Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Soprano/tenor duet suggestions?

87 views
Skip to first unread message

Melanie Lynch

unread,
Jan 18, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/18/99
to
I have always ended up singing duets with baritones, but now I get to
play with my very own tenor!! (Well, maybe not my *very* own but U get
to sing with him anyway). Consequently, I need to expand my repertoire.
Other than Brigadoon and Showboat, I am in search of suggestions because
I am simply drawing a blank on possibilities (must be a senior moment).
. We both have at least D's, so there's not a whole lot of range
limitation. Bright ideas are needed!!

Melanie

MagicPantz

unread,
Jan 18, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/18/99
to
Summer Nights, from Grease?

-MagicPantz
Site Address: http://hometown.aol.com/magicpantz/index.html


BdwyBear

unread,
Jan 18, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/18/99
to
>I have always ended up singing duets with baritones, but now I get to play
with my very own tenor!! . Consequently, I need to expand my repertoire.
>Other than Brigadoon and Showboat, I am in search of suggestions
>
>Melanie

"Oh Happy We" and "You Were Dead You Know" from CANDIDE
"Tonight" and "One Hand, One Heart" from WEST SIDE STORY
"Make a Miracle" from WHERE'S CHARLEY
"I Have Dreamed" and "We Kiss in the Shadows" from THE KING AND I

Bart

Jennifer Pitkin

unread,
Jan 18, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/18/99
to
How about something from "Carnival"?

Melanie Lynch wrote:

> I have always ended up singing duets with baritones, but now I get to

> play with my very own tenor!! (Well, maybe not my *very* own but U get

> to sing with him anyway). Consequently, I need to expand my repertoire.

Sarah9165

unread,
Jan 18, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/18/99
to
"I'll Know" from Guys and Dolls
-- Sarah ;o)

LilysEye

unread,
Jan 18, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/18/99
to
So, no Show Boat? Are you absolutely sure? Because "Make Believe" is a GREAT
sop/tenor duet. Also:

"How Could I Ever Know" from The Secret Garden
"If I Loved You" from Carousel (it can be done as a duet, if you like)
"A Heart Full of Love" from Les Mis


Good Luck!

Julie

Martin Pasching

unread,
Jan 18, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/18/99
to
LAST NIGHT OF THE WORLD from Miss Saigon
SUN AND MOON from Miss Saigon
LET´S PLAY A LOVE SEEEN from Fame
TOO MUCH IN LOVE TO CARE from Sunset Boulevard

Melanie Lynch schrieb in Nachricht <36A2DC...@chardonnay.org>...

Dalila

unread,
Jan 18, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/18/99
to Melanie Lynch
On Mon, 18 Jan 1999, Melanie Lynch wrote:

> I have always ended up singing duets with baritones, but now I get to
> play with my very own tenor!! (Well, maybe not my *very* own but U get
> to sing with him anyway). Consequently, I need to expand my repertoire.
> Other than Brigadoon and Showboat, I am in search of suggestions because
> I am simply drawing a blank on possibilities (must be a senior moment).
> . We both have at least D's, so there's not a whole lot of range
> limitation. Bright ideas are needed!!

CANDIDE - O Happy We; You Were Dead You Know

WEST SIDE STORY - Tonight; One Hand, One Heart

ASPECTS OF LOVE - Seeing is Believing

KISMET - Stranger in Paradise

SHOW BOAT - Make Believe; You Are Love (Gaylord Ravenal was originally a
tenor; he was transposed downward by Hollywood for the '50s remake.)

THE CAT AND THE FIDDLE (Jerome Kern) - The Night was Made for Love; I
Watch the Love Parade

THE KING AND I - I Have Dreamed

LES MISERABLES - A Heart full of Love

THE MYSTERY OF EDWIN DROOD - Perfect Strangers

HALF A SIXPENCE - Long Ago

FLOWERS FOR ALGERNON - Whatever Time there is

HELLO, DOLLY - It Only takes a Moment

ROBERT AND ELIZABETH - I Know Now; In a Simple Way

LOCK UP YOUR DAUGHTERS - Lovely Lover; Kind Fate; On a Sunny Sunday
Morning

PHANTOM OF THE OPERA - Phantom of the Opera; Point of No Return

Then there are LOTS of things from operetta - let me know if you're
interested in those too and I'll list some.

