I remember reading that some gunowners use some sort of auto parts
cleaner in cleaning their guns. Is brake cleaner OK - does anyone use
it? I noticed the other day in the auto parts store that it is a
fraction of the cost of the stuff by Tetra (and others) so this could
be a valuable alternative.
Any help would be much appreciated.
TIA
Terry
------------------------------------------------------------------------
You can learn about rec.guns at http://doubletap.cs.umd.edu/rec.guns
Dick Burg
Some words of caution which you probably already know: NEVER use the stuff
indoors, NEVER near wood, and I tend to keep it away from plastic
parts...just in case. Remember also it removes everything from the surface
to make sure to oil the gun later. Other than that, the cleaner works just
fine on my 1911's and other autoloaders. Good luck.
================================================
Terry Reid <Re...@prontomail.com> ... I've been using Tetra's action blaster
as part of my cleaning regimen and have really gotten to like it.
Unfortunately I don't like the cost all that much.
# I remember reading that some gunowners use some sort of auto parts
cleaner in cleaning their guns. Is brake cleaner OK - does anyone use it?
1 part Dexron II, IIe or III ATF, GM Spec. D-20265 or later.
1 part Kerosene - deodorized, K1
1 part Aliphatic Mineral Spirits, Fed. Spec. TT-T-2981F, CAS
#64741-49-9, or may substitute "Stoddard Solvent", CAS
#8052-41-3, or equivalent, (aka "Varsol")
1 part Acetone, CAS #67-64-1.
1 lb. Anhydrous lanolin/gallon for additional anti-corrosion and
lubricating properties.
Add the ATF first. Use its empty container to measure the other
components. If adding lanolin, melt in a doubleboiler, add, stir
until it dissolves.
Happy cleaning.
> ...
Any of those high end (in terms of volubility) solvents remove ALL the
oils, as well as dirt, from your firearm, leaving it vulnerable to
corrosion and wear. If you immediately re lubricate everything (not
too much, of course), you'll be okay. On metals they won't cause harm,
but some will destroy certain kinds of plastics, beware!
I sprayed some contact cleaner on a piece of polycarbonate tubing
once and, just sitting there, it shattered into a million pieces all
by itself.
Bill Smith
If you can't clean your weapon by the proper cloth and solvent method
then be prepared to pay what ever it costs. A quality weapon should
last a lifetime if properly cared for, that means cleaning and
lubrication. If you can not clean the weapon properly, be prepared to
pay extra for shortcuts.
> ...
#I've been using Tetra's action blaster as part of my cleaning regimen
#and have really gotten to like it. Unfortunately I don't like the cost
#all that much.
#
#I remember reading that some gunowners use some sort of auto parts
#cleaner in cleaning their guns. Is brake cleaner OK - does anyone use
#it? I noticed the other day in the auto parts store that it is a
#fraction of the cost of the stuff by Tetra (and others) so this could
#be a valuable alternative.
I've used CRC Brake-Cleen for years without a problem.
# I remember reading that some gunowners use some sort of auto parts
# cleaner in cleaning their guns. Is brake cleaner OK - does anyone use
# it?
I use BRAKLEEN brand brake cleaner on both stainless and blued guns. No
problems. Cleans it like nothing else will, thats for sure - and leaves the gun
DRY after it evaporates. You will need to oil in places you have long forgotten
about :)
Carb & Choke Cleaner works in a pinch, as does wd-40
---
New Web Site! http://www.robak.net
All opinions and comments in this message are my own, and are not on behalf of
any or all of Indiana University in any way.
Support Search and Rescue - Get Lost!
----------------------------------------------------
Shawn C. Robak sro...@indiana.edu
Indiana University Alumni Association
Network Analyst http://www.alumni.indiana.edu
---------------------------------------------------
http://php.indiana.edu/~srobak
ICQ#: 41962699 75232335
--
"Terry Reid" <Re...@prontomail.com> wrote in message
news:9eg963$l4i$1...@xring.cs.umd.edu...
> ...
It can harm some finishes and plastics, at least potentially, so
be careful. I do not mean to scare you, just to wan you that it
works but use sensible care.
Cordially,
Red
Terry Reid wrote:
> ...
I have been using "Brake Parts Cleaner" for years. It works great with a
couple "cautions".
1 There is an environmentaly friendly version out that is water based.
It does not work very well and is a pain, so read the ingredients first.
2 It strips ALL grease and oil, so you have to be careful about re
oiling after.
3 Be careful what you get it on. It dissolves some plastics, it can play
hell with some wood finishes and painted on gun finishes. I use it on
Polymer frame (Ruger) with no problem.
# I remember reading that some gunowners use some sort of auto parts
# cleaner in cleaning their guns. Is brake cleaner OK - does anyone use
# it?
I use it all the time.... just keep it off your wood. It'll clean crap out like there's no tomorrow.
