Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Y&R Poll - Best and Worst Actor/Actress Ever

525 views
Skip to first unread message

bacardilimonboy

unread,
Aug 23, 2002, 12:36:55 PM8/23/02
to
Okay, let's start Friday off on a bitchy note... Who do you think is
the single worst actor and actress ever to "grace" Y&R's screen? It
can be someone current or from the old days... Someone who's delivery
was so bad you wonder how they even made it past the first audition,
let alone being approved by the network. And you can't vote for
Lauralee Bell (who I happen to like) because she's too easy of an
answer since most people on here seem to depsise her. My votes are:

Worst Actor of all time: Joshua Morrow (Nicholas)
Worst Actress of all time: Shari Shattuck (-ex Ashley)

Ian J. Ball

unread,
Aug 23, 2002, 2:30:03 PM8/23/02
to
In article <d5b694a.02082...@posting.google.com>,
bacardi...@yahoo.com (bacardilimonboy) wrote:

> Worst Actor of all time: Joshua Morrow (Nicholas)
> Worst Actress of all time: Shari Shattuck (-ex Ashley)

I don't consider Morrow the "worst", but I think Shattuck may be the
single worst *recast* in soap opera history.

--
Ian J. Ball | "Do you know why I left you to die? - Because you're
TV lover, and | just so uncompromisingly *inferior*!" - Tyr Anasazi,
Usenet slacker | from the "Andromeda" episode "Exit Strategies"
ib...@san.rr.com | http://members.aol.com/IJBall/WWW/TV.html

Carol

unread,
Aug 23, 2002, 3:12:54 PM8/23/02
to
>bacardi...@yahoo.com (bacardilimonboy) virtually pens:

Worst Actor: Heath Kizzier (ex-Josh Landers), Joshua Morrow, Granville Van
Dusen (ex-Keith Dennison)
Worst Actress: Shari Shattuck, Jennifer Gareis (Grace), Diana Barton (ex-Mary
Jo)

Carol Frilegh

unread,
Aug 23, 2002, 4:18:43 PM8/23/02
to

Some of my favorite "bests":

Rick Hearst (Matt Clark)
Michelle Stafford (Phylliss Abbott)
Camaryn Grimes (Cassie)
Sabryn Genet (Trisha)
Tamara Clutterbuck (Alice Johnson)

In article
<iball***SPAM-No***-E7E171.113...@orngca-news03.socal.rr.com>,

ravelation

unread,
Aug 23, 2002, 5:58:38 PM8/23/02
to
Tom Bierdz was pretty bad as Phillip.
Shari Shattuck was worse.

Best actor's gotta be Christian LeBlanc (who was picked by Heather Tom
to be stranded on a deserted island with).
My favorite actress is Melody Thomas Scott.

Ravl
hoping Phil won't be all bent outta shape cause I didn't cute and past.
;)

Ian J. Ball

unread,
Aug 23, 2002, 6:42:02 PM8/23/02
to
In article <230820021618435669%c...@sympatico.ca>,
Carol Frilegh <c...@sympatico.ca> wrote:

> Some of my favorite "bests":
>
> Rick Hearst (Matt Clark)
> Michelle Stafford (Phylliss Abbott)
> Camaryn Grimes (Cassie)
> Sabryn Genet (Trisha)

You forgot Ashley Jones (Megan)! ;)

HTH! :D

Phil R.

unread,
Aug 23, 2002, 6:48:32 PM8/23/02
to
ravl wrote:

>hoping Phil won't be all bent outta shape cause I didn't cute and past.

Nah, because the actual question is in the header. You're safe.

--Phil

Aaron

unread,
Aug 23, 2002, 8:14:54 PM8/23/02
to
Here are my favorites
Sharon (Sharon Case)
Nicholas (Joshua Morrow)
Nikki (Melody Thomas Scott)
Victor ( Eric Braedon)


"Phil R." <ihaveeve...@aol.complicated> wrote in message
news:20020823184832...@mb-mq.aol.com...

Carol Frilegh

unread,
Aug 23, 2002, 8:12:56 PM8/23/02
to
Sje was nice but not one of my favorites. I like them with a dash of
spark.

In article
<iball***SPAM-No***-0F4DFC.154...@orngca-news03.socal.rr.com>,


Ian J. Ball <iball***SPAM-No***@san.rr.com> wrote:

H&S&Knees

unread,
Aug 23, 2002, 8:36:35 PM8/23/02
to
Oh come on, J.Morrow is not the worst actor. He can be pretty darn good at
times. His "angry" is a little over the top though. I saw him in a USA movie
and he was really good! I think his Newman character is written poorly most
of the time.


