Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

lyrics for "Phoolon taron ka ....."

293 views
Skip to first unread message

A A Husain

unread,
Nov 30, 1992, 4:29:08 AM11/30/92
to mail...@gate.demon.co.uk

Hello Everyone,

This is my first venture into your newsgroup, so please forgive any mistakes.

Could anyone please provide me with the lyrics of the song:

"Phoolon ka taron ka Sab ka Kahna Hai......."

Thanks in advance,


Amir

P.S. I am still working on a decent signature file !!!!

Venkatasubramanian K Gopalakrishnan

unread,
Nov 30, 1992, 12:24:45 PM11/30/92
to
In article <1992Nov30....@alex.com>, am...@alex.com (A A Husain) writes:

|> Could anyone please provide me with the lyrics of the song:
|> "Phoolon ka taron ka Sab ka Kahna Hai......."
|>

|> Amir

Phoolon ka taaron ka, sabka kehna hai
Ek hazaaron meri behna hai
Saari, umar hame sang rehna hai
Phoolon..

Jab se meri aankhon se ho gayi tu door
Tab se saare jeevan ke sapne hain choor
Aankhon mein neend na, man mein chaina hai
Ek haz...

Dekho ham tum dono hain ek daali ke phool
Maina bhoola tu kaise mujhko gayi bhool
Aa mere paas a, kah jo kahna hai
Ek haz...

-KGB

--

Arati Deo

unread,
Nov 30, 1992, 2:56:42 PM11/30/92
to
Article: 3461 of rec.music.indian.misc
Newsgroups: rec.music.indian.misc
Path: rice!owlnet.rice.edu!arati
From: ar...@owlnet.rice.edu (Arati Suresh Deo)
Subject: Re: lyrics for "Phoolon taron ka ....."
Message-ID: <ByJJ0...@rice.edu>
Sender: ne...@rice.edu (News)
Organization: Rice University
References: <1992Nov30....@alex.com> <1992Nov30....@cs.wisc.edu>
Distribution: rice
Date: Mon, 30 Nov 1992 17:53:05 GMT

There is one more paragraph in this version (this is the male version)

Jeevan ke dukhon se, yoon darte nahin hain
Aise bachhke sach se guzarte nahin hain
Sukh ki hai chhaah to, dukh bhi sehena hai,
Ek hazaron ...

---------------------------------------------------

Arati


Venkatasubramanian K Gopalakrishnan

unread,
Nov 30, 1992, 4:06:36 PM11/30/92
to
In article <ByJoq...@rice.edu>, ar...@taj.rice.edu (Arati Deo) writes:
|> There is one more paragraph in this version (this is the male version)
|>
|> Jeevan ke dukhon se, yoon darte nahin hain
|> Aise bachhke sach se guzarte nahin hain
|> Sukh ki hai chhaah to, dukh bhi sehena hai,
|> Ek hazaron ...
|>
|> ---------------------------------------------------
|>
|> Arati


Thanks for the extension. I didn't know a female version existed.
Are the lyrics of the female version different and if so, can somebody
post them? Also, who is the singer in the female version and who are
the lyricist & Music Director?

-KGB

--

Kunal N Taravade

unread,
Nov 30, 1992, 4:59:29 PM11/30/92
to
gop...@cs.wisc.edu (Venkatasubramanian K Gopalakrishnan) writes:

>-KGB

>--

Male version: Kishore Kumar
Female version: Lata
Lyrics: Anand Bakshi
Music: R.D. Burman

-Kunal


Suneeta Aggarwal (415)617-2428

unread,
Nov 30, 1992, 12:58:32 PM11/30/92
to

Phoolon ka taaron ka sabka kahna hai
ek hazaron mein meri behna hai
saari umar hume sangh rahna hai

yeh na jaana duniya ne tu hai kyoon udaas
teri pyaasi aankhon mein pyaar ki hai pyaas
aa mere paas aa mera kehna hai
ek hazaaon mein...

dekho hum tum dono hai ek daali ke phool
main na bhoola tu kaise mujhko gayi bhool
aa mere paas aa kah jo kehna hai
ek hazaaon mein...

jabse meri aankhon se ho gayi tu door
tabse saare jeevan ke sapne hai choor
aankhon mein neend na man mein chaina hai
ek hazaaon mein...

jeevan ke dukhon se yun darte nahin hai
aise bachke sach se guzarte nahin hai
sukh ki hai chaah to dukh bhi sahna hai
ek hazaaon mein...