Mortimer Schnerd, RN
msch...@carolina.rr.com.nospam
http://home.carolina.rr.com/mortimerschnerd
Terry Reid wrote:
> ...
Aerosol brake cleaner is better, and you can also use aerosol carb cleaner.
If you look at the ingredients, they're very much like the gun scrubber type
stuff. Just remember to re-oil quickly, as the metal will be totally dry &
open to the air.
That's the first time I ever that, Then why would someone use brake
cleaner on all the brake parts in a auto?, after 20+years of being a
mechanic myself and using the stuff on tons of parts I have never seen
a part of any type of metal break, Rust quickly yes - very quickly.
When degreasing the bore to clean it with my Outers Foul Out III unit, I
always use BraKleen brake cleaner instead of the "made for firearms" degreasers.
Works better too.
Steve
-----= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =-----
http://www.newsfeeds.com - The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
-----== Over 80,000 Newsgroups - 16 Different Servers! =-----
# What ever you do, don't use brake cleaner! The solvents will draw out
# all lubrication from the metal eventually making it brittle (could
# result in catastrophic failure of the metal).
What an absurd statement that is.
Sure, solvents remove lubrication, but the rest is fantasy.
Karl
I often wonder where this kind of pure horse puckey gets started. Metal
embrittlement has nothing to do with the amount of, or lack of, lubricant.
I have used both brake cleaner and carburetor cleaner to clean my guns for at
least 30 years. The only difference I can see is that some carburetor
cleaners
leave a film, perhaps a lubricant, while the brake cleaners do not. When I
get
really serious about cleaning, I buy a quart or two of engine cleaner (Gunk is
one) and soak the action after removing grips and optics. Flushing with
boiling water or mineral spirits, carries away all the goo and leaves the gun
nice and dry. I apply oil only at bearing points unless I am going to be out
in the field. My guns are much used and most look nearly new.
God Bless!
Norm
Frank Logullo wrote:
#
# Don't know about brake cleaner but here's a recipe I've been thinking about
# trying.
# Haven't pinned down a source of lanolin yet. Any comments? Came from Uncle
--
"And so castles made of sand fall into the sea...eventually."
Water is death to a brake system. I can't imagine any mechanic using
brake cleaner with water in it.
--
You don't have much to say about the length
of your life, but you have a lot to say
about the breadth and depth.
The solvent that you are using on the cloth will clean all the
old lubricant from the metal, just as will a spray cleaner.
No dis-respect, but I think that you really do not have to worry
about metal embrittlement from most solvents. There are some
solvent that could cause problems, but you will not find them in
the average store but only in exotic laboratories.
Cordially,
Red
Just remember that brake cleaner is alcohol based, including methanol in
many brands. If you breathe the stuff you risk permanent nerve damage
and blindness.
--
You don't have much to say about the length
of your life, but you have a lot to say
about the breadth and depth.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Frank Logullo wrote:
> ...
Sorry to be so dramatic, but the stuff is made to burn even
better than gasoline. A story that I have always enjoyed is one
about the Old Time finishes on Colts. It has been years, but if
there is any secret to getting a good bluing finish, it is to
get the metal super clean. Colt used boiling gasoline (No idea
about high test or regular, maybe high test for expensive guns)
and it is a super cleaner and the cleaning line burned to the
ground every so often. Most of the folks now use boiling
Tri-Sodium-Phosphate, nice cheap and very good, but it will eat
aluminum.
Your description of your process for cleaning new guns is a
beauty. I have found small metal shavings inside new guns and
in the bolt recesses in rifle actions and your advice is really
good. That's why I do not want you to Flambeau your self with
ether. It really is one of the few things that scares me in
common use.
Cordially,
Red
Brake Cleaner does a wonderful job. You must, however, use the
non-water-based cleaner. It does remove ALL the oil, so you will need to
re-lubricate afterwards.
The best I've found for lubricating and rust inhibiting, is BoreCote
www.borecote.com . It keeps your gun from rusting and is COMPLETELY DRY.
DG
"Terry Reid" <Re...@prontomail.com> wrote in message
news:9eg963$l4i$1...@xring.cs.umd.edu...
# ...Is brake cleaner OK - does anyone use it?
#
Thanks very much to all who responded. This was pretty much what I'd
hoped to hear.
I've used the brake cleaner now, and in the same way I've been using
Action Blaster - not as a replacement for cleaning, but as an adjunct
to it. What I mean is that I blast parts between steps of cleaning to
carry away crud that I've scrubbed out with CLP or solvent, and then
re-lube.
I *am* however, concerned about the "plastics" caveats. While I
wouldn't get the stuff on removable plastic grips (e.g. my Sig and
1911) there's no way around contacting the polymer frames of my Glock
and HK USP.
Am I making a serious mistake here?
thanks,
Terry
Terry Reid wrote:
> ...
