RESULT: rec.music.50s-60s fails 175:83
Rick Schubert
rec.music.50s-60s:
YES 175 votes 67.8%
NO 83 votes 32.2%
-----------------
TOTAL 258 votes
MARGIN 92 votes (YES-NO)
In order for the vote to pass, two criteria had to have been met:
1. At least 2/3 (66.7%) of the total votes had to be YES votes
2. There had to be at least 100 more YES than NO votes.
The first criterion was met, but the second was not.
For the vote to have passed, at least one of the following would have
been required:
1. 8 additional YES votes;
2. 8 fewer NO votes;
3. 4 NO votes changed to YES votes;
4. some linear combination of the above, whose mathematical
formula I can send to whoever is interested.
There was one vote received after the voting deadline; it was a YES vote
that was not counted in the above.
Those who voted are listed below. Contact me if you are listed in the
wrong category or if you voted and are not listed.
The following are the 175 YES votes:
76424...@compuserve.com Mike Hubbard (76424,1703)
aa2...@freenet.lorain.oberlin.edu Sally L. Snyder
a...@doc.ic.ac.uk Afonso C Pinto
am...@yfn.ysu.edu Kathleen E. Buller
avd...@csn.org David Ewing
b79...@xlab.nthu.edu.tw Incredible huge spirit.
b...@pismo.sw.stratus.com Bruce Dumes
bec...@boilerbob.corp.mot.com John Becker
b...@anarres.cs.berkeley.edu Brian Harvey
b...@panix.com Bruce H Prussack
bn...@cleveland.freenet.edu Ruth White
bog...@bpb.it Max.Lanfranconi
bre...@cunixf.cc.columbia.edu Joseph Brennan
bsbi...@orion.arc.nasa.gov Brad S. Bigelow
bs...@midway.uchicago.edu Ben Gerber
bs...@charm.isi.edu Barry C. Silk
bwa...@apssgi.nswc.navy.mil Brad Wallet
c...@nsscmail.att.com
ce...@whamr.att.com
charles_rus...@xerox.com
cl...@nrsta2.enet.dec.com dtn 223-8572 13-May-1993 1028
clem...@diamond.bbn.com Bob Clements
c...@ksr.com Chris Reeve
coc...@dg-rtp.dg.com Dave Cochran
con...@sunstroke.eng.usf.edu Michael Conner (EC)
cran...@iseeu.enet.dec.com Norm Crandall 264-7440
dan...@tekgen.bv.tek.com
dat...@genesis.mcs.com DWT
dave!!vogon1!wa3wbu!frackit!da...@psuvax1.cs.psu.edu Dave Ratcliffe
Dave....@east.sun.com Dave Brewer
da...@polaris.unm.edu Dave Grisham
da...@roth-music.com David A. Roth
del...@hplmango.hpl.hp.com Laura de Leon
dfau...@zach.fit.edu Donald W. Fausett
dm...@math.ucla.edu saki
do...@ksr.com
dtho...@vixvax.mgi.com
e...@summa4.mv.com Ed Sinamark
eijk...@cs.utk.edu
en...@athens.uchicago.edu Eric Fischer
EN...@wombat.newcastle.edu.au James Smith
er...@tc.fluke.com Chris Beckmeyer
FANT...@itnvax.cineca.it Barbara Fantechi, Dip. di Matematica, I-38050 POVO
fem...@power.ci.uv.es Jose M. Femenia Herrero
fis...@alexia.lis.uiuc.edu W. T. Fischer
fo...@symcom.math.uiuc.edu Kevin Ford
Franco....@cselt.stet.it
fr...@turner.uni-muenster.de Frank Schumacher
g92r...@giraffe.ru.ac.za MS DJ ROBB
gaja...@pilot.njin.net Bob Gajarsky - Hobokenite
gal...@athena.mit.edu
gan...@husc.harvard.edu
Gary.M...@corp.sun.com Gary Milliken
gedw...@ncratl.atlantaga.ncr.com Gordon Edwards
ge...@access.digex.net Geff King
geo...@meaddata.com George Dibos
geo...@g2syd.genasys.com.au George Quinlan
ger...@boulder.parcplace.com Andrew Gerber
GERRY_...@act.educ.ualberta.ca Gerry Kendal
giga...@info.win.tue.nl Walter "GigaWalt" Belgers
gold...@scratchy.gtri.gatech.edu Michael G. Goldsman
go...@umcc.umich.edu Christopher L. Goosman
gr8...@iastate.edu
gsp...@cmu.edu Geoffrey Spear
h...@scubed.scubed.com Hap Freiberg
HAR...@wsuvm1.csc.wsu.edu Greg Harness
h...@floyd.att.com Howard Teitelbaum
headly.we...@bville.gts.org Headly Westerfield
hei...@alleg.edu Jason Heideloff
how...@pioneer.arc.nasa.gov John Howells
hymo...@server.cs.jhu.edu Hymie!
