--------------------------------------------------------------
Learn about rec.guns at http://www.recguns.net
Last call to win a Fulton Armory .308 Titan Carbine and defend
liberty at the same time! Details at http://myguns.net
--------------------------------------------------------------
#Many years ago ( mid 1980's) I received from Colt a bunch of original
#handgun and AR15, M16 rifle owner manuals....all that were actually
#available! I've started scanning them in PDF (Adobe) format.
#I'm wondering if anyone out there would be interested in these on CD
#(for a fee of $10 each + shipping to cover my costs) ?
Colt will probably take issue with your selling what they consider to
be their copyrighted information. Further, most gun manufactures
either give away or sell their manuals for less than that.
Or check out this site:
http://stevespages.com/page7b.htm
He's got you beat. Don't quit your day job.
#Thanks...looked at a few pf his Colt scan...his covers are B&W...mine
#are in color and the OCR on mine is far better! :o)
Color covers are somehow worth 10 bucks? Who cares about OCR? unless
it's 100% perfect (it ain't) it's less than worthless.
Works created on or after January 1, 1978.
The following rules apply to published and unpublished works:
For one author, the work is copyright-protected for the life of the
author plus 70 years.
For joint authors, the work is protected for the life of the surviving
author plus 70 years.
For works made for hire, the work is protected for 95 years from the
first publication or 120 years from the date of its creation,
whichever is less.
For anonymous and pseudonymous works, the work is protected for 95
years from the first publication or 120 years from the date of its
creation, whichever is less. (However, if the author's name is
disclosed to the U.S. Copyright Office, the work is protected for the
life of the author plus 70 years.)
In the case of the Colt owners manuals they DO NOT say they are
copyrighted nor do they say it is prohibited to copy/distribute them.
They bear only the Colt logo trademark which is copyrighted!!!!!
When I received them back in the 1980s or so the Colt rep made a point
of letting me know distribution by copies (Xerox back then) was
authorized.
It is my belief Colt would like to have their safety/owners manuals in
the hands of as many people as possible and since these (so dated) are
out of print I'm simply offering them to anyone interested. The fee
simply recovers my cost of time and labor, cost of a new CD and
plastic jacket/enclosure, as well as wear and tear on the scanner and
cost of electricty!
It takes over an hour to properly scan and catalog just one 40-page
owners manual for Adobe PDF! (and thats conservative if you take into
account any mistakes made and it has to be scanned again!)
Please contact me with relevant questions but do refrain from comments
like the fee is excessive for all 18 manuals or OCR quality is
meaningless like I received from one member.
If you feel the fee is too high, I promise I won't twist your arm to
purchase one!
Thanks...
Henry J
Copyrights: Good for 21 years. These manuals are older than that!
#Copyrights: Good for 21 years. These manuals are older than that!
What's your source for that information? According to the US
copyright office, for materials published before 1978, the first term
is good for 28 years, then it may be renewed for an additional 28
years.
#Update on copyrights for publications:
#
#Works created on or after January 1, 1978.
#The following rules apply to published and unpublished works:
#For works made for hire, the work is protected for 95 years from the
#first publication or 120 years from the date of its creation,
#whichever is less.
So the copyrights on the manuals you want to sell still apply.
#In the case of the Colt owners manuals they DO NOT say they are
#copyrighted nor do they say it is prohibited to copy/distribute them.
That's immaterial. Work is under copyright protection the moment it
is created and fixed in a tangible form that it is perceptible either
directly or with the aid of a machine or device.
Seems to me that if it's on paper, it's "fixed in a tangible form that
it is perceptible either directly or with the aid of a machine or
device."
#They bear only the Colt logo trademark which is copyrighted!!!!!
No, logos are protected under trademark laws.
#When I received them back in the 1980s or so the Colt rep made a point
#of letting me know distribution by copies (Xerox back then) was
#authorized.
Hey, that statement will be sure to protect you in the event that Colt
takes issue with your selling their copyrighted works! :)
#It is my belief Colt would like to have their safety/owners manuals in
#the hands of as many people as possible and since these (so dated) are
#out of print I'm simply offering them to anyone interested. The fee
#simply recovers my cost of time and labor, cost of a new CD and
#plastic jacket/enclosure, as well as wear and tear on the scanner and
#cost of electricty!