#Dick:
#You are a nice guy and have always been a straight arrow type so
#just for my own peace of mind, Please Understand That Starter
#Fluid Is Mostly Ether
# It really is one of the few things that scares me in
#common use.
Of course you are right about its properties. I've once heard it
said that its only a little more explosive than Nitroglycern.....
That said, When the other solvents fail, I always keep a can
on hand and try it too. Sometimes there is grit that only the
very strongest things will move. Acetone is another bad
substance that has uses. Just not the womens stuff with
lanolin for nails. Your cautions are all well taken, and should
be repeated to those who don't exercise due care. Rule 1
is don't smoke or have any electric motors anywhere near
you.
Dick Burg
# I've used the brake cleaner now, and in the same way I've been using
# Action Blaster - not as a replacement for cleaning, but as an adjunct
# to it. What I mean is that I blast parts between steps of cleaning to
# carry away crud that I've scrubbed out with CLP or solvent, and then
# re-lube.
#
# I *am* however, concerned about the "plastics" caveats. While I
# wouldn't get the stuff on removable plastic grips (e.g. my Sig and
# 1911) there's no way around contacting the polymer frames of my Glock
# and HK USP.
I've had Glocks for over 10 years. I've used brake cleaner, carb
cleaner, and darn near every thing that comes in a spray can from a gun
store and an autoparts store.
If Glock's were going to do anything untowards by using brake cleaner, I
would have already melted mine to slag. There are no soft spots, melted
looking places or anything else.
Don't use oven cleaner, other than that, don't worry about it.
DanH
--
Air Cav Reference Board
http://www.cavalrypilot.com
UNIX - Not just for vestal virgins anymore
"Tom & Marge" <jor...@earthlink.net> wrote in message
news:3B0F1763...@earthlink.net...
#Just remember that brake cleaner is alcohol based, including methanol in
#many brands. If you breathe the stuff you risk permanent nerve damage
#and blindness.
Actually, the two brands I have in the shop list toluene as the
primary ingredient....along with methanol and petroleum distillates.
Toluene is a potent carcinogen. Use gloves and a resperator in a
well-ventilated area!
Jay T
#Water is death to a brake system. I can't imagine any mechanic using
#brake cleaner with water in it.
Spray brake cleaners are normally used on areas of the brake system
commonly exposed to water when driving. What happened the last itme
you drove through a puddle? It isn't surprising to me that spray
cleaners might have water in them.
Jay T
: #Dick:
: #You are a nice guy and have always been a straight arrow type so
: #just for my own peace of mind, Please Understand That Starter
: #Fluid Is Mostly Ether
: # It really is one of the few things that scares me in
: #common use.
: Of course you are right about its properties. I've once heard it
: said that its only a little more explosive than Nitroglycern.....
: That said, When the other solvents fail, I always keep a can
Regarding ether, specifically diethyl ether, this is a pretty heavy
molecule, and will sink in the atmosphere. It can literally flow as
well. Back in chemistry, when using the stuff for alkaloid extraction
(which also involves heat from Bunsen burners, it was stressed as to its
potential to literally flow across the bench as fumes, and catch fire.
Now when it does catch fire, its flames, still being hot, are nearly
invisible. One must watch for that especially lest they leave the area
with it literally on fire.
Of course being young at that time and experimentally inclined, this did
not stop me from moving a bit to my house for an ether party ....
--
John M. Price, PhD jmp...@calweb.com
Life: Chemistry, but with feeling! | PGP Key on request or FTP!
Email responses to my Usenet articles will be posted at my discretion.
Comoderator: sci.psychology.psychotherapy.moderated Atheist# 683
The whole aim of practical politics is to keep the populace alarmed (and
hence clamorous to be led to safety) by menacing it with an endless
series of hobgoblins, all of them imaginary.
- H. L. Mencken
If memory serves me right, plating shops used to use a boiling sodium
cyanide solution in an extremely well ventilated area, then rub with fuming
nitric acid, all of which I'm sure OSHA has now outlawed and which I
definitely do not recommend.
--
Nick, Retired in the San Fernando Valley www.boonchoo.com
"Giving violent criminals a government guarantee that their intended
victims are defenseless is bad public policy."
- John Ross, "Unintended Consequences"
The cyanide is normally sold as eggs about the size and shape of
small chicken eggs. If you put it in a nice cast iron pot and
take it up to about 1,600 to 2,000 degrees (I do not remember
the exact temp), it is fine surface hardening material for steel
and acts very like a case hardening process by producing a
surface layer of carbides and nitrides. The look is a sort of
silver gray and it is really wear resistant.
Cordially,
Red
n_cr...@pacbell.net wrote:
> ...
> ...