if...@midway.uchicago.edu andrea m koziol
ir...@ocpt.ccur.com irish
j...@ZGS.NeoSoft.com
ja...@hermes.chpc.utexas.edu Jan Hoiberg
jbmo...@bronze.ucs.indiana.edu Jeff Morris
jch...@leland.stanford.edu
je...@godzilla.quotron.com Jeff Marder
je...@grserv.wustl.edu Jeff Seale
jfr...@rdrc.rpi.edu
jh...@dc.shl.com Julie Holm
j...@donuts0.bellcore.com Jamie Lubin
jim...@bonnie.ics.uci.edu Jimmy Shaw
jmay...@nyx.cs.du.edu Jay Maynard
jon...@csd.uu.se Jonas Jonsson
jo...@g2syd.genasys.com.au Jonathan Gowland
jor...@rex.cs.tulane.edu Grizabella
j...@g2syd.genasys.com.au Jo Turner
jr...@halcon.dpi.udec.cl Jesus Ruiz Matus
jst...@bozell.com Joe Stroop
jx...@cs.nps.navy.mil John Locke
KEN...@yang.earlham.edu
KRO...@cs.umass.edu
ks55...@sycom.mi.org Kathi Seidl
lfau...@zach.fit.edu Laurene V. Fausett
lmc...@lmc.ericsson.se Marco Masse
lmey...@ux4.cso.uiuc.edu Astrid
loc...@imsa.edu Michael Holl
lo...@ihlpm.att.com
LY...@UTKVX.UTCC.UTK.EDU Bradley S. Lyle
M.E.M...@bnr.co.uk
M15...@mwvm.mitre.org
ma...@acuson.com David Mack
ma...@harlequin.com Marc Dashevsky
mar...@convex.csd.uwm.edu Martin A Miller
mcc...@alleg.edu
mcod...@nyx.cs.du.edu Maurizio Codogno
mda...@lamar.colostate.edu MDallin
mi...@ocpt.ccur.com Mike Bixenman
ml...@micrognosis.co.uk Malcolm Lee
mmel...@wam.umd.edu The Meltz Inc.
MORR...@stsci.edu Life's a Witch, and then you Fly!
