Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Is Bob too comfortable?

2 views
Skip to first unread message

geminij...@yahoo.com

unread,
Sep 12, 2007, 7:42:46 PM9/12/07
to
I've been all over the map lately listen to the many lives of Dylan
and it got me to thinking... He usually changes hats often, mostly I
think due to staying on the move throughout life. I know he's getting
long in the tooth but does anyone here think he'll do another 'change'
of style? He's been in roughly the same zone musically since the late
90's. And the man himself has said that an artist shouldn't let
himself get too comfortable, or something like that. IOW, 'he not
busy being born...' Given his vocal range and playing abilities these
days I wonder if he'd brave a solo show or two. And I say all this
with all due respect and admiration of his accomplishments in the last
decade.
-GJ

Martin

unread,
Sep 12, 2007, 7:45:27 PM9/12/07
to
On Sep 13, 12:42 am, geminijackso...@yahoo.com wrote:

> I wonder if he'd brave a solo show or two

Yes...yes...YES

badlands420

unread,
Sep 12, 2007, 8:33:28 PM9/12/07
to

> He's been in roughly the same zone musically since the late
> 90's.

I'd rather not see him leave the zone he's in. It's a zone that's produced
some of the most consistently excellent music of his career.


crazytimes

unread,
Sep 12, 2007, 9:12:06 PM9/12/07
to


Be careful for what zone you wish for...

kfw...@yahoo.com

unread,
Sep 12, 2007, 9:36:48 PM9/12/07
to
On Sep 12, 8:33 pm, "badlands420" <b...@hole.com> wrote:

I wish his voice was still good enough for a solo show, but the
thought of one is painful.

dyl...@gmail.com

unread,
Sep 12, 2007, 10:57:05 PM9/12/07
to

A solo show would be nice I suppose but the bass player is awfully
cute and I'd miss that :p

crazytimes

unread,
Sep 12, 2007, 11:08:16 PM9/12/07
to


I don't think the bass player is cute, but he seems to be Bob's
security bassist, so bassed on that, I'd settle for a Bob with Bass
tour...

Kurt Straub

unread,
Sep 12, 2007, 11:25:30 PM9/12/07
to
I find myself in agreement with this sentiment, surprising myself even. In
a long career of sutained excellence, going on 45 years now, the current
period of TOOM, Love & Theft, and Modern Times really is Dylan at his
finest, isn't it? Amazing. Absolutely amazing.

---- Kurt Straub

"badlands420" <bu...@hole.com> wrote in message
news:xz%Fi.133458$TW6....@newsfe06.phx...

Martin

unread,
Sep 13, 2007, 4:44:54 AM9/13/07
to
On Sep 13, 12:42 am, geminijackso...@yahoo.com wrote:

> I know he's getting
> long in the tooth but does anyone here think he'll do another 'change'
> of style?

Looks like you might be on the right track if the rumour about a new
album next year is correct. Although I believe he's changed almost
every year, the last few have certainly been more subtle than most. I
think the NET has helped to slow down changes too. There's a uniform
pattern to the NET that on any previous year would have been
interrupted by anything from a big band with horns or an entire show
of new songs to a tour with an existing band like the Heartbreakers,
or half the show performed solo. There have been some stunning
moments on the NET, and in many ways it's more consistent than what
came before, but I do think it's made for a less diverse 20 years

geminij...@yahoo.com

unread,
Sep 13, 2007, 6:32:08 AM9/13/07
to
On Sep 13, 4:44 am, Martin <martingayf...@yahoo.co.uk> wrote:

> Looks like you might be on the right track if the rumour about a new
> album next year is correct.

I just read that. It looks like it may very well be a different sound
alright. I knew Bob wouldn't let us down.
-GJ

Martin

unread,
Sep 13, 2007, 7:17:29 AM9/13/07
to
On Sep 13, 11:32 am, geminijackso...@yahoo.com wrote:

> I just read that. It looks like it may very well be a different sound
> alright. I knew Bob wouldn't let us down

My fingers are very tightly crossed

Mr Jinx

unread,
Sep 13, 2007, 3:49:37 PM9/13/07
to


I think Dylan is far from comfortable. It must be hell at times
rattling around the globe in a tour bus at his age and facing audience
after audience under the hot lights no matter how you feel personally.