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
You can learn about rec.guns at http://doubletap.cs.umd.edu/rec.guns
Shoot the best, forget the rest. Win a Fulton Armory AR-15 Tactical
Carbine while rec.guns shows our strength supporting the RKBA.
Click on www.direct-action.org
Take note that sometimes these cleaners may contain chemicals that may
may leave a whitish film behind on your blued metal. I would recommend
you test any unknown brand first somewhere where it won't be noticed
like the inside of a slide. The whitish film can be hidden by a bit of
oil though.
Also wear protective gloves if you use these cleaners often. Chemicals
like the trichlorials can be absorbed through the skin. Use in
ventilated areas or your head will be spinning for sure!
Dave
#Take note that sometimes these cleaners may contain chemicals that may
#may leave a whitish film behind on your blued metal. I would recommend
#you test any unknown brand first
Its even worse than that. Brands sometimes change their
formula. From one production lot to another, you may not
be getting the same stuff. This isn't food grade stuff, its
only designed to remove oil and grease and evaporate.
I buy mine at auto parts swap meets. No idea what I'm
getting, but when its cheap enough, I buy a case of it.
Thats usually abut $10 for 12. And before I buy, I make
the seller show me that it still sprays.
Dick Burg
clone
behind the lines
occupied socal
"Where do I stand in this form of power, where do I fit with this
government? I have no choice!" -TSOL "World War III"
# Which brand do you use? In my neck of the woods, I see approximately 14
# different brands. Some are No name type products, some are high end,
# and some are even listed as synthetic.
#
# Gale wrote:
Watch out for some brands that have water in them. Most of the cheaper
brands are all solvent, but I have seen some of the more expensive
types now contain lots of water. Hmm, might actually be better for
cleanup after shooting corrosive stuff.
Or you could mount it on a nice 7 foot hardwood staff an have a
naginata.
(sorry, this should have gone with my other reply)
Joseph
So this gave you the opportunity to try your hand at making a new hilt
for it. What did you use? Stag horn? Sharkskin over hardwood and
wrapped with flat silk cord? Maybe some nicely tooled brass?
Joseph
Since then I haven't tried any shortcuts.
Steve Gray
Tampa, FL
Joseph Lovell <sub...@sonic.net> wrote in message
news:9kjb0u$jtt$1...@xring.cs.umd.edu...
# Romeyclone wrote:
# # I cleaned my Emerson/Benchmade tanto with
William Gray wrote:
> ...
#William:
#Brake cleaner is about at the extreme edge of the normal class of
#cleaners that I would use on a handgun and then I would dip it in a good
#grade of thin oil or transmission fluid to get oil back into all of the
#places that the brake cleaner cleaned out. Normally, it works fine on
#almost all kinds of gunk and may hurt some plastics and paint, but
#otherwise, it is fine.
I've used brake cleaner on a variety of firearms, including "tupperware"
frames, with no problems. Do avoid the "environmentally friendly"
product however -- it doesn't work as well and leaves a white residue
behind.
I lube the gun with a coating of "Ed's Red," (a thin cleaner/lubricant
containing the transmission fluid mentioned above) or a spraying of
Rem-Oil, a light oil containing teflon. The Ed's Red goes on the
load-bearing and heat-receiving areas, while the Rem-Oil goes primarily
on the trigger, hammer, sear and mag-catch components.
Our IPSC guns have received this treatment for several years (over
20,000 rounds each), and show almost no signs of wear.
__
COA is running a PRO-gun advertising campaign,
and YOU can get involved!
http://www.CitizensOfAmerica.org
#William:
#Brake cleaner is about at the extreme edge of the normal class of
#cleaners that I would use on a handgun and then I would dip it in a good
#grade of thin oil or transmission fluid to get oil back into all of the
#places that the brake cleaner cleaned out. Normally, it works fine on
#almost all kinds of gunk and may hurt some plastics and paint, but
#otherwise, it is fine.
I've used brake cleaner on a variety of firearms, including "tupperware"
frames, with no problems. Do avoid the "environmentally friendly"
product however -- it doesn't work as well and leaves a white residue
behind.
I lube the gun with a coating of "Ed's Red," (a thin cleaner/lubricant
containing the transmission fluid mentioned above) or a spraying of
Rem-Oil, a light oil containing teflon. The Ed's Red goes on the
load-bearing and heat-receiving areas, while the Rem-Oil goes primarily
on the trigger, hammer, sear and mag-catch components.
Our IPSC guns have received this treatment for several years (over
20,000 rounds each), and show almost no signs of wear.
__
COA is running a PRO-gun advertising campaign,
and YOU can get involved!
http://www.CitizensOfAmerica.org
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
"Dan Z" <dan...@ix.netcom.com> wrote in message
news:9r2iup$7b4$1...@xring.cs.umd.edu...
> ...
Ray,
(Si vis pacem,
para bellum) U.S.A.
Nothing says comfort like a .357 Magnum!
Adam