Dalila
=====
Ce n'est pourtant pas la voix
Qui me fait defaut, je crois;
Non, c'est la methode!


Dalila

unread,
Jan 18, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/18/99
to Jennifer Pitkin
The leading man in CARNIVAL is a baritone, not a tenor; Jerry Orbach
originated the role on Broadway.

On the other hand, "Soon it's Gonna Rain", and
"They Were You" from another Orbach show, THE FANTASTICKS, would work,
because The Boy is a tenor who sings with The Girl, a
(mezzo)soprano.

Dalila

=====

Dalila

unread,
Jan 18, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/18/99
to Sarah9165
Guy Masterson is a baritone, not a tenor.

Dalila

unread,
Jan 18, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/18/99
to LilysEye
Archy in SECRET GARDEN and Billy Bigelow in CAROUSEL are both baritones,
not tenors.

I agree with your LES MIS and SHOW BOAT suggestions, and would also add
"You Are Love" from SHOW BOAT.

Dalila
=====

Abfou

unread,
Jan 19, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/19/99
to
Dalila <dal...@radix.net> wrote:

>The leading man in CARNIVAL is a baritone, not a tenor; Jerry Orbach
>originated the role on Broadway.

>On the other hand, "Soon it's Gonna Rain", and
>"They Were You" from another Orbach show, THE FANTASTICKS, would work,
>because The Boy is a tenor who sings with The Girl, a
>(mezzo)soprano.

>Dalila
__________________________

Unless they rewrote the role for me when I played it [sudden coughing
fit] years ago, the Boy is not a tenor, not even a "bari-tenor." As I
recall (and this is strictly from memory so I welcome fact-checking),
Matt has no high G's and only one sustained F (the end of "I Can See
It"). Mostly he stays in a comfortable "if I can sing, you can sing"
range, from low B (where all his songs rest comfortably) to
not-so-high D (his money note).

This is only a step away from Paul's (Orbach's) range in CARNIVAL! He
bottoms out around B or B-flat (I think in the "Her Face" counterpoint
to "I Hate Him" he has to growl a low A) and has a few high E-flats,
popping an F in "I've Got to Find a Reason."

Abfou


Shaw Thompson

unread,
Jan 19, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/19/99
to

Sarah9165 wrote in message <19990118164701...@ng-fq1.aol.com>...

>"I'll Know" from Guys and Dolls
>-- Sarah ;o)

I've Never Been in Love Before from Guys and Dolls
Almost Like Being IN Love from Brigadoon
We Kiss in a Shadow - The King and I
I Have Dreamed - The King and I
You Are Love, Make Believe - Showboat
The List goes on.....

If you can tell me general style and quality of the voices, I could probably
recommend many more. I am a tenor married to a soprano, so I am somewhat
familiar with rep.

Shaw

LilysEye

unread,
Jan 19, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/19/99
to

Dalila wrote:
:Archy in SECRET GARDEN and Billy Bigelow in CAROUSEL are both :baritones,
:not tenors.

since when? If Billy were only a baritone, there's no way he could sing the
end of "Soliliquey." and Archie would definitely have a hard time with such
songs as "Lily's Eyes" and "Race You To the Top of the Mountain." Neville is
the lower singing part of that show.

Just my thoughts,

Julie

Sarah9165

unread,
Jan 20, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/20/99
to
>I've Never Been in Love Before from Guys and Dolls

Thank you..people are telling me that the role of Sky Masterson isn't (or
couldn't be) a tenor role. Everytime I've worked on this show Sky as been
played by a guy who is a tenor.
Live, Love, Laugh, & Ride-

--Sarah

Dalila

unread,
Jan 20, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/20/99
to Abfou
On Tue, 19 Jan 1999, Abfou wrote:

> Unless they rewrote the role for me when I played it [sudden coughing
> fit] years ago, the Boy is not a tenor, not even a "bari-tenor." As I
> recall (and this is strictly from memory so I welcome fact-checking),
> Matt has no high G's and only one sustained F (the end of "I Can See
> It"). Mostly he stays in a comfortable "if I can sing, you can sing"
> range, from low B (where all his songs rest comfortably) to
> not-so-high D (his money note).
>

But _fach_ has to do with more than just the range of the songs. It also
has to do with the tessitura, and in the case of the Boy in FANTASTICKS,
it has most of all to do with the colour and timbre of the voice that is
appropriate for the character. The people I've heard do the role have all
been either tenors or very light lyric baritones - i.e., voices that have
an extremely youthful, even adolescent, quality to them. A darker
baritone voice would simply be wrong from a characterisation standpoint.