I also don't agree with the idea that Dylan has been in the 'same
zone' musically since the late 90s. The change from Time Out Of Mind
to "Love And Theft", for example, was one of the most unexpected of
his career. Who could have imagened he would go for riverboat
Mississippi Jazz laced with Swing after the sepulcral doom-laden kiss-
off TOOM seemed to be???

For those who watch the NET tours closely there is amazing variety to
be found from show to show and especially from tour to tour. The
harmonies of Larry and Charlie give way to the mad stutter of Freddie
and then on to the precision and subtlety of today's boys.

Now if you are asking me if I would like the chance to see Dylan play
solo or in another setting than as band leader I would, of course, say
yes. But only if he wanted to do that. There is no particular virtue
in him playing solo. He is still fully present when fronting a band.
We are still getting the full Dylan hit either way. It's just that one
of 'em has backing.

And you can bet your life after 20 solo shows people would be moaning
about the 'good old days' with the band!

As to this new album I have a hunch it may be the re-recorded songs he
has talked about wanting to do. Ruben would be the man for that job.
Maybe we'll get lucky and have a late blossoming of studio albums a la
Cash. Or maybe we'll get equally lucky and Dylan will continue to
tour and twist his songbook into new shapes. It's a win / win either
way.

Mr Jinx

Martin

unread,
Sep 13, 2007, 4:27:39 PM9/13/07
to
On Sep 13, 8:49 pm, Mr Jinx <vernon__bris...@hotmail.com> wrote:

> Now if you are asking me if I would like the chance to see Dylan play
> solo or in another setting than as band leader I would, of course, say
> yes. But only if he wanted to do that

The alternative being...?

kfw...@yahoo.com

unread,
Sep 13, 2007, 9:24:11 PM9/13/07
to
On Sep 13, 3:49 pm, Mr Jinx <vernon__bris...@hotmail.com> wrote:
> I think Dylan is far from comfortable. It must be hell at times
> rattling around the globe in a tour bus at his age and facing audience
> after audience under the hot lights no matter how you feel personally.

I agree, but the question is whether or not he's musically
comfortable, and the stagnant setlists and reigned in band/predicable
playing suggest that he's coasting.

> I also don't agree with the idea that Dylan has been in the 'same
> zone' musically since the late 90s. The change from Time Out Of Mind
> to "Love And Theft", for example, was one of the most unexpected of
> his career. Who could have imagened he would go for riverboat
> Mississippi Jazz laced with Swing after the sepulcral doom-laden kiss-
> off TOOM seemed to be???

The first was rooted in the blues, the second had two jazz-inflected
numbers. Only two out of twelve. Nice but not a major shift.

> For those who watch the NET tours closely there is amazing variety to
> be found from show to show and especially from tour to tour. The
> harmonies of Larry and Charlie give way to the mad stutter of Freddie
> and then on to the precision and subtlety of today's boys.

Things changed from show to show while Charlie was still around. Not
much anymore from the mp3s I've heard. And what band performances
since Charlie left can match what we heard before?

> There is no particular virtue
> in him playing solo. H

Sure there is, the same virtue of dynamics he himself recognized, and
the many other artists recognize, when they do both in the same show.

> And you can bet your life after 20 solo shows people would be moaning
> about the 'good old days' with the band!

Because he lacks the vocal range to make a whole acoustic show
interesting.

Message has been deleted

Martin

unread,
Sep 14, 2007, 5:22:08 AM9/14/07
to
> On Sep 13, 3:49 pm, Mr Jinx <vernon__bris...@hotmail.com> wrote:

> I think Dylan is far from comfortable. It must be hell at times
> rattling around the globe in a tour bus at his age and facing
audience
> after audience under the hot lights no matter how you feel
personally

Yes, I've heard the quality of tour bus seats has really deteriorated
in recent years, not to mention the availability of the instant
coffee, packets of Quavers, cans of Coke etc. And it's not easy to
get those skinny black jeans to sit right once you hit the big 6-0.
Plus, I've heard he's got a dodgy back at the moment. No, Dylan
really isn't comfortable at all is he? Oh hang on, you meant -

Mr Jinx

unread,
Sep 14, 2007, 5:47:53 AM9/14/07
to
On 14 Sep, 02:24, kfw1...@yahoo.com wrote:
> On Sep 13, 3:49 pm, Mr Jinx <vernon__bris...@hotmail.com> wrote:
>
> > I think Dylan is far from comfortable. It must be hell at times
> > rattling around the globe in a tour bus at his age and facing audience
> > after audience under the hot lights no matter how you feel personally.
>
> I agree, but the question is whether or not he's musically
> comfortable, and the stagnant setlists and reigned in band/predicable
> playing suggest that he's coasting.
>

The set lists were 'stagnant' in 1966 did that mean he was coasting?