--
===============================================================
Suneeta Aggarwal

email: sun...@tss.com
uunet!tekbspa!suneeta

Teknekron Software Systems
Palo Alto, CA
415-617-2428

===============================================================

Satyen Baindur

unread,
Nov 30, 1992, 6:58:35 PM11/30/92
to

I think the song appears twice in the movie (Dum Maro Dum), and there
are different lyrics, except for the refrain, which is the same both
times. This may explain the 'male' and 'female' versions. The people
singing the song are male-female siblings, so part of the refrain,
(Ek Hazaaron mein meri behnaa hai) cannot be sung by the female.
In the story line, the sibling pair is separated early in life and
are then re-united as young adults.( I hope I am not repeating something
everyone already knows ! )

To start another thread, do people have other examples of songs which
appear twice or more times in a movie, but perhaps with different
set of lyrics or characters in the movie etc ?


Satyen

Preetham Gopalaswamy

unread,
Dec 1, 1992, 12:13:14 PM12/1/92
to
In article <1992Nov30.2...@aplcen.apl.jhu.edu>, bai...@aplcen.apl.jhu.edu (Satyen Baindur) writes:
|> In article <taravade....@shark.ecn.purdue.edu> tara...@shark.ecn.purdue.edu (Kunal N Taravade) writes:
|> >gop...@cs.wisc.edu (Venkatasubramanian K Gopalakrishnan) writes:
|> >
|> >
|> >>Thanks for the extension. I didn't know a female version existed.
|> >>Are the lyrics of the female version different and if so, can somebody
|> >>post them? Also, who is the singer in the female version and who are
|> >>the lyricist & Music Director?
|> >
|> >>-KGB
|> >
|> >>--
|> >
|> >Male version: Kishore Kumar
|> >Female version: Lata
|> >Lyrics: Anand Bakshi
|> >Music: R.D. Burman
|> >
|> >
|> >-Kunal
|>
|> I think the song appears twice in the movie (Dum Maro Dum), and there
|> are different lyrics, except for the refrain, which is the same both
|> times. This may explain the 'male' and 'female' versions. The people
|> singing the song are male-female siblings, so part of the refrain,
|> (Ek Hazaaron mein meri behnaa hai) cannot be sung by the female.
|> In the story line, the sibling pair is separated early in life and
|> are then re-united as young adults.( I hope I am not repeating something
|> everyone already knows ! )
|>
Actually your description is incorrect. The song DOES appear twice in the film
but both times it is sung by the same character (Dev Anand). It is just that
the first time around, he is a little kid playing with his sister and sings this
song to her and in true Hindi film style, they got Lata to sing for the little
MALE kid. That is why Lata's version also has the "meri behna hai" part.
This is one of those situations where Lata does a poor job of singing for a little
kid. I still think that it is a really nice tune and sung well, but totally
inappropriate for the character that it is picturized on. Another example of
inappropriate voice for a child was Asha Bhonsle singing "O saathi re" in
"Muquaddar ka Sikandar" for the young Rakhee character. When I first heard the
song on the radio, I really liked it but thought it was being sung by a grownup.
The picturized really spoilt it for me. And the sad part is that Asha was capable
of doing an incredible job of singing for kids and teenagers. My favorite
example is her rendition of "Tu rootha to mai ro doongi sanam" in the film
"Jawaani". Asha does an immature teenager without overdoing it to perfection.


|> To start another thread, do people have other examples of songs which
|> appear twice or more times in a movie, but perhaps with different
|> set of lyrics or characters in the movie etc ?
|>

Hindi films are full of 2 part songs, one being a duet and the other a solo or
a male solo and a female solo version. I can only think of one song which has
2 male versions, "Tum bin jaaon kahan" from "Pyaar ka Mausam" has a version by
Rafi and one by Kishore.
Examples of 2 part songs are
1] "Pyaar par bas to nahi hai mera lekin" from "Sone ki Chidiya"
There is a version by Asha and one is a duet by Talat and Asha
2] "Zindagi ek safar hai suhaana" from "Andaz"
Version by Kishore and one by Asha
3] "Mujhe gale se lagaalo" from "Aaj aur Kal"
Duet by Rafi-Asha and solo by Asha
4] "Jaayen to jaayen kahaan" from "Taxi Driver"
Solo by Talat and by Lata
5] "Dil jo na keh sakaa" from "Bheegi Raat"
Solo by Rafi and by Lata
6] "Subah ka intezaar kaun kare" from "Joru ka Bhai" (love this song)
Solor by Talat and by Lata
7] "Mujhko is raat ki tanhaai me aawaz na do" from "Dil bhi tera, Hum bhi tere"
Solo by Mukesh and by Lata

