On Mon, 1 Aug 2022 07:14:15 -0700 (PDT), Justisaur
<
just...@gmail.com> wrote:
>>>BFP took quite a hit, as they were at 11 vs. 5 now. 3.5
>>>ealso had 13 and is now down to 1.
>>>As to AD&D 1e is gone now, where there were 2 or 3
>>>games before. Oe took a hit as it was between 3-5
>>>(counting a couple clones) and is now only 2 if you
>>>include Black Hack. 2e went up in popularity a lot,
>>>being previously 2 games. LotFP is gone, there was
>>>one game previously. DCC gained 1 game.
>> No 4th Ed D&D at all? Wow... gamers really dropped that version
>> quickly. I thought the outrage over how disliked it was disliked was
>> the Internet being its usual self (mind you, I wasn't fond of the
>> system either, but I'm peculiar ;-) , but seeing it so quickly
>> abandoned makes me think that maybe it really /was/ that hated.
>I wasn't quite so interested in the non-OSR stuff, so didn't report
>how many of each of those there were, but I went back and
>double checked, absolutely no 4th edition games. Well, o.k.
>there was one, 4th edition of Champions :)
>There was one 13th Age game, which was based off of 4e.
>From what I've read of it, it's not really very 4e though and probably
>further from 4e than most OSR games are from 3e/5e.
4th Edition D&D: the "Windows Vista" of the pen-n-paper role-playing
world. Irrationally hated by most users even though it included most
of what people had been asking for in a new version at that point, and
many of its features continued to persist in the rebranded successor
that was beloved largely because it wasn't Vista/4E.
Which isn't to say either product was faultless or up to the standards
and expectations of their predecessors/sequels... but the dislike both
products garnered seemed out of proportion to its problems. Had D&D
4th Ed been released as "Bob's Fantasy Role-playing Game" it probably
would have been much better received.
I mean, I didn't like 4th Ed either, but I /know/ my dislike is
irrational and I didn't hold that against 4th Edition in particular. I
just like don't like ANY modern rules systems ;-)