Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Blissful Agony, Psyche! and who is the acting minion

20 views
Skip to first unread message

the_capuchin

unread,
Dec 12, 2003, 8:56:17 AM12/12/03
to
Last night a question about an effect has arise in our local
playgroup.

Meth A tried to equip a !Salubri with something.
Meth B, his prey, blocked the action with a Tremere.
Combat begins, range set to close, nothing else, go directly to
strike.
Meth A's !Salubri strikes with a Blissful Agony at superior, choosing
a !Brujah controlled by Meth C, Meth B's prey.
in this new combat, who's the "acting minion" for purposes of playing
cards first?

At the moment, we ruled that since Meth B's Tremere was originally the
blocking minion, so Meth C's !Brujah should play cards first.

Now, reading the text in Blissful Agony, it seems to me that since the
post-S:CE effect is "the opposing vampire ENTERS COMBAT with the
chosen minion", in the above mentioned case, Meth B's Tremere is the
acting minion in the new combat. Is it correct?

If it is, the same would not happen in a new combat generated by
Psyche! at superior is scheduled by a blocking minion, making him the
acting minion now?

many thanks,

the_capuchin

Colin McGuigan

unread,
Dec 12, 2003, 9:15:03 AM12/12/03
to
the_capuchin wrote:
> Last night a question about an effect has arise in our local
> playgroup.
>
> Meth A tried to equip a !Salubri with something.
> Meth B, his prey, blocked the action with a Tremere.
> Combat begins, range set to close, nothing else, go directly to
> strike.
> Meth A's !Salubri strikes with a Blissful Agony at superior, choosing
> a !Brujah controlled by Meth C, Meth B's prey.
> in this new combat, who's the "acting minion" for purposes of playing
> cards first?

Well, see below, but neither of them are the "acting minion" for card
purposes.

> At the moment, we ruled that since Meth B's Tremere was originally the
> blocking minion, so Meth C's !Brujah should play cards first.

I believe that 1.6.1.6 still holds, that is, Meths play cards in this order:

1) Acting Meth
2) Defending Meth
3) Any other Meth, clockwise from acting

So, Meth B (who is still the blocking minion), then Meth C.

> Now, reading the text in Blissful Agony, it seems to me that since the
> post-S:CE effect is "the opposing vampire ENTERS COMBAT with the
> chosen minion", in the above mentioned case, Meth B's Tremere is the
> acting minion in the new combat. Is it correct?

Don't think so.

> If it is, the same would not happen in a new combat generated by
> Psyche! at superior is scheduled by a blocking minion, making him the
> acting minion now?

Probably moot.

--Colin McGuigan

LSJ

unread,
Dec 12, 2003, 9:22:10 AM12/12/03
to
the_capuchin wrote:
> Last night a question about an effect has arise in our local
> playgroup.
>
> Meth A tried to equip a !Salubri with something.
> Meth B, his prey, blocked the action with a Tremere.
> Combat begins, range set to close, nothing else, go directly to
> strike.
> Meth A's !Salubri strikes with a Blissful Agony at superior, choosing
> a !Brujah controlled by Meth C, Meth B's prey.
> in this new combat, who's the "acting minion" for purposes of playing
> cards first?
>
> At the moment, we ruled that since Meth B's Tremere was originally the
> blocking minion, so Meth C's !Brujah should play cards first.
>
> Now, reading the text in Blissful Agony, it seems to me that since the
> post-S:CE effect is "the opposing vampire ENTERS COMBAT with the
> chosen minion", in the above mentioned case, Meth B's Tremere is the
> acting minion in the new combat. Is it correct?

Neither minion is the acting minion.

Meth B's Tremere plays cards first, since she is higher in the priority
list than Meth C.:

1) Acting
2) (D)-Target/Blocker
3) Others (clockwise from Acting)

> If it is, the same would not happen in a new combat generated by
> Psyche! at superior is scheduled by a blocking minion, making him the
> acting minion now?

Psyche! wouldn't change the order of the combatants.

--
LSJ (vte...@white-wolf.com) V:TES Net.Rep for White Wolf, Inc.
Links to V:TES news, rules, cards, utilities, and tournament calendar:
http://www.white-wolf.com/vtes/

0 new messages