The list is endless.

|>
|> Satyen


Preetham Gopalaswamy

Sudeep Surender

unread,
Dec 1, 1992, 12:17:22 PM12/1/92
to
> >
> >>Thanks for the extension. I didn't know a female version existed.
> >>Are the lyrics of the female version different and if so, can somebody
> >>post them? Also, who is the singer in the female version and who are
> >>the lyricist & Music Director?
> >
> >>-KGB
> >
> >>--
> >
> >Male version: Kishore Kumar
> >Female version: Lata
> >Lyrics: Anand Bakshi
> >Music: R.D. Burman
> >
> >
> >-Kunal
>
> I think the song appears twice in the movie (Dum Maro Dum), and there
> are different lyrics, except for the refrain, which is the same both
> times. This may explain the 'male' and 'female' versions. The people
> singing the song are male-female siblings, so part of the refrain,
> (Ek Hazaaron mein meri behnaa hai) cannot be sung by the female.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
That was a tricky one. Lata is singing for a very young Dev
Anand played by Master Satyajit. This is an old practice of female
singers playbacking for minors.

> To start another thread, do people have other examples of songs which
> appear twice or more times in a movie, but perhaps with different
> set of lyrics or characters in the movie etc ?
>
> Satyen

There must be countless such examples. Here's one:
Film: Hum kisi se kum nahin
Song: Kya Huan tera vada
Singers: I dont know who playbacks for kids - Kajal kiron and
Tariq, Rafi for an older Tariq.
Music: R.D. Burman


Sudeep Surender

Satyen G Baindur

unread,
Dec 1, 1992, 12:51:54 PM12/1/92
to
In article <1992Dec1.1...@ennews.eas.asu.edu> sure...@enuxha.eas.asu.edu (Sudeep Surender) writes:
>> are different lyrics, except for the refrain, which is the same both
>> times. This may explain the 'male' and 'female' versions. The people
>> singing the song are male-female siblings, so part of the refrain,
>> (Ek Hazaaron mein meri behnaa hai) cannot be sung by the female.
> ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
> That was a tricky one. Lata is singing for a very young Dev
>Anand played by Master Satyajit. This is an old practice of female
>singers playbacking for minors.

Now that I've been flamed twice, in what I actually thought was a flame-free
group, let me apologize for the ambiguous wording. Note that I put
'female' in quotes the first time, and not the second time. I thought
this would make things clear enough, when seen in the context of other
information in that posting But alas, I was wrong, and will be more
careful in the future !

Satyen [with great respect for the gurus here]

A A Husain

unread,
Dec 1, 1992, 4:36:22 AM12/1/92
to mail...@news.demon.co.uk
Thanks for the lyrics KGB.

Amir

Ashish Bokil

unread,
Dec 1, 1992, 1:32:41 PM12/1/92
to
pree...@chisti.umiacs.umd.edu (Preetham Gopalaswamy) writes:

>In article <1992Nov30.2...@aplcen.apl.jhu.edu>, bai...@aplcen.apl.jhu.edu (Satyen Baindur) writes:
>|> In article <taravade....@shark.ecn.purdue.edu> tara...@shark.ecn.purdue.edu (Kunal N Taravade) writes:
>|> >gop...@cs.wisc.edu (Venkatasubramanian K Gopalakrishnan) writes:
>|> >
>|> >
>|> >>Thanks for the extension. I didn't know a female version existed.
>|> >>Are the lyrics of the female version different and if so, can somebody
>|> >>post them? Also, who is the singer in the female version and who are
>|> >>the lyricist & Music Director?
>|> >
>|> >>-KGB
>|> >
>|> >>--
>|> >
>|> >Male version: Kishore Kumar
>|> >Female version: Lata
>|> >Lyrics: Anand Bakshi
>|> >Music: R.D. Burman
>|> >
>|> >
>|> >-Kunal
>|>
>|> I think the song appears twice in the movie (Dum Maro Dum), and there

***** Just a small correction here .... the movie is not Dum Maro Dum
but HARE RAMA HARE KRISHNA
--------Rest of the stuff by Satyen is deleted.---------

>Actually your description is incorrect. The song DOES appear twice in the film.........Rest fo the stuff by Preetham Gopalaswami deleted

>|> To start another thread, do people have other examples of songs which
>|> appear twice or more times in a movie, but perhaps with different
>|> set of lyrics or characters in the movie etc ?
>|>
>Hindi films are full of 2 part songs, one being a duet and the other a solo or
>a male solo and a female solo version. I can only think of one song which has
>2 male versions, "Tum bin jaaon kahan" from "Pyaar ka Mausam" has a version by
>Rafi and one by Kishore.

