On Wed, 15 Aug 2012 10:21:17 -0700, Arthur Lipscomb
-----
Okay that is a totally different thing all together whch is why I said
if it was a supernatural being..
>
>Second, you can *not* be serious! Are you saying a dog or any animal
>can hear and smell through a car and a wall with such precision that
>assuming it could drive, it could drive a truck through the wall and
>*only* hit the bad guy?
------
The heightened senses of the mythical werewolf is *based* on the real
life better hearing of a wolf. The supernatural ability exaggerates
this so the were it could do it if the bad guy was making noise-or
maybe just hearing his heart beat. To repeat in this hypothetiical
case it is *based* on reality, giving it plausibility, not literally
real.
>
>A professional sniper who can actually *see* the target still waits for
>a clear shot, what you're suggesting is the equivalent of firing a
>rocket launcher blind in the general vicinity of the hostages using
>sonar to aim.
>
>Third, you can *not* be serious!
-------
It is a supernatural show, so it can't be.
The proper sniper analogy would be with one of the werewolves taking a
rifle, closing his eyes, then ranges and fires on the target with just
his hearing alone from say 200 yards. Now yes that would be impossible
for us mere mortals but that what makes it a supernatural ability,
that the werewolf's hearing is acute enough together enough sound
information that he can do that..
But if it was a werewolf we were talking about and from the above in
this post t wasn't-then I can believe that t could hear or smell with
enough accuracy to ht the target without seeing it. The analogy with a
sniper is not accurate in this case because we are talking about human
snipers who rely on sight and you are assuming the werewolves would be
the same.
The werewolves don't have to rely on sight. Their ears are as good as
our eyes if not much better so they don't have to rely on seeing. That
is *our* bias because we are visual creatures. So in that vain I am
serious because the supernatural premise is that that ability is
superhuman and so they can do it and we with our comparatively deaf
ears have to rely on actually seeing the target.
However, now that you have pointed out that it was a mere human who
supposed to have that uncanny ability, then that is a different story
and so yes it would be hard to believe that a human could do that, but
if it was a werewolf driving the car I am willing to believe that a
werewolf with its far superior hearing could rely on the sound
information alone and get an accurate fix on a target even if it
doesn't' see it, because its ears are as good as a human sniper's
eyes. Unbelievable? Well I guess that what makes it supernatural.:-)
Again, if one can prepare to believe that a being can morph from a
human to a part wolf or absorb the pain of other beings then yes I am
serious that I am willing to suspend disbelief and accept a werewolf
could hear its target well enough to hit the target crashing trough a
wall because I can see a way based on what is known about wolves in
real life that makes it plausible. They do have far superior hearing
than human but of curse they cannot morph or absorb pain. You see what
I'm getting aat now? The other supernatural aspects are impossible but
the hearing is at least based on real life. The supernatural aspect of
that exaggerates this ability to, well, supernatural levels.
But since it was fully human then the augment is moot and so it would
be unbelievable in this case.
Generally ths is a supenatural show. Many impossible thiings happen.
The thought of a being wth superhearing is able to target something
he can't see and hit it is the least improbable thing about the show.