How many kinds of Bilawal

[CMP...@lsuvm.sncc.lsu.edu]

to claim a quarter of makarandji's kingdom...

1) Kesar bai's two cassettes (i don't know its titles, there are about
ten short pieces in each) have two kinds, i think they are shukla and
alhaiya bilawal. Mogubai kurdikar's cassette also has one, but i don't recall
the name.

2) one of Mallikarjun Mansoor's cassette has complete rendition of
a khyaal in yamani bilawal. the other side is deshkar if i remember correctly.

-Ajit Pendse
cmp...@lsuvm.bitnet

[Makarand A. Kulkarni]

In article <940907.14164...@LSUVM.SNCC.LSU.EDU> CMP...@LSUVM.SNCC.LSU.EDU writes:
>to claim a quarter of makarandji's kingdom...
>

Ji nahin. :)

List of bilawal recordings and nettors who have them. This is final for
now, lest other nettors get bored of this thread. I will continue
to store bilawal related articles and post another summary later if
there is need for it.

Kinds of Bilawal (Siddharta Chatterjee,qouting from
Bimalakanto Roychoudhuri's "Bharatiya Sangeetkosh")

1. Alahiya
2. Ahiri
3. Ahiribhairav (this could be a typo in the book, IMHO)
4. Yamani
5. Ouduv
6. Ouduv Devgiri
7. Kukubh
8. Kshem
9. Jayajay
10. Devgiri
11. Nat
12. Bangal
13. Bibhas
14. Maru
15. Mudra
16. Mudrik
17. Lacchasakh
18. Shukla
19. Shuddha
20. Sarfarda
21. Hansa
22. Hem

*******************************************
List of nettors who have bilawal recordings
*******************************************

pankaj joshi
paj...@enuxsa.eas.asu.edu
sukhiya(?) bilawal ashwini bhide
kukubh bilawal mallikarjun mansur

makarand kulkarni
maka...@puma.larc.nasa.gov (804)-838-1659
alhaiya bilawal padma talwalkar
kukubh bilawal mallikarjun, kesarbai
shukla bilalwal mallikarjun, mogubai
bilahari t.n. krishnan (live)

atul sudhalkar
at...@cs.cmu.edu (Atul Sudhalkar)
alhaiya(?) bilawal kishori amonkar (live)
bilawal jasraj

subu ramasubramanian
rama...@ecn.purdue.edu
alhaiya bilawal ravi shankar

siddharta chatterjee
s...@cs.unc.edu (Siddhartha Chatterjee)
shudha bilawal abdul karim khan
sarfarda abdul karim khan
nat bilawal radhika mohan moitra
shukla bilawal mallikarjun mansur
bilawal prakar bdg (talim tape)

sarbpreet singh
sin...@enterprise.uucp
yemeni bilawal malikarjun mansoor

ajit pendse
cmp...@lsuvm.bitnet
yemeni bilawal mallikarjun mansoor

***************** end of list *****************

Regards
Makarand
maka...@puma.larc.nasa.gov

[Shantha Benegal]

Another Bilawal I have heard, Vilayat Khan, sitar, and his family playing
Hamir Bilawal.

[Arthur Levine]

Watch out for Kesarbai's "Kukubh bilaval". Most recently released on
the "Atrauli-Jaipur" volume of "Chairman's Choice" (EMI CD CMC 1
82505-506). Careful analysis shows it to be rag "Savani Nat". The
composition is "Devi durge". Of course, it is true to form that the
great Mr. RP Goenka (a.k.a. "The Chairman") and cohorts didn't bother
to address the error, despite the fact that they had -- what? --
thirty years to sort it out. Caveat emptor! (and a pox take the
vendor!).

Art

am i right about this? i wonder ...

[Makarand A. Kulkarni]

Art, are you sure that this is a mistake? I have a recording of
Kesarbai's Devi Durge on the rare morning ragas series of
four cassettes (on HMV) and also a recording of Kukubh Bilawal,
Sughrai and Nand of Mallikarjun Mansur. These two recordings
are very similar.

I cannot argue as an analyst, but I doubt
that both these recordings have the same mistake.

Regards
Makarand