Investment. No, I don't mean monetary investment. I'm referring to
the investment of your time, and the investment of your skill, and the
investment of your creativity.
I come from the computer games industry.
(pauses to let the wailing and gnashing of teeth subside.)
As part of our next project we will be covering Warmaster as a
community and news web portal.
What we have found is that any game, whether it be a computer game,
board game, or a pen and paper game, is better if the player has an
investment in it.
Painting the miniatures in Warmaster gives most people a great sense
of accomplishment. They become *your* army moreso than if you just
stuck them on bases and played the game for the sake of playing.
When your hand-painted bone giant crashes into the hapless High Elf
spearmen it is more enjoyable when you have invested the time in
painting the gargantuan beast. It also hurts a lot more when he
falls in battle.
Painting also gives the player a secondary benefit, immersion.
Painted units look more realistic. It is easier to imagine a battle
between painted carrion and painted eagles than one between two pieces
of cardboard or between two white metal globs stuck on a black piece
of plastic.
Warmaster, and I'm sure Warhammer, are great games partially because
they give the player the following things:
1) Investment
2) Choice (army allocation, army look, terrain choice.. etc, etc,
etc,)
3) Emotion (How happy do you feel before and during and after the
game? How many other emotions run through your head while you play?)
Warmaster is a truly elegant game. It can be played simply or with a
great complexity that we have not even begun to see.
Hopefully I have made at least one person go, "Hey, he's right. I do
that."
I look forward to working with this community for the next few years.
Hopefully I can bring some of my gaming knowledge to its members. I
know that they will educate me beyond my wildest dreams in respect to
minatures.
See you on the battlefield.
JAH
johnN...@go2themax.com
(remove NOSPAM for e-mail)
http://community.webtv.net/Tiger40000/CodexImperialTigers
<snip merits of painting figs>
Altho I agree with your post about painting your miniatures, I'd like to
warn you this topic is banned in the r.g.m.w faq due to the highly
flammable subject matter.
- GB
Thank you.
My comment was not a pro or con comment though. It was merely an
outsider's look at what makes a game successful. Nearly all good
computer games have the factors I mentioned. I believe that those
factors are also found in good board games, miniature games, etc.
That is not to say that the factors I mentioned are a requirement for
a good game. Tetris for example has very little in the way of
investment or emotion. It was a very successful game nonetheless.
My intention was not to cause a flame-war. So far so good. I do
appreciate your warning however.
JAH
GRR OOT! HARK!! ME IZ DA GOD OF FLAMY FLAMES AND I PUT VOODOO FLAMEY
CURSE ON YOU! U EEZ FLAME ED NOWZ. GRR CHEESE!!! BE FLAMEY AND BURN WITH
FLAMEYNESS YOU FAQ BREAKY FLAME BAITY MAN. POO IS YOUR GOD, AND YOU
SMELL. I NO LIKE PAINT. PAINT BAD. FNORD. MY FIGURES ARE SO UNPAINTED
THEY ARE NEGATIVELY PAINTED. PAINT BAD. FLAME GOOD. FLAME! FLAME! I'M
FLIM FLAM FLAMING YOU! WHO PUT THE FLAME IN THE FLAMALAMA DING DONG? I
DID! FLAMEY FLAM FLAMADY FLAME! :P
~Screaming Vermillian
P.S. Jumpin' Jesus on a Pogo stick. No one's going to flame you. if they
do it will probally resemble the above. Nice comments, but they were a
little too happy and warm and commerade-esk for me. Anywho, this PS is
too long, so yeah.
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
Before you buy.
I don't play Warmaster myself, but I totally comprehend what you're talking
about. You're 100% right.
<< After crawling through numerous threads where people debated, and I'll use
that term loosely, the merits of painting your miniatures...
[SNIP!]
..."Hey, he's right. I do that.">>
Yeah, I do that.
<<I look forward to working with this community for the next few years.>>
Hope you brought your whip and chair to deal with the lions....
<< Hopefully I can bring some of my gaming knowledge to its members. I know
that they will educate me beyond my wildest dreams in respect to minatures.>>
With respect to miniature games as a whole, I daresay there are other
newsgroups that might prove more productive for you. There certainly seems to
be less static anyway on r.g.m.misc.
<< See you on the battlefield. >>
You've just stepped on it. Welcome to r.g.m.warhammer.....good luck....
Angulion wrote:
> With respect to miniature games as a whole, I daresay there are other
> newsgroups that might prove more productive for you. There certainly seems to
> be less static anyway on r.g.m.misc.
*yawn* yes, you are right about that.
--
The Rogue Trader Maitreya
Master Academic and Statistician, R.G.M.W.