> > I also don't agree with the idea that Dylan has been in the 'same
> > zone' musically since the late 90s. The change from Time Out Of Mind
> > to "Love And Theft", for example, was one of the most unexpected of
> > his career. Who could have imagened he would go for riverboat
> > Mississippi Jazz laced with Swing after the sepulcral doom-laden kiss-
> > off TOOM seemed to be???
>
> The first was rooted in the blues, the second had two jazz-inflected
> numbers. Only two out of twelve. Nice but not a major shift.
>

Could you have predicted a song like Floater or Moonlight from Bob
before 2001? I couldn't.

> > For those who watch the NET tours closely there is amazing variety to
> > be found from show to show and especially from tour to tour. The
> > harmonies of Larry and Charlie give way to the mad stutter of Freddie
> > and then on to the precision and subtlety of today's boys.
>
> Things changed from show to show while Charlie was still around. Not
> much anymore from the mp3s I've heard. And what band performances
> since Charlie left can match what we heard before?
>
> > There is no particular virtue
> > in him playing solo. H
>
> Sure there is, the same virtue of dynamics he himself recognized, and
> the many other artists recognize, when they do both in the same show.
>
> > And you can bet your life after 20 solo shows people would be moaning
> > about the 'good old days' with the band!
>
> Because he lacks the vocal range to make a whole acoustic show
> interesting.

Eh?? So it's all about range is it? Hmm.


Mr Jinx

kfw...@yahoo.com

unread,
Sep 14, 2007, 10:29:55 AM9/14/07
to
On Sep 14, 5:47 am, Mr Jinx <vernon__bris...@hotmail.com> wrote:
> > I agree, but the question is whether or not he's musically
> > comfortable, and the stagnant setlists and reigned in band/predicable
> > playing suggest that he's coasting.
>
> The set lists were 'stagnant' in 1966 did that mean he was coasting?

He had a much smaller catalogue to draw from in 1966, and the Hawks
were something new to most of his audience.

> > > I also don't agree with the idea that Dylan has been in the 'same
> > > zone' musically since the late 90s. The change from Time Out Of Mind
> > > to "Love And Theft", for example, was one of the most unexpected of
> > > his career. Who could have imagened he would go for riverboat
> > > Mississippi Jazz laced with Swing after the sepulcral doom-laden kiss-
> > > off TOOM seemed to be???
>
> > The first was rooted in the blues, the second had two jazz-inflected
> > numbers. Only two out of twelve. Nice but not a major shift.
>
> Could you have predicted a song like Floater or Moonlight from Bob
> before 2001? I couldn't.

No, I could have, I'm just saying it's not a big direction change. But
I have high hopes for the upcoming record.

> > Because he lacks the vocal range to make a whole acoustic show
> > interesting.
>
> Eh?? So it's all about range is it? Hmm.

When it's just a singer and one other instrument, the singer darn well
ought to be able to sing.

geminij...@yahoo.com

unread,
Sep 14, 2007, 12:35:23 PM9/14/07
to

> > Eh?? So it's all about range is it? Hmm.
>
> When it's just a singer and one other instrument, the singer darn well
> ought to be able to sing.

Lol! Ok, maybe a one-off. Perhaps a solo 'tour' isn't such a good
idea.

crazytimes

unread,
Sep 14, 2007, 12:43:58 PM9/14/07
to


A solo tour would be just the kick in the ass Dylan wants... needs...
Even a show with just tony on stand-up bass would be nice... I think
Dylan's mid-range pipes can still muster it... That would mean that
certain people on Dylan's payroll would be out of work, so short of
him closing that shop, I don't see the solo tour happening... Too
many mouths are being fed by the band concept... including extra
instrument and sound techs... They wouldn't like to see Bob play
solo!...

