is " Ek Ruka Hua Faisla ".
srini
ajo...@ac.dal.ca
released in 1984, whereas 48 Hrs was released in 1982. The plots for both
movies are quite similar.
-Samir
ajo...@ac.dal.ca
flop (as it did.) Poor direction, and poor editing. The thing that irked me the
most was the ending! When Mithun came to rescue everyone at the end, why didn't
Dimple introduce him as Divya Bharti's father? Strange.
-Samir
rth...@vax1.umkc.edu
>> Masoom - (don't know the name of the English movie)
>> Jamai Raja - same as abov
starrer
>> Vaansh - same as above
.......Renu.
devisharade
Now why this changed ending-was it to avoid any doubts reg plagiarism? And why? Aren't the makers of both films the same person/s?
shu...@gmail.com
> Hi:
> Since we are on the topic of plagiarism these days, I would like to add
> my two cents worth. I can remember at least two movies that have been
> cogged from oldies. 'angoor' from 'do duni char' originally from
> Shakespeare's 'Comedy of Errors' and 'Dil hai ke manta nahin' from
> 'Chori Chori'.
> In addition to the oldies being pretty good movies, the recent versions
> were also very entertaining. Thus the question arises: 'Is it OK to
> cog if the new work is as entertaining as the old one?' It is also
> granted that a large fraction of us would not have been entertained by
> these stories if it were not for the new version of the oldies. Or can
> this be considered cogging at all, since most pieces of art if left in
> public domain for a long enough time (20 or so yrs) become public
> property (you know what I mean).
>
> Can any of you think of any other old Hindi movies that have been
> reproduced?
>
> Regards
>
> Udit
>
>
> --
> Udit Batra
> Chemical Engineering, Princeton University
> "Insaaf tere saath hai ilzaam utha le,
> apne pe bharosa hai to yeh dauv laga le"
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
raaz - what lies beneath]
Jism Body Hit
BHarfi Missiong the rain , Noteboo
kMurder 2 Bad gAY (Korean film ) even the poster was copy
Jannat 2 For theMoney
Sangarsh The Silence of Lamb
Fir Milenge Philadelfia
Black The Miracle Worker
Bunty or Bubalee Boney and Clyde.
From a news paper.
In this context a documentary "Four step plan" is worth watching.