I have found a similar thing even with Yaman. Some people take pancham in
the aroha as well as awaroha while some people take it only in awaroha.
Well, the same fight again!
If one really does some research on such kind of cases I am sure, there will be
1760 of these.
Abhinav
===============================================================================
Abhinav M. Jawadekar,
Engineer R&D (at Hoody),
Tata Elxsi India Ltd.
123, Richmond Road,
Bangalore 560025.
India.
Phone(office): 91-80-8452017
===============================================================================
Here is some starting material from Subba Rao's book:
Hindustani
----------
Belongs to kafi (carnatic melakartha: karaharapriya) taht and uses: Tiwra Ri,
Komal Ga, Shuddha Ma, Tiwra Dha and Komal Ni.
There are three types of bAgEshrI according to the swaras used in the
aarohana, avarohana..
Type 1:
Aaroh: s m g m d n s
Avaroh: s n d m g r s
Type 2:
Aaroh: s r g m d n s
Avaroh: s n d m g r s
This type is also called shuddha bAgEshrI.
Type 3:
Aaroh: s r g m d n s
Avaroh: s n d m p d m g r s
Pa is used in a vakra fashion.
Some use tivra ni when halting on tara shadja. This sounds nice
and no harm is done to the rAgabhAvA.
In all types,
vAdi: Ma
samvAdi: Sa
The phrases "m d" and "m n" add beauty to the raga.
rAga Abhogi / Abhogi kanada ( came from carnatic abhogi) also resembles
bageshree. In abhogi, ni is dropped completely.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
* Subbarao also mentions that bahAr and carnatic rItigowlA are close to
some versions of bageshree.
* Avarohanam of this rAgA is not well captured in the above three versions.
I have heard phrases like "m p d g", "m d n d p g" which bring the beauty
of this rAgA out.
* Subba Rao's book does not talk about the carnatic version of bAgEshrI
The popular carnatic aarohanam and avarohanam are:
s g m d n s :: s n d m p d g m r s
* Yes, there are several versions of bAgEshrI in different gharAnAs. Type 2
for instance has exactly the same set of aarohanam and avarohanam as
carnatic shrIranjani. There is a strong bAgEshrE flavour even in this
version, which makes is sound very different from shrIranjani.
Purdue Dudes, remember that Subhasish Mukerjee's bAgEshrI?
- Subu