Most Helpful Poster (shared title), R.G.M.W. Awards, 1999.
Plonker of many trolls, idiots, preachers, and spazoids.
http://mems.cwru.edu/~dan/personal/wh40k.html
Newbies: Read The FAQing Manual! RTfM at:
http://www.sheppard.demon.co.uk/rgmw_faq/rgmw_faq.htm
. . . .
"Hic locus est unus quo por fugiant, hic portus, haec arx, haec ara
soiorum." : "This is the only place to which they can flee for refuge,
for this is the haven, the citadel, the altar of our allies."
What a load of nonsence...... You sound as if you are speaking for
all gamers.
Of course a table full of painted figures look good, but if the drive
of the hobby is playing, then painting comes in last.
I have no problems about buying 1000 - 1200 points worth of army, and
then throwing them on the table as they are.
When i have been at a gaming evening, and i have had a good game,
win or lose, then I mesure the result in how mentally tired I am
afterwards.
Not in "wow my army was painted finer than his".
Of course my figs get painted eventually, but I find it boring, having
to wait to play untill my latest 1000 points are painted. Especially
when you know how slow I am at painting.
And the guys in my gaming club, don't have a problem with it either.
regards
Nightmare
"Accept that some days you are the pigeon and
some days the statue"
>I have no problems about buying 1000 - 1200 points worth of army, and
>then throwing them on the table as they are.
>When i have been at a gaming evening, and i have had a good game,
>win or lose, then I mesure the result in how mentally tired I am
>afterwards.
>Not in "wow my army was painted finer than his".
I agree 100%. I got into the game because it looked like fun to play, not
because I'm some great artist. I want to play. Sure, I love the way a
unit looks when it's all painted up nicely, but that's not my reason for
playing. Maybe other people really love to paint. That's cool, but not
everyone has the same reasons for participating in this hobby.
>Of course my figs get painted eventually, but I find it boring, having
>to wait to play untill my latest 1000 points are painted. Especially
>when you know how slow I am at painting.
>
>And the guys in my gaming club, don't have a problem with it either.
Yup, same here. I have a half painted Wood Elf army, and a totally
unpainted Lizardmen army (I've been working 75 hour weeks since I bought
them, they'll get done in due time).
-Nate
Apparently I hit a nerve. I certainly do not speak for all gamers.
Nor do I want to. My opinion on games is formulated from years of
working in the industry. Does that make it right? The answer is a
resounding maybe. It certainly doesn't make your opinion wrong.
There are so many schools of thought in the gaming industry that I
could literally write an article a day for 6 months and not put them
all in front of you.
The one that I happen to believe most accurately reflects what makes
good games great is the one I posted previously.
>Of course a table full of painted figures look good, but if the drive
>of the hobby is playing, then painting comes in last.
I obviously was not clear enough. The drive of any game is playing.
You are quite correct. That is, in essence, what makes it a game.
The investment, and other factors I mentioned are what enhance the
gameplay.
>
>I have no problems about buying 1000 - 1200 points worth of army, and
>then throwing them on the table as they are.
>When i have been at a gaming evening, and i have had a good game,
>win or lose, then I mesure the result in how mentally tired I am
>afterwards.
>Not in "wow my army was painted finer than his".
That wasn't the point. :) The point was that most players will be
more attached to units that they have painted than those that they
have not.
I would bet that most players remove non-painted units as casualties
before removing painted ones. Why? Investment. They feel more of
a connection to the painted armies than to those that are still bare.
>
>Of course my figs get painted eventually, but I find it boring, having
>to wait to play untill my latest 1000 points are painted. Especially
>when you know how slow I am at painting.
Here is a question I will put to you. Why do you paint them at all?
Does it enhance the gaming experience for you?
Remember, I never once said that figures must be painted in order to
play the game and have fun. I only said that I felt it enhanced the
gameplay.
>
>And the guys in my gaming club, don't have a problem with it either.
Nor should they. You play the game to have fun. Paint should not
take the fun away. It could be the sugar in your coffee or the icing
on your cake though. It could be that little extra that makes the
experience all the more enjoyable.
Hopefully I clarified my thoughts for you. Once our site is live to
the public I will open a public forum so that topics like this can be
discussed in a depth not really available in a newsgroup.
See you on the battlefield.
Very true. Apparently I was not clear enough. My point wasn't that
painting was a necessity to play. My point was that painting
enchanced the gameplay experience.
(...)
>FLAMALAMA DING DONG?
I swear this was a line in an ELO song.
-Shim.
