Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Has anyone tried/used a Mosquito Magnet ?

0 views
Skip to first unread message

Robert E. Watts

unread,
Sep 6, 2001, 3:09:20 PM9/6/01
to
Hello !

My apologies if this has been covered already....

....but if anyone here has experience using the Mosquito Magnet, I would
certainly appreciate hearing your comments about the (very
expensive )device.

Thank you !

bobwatts


--
Diesel Chevette Cabana http://w3.one.net/~watscarb/dieselvette.htm
Watts Carburetion Service http://w3.one.net/~watscarb/CarbHome.htm
//////////$$$$$\\\\\\\\\\
Bob Watts
Watts Carburetion Service
Whizzbang Computer Emporium
Cincinnati, Ohio
USA, Earth
Since 1984
\\\\\\\\\\$$$$$//////////
wats...@one.net
http://w3.one.net/~watscarb/dieselvette.htm


Paul Onstad

unread,
Sep 6, 2001, 3:32:49 PM9/6/01
to
Robert E. Watts wrote:
>
> Hello !
>
> My apologies if this has been covered already....
>
> ....but if anyone here has experience using the Mosquito Magnet, I would
> certainly appreciate hearing your comments about the (very
> expensive )device.

A thread was here a month or so back--most interesting for a dissatisfied
user who has put up a web site detailing problems he had experienced. I
don't have it but you could search Deja/Google and spot it I'm sure.

The problem seems to be its price and the fact that mosquitoes respond to
more than just CO_2 signals. Wind direction was also crucial and the unit
could not easily be moved without dismantling it to some degree. Finally, a
person without even one bad thing to say about it claimed it had already
caught about 100 mosquitos. Heck, around here, that would not even clear the
smallest area on a bad mosquito day.

Mosquitoes can come from a mile away so removing them at a point is like
taking a teaspoon to make a hole in the ocean.

The best thing is to reduce breeding areas--plugged gutters, old
tires....any standing water. It must be a neighborhood effort.

-Paul

Robert E. Watts

unread,
Sep 6, 2001, 4:03:07 PM9/6/01
to
Hello Mr. Onstad !

>
> A thread was here a month or so back--most interesting for a dissatisfied
> user who has put up a web site detailing problems he had experienced. I
> don't have it but you could search Deja/Google and spot it I'm sure.
>


Ok, thanks, I'll find it.


> The problem seems to be its price

Yes ! I'm reluctant to spend $700 + for this thing.

and the fact that mosquitoes respond to
> more than just CO_2 signals. Wind direction was also crucial

Those were a couple of my concerns.....

and the unit
> could not easily be moved without dismantling it to some degree. Finally,
a
> person without even one bad thing to say about it claimed it had already
> caught about 100 mosquitos. Heck, around here, that would not even clear
the
> smallest area on a bad mosquito day.
>

Here at my property in the Ohio Valley, I get swarmed by dozens of mosquitos
as soon as I go outside. It's really unbelieveable. I AM the Human Mosquito
Magnet. :-)

The advertisements claim to kill "hundreds" a day....

> Mosquitoes can come from a mile away so removing them at a point is like
> taking a teaspoon to make a hole in the ocean.
>
> The best thing is to reduce breeding areas--plugged gutters, old
> tires....any standing water. It must be a neighborhood effort.


Agreed. I do my part, but unless the whole neighborhood participates, it's
useless. ( Especially in this extremely wet summer we're having. )

Thanks for your response !

Dr. Rev. Chuck, M.D., P.A.

unread,
Sep 7, 2001, 5:32:58 AM9/7/01
to
Robert E. Watts wrote:
>
> Hello !
>
> My apologies if this has been covered already....
>
> ....but if anyone here has experience using the Mosquito Magnet, I would
> certainly appreciate hearing your comments about the (very
> expensive )device.

Garlic. Seems to work for me.

KrisHur

unread,
Sep 7, 2001, 9:09:19 AM9/7/01
to
I bought the commercial sized one, It was on backorder forever and when it
arrived all the mosquitoes have been gone for a while--still don't see any.
I have a "swamp" in the back and yet there are no mosquitoes for quite a
while now. It has caught a bunch of tiny biting bugs (no see-ums?, but I can
see um) and some mosquitoes. So anyway, I'm reserving judgment until
spring--when ordered from Frontgate you have just over a year to return it.
I don't know about the residential size, but this one can be moved no
problem--large wheels--although the tank is not strapped on, so someone else
to prevent it from falling off when moving it is a good idea.

