Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Substitute for baking powder?

16 views
Skip to first unread message

Ephraim Vishniac

unread,
Jan 29, 1994, 1:17:12 PM1/29/94
to

What other leavening agents can I use (and in what quantities) when
recipes call for baking powder? My problem is that baking powder is
primarily cornstarch, and I'm allergic to all corn products.

--
Ephraim Vishniac Thinking Machines Corporation ...for by error of some
eph...@think.com 245 First Street calculator the vessel often
Cambridge, MA 02142 splits upon a rock that should
have reached a friendly pier...

Bruce Smith

unread,
Feb 1, 1994, 10:07:44 AM2/1/94
to
In article <2ie978...@early-bird.think.com> eph...@think.com (Ephraim Vishniac) writes:
>
>What other leavening agents can I use (and in what quantities) when
>recipes call for baking powder? My problem is that baking powder is
>primarily cornstarch, and I'm allergic to all corn products.
>
I consulted three cookbooks--and got three different answers. The ingredients
used for substitution were the same in each case: cream of tartar and baking
soda. I seem to remember having done this same substitution successfully.
The two most likely proportions are:
For one teaspoon of baking powder use 1/2 tsp. cream of tartar and 1/4 tsp.
baking soda.
For one tsp. baking powder use 1 tsp. cream of tartar and 1/2 tsp. baking soda.
The third formula involved measuring 5/8 tsp. of one of the ingredients. That
was in, I believe, the Joy of Cooking. Given the other options, I prefer not
to deal with measuring 5/8 tsp., which requires either using 2 measuring spoons
or estimating. (Does anyone have a 5/8 tsp. measurer?)

In any case, neither bakibg soda nor cream of tartar contains cornstarch.

Bruce Smith

Ben A. Fairbank

unread,
Feb 1, 1994, 12:42:01 PM2/1/94
to
>In article <2ie978...@early-bird.think.com> eph...@think.com (Ephraim Vishniac) writes:
>>
>>What other leavening agents can I use (and in what quantities) when
>>recipes call for baking powder? My problem is that baking powder is
>>primarily cornstarch, and I'm allergic to all corn products.
>
Since cornstarch does not contribute to the leavening of the mixture it
is added to, I suspect that it is there only to keep the leaveners from
caking or clumping. Do you know what percentage is cornstarch?
Thus if you add a teaspooon of baking powder to
a recipe that serves four, a single serving will have a quarter of a
teaspoon of baking powder which will contain rather little cornstarch. If
you are sensitive enough to react to such concentrations, you should also
be aware that confectioner's (or powdered) sugar usually also contains about
four percent corn starch, also to keep it from caking up. Eternal vigilance
is the price of health...
Ben Fairbank


Ephraim Vishniac

unread,
Feb 2, 1994, 11:47:43 AM2/2/94
to
In article <1994Feb1.1...@ringer.cs.utsa.edu> b...@lonestar.utsa.edu (Ben A. Fairbank) writes:
>>In article <2ie978...@early-bird.think.com> eph...@think.com (Ephraim Vishniac) writes:

>>>What other leavening agents can I use (and in what quantities) when
>>>recipes call for baking powder? My problem is that baking powder is
>>>primarily cornstarch, and I'm allergic to all corn products.

>Since cornstarch does not contribute to the leavening of the mixture it
>is added to, I suspect that it is there only to keep the leaveners from
>caking or clumping. Do you know what percentage is cornstarch?

On one brand of baking powder it's the first ingredient; on another
it's the last. Since I doubt the brands are really very different, I'm
tempted to guess that a typical baking powder is about one-third
cornstarch.

BTW, another respondent tells me that Featherweight brand baking
powder is made with potato starch and is also sodium-free, for those
of you on restricted-salt diets.

>Thus if you add a teaspooon of baking powder to
>a recipe that serves four, a single serving will have a quarter of a
>teaspoon of baking powder which will contain rather little cornstarch. If
>you are sensitive enough to react to such concentrations, you should also
>be aware that confectioner's (or powdered) sugar usually also contains about
>four percent corn starch, also to keep it from caking up. Eternal vigilance
>is the price of health...

I don't know exactly how little corn it takes to produce a reaction,
but I do know that eating baked goods I didn't make myself (say, one
cookie a day from Michela's) is enough to sustain a mild reaction. Two
aspirin a day (aspirin tablets are mostly cornstarch) for a couple of
days is enough to produce a severe reaction, which is why I only take
Alka-Seltzer now. So, confectioner's sugar should probably join my
list :-(.

--
Ephraim Vishniac Thinking Machines Corporation One of the flaws in the
eph...@think.com 245 First Street anarchic bopper society
Cambridge, MA 02142 was the ease with which
such crazed rumors could spread.

aly...@news.delphi.com

unread,
Feb 6, 1994, 7:42:14 PM2/6/94
to
bsm...@osf.org (Bruce Smith) writes:

>In article <2ie978...@early-bird.think.com> eph...@think.com (Ephraim Vishniac) writes:
>>
>>What other leavening agents can I use (and in what quantities) when
>>recipes call for baking powder? My problem is that baking powder is
>>primarily cornstarch, and I'm allergic to all corn products.
>>

You can use arrowroot powder in place of cornstarch. It even works
as a thickener, like corn starch does.

To make baking powder, I use 1 part baking soda, 2 parts cream of tartar,
and 2 parts arrowroot.

Speaking of corn allergies, I heard somewhere that the glue on some postage
stamps is corn-based.

Blake (aly...@delphi.com)

0 new messages