********There is one example of the same song ( with same `mukhda' but
different `antaras' sung by 3 different male singers which comes to my mind
right now .... It is from film "Aap to aise naa the" ;lyrics by Nida Faazli;
music by Usha Khanna and singers -Mohammad Rafi ( happy version ), Anwar and
Manhar ( the best of the three ) (both sad versions) and the song is ...
you guessed it...
Tu is tarah se meri zindagi main shaamil hai.....


Do any of you guys remember any seconds to this example.. I have a feeling
that this is unique (though not sure).....


>Examples of 2 part songs are
>1] "Pyaar par bas to nahi hai mera lekin" from "Sone ki Chidiya"
> There is a version by Asha and one is a duet by Talat and Asha
>2] "Zindagi ek safar hai suhaana" from "Andaz"
> Version by Kishore and one by Asha
>3] "Mujhe gale se lagaalo" from "Aaj aur Kal"
> Duet by Rafi-Asha and solo by Asha
>4] "Jaayen to jaayen kahaan" from "Taxi Driver"
> Solo by Talat and by Lata
>5] "Dil jo na keh sakaa" from "Bheegi Raat"
> Solo by Rafi and by Lata
>6] "Subah ka intezaar kaun kare" from "Joru ka Bhai" (love this song)
> Solor by Talat and by Lata
>7] "Mujhko is raat ki tanhaai me aawaz na do" from "Dil bhi tera, Hum bhi tere"
> Solo by Mukesh and by Lata

>The list is endless.

****************************
*******few more additions to this list

8] Na tum hame jaano -i) Hemant ii) Lata

9] Yaadon ki baaraat nikli.. -i)Lata ii)Kishore and ....

10] Neelaa aasmaan so gayaa -i)Lata ii)Amitabh

11]Mere naina saawan bhado i)Lata ii)Kishore

12] Rimjhim gire saawan i)Lata ii)Kishore

13] Khilte hain gul yahan i)Lata ii)Kishore

14] Zindagi pyar kaa geet hai i)Lata ii)Kishore

15] Jidhar dekhoon teri tasweer i)Amitabh ii)Kishore

14] Mere angane main ... i)Alka Yagnik ii)Amitabh

And emphasising again what Preetham has said -"the list is endless

>|>
>|> Satyen


> Preetham Gopalaswamy

**************Ashish Bokil
**************ashi...@uxa.cso.uiuc.edu

Arati Deo

unread,
Dec 1, 1992, 4:18:51 PM12/1/92
to

|> |> To start another thread, do people have other examples of songs which
|> |> appear twice or more times in a movie, but perhaps with different
|> |> set of lyrics or characters in the movie etc ?
|> |>
|> Hindi films are full of 2 part songs, one being a duet and the other a solo or
|> a male solo and a female solo version. I can only think of one song which has
|> 2 male versions, "Tum bin jaaon kahan" from "Pyaar ka Mausam" has a version by
|> Rafi and one by Kishore.
|> Examples of 2 part songs are
|> 1] "Pyaar par bas to nahi hai mera lekin" from "Sone ki Chidiya"
|> There is a version by Asha and one is a duet by Talat and Asha
|> 2] "Zindagi ek safar hai suhaana" from "Andaz"
|> Version by Kishore and one by Asha
|> 3] "Mujhe gale se lagaalo" from "Aaj aur Kal"
|> Duet by Rafi-Asha and solo by Asha
|> 4] "Jaayen to jaayen kahaan" from "Taxi Driver"
|> Solo by Talat and by Lata
|> 5] "Dil jo na keh sakaa" from "Bheegi Raat"
|> Solo by Rafi and by Lata
|> 6] "Subah ka intezaar kaun kare" from "Joru ka Bhai" (love this song)
|> Solor by Talat and by Lata
|> 7] "Mujhko is raat ki tanhaai me aawaz na do" from "Dil bhi tera, Hum bhi tere"
|> Solo by Mukesh and by Lata
|>

Some more examples :

8] "Dil dhoondta hai phir wohi fursat ke raat din" from "Mausam"
This one is a bit different in that the tunes of the two versions
differ.

