OK, I've gotta post my 2 cents here.
I like the EM's way more than the DMD's and most of the SS (although
some of the early SS were basically EMs w digital displays).
To me, pinball is all about the excitement of watching the ball race
around the playfield, and making skill shots to get the highest score.
EMs had light, bright playfields that had lots of open area for the ball
to travel around, make side to side shots, and the game rules were much
easier to understand. You can tell, even with fast ball action, which
target you need to hit next to enable a feature or score. Generally, the
play time per ball is about right, so that you don't get bored. The
mechanical bells/chimes have a true "ring" to them, are at a consistent
volume level, and provide the player with audible feedback on how well
they are scoring.
DMDs often have dark themes/playfields and flashing strobe lights that
make it difficult to visually track the ball. Often the playfield is
covered with ramps and other "toys" that reduce the playable area. It
may be fun to discover these toys when first played, but after that they
are pretty mundane. The flippers are often so strong that targets aren't
much of a challenge to hit, and many times the play time per ball is so
long, that you get bored and almost wish the ball would drain faster.
The synthesized sounds and voices are often distracting, and frequently
the volume is too loud or too soft. The DMD machines remind me of video
games, which I generally find pretty boring.
Maintenance wise, I would much rather repair an EM than a DMD. Most EM
problems are easy to locate if you have a schematic. Often times a
contact adjustment is all that is needed, or a stepper cleaning or
adjustment. DMD machine repairs often require parts that are not on
hand, are very expensive (a DMD or CPU board costs more than my EMs
did), and problems can be much more difficult to locate. When was the
last time you found an overheated connector in an EM? Burnt/failed
connectors are way too common in the SS/DMD machines. EMs have
relatively flat playfield glass that will hold a toolbox or a beer, try
that with many DMD machines, and your tools/drinks will be on the floor.
EM playfields are generally easy to lift and prop for maintenance, while
DMD playfields are often heavy/massive, have weird/crazy prop rods or
brackets, and some features are multiple layers deep- a PITA to get at.
Moving and setting up an EM is much easier, the head comes off easily,
and can be used to prop up the lower cabinet while installing the last 2
legs.
OK all you DMD lovers, flame on! To each their own, I will stick with
EMs.
Have a great Memorial Day all!
--
Tektune