Some years back I made a small effort to find a good match for the SH nextel paint. In that process, I found this ultra flat quick dry product from myperfectcolor.
It dries very quickly and once it's dried for a day or so doesn't smell and isn't tacky, even with multiple coats. It dries fast enough that you can re-coat in minutes and has held up very well long term.
While I took the SH glare shield cover down to my local Lowes to try to get a paint match, Lowes was only willing/able to cross to the nearest paint color available at Lowes and not willing to give me the color specifications.
What I ended up with was close-ish, but definitely not a match when held up side by side.
I much prefer this stuff over the Rustoleum or Krylon, etc.
https://www.myperfectcolor.com/en/product/994554_Hedrix-Spray-Paint-11oz-Ultra-Flat-Fast-Dry-Acrylic-Enamel