9] "Tujhse naaraz nahin zindagi, hairan hoon mein" from "Masoom"
sung by (somebody) Ghoshal(?) and by Lata

10] "Khilte hain gul yahan, khilke bikharne ko" from "Sharmilee"
sung by Kishore and by Lata (?)

Jayaraman Anand

unread,
Dec 1, 1992, 5:22:08 PM12/1/92
to

>Anand played by Master Satyajit. This is an old practice of female
>singers playbacking for minors.

Is it playbacking or playingback ? Just curious.

J Anand.

--
!!!!!!!!!%-----+++++=====/**##!!!!!!!!!!!!!/**##=====+++++-----%!!!!!!!!
When you don't know what to do, walk fast and look worried.
!!!!!!!!!%-----+++++=====/**##!!!!!!!!!!!!/**##=====+++++-----%!!!!!!!!!

Ramesh Hariharan

unread,
Dec 1, 1992, 5:10:38 PM12/1/92
to

How about :

Oh Sathee re tere bina bhi kya jeena.. sung by both Amitabh and Rakhee
at different times in the movie 'mk sikander'


--
**************************************************************************
Ramesh Hariharan , Chem Engg. Dept., Princeton Univ.
Research topic : Stabilization of Colloids using diblock copolymers.
Research baap : Bill Russel (no ! not the Celtic legend)

GUNNA, SANDEEP

unread,
Dec 1, 1992, 10:20:00 PM12/1/92
to
In article <ByLn7...@rice.edu>, ar...@pi.rice.edu (Arati Deo) writes...

>
>|> |> To start another thread, do people have other examples of songs which
>|> |> appear twice or more times in a movie.

>Some more examples :
>
>8] "Dil dhoondta hai phir wohi fursat ke raat din" from "Mausam"
> This one is a bit different in that the tunes of the two versions
> differ.
>
>9] "Tujhse naaraz nahin zindagi, hairan hoon mein" from "Masoom"
*********************************************

> sung by (somebody) Ghoshal(?) and by Lata


Can someone send the lyrics of the above song from Masoom
thanks
/Sandeep

Preetham Gopalaswamy

unread,
Dec 2, 1992, 12:29:53 PM12/2/92
to
In article <1DEC1992...@ucis.vill.edu>, 0000...@ucis.vill.edu (GUNNA, SANDEEP) writes:
|> In article <ByLn7...@rice.edu>, ar...@pi.rice.edu (Arati Deo) writes...
|> >
|> >9] "Tujhse naaraz nahin zindagi, hairan hoon mein" from "Masoom"
|> *********************************************
|> > sung by (somebody) Ghoshal(?) and by Lata
|>
|>
|> Can someone send the lyrics of the above song from Masoom
|> thanks
|> Sandeep

Film : Masoom
Music : Rahul Dev Burman
Lyrics : Gulzar
Singer : 2 versions, one by Anup Ghosal, other by Lata Mangeshkar

Tujhse naaraz nahi zindagi, hairaan hooN mai, o hairaan hooN mai
tere masoom sawaaloN se pareshaan hooN mai, o pareshaan hooN mai

Jeene keliye socha hi nahi, dard sambhaalne honge
muskuraooN to, muskuraane ke karz uthaane honge
muskuraooN kabhi to lagta hai, jaise hontoN pe karz rakhaa hai
Tujhse ....

Aaj agar bhar aayi haiN, boonde baras jaayeNgi
kal kya pataa inkeliye aaNkheN taras jaayeNgi
jaane kahaaN gum kahaaN khoya, ek aaNsoo chupaake rakhaa tha
Tujhse ....


Preetham Gopalaswamy

Allwyn T. Carvalho

unread,
Dec 3, 1992, 7:34:50 PM12/3/92
to
Pardon my ignorance, but, can Indian music be written down (the way
western music is written)?
--
Allwyn Carvalho Internet: a...@cs.arizona.edu
Department of Computer Science UUCP: uunet!arizona!atc
University of Arizona Bitnet: atc%cs.ariz...@arizona.bitnet
Tucson, Arizona 85721 AT&T: (602) 325-4051

dataentr...@gmail.com

unread,
Aug 11, 2015, 1:17:54 AM8/11/15
to
0 new messages