>On Tue, 4 Apr 2000 09:24:59 -0400, Nate Finch <na...@wpi.edu> wrote:
>>
>>I agree 100%. I got into the game because it looked like fun to play, not
>>because I'm some great artist. I want to play. Sure, I love the way a
>>unit looks when it's all painted up nicely, but that's not my reason for
>>playing. Maybe other people really love to paint. That's cool, but not
>>everyone has the same reasons for participating in this hobby.
>
>Very true. Apparently I was not clear enough. My point wasn't that
>painting was a necessity to play. My point was that painting
>enchanced the gameplay experience.
Yes, I can see that. Much in the way cheerleaders enhance a football
game. They don't change the game at all, but they make it more visually
appealing, and if the other side has them and your side doesn't, you're
going to feel like they have some kind of psychological advantage.
It's good to see someone on this newsgroup with a level head and the
ability to understand someone else's viewpoint. I'm fairly new, but most
of what I've seen is bickering. I hope to see more posts like these.
-Nate
Amin
Nate Finch <na...@wpi.edu> wrote in message
news:Pine.OSF.4.21.00040...@wpi.WPI.EDU...
However, the w&b bunch who gripe about the prices of GW merchandise DO tend
to grab my attention, and occasionally I tend to agree with them. But then,
I'm an old fart with a memory long enough to remember buying an AMT Mustang
for $5.00, including tax!
So shoot me again. Big deal.
The Mad Yank
Amin_Ibrahim <Amin_I...@baylor.edu> wrote in message
news:8cdlmt$6if$1...@ccis12.baylor.edu...
<snip>
>Hopefully I clarified my thoughts for you. Once our site is live to
>the public I will open a public forum so that topics like this can be
>discussed in a depth not really available in a newsgroup.
>
>See you on the battlefield.
>
<snip>
How nice to have a reply without @$%&*^#@@ included. :-)
I see that we have a fairly similar view on the game... And also how
true that casualties almost allways are from the unpainted figs.
I will be looking forward to your open forum. Keep up the good work.
May your victories be many and bloody...
Regards
Cheers,
--
Moramarth
-Nate
John Secker <jo...@secker.demon.co.uk> wrote in article
<kZ3RVLAm...@secker.demon.co.uk>...
Ahhh, the lost art of polite conversation.
--
Big Al
The Doctor is in.
Email: neur...@defilernet.com
RGMWeb - The Premier RGMW Website!
Now with extra Vitamin C and Zinc for
your unpleasant acne affliction!
http://www.defilernet.com/rgmweb
Clanlord of Clan Wenskab and Bitch-King of
Naggaroth, Arch-Magus of the Church of the
Blessed Children
* Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet's Discussion Network *
The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet - Free!
Cheers,
--
Moramarth
--
"LONG LIVE EMPEROR KARL FRANZ!" - Boris Todbringer, Elector Count of
Middenland
Be sure to remove all the SPAM from the can, and my email address
iPad wrote in message <23570238...@usw-ex0107-050.remarq.com>...
I agree. And just as a side note, "Investment" can not only apply to
painting your minis but also to how you put them together. Chances are you
will care more about squad A who's figures were carefully built and who's
sergeant you spent hours painstakingly converting than squad B who's minis
were just pulled off the sprues and slapped together. Basically any mini
you spend a lot of time on will give you a sense of "Investment".
--
- smithdoerr
>I agree. And just as a side note, "Investment" can not only apply to
>painting your minis but also to how you put them together. Chances are you
>will care more about squad A who's figures were carefully built and who's
>sergeant you spent hours painstakingly converting than squad B who's minis
>were just pulled off the sprues and slapped together. Basically any mini
>you spend a lot of time on will give you a sense of "Investment".
>
>--
>
>- smithdoerr
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
-Viper
without the minis, warhammer would just turn into a combat version of ad&d
(with much quicker rules)
Same here... I play maybe once a month if I'm lucky, but I paint nearly
every night. I paint slowly and carefully; there is no reason to rush
through figures that I won't use for a few weeks.
Its taken me almost 4 years to get my space marine army up to almost
4000 points, but now I have a great looking army to show for it.
And, just like you, I'd rather have the better painted army than win the
game (altho I like winning too!).
- GB
Amin
GB Bowes <gbb...@home.com> wrote in message news:38EF8C...@home.com...
Amin
Viper12873 <viper...@aol.com> wrote in message
news:20000408124736...@ng-fx1.aol.com...
I know just how you feel, my assault squad took weeks to paint. It took
2-3 nights of painting for each figure. Don't even ask how long it took
me to paint my dread.
Just started my LotD, and even after spraying them black, it takes two
nights of work to paint one. (I always paint after coming home from
work at 11pm).
I feel your pain...
- GB
> Just started my LotD, and even after spraying them black, it takes two
> nights of work to paint one. (I always paint after coming home from
> work at 11pm).
