Left wing piss water favorite Pabst says MillerCoors is trying to put it out of business

[Rob Woodward]

MILWAUKEE — Pabst Brewing Company and MillerCoors are going to trial,
with hipster favorite Pabst contending that MillerCoors wants to put
it out of business by ending a longstanding partnership through which
it brews Pabst’s beers.

The case has high stakes for Pabst, whose lawyers argue that the
company’s very existence relies on the partnership with Chicago-based
MillerCoors, which produces, packages and ships nearly all its
products, which include Pabst Blue Ribbon, Old Milwaukee, Natty Boh
and Lone Star. MillerCoors, meanwhile, says it’s not obligated to
continue brewing for Pabst and that Pabst doesn’t want to pay enough
to justify doing so.

The trial in Milwaukee County Circuit Court begins Monday and is
scheduled through Nov. 30.

Pabst’s attorneys have said in court documents and hearings that
MillerCoors LLC is lying about its brewing capacity to break away from
Pabst and capture its share of the cheap beer market by disrupting
Pabst’s ability to compete. At a March hearing in which MillerCoors
tried to have the lawsuit dismissed, Pabst attorney Adam Paris said
“stunning documents” obtained from MillerCoors show that it went as
far as hiring a consultant to “figure out ways to get rid of us.”
MillerCoors has called that a mischaracterization of the consultant’s
work.

The 1999 agreement between MillerCoors and Pabst, which was founded in
Milwaukee in 1844 but is now headquartered in Los Angeles, expires in
2020 but provides for two possible five-year extensions. The companies
dispute how the extensions should be negotiated: MillerCoors argues
that it has sole discretion to determine whether it can continue
brewing for Pabst, whereas Pabst says the companies must work “in good
faith” to find a solution if Pabst wants to extend the agreement but
MillerCoors lacks the capacity.

Pabst needs 4 million to 4.5 million barrels brewed annually and
claims MillerCoors is its only option. It is seeking more than $400
million in damages and for MillerCoors to be ordered to honor its
contract.

During 2015 negotiations about extending the contract, MillerCoors
announced it would close its brewing facility in Eden, North Carolina,
and that it eventually might have to shutter another facility in
Irwindale, California. Pabst contends that MillerCoors refused to
provide any information to substantiate its claim that it would no
longer have the capacity to continue brewing Pabst’s beers, and that
it wouldn’t consider leasing the Eden facility and would only sell it
for an “astronomical” price.

Pabst says MillerCoors wouldn’t agree to an extension unless Pabst
paid $45 per barrel — “a commercially devastating, near-triple price
increase” from what it pays now. At the March hearing, Paris said
MillerCoors knew Pabst couldn’t accept that proposal “because it would
have bankrupted us three times over.”

In court filings, MillersCoors said Pabst’s proposals to keep the Eden
facility open “were commercially unreasonable” and that Pabst sought
“a windfall through litigation” instead of offering to pay enough to
keep a facility open. It also said the facility’s closing was “to
ensure the longer-term sustainability” of MillerCoors because
thousands of new brewers have entered the market over the past decade.

MillerCoors and Anheuser-Busch, which have the biggest U.S. market
share at 24.8 percent and 41.6 percent, respectively, have been losing
business to smaller independent brewers, imports, and wine and spirits
in recent years, according to the Brewers Association.

“The beer market has shifted and beer lovers are increasingly
demanding more variety, fuller-flavor, and local products from small
and independent producers,” said Bart Watson, the Brewers
Association’s chief economist.

Overall U.S. beer sales have declined, with shipments down from 213.1
million barrels in 2008 to 204.2 million in 2017, according to the
Brewers Association.

Pabst depends on MillerCoors because the only other U.S. brewer with
capacity to make its products is Anheuser-Busch, which doesn’t do
contract brewing, Paris said.

“It really is an existential issue for Pabst because it has no real
alternatives,” Paris said at the March hearing.

Paris said the report from the consultant MillerCoors hired in 2013
proves the company never intended to act in good faith. Pabst’s
attorneys say the report had sections focused on how to “eliminate
Pabst altogether” and noted that MillerCoors would need to close two
breweries “to be sure they don’t have excess capacity for contract
manufacturing.”

MillerCoors’ attorney, Eric Van Vugt, said in court that the company
didn’t rely on the consultant’s report when it decided to close Eden
or when it has contemplated closing the Irwindale brewery.
“If we keep Irwindale open, yes, we can supply their beer,” Van Vugt
said. “No one disputes that. That’s the only factor that we need to
look at.”

https://www.mercurynews.com/2018/11/11/pabst-says-millercoors-is-trying-to-put-it-out-of-business/