The new inmate is puzzled by all this and asks his friend what was going on.
"Well", said the friend, "since we are cut off from society, we rarely
get to hear any new jokes. Since we've all heard them so many times, we
have them all numbered. So, if someone wants to tell a joke they just
shout out the number rather than repeat the entire joke since we've all
heard them before".
The new inmate ponders this for a moment and decides it is probably a
good system.
Anyway, all through lunch this continues, people shouting out numbers
followed by fits of laughter. Finally, the new inmate decides that this
may be a good way to make friends with everyone at the prison so he
stands up and yells "NUMBER 12". To his suprise and shock, no one
laughs. In fact, the place remains dead quiet. Slowly he sits back down
wondering about what has just happened. He turns to his friend and asks
why no one laughed.
The friend replies: "Well, I guess some people can tell a joke and some
can't".
SW
And then another inmate gets up and says, "NUMBER 86." All are quiet
except one inmate who is laughing quite earnestly. "Why are you
laughing?" And he replies, "I never heard that one before"
Tom
LLoyd
*peace in this world please*
Answer 1: Nothing happens. Kid says "What did I do wrong?" And his
new friend says "You didn't tell it right."
Answer 2: Everyone goes hysterical, falling off their benches. Kid
says "What happened?" And, through laughter, new friend says "We never
heard that one before!"
And, of course, assorted variations. But if I recall, there's a third
answer to this joke. I used to use it as a good example of how a joke
can manifest itself in various forms and NOT be essentially identical
every time.
Does anyone happen to know the third ending I'm talking about? It's
something along these same lines, I just can't quite put my hand on it.
Thanks.
ObSomething: Did Shakespeare write the first knock knock joke in The
Taming of the Shrew? (Sorry, I'm not going to transcribe the scene)
Duane
Answer 3: At first, silence. Then, the whole place bursts out in
laughter. New guy, "What's going on?" Old guy, "We like the way you
tell it better."
My girlfriend insists that this is the other ending I'm searching for,
but it just doesnt seem right. Alas.
>
>Duane
>
There is just silence, the new guy says "What's wrong?" the old guy says,
Some people just can't tell a joke well.
Also ...
Big silence, and the old man says "Gee you're disgusting, telling this kind
of tasteless jokes while we're eating !"
Bart
This is my favorite joke. I told it to my girlfriend Maribel and warned
her on the way to Thanksgiving dinner to watch for it, my dad would use
it. Sure enough, he started saying 6, 24, 19, 54 at the dinner table.
Of course, my family knew what was going on, but Maribel had forgotton.
When she didn't start laughing, it was all I could do
not to give her a number to tell. My family was laughing so hard
because Maribel wasn't laughing, so my Dad kept rattling off reasons
Maribel wasn't laughing. He had four or five reasons so I think we
should keep looking.
Why wasn't Maribel laughing:
Dad didn't tell joke right
Maribel heard it before
Maribel didn't get punchline
...