Pea

unread,
Aug 23, 2002, 9:50:27 PM8/23/02
to
bacardi...@yahoo.com (bacardilimonboy) wrote in message news:<d5b694a.02082...@posting.google.com>...


Worst actress on Y&R: the woman who played Mari Jo Mason
Worst actor - I have to go with Ronn Moss - Ridge on B&B.

Lonnie

unread,
Aug 23, 2002, 11:51:37 PM8/23/02
to
Worst Actor of all time: (Paul Williams)
Worst Actress of all time: Melanie Thomas (Nikki Newman) Never could act and
the thought of how terrible she was when she first cam on board. She is
still the same.

"Pea" <tara...@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:f4bfa101.02082...@posting.google.com...

Danishone2

unread,
Aug 24, 2002, 5:38:57 PM8/24/02
to
>From: "Lonnie" lonni...@attbi.com

>Worst Actor of all time: (Paul Williams)
>Worst Actress of all time: Melanie Thomas (Nikki Newman) Never could act and
>the thought of how terrible she was when she first cam on board. She is
>still the same.

If there were any flaming doubts that you are clueless when it comes to judging
acting ability, this post of yours should completely extinguish them.

Lonnie...isn't that a Latin word for "thick"?


DM


Lambofsorrows

unread,
Aug 24, 2002, 7:30:18 PM8/24/02
to
Fav actress Grace Gareis and Eileen Davidson
Fav actor: Peter Bergman, Scott Reeves, Greg Vaughn

Nancy Johnston

unread,
Aug 24, 2002, 9:07:23 PM8/24/02
to
ex-Ashley
Nu-Mac
In my opinion, although you never asked for it, the best on Y&R is Jill!
She really emotes! :-)
Nancy Jane

WB

unread,
Aug 25, 2002, 1:00:16 AM8/25/02
to
Worst actor - that kid who plays Nate
Best actor - the guy that plays Michael Baldwin, the woman who plays
Phyllis (the current one, NOT the other stand in lady from before), and
the guy who plays Miguel

wb
"Nancy Johnston" <nancy.j...@ns.sympatico.ca> wrote in message
news:3D682B08...@ns.sympatico.ca...

soapfan4

unread,
Aug 25, 2002, 2:49:20 PM8/25/02
to
"WB" <donotspa...@jps.net> wrote in message
news:AvZ99.5573$ld4.5...@newsread2.prod.itd.earthlink.net...

> Worst actor - that kid who plays Nate
> Best actor - the guy that plays Michael Baldwin, the woman who plays
> Phyllis (the current one, NOT the other stand in lady from before), and
> the guy who plays Miguel
>
> wb

I've complained often about little Bryant Jones, who plays Nate. I found
him to be an unusually stilted and untalented child actor, even while I felt
terrible saying it b/c he seems to be such a nice kid off-screen, well-liked
by his colleagues on the show, as well as a child who has been through an
awful lot lately (the untimely death of his 30-year-old father to leukemia,
and having to act out the death of his on-screen father shortly thereafter).
But he seems to finally be coming into his own as an actor--gone is the
wooden delivery, as well as the blank stares. He can actually say his lines
now with some conviction, and he shows emotion with a lot more believability
than before. So I give him a "Most Improved" standing for now.

I do agree with your "bests," though. Michelle Stafford and Christian
LeBlanc are, far and away, the outstanding actors on this show. I was
dismayed to find out recently that Stafford is a Scientologist--what a
letdown. I'm gonna try to just concentrate on her powerhouse performances
(who can forget that belly dance she did for Danny years ago?) and not her
personal life. As far as Miguel, I would be much happier if he weren't
portrayed as a lackey to the much-hated Newmans. When the writers did deign
to give the man a life of his own outside of his "yes, Massa Newman"
persona, he wound up in love with a psycho. That'll teach him to try to be
independent--after that, it was back to "Can I get you anything else before
I go to the store, Mrs. Newman?" Of course, Miguel is the only sane and
moral individual in that entire household, so he gets props for that. But
that man needs to let loose and trash the place, writing "Suckas!" on the bi
g mirror in Mistress Newman's ruby red lipstick.

sf4


WB

unread,
Aug 25, 2002, 7:33:11 PM8/25/02
to
Hey soapfan4 - are we separated at birth or what?
Wendy
"soapfan4" <soap...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:umi9lif...@corp.supernews.com...

goddess

unread,
Aug 25, 2002, 9:58:38 PM8/25/02
to
BEST: Christian LeBlanc
WORST: The BUG

"WB" <donotspa...@jps.net> wrote in message
news:XOda9.6725$ld4.6...@newsread2.prod.itd.earthlink.net...

