QUESTION: Ancient Influence
Eric Pettersen
can be played in a game." My question is: what exactly constitutes a
"play"? I've listed some situations below in order from what I think is
most likely a "play" to least likely. Where is the dividing line between
"play" and "non-play"?
1) Ancient Influence vote called and passed.
2) AI vote called and defeated.
3) AI vote called and cancelled (Telepathic Vote Counting, Delaying
Tactics).
4) Attempt to call AI vote, but blocked.
5) AI used to add 1 vote to some other referendum (possibly an AI
vote!).
---
Eric Pettersen
pe...@cgl.ucsf.edu (NeXTmail capable)
L. Scott Johnson
> The text on Ancient Influence says: "Only one Ancient Influence
>can be played in a game." My question is: what exactly constitutes a
>"play"? I've listed some situations below in order from what I think is
>most likely a "play" to least likely. Where is the dividing line between
>"play" and "non-play"?
> 1) Ancient Influence vote called and passed.
> 2) AI vote called and defeated.
>-------3) AI vote called and cancelled (Telepathic Vote Counting, Delaying
> Tactics).
> 4) Attempt to call AI vote, but blocked.
> 5) AI used to add 1 vote to some other referendum (possibly an AI
> vote!).
I would say that the line is before 3), because of the "cancelled" text
on the cards you mention. But, by virtue of the Sudden Reversal/Giant's
Blood ruling, it may fall immediately after 3).
It would certainly fall before 5), because the text on PAs burned for votes
is ignored altogether.
--
L. Scott Johnson (sjoh...@math.sc.edu) | These opinions are mine and
http://www.math.sc.edu/~sjohnson | are subject to card text.
Graphics Specialist and V:tES Rulemonger. |
Thomas R Wylie
As soon as you take an action to play Ancient Influence, you have used
up its one "play" for the game. It doesn't matter whether the action
is blocked, the vote is cancelled, etc. Burning AI for a vote doesn't
count as its one play for the game.
Tom Wylie rec.games.trading-cards.* Network Representative for
aa...@cats.ucsc.edu Wizards of the Coast, Inc.
Shane Travis
: As soon as you take an action to play Ancient Influence, you have used
: up its one "play" for the game. It doesn't matter whether the action
: is blocked, the vote is cancelled, etc. Burning AI for a vote doesn't
: count as its one play for the game.
How does this interact with the ruling on Giant's Blood then? IIRC, if
one plays a Giant's Blood and it is Sudden Reversal'd, then it doesn't
count as having been played; another could be played for positive effect
later on, no? Wouldn't that seem to indicate then that the card must be
_successfully_ played (i.e. not blocked) for it to count as 'played'?
(I may be recalling the GB ruling incorrectly; if so, I'm sure I'll be
corrected.)
Shane H.W. Travis | I try to take one day at a time,
tra...@duke.usask.ca | but sometimes several days attack at once.
Saskatoon, Saskatchewan | -- Ashleigh Brilliant
Thomas R Wylie
Shane Travis <tra...@duke.usask.ca> wrote:
>: As soon as you take an action to play Ancient Influence, you have used
>: up its one "play" for the game. It doesn't matter whether the action
>: is blocked, the vote is cancelled, etc. Burning AI for a vote doesn't
>: count as its one play for the game.
>How does this interact with the ruling on Giant's Blood then? IIRC, if
>one plays a Giant's Blood and it is Sudden Reversal'd, then it doesn't
>count as having been played; another could be played for positive effect
No. Sudden Reversal doesn't erase the fact that a card was played, it
just cancels the effects and and pool.