>
How in the world can you possibly stretch the LotD into that much work?
Especially since I know you rarely mix your own colors.
Rob Fungsang
Amin
GB Bowes <gbb...@home.com> wrote in message news:38F0ED...@home.com...
> Amin_Ibrahim wrote:
> >
> > My problem is that I go to town on each individual miniature. I'm
getting
> > rid of my Dark Angels, and starting up my own vanilla chapter that uses
only
> > marines. I have so far painted 3 minis. Only 113 to go. Arghghghghg
> >
> > Amin
>
> I know just how you feel, my assault squad took weeks to paint. It took
> 2-3 nights of painting for each figure. Don't even ask how long it took
> me to paint my dread.
>
> Just started my LotD, and even after spraying them black, it takes two
> nights of work to paint one. (I always paint after coming home from
> work at 11pm).
>
> Amin_Ibrahim wrote:
> >
> > My problem is that I go to town on each individual miniature. I'm getting
> > rid of my Dark Angels, and starting up my own vanilla chapter that uses only
> > marines. I have so far painted 3 minis. Only 113 to go. Arghghghghg
> >
> > Amin
>
> I know just how you feel, my assault squad took weeks to paint. It took
> 2-3 nights of painting for each figure. Don't even ask how long it took
> me to paint my dread.
>
> Just started my LotD, and even after spraying them black, it takes two
> nights of work to paint one. (I always paint after coming home from
> work at 11pm).
>
> I feel your pain...
I feel pain already. My army is entirely LotD with some non-LotD stuff thrown in
to make it usable as a normal SM unit. And I have 80+ figs to complete (most are
primed black, just waiting for another warm day to finish). Getting the bones and
flames just right is a real pain. And I don't look forward to my Rhinos,
Landspeeders and Dreadnoughts (yes, plural - got 2 of 'em). *sigh*
And I never seem to have the energy or ambition to work on them. Just keep
working on the various conversions I want (my standard bearer has pieces from 8
completely different models and 3 different GW games). My dremel is just too much
fun to play with. *sigh* Must stop converting and start painting.
Anyone else have this problem??
Devin
>
>
> - GB
> I'm a relatively new WH40K player, although I ran a brigade in BattleTech
> for @2 years (well, a short brigade - 2 regiments. So shoot me!)
*bang*
So what drew you to 40K from BT??
Devin
Cmdr, LotD, Prairies
Major, Intelligence and Operations, 3rd Light Brigade, SLDF
First night (I paint about 1-2 hours a night) I paint the flames and
bones on the main body which can be quite difficult to get the right
effect. If there is a lot of detail it can take awhile, if there isn't
I can do the whole figure (arms, weapons, bakcpack) in one night.
Otherwise, the next night I paint the bolt pistol and CCW as well as cut
and greenstuff the arms for different poses, and then paint the
backpacks which all have two large skulls on them that look horrible if
rushed thru. I suppose I could paint faster, but I hate correcting
mistakes, so I just try to avoid making *any* in the first place.
Example: To paint bones and skulls, they must be painted bestial brown,
then bleached bone, then skull white in progressively smaller amounts.
the flames are easier; paint them bad moon yellow, then fiery orange at
the bottom, then a watery layer of bad moon yellow to blend the two
colors together, then white at the tips of the flames.
Yes, I've tried the "assembly line" style of painting and it is faster,
but boring as hell to do the same thing over and over and over. This
way I get a little painting variety in one session.
When it comes to vehicles, I can crank those out with a big brush... I
can paint an entire rhino or rhino variant in 1-2 days of painting. I
love painting vehicles.
Oh, and I do mix my own colors for highlighting now.
- GB
> I love it when people gape in awe at my minis.
As good a reason to do a great paint job as I've ever heard.
Try doing some stuff in Epic though - especially conversions.
You get the same effect with less work.
e.g.
http://www.egroups.com/files/epic/Images/GOFFIK2.JPG
(Epic scale Goffik Rok Band Conversion - lead singer)
http://www.egroups.com/files/epic/Images/GOFFIK3.JPG
(Drum Kit for same)
http://www.egroups.com/files/epic/Images/SANDWM2.JPG
How big is a Sandworm compared to:
A Space Marine Squad?
A Land Raider?
An Imperator Titan?
<<snip>>
Would it bad form for me to mention that I've painted roughly 1000 points of
Warmaster Undead in roughly 3 days? :)
Richard the Other, Critic of all things Elf, Fan of all things red, Defender of
Fun
When my Empire arrive, I'm going to town on them. Each one will look
amazing. I can't wait.
Amin
Richard B <ldaz...@aol.combadspam> wrote in message
news:20000410164045...@ng-fa1.aol.com...