Placement is very important, but pretty easy, check the which way the
prevailing winds blow for that season (weather.com), and place it upwind of
the breeding ground, so that the wind will carry the scent across the
breeding ground.

"Robert E. Watts" <wats...@one.net> wrote in message
news:tpfic36...@corp.supernews.com...

Robert E. Watts

unread,
Sep 7, 2001, 9:59:46 AM9/7/01
to
Hello KrisHur !


"KrisHur" <kris...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:RB3m7.263324$rV6.11...@e420r-atl2.usenetserver.com...


> I bought the commercial sized one, It was on backorder forever and when it
> arrived all the mosquitoes have been gone for a while--still don't see
any.
> I have a "swamp" in the back and yet there are no mosquitoes for quite a
> while now. It has caught a bunch of tiny biting bugs (no see-ums?, but I
can
> see um) and some mosquitoes. So anyway, I'm reserving judgment until
> spring--when ordered from Frontgate you have just over a year to return
it.
> I don't know about the residential size, but this one can be moved no
> problem--large wheels--although the tank is not strapped on, so someone
else
> to prevent it from falling off when moving it is a good idea.
>
> Placement is very important, but pretty easy, check the which way the
> prevailing winds blow for that season (weather.com), and place it upwind
of
> the breeding ground, so that the wind will carry the scent across the
> breeding ground.


Interesting. Your particular experience is what the manufacturer "claims"
will happen. The mosquito population will collapse within a short time
period.

I'm glad that you had such success, but I remain skeptical, much like your
reserving judgment. That is probably wise.

I'm hoping that the price of this device drops dramatically, and I will try
one. I can't go outside anymore, because the mosquito's here are frankly
unbelievable this year, worse than the usual terrible conditions.

( Yes, I have taken all the normal precautions in my Mosquito War, and even
have 5 bug zappers, including the biggest of the big. I'm aware that they
are vitally useless against mosquito's, but it's somewhat satisfying to hear
electrical "zaps" :-)

Hopefully others will relate their experience with this machine, or what
methods they have used to combat these d**m bugs.

By the way Dr. Rev Chuck, just exactly what is it you do with the Garlic ?
Eat it, wear it, arrange a necklace, frolic around the yard spreading it
around, have barbecue's for the mosquito's serving them garlic, plant garlic
trees, string it around fancy garden lights, or what ? :-) :-)

I'm mad as hell, and I'm not going to take it anymore.

Sincere regards,

Dennis Bishop

unread,
Sep 7, 2001, 11:07:59 AM9/7/01
to
One Word ... "Suckerbait" for buying it.


--

The Babylon project was our last best hope
for Peace, it failed ... In the year of the Shadow
War it became something bigger ... Our
last best hope for Victory! The year is
2260 ... The Place is Babylon 5

www.starlords.org

"Robert E. Watts" <wats...@one.net> wrote in message
news:tpfic36...@corp.supernews.com...

KrisHur

unread,
Sep 8, 2001, 8:55:01 AM9/8/01
to
Not really, I have a year to return it, for any reason. I once had them
replace some fairly expensive doormats that faded faster than they said they
would a year after I bought them.


"Dennis Bishop" <hak...@earthlink.net> wrote in message
news:jp5m7.3129$d86.2...@newsread1.prod.itd.earthlink.net...

Vox Humana

unread,
Sep 8, 2001, 9:23:45 PM9/8/01
to

"KrisHur" <kris...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:Vyom7.2208$Sn1.2...@e420r-atl1.usenetserver.com...

> Not really, I have a year to return it, for any reason. I once had them
> replace some fairly expensive doormats that faded faster than they said
they
> would a year after I bought them.
>

I was at the Frontage outlet store recently and I noticed that they had
these units there at a pretty good discount. I don't know if that means
people aren't buying them or if they were returned.


