A blunt question about MD; Hafiz (Khan) & KM
Jay
(a) Has Nurjahan ever sung any film song(s) under the
direction of Singer / MD: Khan Mastana , &
(b) Has Khan Mastana ever sung / rendered anything under
MD: Hafiz (Khan) ??
( Think well before answering. and have your own opinion only...
since this is possible only when you are a passionate listener )
I am cent percent certain, that HH will NOT be in a position to answer
since he isn't passionate enough to negotiate this 'googly/doosra' of
mine ! )
Jay
4/1
My question is very clear
Jay
Surjit Singh
First a very simple and blunt question to you. Why do you bring HH into
every discussion? usnae aapke kaun se kheta ujaa.De hain?
>
> Jay
> 4/1
>
>
>
>
> My question is very clear
--
Surjit Singh, a diehard movie fan(atic), period.
http://hindi-movies-songs.com/index.html
shri37
Congratulations for raising a query and asking "blunt" questions.This
has resulted in clearing a long unsolved question.
shri37
Dear,
What Mr Nani stated is correct.
I also have the information that MD of Zeenat , Hafeez Khan
was different, so before two years back , when i gave list
of films of H Khan Mastana in Aar Paar weekly , i didn't give the
film Zeenat and
few other films.
Harish
4-1-2008
Surjit Singh
Harish Bhai:
LB #39 published in November 1979 also has that list! But, I am sure you
knew that.
>
> Harish
> 4-1-2008
Jay
Hello Profjee:
Good: you asked me this question.
Remember this:
HH is supposed to be the editor of GK volumes 1-4 . He, as well his
close votaries OWE the innumerable afficionadoes of Indian Cine
Music / readers / fans
answer(s) for any question(s) referred to him ,or on this ideal forum.
In the process, this does not mean that he is being criticized. He is
ACCOUNTABLE for his statistical ventures. Simply owning errors /
mistakes directly / indirectly is meaningless. He is a reputed EDITOR
of a popular BULLETIN...one should not forget this
You too have got your own website. Whatever info you put up, can be
disputed as and when necessary for authentic clarifications on Indian
Cine Music. You cannot sit idle or evade answers just because you have
no proper answer(s) or fine yourself in 'a soup'.
You are free to ask me any question relating to what I have stated.
For this very reason, I had requested you to come on Yahoo Msngr and
chat with me on various issues You never responded.
=Jay
4/1
Jay
>
> - Show quoted text -
Are you H.Raghuvanshi of Surat?
What do you mean by DIFFERENT? Please: just answer in BRIEF to the 2
questions I have put up ? Do this first. Further we will decide
mutually.
I request you also to come on Yahoo Msngr for CHAT. My ID: jaythrilz
OK. Tell me have you ever seen this ZEENAT film recently on video ..If
you have not, please try to see it as when you get the opportunity and
watch out carefully for the TITLES in the begining and advise by
return.
Jay
4/1
Surjit Singh
Yes, but he does not visit RMIM. You should communicate with him
directly. Everybody else does.
>
> You too have got your own website. Whatever info you put up, can be
> disputed as and when necessary for authentic clarifications on Indian
> Cine Music. You cannot sit idle or evade answers just because you have
> no proper answer(s) or fine yourself in 'a soup'.
>
> You are free to ask me any question relating to what I have stated.
You never reply properly to any questions. Time and again you just run
away and later return to ask the same questions again. You asked the
Zeenat questions in 2002 and you have been answered many times by KP,
Ashok, me and others. But we have not have heard any reasonable opinions
from you, nor any reputable proof. In a nutshell, you are a you-know what.
> For this very reason, I had requested you to come on Yahoo Msngr and
> chat with me on various issues You never responded.
> =Jay
> 4/1
>
--
Jay
>
> - Show quoted text -
Look Prof:
You are one of the most ardent admirers / votary of HH. So be it !
Anything I state
about him pinches you. Why are you bothered ? Until and unless my
remarks are reaching HH in some way or the other. HH is much younger
to me even in age and research. Perhaps you may not be aware: I have
helped him a lot during those days when GK-II was in the liquid stage.