I'm still thinking Colt will take an issue with your selling their
copyrighted works for profit.
#Please contact me with relevant questions but do refrain from comments
#like the fee is excessive for all 18 manuals or OCR quality is
#meaningless like I received from one member.
My mistake, I just assumed that since you posted to a discussion
board, you wanted to discuss the issue.
Just write to Colt, describe your project, and ask them if they have any
legal objections. That should give you a secure feeling that you aren't
risking your life savings on a potential lawsuit and will settle the issue
with any readers or purchasers that they are buying legal copies.
The direct approach. Easy. They actually may appreciate the effort as it
would take some of the load off of their own facilities to provide copies of
these manuals. They may not guard the copyrights on technical manuals as
much as a novel writer might guard his fiction since it is just a manual of
engineering facts and does not impinge on any single writer's imagination
and creativity. Heck, they might even send you a clean original set on CD
for you to further distribute. Who knows?
Please let us know the results of your correspondence with Colt.
This information is already contained in the manuals themselves, which
are available at http://www.coltsmfg.com/publications.aspx
In addition to the usual "all rights reserved" clause, they further
state "for permission to reprint for noncommercial instructional
purposes, prior approval from Colt's is required".
# The direct approach. Easy. They actually may appreciate the effort as it
# would take some of the load off of their own facilities to provide copies of
# these manuals. They may not guard the copyrights on technical manuals as
# much as a novel writer might guard his fiction since it is just a manual of
# engineering facts and does not impinge on any single writer's imagination
# and creativity. Heck, they might even send you a clean original set on CD
# for you to further distribute. Who knows?
#
# Please let us know the results of your correspondence with Colt.
I'd be willing to bet they'll say no. Not because of any profit motive
but because of product liability. They lose direct control of the
information that's being published and if any of it's faulty, they may
end up holding the bag none the less. Just my opinion, mind you.
Mortimer Schnerd, RN
mschnerd at carolina.rr.com
Good points. The liability for incorrect or faulty editions might still
fall back on Colt. "IF" he has the courage to actually correspond directly
with Colt, I expect them to take the conservative approach and deny
permission.
That looks like pretty good evidence of their intentions. If they require
permission for noncommercial purposes, I expect they would also demand it
for commercial reasons. Also, why buy these manuals when Colt offers them
for free download from their own site? I guess the good old entrepreneurial
spirit kicked in but not enough research was done before going ahead with
the project. Good try though.
Bluehawk has that covered. Some guy told him 20+ years ago he could
distribute them.
I just got off the phone with Colt Industries. Left voicemail for the
gentleman I was directed to that could clear this up. Have to wait now
for the call back.
As far as being late with all this I started this project a year
ago...before the manuals were put on Colts website.
Why get them from me? You certainly can download from their site and
do all the work yourself and go out and buy blank CDs (if you dont
have any) or get them from me with all the work done.
This wasn't a for-profit venture...it's simply a share-with-you-guys
info if you want it. At $10 there is no profit if you consider it
takes about 20 hours or so to scan all these booklets plus the cost of
the CDs and jackets...add to that wear and tear on the scanner as well
as the cost of electricity!
Where is the profit??
Minimum wage is $8/hour...and I've been demoted to Admin Asst?? All
this time I thought I was the CEO!
I figured at most possibly 10 folks interested in the project.
You are forgetting cost of plastic flip-open CD jackets PLUS the cost
of electricity. It's not just electrical cost of running the PC and
scanner but the cost of it for lights and especially the AC running
here to keep things cool!
#Well, let's see. 20 hours at $8 / hour (for an administrative
#assistant) that's $160. CDs, about a quarter apeice. So figure 15
#minutes foe each copy you want to produce at $2. That's $2.25 for time
#and materials leaving $7.75 profit on each one. Figure in your ROI at
#21 CDs, and the rest is $7.75 profit from then on.
Then there's the legal costs Henry will have to pay after Colt finds
out he's selling their copyrighted materials.
#I figured at most possibly 10 folks interested in the project.
#You are forgetting cost of plastic flip-open CD jackets PLUS the cost
#of electricity. It's not just electrical cost of running the PC and
#scanner but the cost of it for lights and especially the AC running
#here to keep things cool!
Now he wants us to pay all his bills! What next, lunch?