There were seven participants in this contest (two only replied in
rec.puzzles), which was less than I'd hoped for, but as I said, this was
a bit of an experiment.
Dan Tilque wrote:
>
> OBJECT: For each letter of the alphabet, think of the alphabetically
> first word that has that letter doubled. That is, the first word with a
> double A, the first with a double B, etc. Well, except that we'll skip
> J, Q, X, and Y since there are very few words with those letters
> doubled. (In fact, the only acceptable words I know of for Q and X are
> found in the OED.)
>
> ALLOWED WORDS: Only those that would be acceptable in Scrabble are
> allowed. That means no capitalized words and none with punctuation or
> internal spaces. Words must be found in an English-language dictionary
> other than the OED.
One contestant missed the Scrabble-legal requirement and gave two
answers with hyphens. I counted one of those wrong, but the other word
is virtually always written without a hyphen, so I was lenient and
considered it a mispelling.
>
> Inflected word forms count the same as their uninflected forms unless
> only the inflected form has the doubled letter.
After seeing the answers, I also decided that variant spellings count
the same as each other.
For misspellings, I did my best to discern what word was meant and
assume that was what was posted. Of course, sometimes the correct
spelling was not a valid answer.
>
> Contest will run until 9:00 p.m. (UTC +7), Saturday, Oct 12 (one week
> from today). I'll post a reminder on Friday.
>
>
> SCORING: The best word for each letter scores 5, second best word scores
> 3 and third best 1. It doesn't matter how many people get each of the
> words. Everyone getting the best word gets 5, etc.
Here's a list of the three best answers for each letter:
A aa aardvark
B abb abba abbacy
C accede access accommodate
D add addled address
E abandonee abductee absentee
F affability affable affair
G abegging agglomerate aggravate
H bathhouse fishhook withhold
I aalii radii skiing
K bookkeeper trekked
L abnormally abolla achillea
M accommodate ammeter anagrammed
N alienness amenning anna
O abloom adulthood afoot
P airdropped appal(l) apparent
R aberrance aberrant arrange
S abbess abscess amass
T abattis abattoir abutter
U continuum duuvir vaccuum
V bevvy bivvy bovver
W arrowwood bowwow powwow
Z abuzz buzzer dazzle
WRONG ANSWERS
accapella -- a cappella
akkadian -- capitalized
anti-inflamatory -- punctuation
avvogadro -- Avogadro
bakkala -- not found in dictionaries
bowward -- not found in dictionaries
One other wrong answer was ashheap. I could only find this word in one
dictionary (Chambers) where it was hyphenated: ash-heap. Unfortunate.
SCORES
And here's the scores (sorry about the compression, but it was the only
way to get all of them on one line).
ABCDEFGHIKLMNOPRSTUVWZ Total
Stephen Perry 5305355555355555555055 94
Andrew B 5555151133151133033535 67
Chris Johnson 5011533555030330005555 62
rthe...@hotmail.com 5155133000553133033015 55
Marc Dashevsky 5055010335050031311015 47
Mark Brader 5105030350010110135301 38
Curlytop 3033000515000000001133 28
Stephen is the winner by quite a bit. Congratulations! (I think he may
have swallowed a word list once.)
Notes and observations:
I was boggled by a few answers. For D, some gave words beginning with
"add-", missing the obvious. There was a couple cases of words given for
one letter which would also have been a better answer than they gave for
another letter.
When I first came up with this idea, I thought I'd restrict it to only
words from one dictionary: Merriam-Webster's Collegiate, which is the
same as their online dictionary. I changed my mind, but not before
compiling a list of best answers from it. You may be interested in that
list:
A aah
B abbacy
C accede
D add
E abductee
F affability
G aggie
H bathhouse
I alibiing
K bookkeeper
L abdominally
M accommodate
N alienness
O abloom
P app
R aberrance
S abbess
T abattoir
U continuum
V chivvy
W arrowwood
Z abuzz
Finally, I made up a list with words taken from any dictionary I could
find, except for the OED. I didn't look through any entire dictionary,
of course. Usually just the first couple dozen or so pages. I also
grepped some word lists and looked those results up as well. Mark Brader
gets credit for gepping a word list I didn't have access to and found a
few words from Webster's Third that I didn't have. Finally, this webpage
was useful for some of the rarer doubled letters:
http://jeff560.tripod.com/words7.html
However, you can't just take any word from that page as valid. Many are
invalid because they are capitalized and some I couldn't find in any
dictionary (aarrghh and arghhood, for example).
A aa [W3]
B abb [W2]
C acca [W3]
D add
E abandonee [W3]
F abaff [W2]
G abegging [RH]
H archhead [W2]
I aalii [W3]
J avijja [W3]
K angekkok [W2]
L abactinally [W3]
M accommodable [W3]
N aannerodite [F&W]
O abloom
P airdropped [RH]
Q zaqqum [W2]
R aberrance
S abaisse [W3]
T abattage [RH]
U ahuula [W3]
V bevvy [Cham]
W arrowweed [W3]
Y cavyyard [W3]
Z abbozzo [W3]
As far as I can tell, there are no Scrabble-legal words with double X
except "waxxenn", a very old spelling of wax (verb) found in the OED.
Thanks to everyone who played.
--
Dan Tilque