But just when you think it's all about plaing it safe, with Dylan, he
changes up and does something drastic, so here's hoping that's what's
in store in the next couple years...

beppe

unread,
Sep 16, 2007, 12:25:21 PM9/16/07
to

"Mr Jinx" <vernon_...@hotmail.com> ha scritto nel messaggio
news:1189712977.3...@k79g2000hse.googlegroups.com...

> I also don't agree with the idea that Dylan has been in the 'same
> zone' musically since the late 90s. The change from Time Out Of Mind
> to "Love And Theft", for example, was one of the most unexpected of
> his career. Who could have imagened he would go for riverboat
> Mississippi Jazz laced with Swing after the sepulcral doom-laden kiss-
> off TOOM seemed to be???


This is true.
TooM is in the same zone of Oh Mercy while LAT is the very start of this
brand new zone he is in here now.


--
Beppe

www.giuseppegazerro.com
www.myspace.com/gazerro
http://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=gazerro

beppe

unread,
Sep 16, 2007, 12:25:19 PM9/16/07
to

<geminij...@yahoo.com> ha scritto nel messaggio
news:1189640566.8...@y42g2000hsy.googlegroups.com...


I agree with each and every word.

And he himself admits something similar, on the other hand, when he talks
about *It's Alright Ma*'s heights not having been reached any more
afterwards.
(and this does NOT coincide with my opinion, my friends, mind you)

oh mercy

unread,
Sep 16, 2007, 1:24:05 PM9/16/07
to
Geminijackso

I've been waiting-- for the next Dylan to emerge.
kind of expecting it, but you know Bob and expectations.
I guess we have to wait till he gets restless and feel he has
transformed and used this "dylan" up.
I think given that he is doing radio and writing the next volume of
Chronicles (hopefully) he has less chance of restlessness... or rather
it takes him longer. Getting older definitely brings one to a settling
in to self, more acceptance of who one is and where.

Would he do a Solo Show? I think he is totally capable of it. Actually
I think his voice would be great solo because he could play and sing
more quietly and enunciate more clearly. I am struck how in the
"judas" tour back in the early days how clearly he enunciated. Listen
or watch him sing Johanna or some of the other performances from then.
I don't think it is just his fabulously ravaged voice or his age that
contributes to the "I can't understand him" complaints. Its the energy
and

oh what do I know, I'm just theoriasing.

Would he do it?
I doubt it, at least not in the foreseeable future.
Could he do it?
Absolutely and it would be an experience like no other and one I would
give up groceries and eating for...(being on a very low fixed
income... which sucks since I haven't been able to see him in years
dammit. Frankly I think there should be a benevolent society that
takes donations and sends the faithful but poor fans to see the man!
LOL))

oh mercy

unread,
Sep 16, 2007, 1:25:46 PM9/16/07
to
Crazytime.
That would be amazing, Bob and Tony.
Whoa.

oh mercy

unread,
Sep 16, 2007, 1:27:29 PM9/16/07
to
Geminijack...
where did you read that?
I'll have to google it and see if I can find it.
YAY.

He certainly is prolific right now.

Martin

unread,
Sep 17, 2007, 6:07:48 AM9/17/07
to
On Sep 16, 6:24 pm, oh mercy <magdalenastud...@gmail.com> wrote:

> I've been waiting-- for the next Dylan to emerge.
> kind of expecting it, but you know Bob and expectations.
> I guess we have to wait till he gets restless and feel he has
> transformed and used this "dylan" up.
> I think given that he is doing radio and writing the next volume of
> Chronicles (hopefully) he has less chance of restlessness...

I think you make some good points here, and I agree that his new
projects could keep him from changing too much. Those projects have
got more consistently rave reviews - in fact I don't think I've seen a
bad one - than his concerts. And I do think that, although he's
changed a lot during the NET, the tours themselves have a uniformity
that is kind of at odds with every pre 1988 tour. There are
differences, obviously, but one tour usually morphs into the next with
a very comfortable similarity. If the 1995 tour had come straight
after the 1988 one, it would be more of an abrupt change

> Would he do a Solo Show? I think he is totally capable of it

Me too

0 new messages