Do you know anything or does anyone know about this.
He used to send me LBs FREE . Why ? I never asked anything in return
To give an instance: Details of Maheshwary's KAHAN GAYE ('45), I
vividly remnmber, was supplied by me. Have you any the slightest idea
of the amount of postal communication between him and I ? You don't..
You are a third person between HH / I. Other examples are also there .
So, just don't bother when I criticize his attitude.
Regarding the accusation that I don't reply to so many puzlzes I have
put on the forum: I have not bothered to give the correct answers
because I found poor response from the RMIMers . But generally
nowadays , I am pursuing matters to the hilt.
jay
4/1
seth...@yahoo.com
>
> > - Show quoted text -
>
> Look Prof:
>
> You are one of the most ardent admirers / votary of HH. So be it !
> Anything I state
> about him pinches you. Why are you bothered ? Until and unless my
> remarks are reaching HH in some way or the other. HH is much younger
> to me even in age and research. Perhaps you may not be aware: I have
> helped him a lot during those days when GK-II was in the liquid stage.
> Do you know anything or does anyone know about this.
>
> He used to send me LBs FREE . Why ? I never asked anything in return
> To give an instance: Details of Maheshwary's KAHAN GAYE ('45), I
> vividly remnmber, was supplied by me. Have you any the slightest idea
> of the amount of postal communication between him and I ? You don't..
>
> You are a third person between HH / I. Other examples are also there .
> So, just don't bother when I criticize his attitude.
>
> Regarding the accusation that I don't reply to so many puzlzes I have
> put on the forum: I have not bothered to give the correct answers
> because I found poor response from the RMIMers . But generally
> nowadays , I am pursuing matters to the hilt.
>
> jay
>
> - Show quoted text -
Hello Jay , This is a discussion group and no one has any right
to question bluntly ?
HSH has given us something which stands as a basic structure
of HFM . We are all discussing to improve it further .
I have come across many books on HFM which are not worth reading .
Dhunon ki Yatra by Pankaj Rag has hudreds of mistakes .
Why don't you go after him and question ?
If you are capable produce another geet kosh in english .
We will admire it .
s
surhall
>
> - Show quoted text -
hello,
Every memember have own words. this is go can get HGK
in english
i see only Rafi ji book in english. waiting
HGK ???
dhall
Jay
>
> - Show quoted text -
I know well what I should do since I am 60+ and please don't expect
from me 'readymade for consumption; like HH. How much is / or,what
will be, your day2day input in this regard? Did you see the
interaction there ? This IS a must for PROGRESS in your ventures. You,
as a music lover is/are only questioning the validity of my remarks
(whatever) on your Guru without caring to investigate deeply. Your
knowledge and interests in film music may/perhaps not be as
passionate as others. Is it not possible?
Why should I write a book in the first place ? Tell me why ? Why don't
you write ? You have all the resources and friends to support. Why
don't you write?
I will not write because i am doint something 'still better' , easier
and 'at no COST for the true music lover'. Compare this with that of
those who write and tell me honestly your opinion. I play the songs
right infront of the listener.Every listener to me is a 'bhakta' at my
small place . He is revered and made comfortable so that he can taste/
feel that 'bliss of music' for which he has taken the trouble to come
to my place. Thats the PRICE he is paying. He has every opportunity to
dispute me, ask any questions / data about the song(s). Which is
better ? And in HH's case ... how is the showdown?
Anything more you require, you will receive it . Just state it.
=Jay=
5/1
Deepak
news:2002e33e-0f79-48fc...@i29g2000prf.googlegroups.com...
I admire HH. He has done more for more people than you can even begin to
imagine. Your 60+ age has nothing to do with any thing. Stick to your good
deeds for the "Bhaktas" and spare the rest of us.
Deepak
Abhay Jain
On Jan 4, 9:32 am, shri37 <shr...@hotmail.com> wrote:
> On Jan 4, 9:12 am, Surjit Singh <surjit_si...@yahoo.com> wrote:
>What do you mean by DIFFERENT? Please: just answer in BRIEF to the 2
Order here is that you cannot be in NUDE when answering :)
AJ
>Jay
>4/1