MD: C.Ramchandra's ways of plaigarism !!

Jay

unread,

Feb 12, 2010, 11:40:15 AM2/12/10

to

Yes, thats a sordid fact which many of his fans may disagree. And on
this forum many have just no idea of that.

Login to BCSP78 and find out for yourselves on the brief CLIP posted
today, 12th at 22 hrs IST

12/2

Deepak

unread,

Feb 12, 2010, 1:54:47 PM2/12/10

to

"Jay" <sjh...@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:8a1a0559-9b54-4442...@g28g2000prb.googlegroups.com...

Why is it wonderful improvisation when GR does it and not when CR does it?
Just wondering...

2/12

surjit singh

unread,

Feb 12, 2010, 1:56:36 PM2/12/10

to

For detailed examples of plagiarism in Indian film music (north, south
etc.) please go to this site and study it very very carefully:

http://www.itwofs.com/

Kammu

unread,

Feb 12, 2010, 5:32:22 PM2/12/10

to

Where is the clip ? Any censuring ?
k

Jay

unread,

Feb 12, 2010, 6:19:48 PM2/12/10

to

On Feb 12, 9:40 pm, Jay <sjhh...@gmail.com> wrote:
> Yes, thats a sordid fact which many of his fans may disagree. And on
> this forum many have just no idea of that.
>
> Login to BCSP78 and find out for yourselves on the brief CLIP posted
> today, 12th at 22 hrs IST
>
> 12/2

Hello Folks;

First-n-foremost, I am experiencing 'uploading problems' since 10.00
pm of 12th and even still at 4.30am of 13th IST.
Nevertheless, attempts are going on now-n-then.

13/2

Jay

unread,

Feb 12, 2010, 6:44:46 PM2/12/10

to

On Feb 12, 11:54 pm, "Deepak" <deepak.sab...@hp.com> wrote:
> "Jay" <sjhh...@gmail.com> wrote in message

I am putting forth a very mighty topic called 'improvisation of songs'
be it any...just any. Examples are right there before you through
BCSP78, FED RIGHT INTO YOUR LISTENING EARS.

But, if your 'listening MIND' ( which every individual has been
endowed with )is UNABLE / or DISAGREES for any reason whatsoever..and
keeps on pointing out references like Profjee ( he may be PH.d in his
field..accepted , but NOT in the field of the STUDY IN THE ART OF
ETHICAL CINE MUSIC COMPOSITION . In this field , I am still learning
day-n-night,round the clock , physically, mentally ( and carrying on
other activities too hither thither ) and much, much remains still
research.

What has Profjee done so far as of date in this area of research?
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

ZERO - except putting up songs collected from various sources...just
anything available from the OLD..and put them on HIS NET that is FREE
ACCESS4ALL - 24 hrs. OK Profjee? Now, it is upto the ITAB rmimers or
music lovers of cine music to access the songs OF THEIR CHOICE out
from the countless no.of songs uplded on that NET and even from
elsewhere.

Profjee has never argued in topics related to my postings... and
merely pointed out BOOKS / Refce materials or sites so far as HIS
KNOWLEDGE goes.....Nothing wrong in that, after all

I will take a short break at this point...before further continuing.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Anyone is it liberty to contradict my above views..thus, I have given
an opportunity to the rmimers to put forth their individual reactions
on the forum ona one2one basis

13/2

Jay

unread,

Feb 12, 2010, 6:57:01 PM2/12/10

to

The SITE is too poor in contrast to the topic in discussion on this
forum...secondly, those individuals who have put their views on that
site can be safely classified as 'non entities' for the simple reason
that the songs refered by them are 'later on songs' . I need
constructive debate TO PROVE that I am WRONG with
documentations..otherwise its ITAB.

Remember this always.
---------------------------------

Who is RPS ? Ex partner of your guru?.

Whatever... I have admiration for his writings..whether he knows or
does not know. Thats one thing.. He has been sending a lot of songs on
mp3 file to a very old friend of mine from Chennai...who incidently
is very much in touch with me on phone every morning seeking
clarification on the mp3 songs recd from RPS. Unfortunately, this RPS
appears to be another example of ITAB.
13/2

Deepak

unread,

Feb 12, 2010, 7:26:10 PM2/12/10

to

Are Bhai,

My question was simple. Why do you consider CR's work as plagiarism
but GR's work as improvisation? Why drag Profji in it? I am looking
for your personal insights.

Also, what exactly does the acronym ITAB stand for?

2/12

Jay

unread,

Feb 12, 2010, 8:49:58 PM2/12/10

to

On Feb 12, 11:54 pm, "Deepak" <deepak.sab...@hp.com> wrote:

> "Jay" <sjhh...@gmail.com> wrote in message

I am coming to that slowly...keep reading on
13/2

Jay

unread,

Feb 12, 2010, 8:51:02 PM2/12/10

to

Upload succesful now - 0725 hrs IST of 13/2
13/2

Jay

unread,

Feb 12, 2010, 8:53:53 PM2/12/10

to

On Feb 12, 11:54 pm, "Deepak" <deepak.sab...@hp.com> wrote:

> "Jay" <sjhh...@gmail.com> wrote in message

Listen to the CLIP first once, twice, thrice. If u still don't
understand, its not my fault.
The reason: IGNORANCE is a BLISS

13/2

Jay

unread,

Feb 12, 2010, 9:02:15 PM2/12/10

to

ITAB means ( Timely coined by me - but full credit goes to Majrooh
Sultanpuri , 100% )
It stands for : Ikdam Thikdam Agdum Bugdum ....pyar mein sab kuchh
chalta hai !!

Can u recollect which song / film ?
========================

13/2

Kalyan

unread,

Feb 13, 2010, 2:19:30 AM2/13/10

to

> 13/2- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -

One may or may not get enlightenment from Jay, but he provides a lot
of entertainment :) And nice songs too. Thanks, Jay.

Kalyan

Kammu

unread,

Feb 13, 2010, 9:07:09 AM2/13/10

to

> 13/2- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -

Yes , it is a modifeid song but unable to recollect
the original one . You may post a clip of it for
our understanding .
Thanks - k