Interesting Right Hand
Steverino
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4IrEnMaEfvw
This guy does everything wrong, yet it ends up so right.
edspyhill01
> I haven't seen this technique exactly before.http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4IrEnMaEfvw
> This guy does everything wrong, yet it ends up so right.
He's not a classical guitarist playing the CG repertoire. He's a guy
playing Brazilian music a classical guitar.
Charlie
classical style. You're sounding like Kent now, sheeeesh! :-)
In any event, it's some very nice clean playing.
Charlie
edspyhill01
It was too early and I was not clear with that post. I like his
technique and wasn't criticizing him. I don't see his RH being to far
from the ideal CG RH. There are times I think Classical Guitar
critics and audiences value body "form" at the same level of musical
performance.
himme...@verizon.net
That is correct Ed, hence the Lutemann Fallacy.
S
edspyhill01
wrote:
I'm lost. the "Luteman Fallacy" is a very fluid ambiguous term that
can mean almost anything.
Learnwell
> I haven't seen this technique exactly before.http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4IrEnMaEfvw
> This guy does everything wrong, yet it ends up so right.
Actually, his technique is pretty good sans the bent right wrist. The
left hand is doing a good job, and other than the wrist so is the
right.
If you are refering to him fretting notes with the right hand that is
just an extended technique. Nothing wrong with that on classical
guitar or elsewhere. It is analogous to playing right hand harmonics;
it is not the default position, but we all do it.
Steverino
Yes. I was referring to a couple of things about the right hand. I
thought that the most interesting part was freting with his right hand
index while strumming with m. I have seen finger tapping before, but
never this particular creative variation.
Although his hand looks incredibly tense to me, I overstated when I
said 'everything wrong'. But the music speaks for itself. I find it
inspiring.
Learnwell
> never this particular creative variation.
Me neither! Thanks for sharing, it gives me ideas. . .
David Raleigh Arnold
This is a concept which I find less and less sympathetic. IMO the
thing to do is to practice all useful strokes and not to be
concerned with a default hand position. The concept of "default", or
more often "correct", hand position causes nothing but self made problems
when it is made law and then constantly and necessarily violated.
The simple and simplified guidelines necessary to teach beginners should
be left behind as soon as possible, abandoned like the improvised raft
used to cross a river. You don't carry a raft around forever just
because it carried you.
I would be surprised if anyone here agrees with me, but that
has not been and will never be my problem. Regards, daveA
--
For beginners: very easy guitar music, solos, duets, exercises. Early
intermediate guitar solos. One best scale set for all guitarists.
http://www.openguitar.com/scalescomparison.html ::: plus new and
better chord and arpeggio exercises. http://www.openguitar.com