KrisHur

unread,
Sep 9, 2001, 7:49:22 AM9/9/01
to
UH-OH, thanks for the head's up. I would think they are returned ones as I
had to wait over two months due to the backorder--the operator told me they
had over 2000 on backorder when I ordered mine; why would they discount
something that's selling so well and move it to the outlet store?

Well, I'm glad I had the patience to wait on them (DH wanted to go out and
get one after one month of waiting) so I still have the option to return it
this spring if it doesn't work. Trying to kill things in federally protected
wetlands (without harming the other critters) is tough....it sounded so
good.

On a good note, it ran out of gas about 3 days ago and yesterday I got my
first mosquito bite, so it must be doing something.

"Vox Humana" <vhu...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:Bwzm7.99613$nh4.13...@typhoon.neo.rr.com...

Robert E. Watts

unread,
Sep 9, 2001, 9:25:48 AM9/9/01
to

"Vox Humana" <vhu...@hotmail.com> wrote in message news:Bwzm7.99613

> I was at the Frontage outlet store recently and I noticed that they had


> these units there at a pretty good discount. I don't know if that means
> people aren't buying them or if they were returned.
>

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

I don't suppose that is anywhere near Cincinnati Ohio is it ?


&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

KrisHur wrote:


UH-OH, thanks for the head's up. I would think they are returned ones as I
had to wait over two months due to the backorder--the operator told me they
had over 2000 on backorder when I ordered mine; why would they discount
something that's selling so well and move it to the outlet store?

Well, I'm glad I had the patience to wait on them (DH wanted to go out and
get one after one month of waiting) so I still have the option to return it
this spring if it doesn't work. Trying to kill things in federally protected
wetlands (without harming the other critters) is tough....it sounded so
good.

On a good note, it ran out of gas about 3 days ago and yesterday I got my
first mosquito bite, so it must be doing something.

*********

"Maybe" good to hear. Keep me/us posted on your research with this device.
I'm sincerely interested, at least until I invent something of my own.

I'm thinking nuclear............

Ed Clarke

unread,
Sep 10, 2001, 11:07:28 AM9/10/01
to
On Sun, 9 Sep 2001 09:25:48 -0400, Robert E. Watts <wats...@one.net> wrote:
>"Maybe" good to hear. Keep me/us posted on your research with this device.
>I'm sincerely interested, at least until I invent something of my own.
>
>I'm thinking nuclear............

Oh great! Now we'll have mosquitoes with a six foot wingspan that can
drain a cow of blood in two minutes.

Robert E. Watts

unread,
Sep 10, 2001, 3:27:24 PM9/10/01
to
Hi Ed !

"Ed Clarke" <cla...@news.cilia.org> wrote in message
news:slrn9pplpg...@news.cilia.org...

...... you know, if you think about it, six foot wing span 'squiters
wouldn't be all bad. At least you could see them to shoot 'em down, using
impressive ordnance probably. ( I'm thinking .50 cal with tracers. Be very
impressive at night ! )

Now you never find out your "hit" until it's too late.

:-)

Carla

unread,
Sep 11, 2001, 10:00:46 PM9/11/01
to
My friend in Florida has what I think she called a magnet or some
contraption that puts out smoke all over her yard and she swears it works
wonders. I put on two different kinds of sprays, one on each arm the other
day, and got bit on both arms. It was botanical repellent, one with
geranium, cinnamon, and other stuff, and the other was wintergreen, and
mints of some sort. Neither kept me from getting bites so I'm back to long
sleeves just to go out and look at my garden.

I don't have the funds to buy up all the gadgets to try them, but I did see
an article that said a lady got good results with citronella candles, Off
candles, but didn't get good results with the mechanical contraptions.
However, she did state she picked a bad day to test them out since the
mosquitoes were not swarming like they should have been even where before
she set out her test equipment. I've been bitten sitting next to a
citronella candle so they don't work that well. However, I've put rubbing
alcohol on my skin then walked outside and was mosquito free for about 10
minutes. I'll just stick to long sleeves with a hood for my head since they
grab my face and neck too.

Carla
Zone 7a


"Robert E. Watts" <wats...@one.net> wrote in message
news:tpfic36...@corp.supernews.com...

0 new messages