micky <
NONONO...@fmguy.com> wrote:
> VanguardLH <V...@nguard.LH> wrote:
>
>> micky <
NONONO...@fmguy.com> wrote:
>>
>>> People laughed at me when I said I wanted a desktop and a laptop with
>>> a DVD drive. No one uses those anymore, they taunted me.
>>
>> My up-vote on suggestions by others: get a USB-attached DVD drive, or
>> even a USB-attached CD/DVD/BD drive. No need for a built-in one.
>
> Good for home, but I wouldn't have had it with me at my brother's, in
> Florida.
>
> I feel good when I know I'm packin'.
That's what carry bags are for: to pack more than the laptop. You
travel without the A/C adapter to charge your laptop? I also pack a BT
mouse and keyboard. And even some pens and paper. And sometimes even a
USB-attached HDD, SSD, or flash stick for more storage of data, and off
the drive with the partition for the OS and apps. And a powered USB hub
since the laptop has a dearth of USB ports. I don't recall seeing
anyone board an airplane with a nude laptop. They're always in a tote.
But, in your case, you already had a built-in optical drive. However,
the arguments were not against that, but that a built-in one is not a
necessity as you claim. All those folks that laughed at you simply
chose a different setup: a non-built-in optical drive via USB.
>> If the attached one breaks, get another USB one. If you break the
>> one in the desktop, you'll have to open the case to replace it.
>
> I can do that. I already have a spare one. You have to transfer the
> outside cover from the old one to the new one.
The comparison you split was about the difficulty of replacing an
optical drive if it breaks versus one inside a desktop.
You're transferring a cover from old to new WHAT? Between laptops?
Disassembling a laptop is a hell of lot more work than of a desktop.
And moving a USB-attached optical drive is even far more easy than
opening laptops to swap optical drives. I have an optical drive in my
laptop. Much easier to plug in a USB one should the internal one break.
Or does "cover" mean the faceplate on the desktop tower? Again, the
comparison was showing the greater difficulty of replacing a broken
optical drive in a laptop versus in a desktop. For my next laptop, I
would NOT get an internal optical drive. I'd stow a USB-attached one in
the laptop's tote bag. I wouldn't limit my candidates for purchase to
only those with internal optical drives. If the price were the same
between with and without optical drive, yeah, I'd get internal.
>> Even harder in a laptop to replace it.
>
> I practially had the DVD drive out when I changed the bad hdd for an
> SDD and added some RAM
That's a different scenario. You had the laptop disassembled for
something ELSE, so you decided to do more. Changing the optical drive
was coincidental, not intentional.
You didn't buy the laptop with an optical drive already installed? Or
are you still focused on what you did with your desktop when the issue
is about optical drives in a laptop?