mr...@cc.swarthmore.edu Michael Rapp
m...@hplb.hpl.hp.com Matteo Vocale
MXWA%Met%T...@encon01.encon.pge.com
mzi...@s.psych.uiuc.edu Mike Zickar
oco...@i88.isc.com Tom O'Connor(Genesis Project
o...@elwood.isgs.uiuc.edu The Reverend Horton Heat
o...@husc10.harvard.edu Jojo
ot...@quark.umd.edu Neil Ottenstein
pa...@chicago.cselt.stet.it Paolo Ruscitti
PATR...@cc.usu.edu XWindows fan
pa...@g2syd.genasys.com.au Pat Thompson
pe...@vipunen.hut.fi Petri 'Pete' Karha
pet...@g2syd.genasys.com.au Peter Johnston
pjb...@ultb.isc.rit.edu Pete - Toonatic - Boulay
pro...@sage.cc.purdue.edu poked ovary dip
p...@slipknot.mit.edu Paul W. Emery
qt...@tacom-emh1.army.mil David Walters
R.T...@bnr.co.uk
re...@centauri.unm.edu Rebecca Dicks
ri...@sq.com Rick Innis
rj...@ihspa.att.com Robert Pietkivitch +1 708 979 2786
rjy...@wpi.wpi.edu Richard J. Yanco
R...@psuvm.psu.edu Ron Crandall
r...@npg-sd.SanDiegoCA.NCR.COM
ro...@ida.org Clyde Roby
rog...@hicomb.hi.com Andrew Rogers
ros...@scs.leeds.ac.uk R Clement
rusb...@mentor.cc.purdue.edu Bob Rusbasan
r...@gov.on.ca Russ Herman
S.J....@newcastle.ac.uk Simon.Eaton
s28...@socrates.sscnet.ucla.edu Eric Rivera
S...@psuvm.psu.edu Sally Crandall 863-4330
sal...@athena.mit.edu
sbutler!!uunet!irscscm!sbutler (Susan Butler)
Scott....@eng.sun.com Scott R. Nelson
sha...@mtgy.gtegsc.com Steven Hanger
sh...@wam.umd.edu follower of chaos out of control
shj...@ncsc.org Rodney Shojinaga
sjs...@cs.umd.edu Stephen Joseph Smith
slu...@tesla.njit.edu
SL...@cornell.edu Steve Worona
sm...@ss0.eng.wayne.edu Salil Mody
ste...@mahogany.cray.com Steven Levine
sts...@st.unocal.com Luis Sandoval
stu...@apollo.hp.com
swil...@channelz.gun.de Sascha Wildner
tbro...@cybernet.cse.fau.edu Thomas Bromley
tg...@cas.org Tom Eshelman
th...@uz.nthu.edu.tw Tee Teck Huat ~{V#5B7\"~}
TIGR...@jaguar.uofs.edu Pam Tigrett, Campus Ministries
t...@ben.dciem.dnd.ca
tpa...@niwot.scd.ucar.edu Tom Parker
t...@lab.jt.dk Torben Skoett
tut...@neptune.convex.com Cari Tuttle
U39...@uicvm.uic.edu Norma Kateeb 3-3624
u926...@cc.uow.edu.au Walker Andrew John
u...@eng.umd.edu Ugo Piomelli
UR...@uz6000.cselt.stet.it
Victoria.M...@dartmouth.edu Victoria M. Haliburton
w...@ice.stx.com John Shepherd
w...@math.canterbury.ac.nz
wsb...@urc.tue.nl Boudewijn Wayers
YZ...@cunyvm.cuny.edu Yaakov Kayman
and the late vote:
nc...@cus.cam.ac.uk Nigel Strudwick
The following are the 83 NO votes:
ac...@ihlpl.att.com
al19...@academ07.mty.itesm.mx Jesus Eugenio S nchez Pe~a
alc...@camelot.bradley.edu Michael Swiston
an...@ccwf.cc.utexas.edu Andrew Hackard
atos...@cc.helsinki.fi Atro S Tossavainen
bai...@utpapa.ph.utexas.edu Ed Bailey
ba...@pop.psu.edu David Barr
bu...@cmu.edu Burt N Holzman
cl...@usceast.cs.scarolina.edu Ernest A. Cline