Carol Frilegh

unread,
Aug 26, 2002, 1:37:33 AM8/26/02
to
Wooden women:
Alex, Callie, NuMac, Ramona, initially Isabella, previous Ashley, Lorie
Brooks, Grace Turner, Marissa, Hope, Ruth Williams, Mary Williams.
Anita Hodges, Christine Williams, Olivia Winters

Macho men:
Matt Clark, Gary Dawson, Raphael, Tomas, Diego, Miichael Baldwin,
Malcom Winters, Larry Wharton, J.T. , Ashley Abbott Carlton

Cigar Store Sculptures: Jack Abbott, Victor Newman, Bradley Carlton,
Max Hollister, Neil Winters, Nicholas Newman, Dr. Reese, Danny
Romalotti, Keith Dennison, Paul Williams, both Seans and Brock

Silly Villains; Juice, Trey, James (never seen) Chet, Ralph

Super secretaries, servants and sidekicks; Lynne, Connie , Chantal.
Esther, Gina Roma, Auntie Mame, Doris, Cody, Katherine's driver Robert,
Miguel, Gabriella, Milly, Gina's bartender

Major miscasts; Billy, nuLily

In article <3d69...@news.nauticom.net>, goddess

Chris Henderson

unread,
Aug 27, 2002, 9:05:18 AM8/27/02
to

WB wrote:

> Worst actor - that kid who plays Nate


I wouldn't say he's the worst, but he's right up there. I give him a
break because he's a kid. Maybe he'll get better someday.

It's hard to choose the worst actors, because there have been so many.
Recently, the first Diego comes to mind. His acting was so wooden and
completely without emotion. NuMac has sucked from Day 1, although I
don't know if it's her acting or the way the character is written.

Further back, I agree with whomever said Josh Landers. He was bad with
a capital "B". I don't think that Shari Shattuck was a horrible actor,
I just think that she was a poor choice for the role of Ashley.


> Best actor - the guy that plays Michael Baldwin, the woman who plays
> Phyllis (the current one, NOT the other stand in lady from before),


Agreed. And I'd add Peter Bergman. He is my fave.

> and
> the guy who plays Miguel


You're joking about Miguel, right? He proved in his storyline with
Veronica, that his acting stinks. He's best sticking with lines like
"Yes, Mrs. Newman" and that's about it.

Oh, and I have to get my shot in at the Bug :) Her acting is just
awful. You'd think that after all these years on the show, she'd be
able to put a little emotion into her acting. She delivers all her
lines in monotone and seems to only show a spark when she's being
sanctimonious and supeior to someone.

chenders


Lambofsorrows

unread,
Aug 27, 2002, 10:18:50 PM8/27/02
to
The "bug" as you people call her, is a good actress. Very annoying lately is
Sharon, I mean she couldn't even suppress her emotions when Diego was mentioned
(in the scene with Victor and Nikki)- like gees, I wonder if they noticed her
behavior once they mentioned his name? This seems way off to me, the writers
suck badly. I don't blame Sharon Case (she can't help it if they make her
character suck)- I mean, come on, this is the same woman who just adored her
husband not too long ago and now (since sleeping with the god's gift to women,
Diego) she can't get Diego out of her mind and she's torn. I find this very
hard to believe. If she loved her husband so much, she'd be just trying to
forget that the one night stand even happened.

WB

unread,
Aug 28, 2002, 11:17:01 AM8/28/02
to
I saw Sharon Case on a local news show here in the LA area and she,
well, is not the sharpest knife in the drawer. She comes off as VERY
kind and sweet, but not too bright. I think that as an actress she is
fine, and she is doing the best she can considering her limitations.

The Bug - well she has improved over the years because she sucked
in the beginning. Does anyone remember how PAINFUL those first
few scenes were eons ago with Michael Damian? Oh God they were
incredibly painful to watch because both actors were pathetic. Over
the years she got "slightly" better but I still cringe when I think of the
"touring" years when she took time away from her busy studies for
the bar exam to follow her husband around on tour and he would
sing to her. My husband actually walked in on one of those scenes
and started roaring because Damian was SO BAD, and Cricket
was worse.

So by comparison to the early years, she has gotten better.

Wendy

"Lambofsorrows" <lambof...@aol.com> wrote in message
news:20020827221850...@mb-ff.aol.com...

0 new messages