Compute;1944454 Wrote:
> That sounds a lot more work than is necessary. We deal with counterfeit
> parts where I work, and they're typically harder to distinguish than
> that. Why use that much labor when you could probably buy damn near
> 18-pin DIP brand new for cheaper than the cost of doing all that work.
> It's not just DIPs they're doing it with, either. QFNs, even BGAs can
> be faked. It's not us hobbyists they're after, it's companies like the
> one I work for. We buy stuff in reels and tubes and trays, thousands at
> a time. That is where the money is.
We deal with counterfeit parts at work as well. Our lawyers have
actually gone after the counterfeiters on ebay but have pretty much
given up after endless filings, Ebay will yank the auction only to have
it reappear a day or two later.
Some manufacturers actually watch ebay for fakes. Some companies such
as Motorola and it's spinoffs apparently don't give a damn.
For users of newer parts, it is much harder to spot fakes. Even the
laser etched parts have pretty good fakes showing up.
But, for us on RGP where we use parts in which have been discontinued
for years, it isn't so hard to spot them. And, they do counterfeit most
everything... but most of us in RGP also don't use the other package
styles.
As for the counterfeitrs actually using this procedure to get parts. Yes
- they actually DO use this method. I have watched a documentary on
this where they show the whole beginning to end process. They get old
boards in, run them over torches to melt the solder then bang the boards
on coffee cans to collect the parts. They have other groups of people
that do nothing but sort parts. And other that do nothing more than
pretty them up.
Gotta remember, labor there is nothing. It costs less there for the
labor for reclaiming old parts than to buy brand new even if the new are
blanks.
You never know what you will get from them. Some of the parts are
recycled garbage guaranteed not to work. Some of the parts are
manufacturer rejects that were supposed to be scrapped but weren't.
Some of the parts are remarked slower or lower voltage/current versions
where they pass them off as a faster or more capable part. Once in a
while - you actually get what you wanted. It's a crap shoot. Some
people will actually gamble with purchasing these parts with hopes that
they will get parts that will work. They might but that's up to them.
I just think it's immoral to send them any money for parts that are
misrepresented.
Some people think this doesn't hurt anybody. Try explaining that to the
family of the victims in a recent helicopter crash which was attributed
to counterfeit components.
--
G-P-E