cl...@midway.uchicago.edu Cory L. Scott
ct...@overpass.seng.calpoly.edu Cliff Tuel
cull...@srg.srg.af.mil Tom Culliton x2278
c...@chaos.cs.brandeis.edu Brandon Magee
da...@cs.umb.edu Dale A. Smoak
da...@cs.uwp.edu David Datta
DMALZAHN%HARP...@uicvm.uic.edu Don Malzahn
dud...@wl.com David T. Dudley
d...@netcom.com dx
e...@kaja.gi.alaska.edu Eric J. Olson
FS...@acad3.alaska.edu Hardcore Alaskan
ge...@marie.physik.tu-berlin.de Georg Schwarz
gib...@ll.mit.edu MargAret D Gibbs
gl...@csli.stanford.edu Clayton Glad
gra...@cs.washington.edu Stephen Graham
vme.heurikon.com!gtaylor%heurik...@cs.wisc.edu Gregory Taylor
ha...@primate.wisc.edu Ray Hamel
hmp...@mosaic.uncc.edu Herbert M Petro
holl...@kpc.com Steve Hollasch
J.J.de...@duticai.twi.tudelft.nl Hans de Graaff
jf...@nyx.cs.du.edu Joel Furr
jo...@uhs1.uhs.uga.edu John D. Hopkins
js...@andrew.cmu.edu James Vincent Schultz
jul...@bongo.tele.com Julian Macassey
j...@athena.mit.edu
ka...@neit.cgd.ucar.edu Brian Kauffman
ki...@wam.umd.edu Yong-Mi Kim
la...@triton.unm.edu Lazlo Nibble
l...@cp.tn.tudelft.nl Leo Breebaart
lis...@vpnet.chi.il.us Gerry Swetsky
majid...@math.yale.edu Fazal Majid
marm...@garnet.msen.com Dave Walker
mbf...@isluga.puc.cl Miguel Farah F.
mcki...@math.wisc.edu Mark McKinzie
men...@ccwf.cc.utexas.edu Charles Paul Menoche
min...@usl.com
mj...@crsa.bu.edu Mike Holmes
m...@pseudo.uucp Murray Nesbitt
m...@redbrick.com Maxime Taksar KC6ZPS
MOR...@fnalv.fnal.gov Greg Morrow
ni...@sunburn.uwaterloo.ca Nick Fitzpatrick
nrab...@itsmail1.hamilton.edu Nancy Rabinowitz
OT...@vaxb.acs.unt.edu M. Otto
p...@bills.sw.stratus.com Peter Rawlings
pau...@ihlpl.att.com
plut...@porter.geo.brown.edu Joel Plutchak
rap...@research.canon.oz.au Andrew Raphael
unisql!r...@cs.utexas.edu Ray Shea
r...@engin.umich.edu R o d Johnson
r...@hpfirhm.fc.hp.com Bob Miller
RIAW...@ubvmsb.cc.buffalo.edu Mad City Blues
ri...@crick.ssctr.bcm.tmc.edu Richard H. Miller
rod...@zeisler.lonestar.org Rodger B. Zeisler
ron...@cisco.com Ronnie B. Kon
rw...@hydra.astro.virginia.edu Robert W. Spiker
sh...@spr.com Shane Hartman
shi...@rpi.edu Larry Shields
sma...@zooid.guild.org Marc Moorcroft
sol...@netcom.com Andrew Solovay
som...@enea.se Erland Sommarskog
sp...@maple.cs.virginia.edu
s...@mole.cis.ufl.edu Stephen P. Potter
stew...@sco.com Stewart Evans
s...@valinor.mythical.com Stu Labovitz
tb...@sybase.com Tony Basoglu
the...@fangio.cipl.uiowa.edu Dan Thedens
to...@cluster.gps.caltech.edu Anthony Domenick Toigo
twpi...@unix.amherst.edu Tim Pierce
ua...@sunyit.edu Andrew Germaine
vag...@vpnet.chi.il.us
wa...@theory.lcs.mit.edu David Wald
wer...@soe.berkeley.edu John Werner
w...@remus.rutgers.edu woj
zir...@echosphere.com Daniel Zirin
-- Rick Schubert (rick.s...@SanDiegoCA.NCR.COM)