Dalila


Abfou

unread,
Jan 21, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/21/99
to
Dalila <dal...@radix.net> wrote:

>Dalila
_________________________

Nonetheless (and I agree with most of what you say), both the range
_and_ the tessitura are way too low for a tenor's voice -- certainly
for his vanity. Actually, trying to pigeonhole this and many other
musical theater roles into this or that "legit" category may be
meaningless. The Boy is (rather craftily) written for an _untrained_
voice. Most actors with the right light, youthful timbre are
undeveloped tenors; train them and they lose those necessary low B's.

The great advantage is that the part, with its reams of blank verse,
can be cast for acting ability -- and fach the tessitura. Sorry.

Abfou


David Zack

unread,
Jan 21, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/21/99
to
>Most actors with the right light, youthful timbre are
>undeveloped tenors; train them and they lose those necessary low B's.

There are actually quite a few tenors who have that low B. (And many have a
low A, for that matter) In musical theatre, tenor roles tend to dip into the
baritone register. And baritone roles get pretty high. The line has
definitely blurred, and voice is often typed more by timbre than by range.
These days as a tenor, you need those low notes. Bobby in Company, Jean
Valjean, Anatoly in Chess, George in Sunday in the Park with George, and many
others all range from a low B-flat or A to at least a G-sharp or A. (Valjean
has a B-natural and a C, though the C is half-screamed)

David

Abfou

unread,
Jan 21, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/21/99
to
davi...@aol.com (David Zack) wrote:

>David
________________

Yes, but do you want those Bobbys, Jeans, Anatolys and Georges playing
The Boy in THE FANTASTICKS? Me neither. My point is that good young
(no more than late teens) actors with a light, boyish sound but a
baritone range are usually undeveloped tenors. And, to preserve our
planet's limited supply of Matts, we should leave them alone lest they
shift their range, start talking about the "mask," and sneak lifts
into their shoes.

Abfou


MARK ANDREW PETERSON

unread,
Jan 22, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/22/99
to

Billy is definitely a baritone role. Even though the end
of Soliloquy is quite high, an operatic baritone can -- and must! --
handle it. In this instance, the range of the repertoire is less
important than the timbre of the voice required. Billy needs a big, dark
baritone -- not a light tenor!

About Archibald, I think that a lighter, gentler tenor sound is more
appropriate. Here are my two cents -- Mandy Patinkin has a very heavy
sound in his upper register, unless he is using falsetto -- I think that's
why he gets on the nerves of so many people. He has to use that falsetto
to lighten it up.

Mark


Dalila

unread,
Jan 23, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/23/99
to MARK ANDREW PETERSON
On Fri, 22 Jan 1999, MARK ANDREW PETERSON wrote:

> About Archibald, I think that a lighter, gentler tenor sound is more
> appropriate. Here are my two cents -- Mandy Patinkin has a very heavy
> sound in his upper register, unless he is using falsetto -- I think that's
> why he gets on the nerves of so many people. He has to use that falsetto
> to lighten it up.

That's because Mandy is definitely a baritone, and a pretty full-voiced
one. If he sang "legit" all the time, his real vocal color and timbre
would make it instantly apparent. AS it is, I've heard him in concert a
few times, and when he sings in the middle part of his range, it's
patently obvious he's truly a baritone - and it's a really NICE baritone
too - I wish he'd use it all the time, instead of that little falsetto
he's so fond of.

To be honest, I much preferred Anthony Warlow's Archy to Mandy's (I admit
to hearing them both only on CD). Warlow is a lyric tenor (at least
that's what he sang when he was with the Australian Opera) but one with a
very bright color to his voice - he's what I'd consider a "baritenor" -
perfect for roles like Danilo in THE MERRY WIDOW, and Archy in THE SECRET
GARDEN, as well as Erik in PHANTOM OF THE OPERA and Valjean in LES MIS.

Dalila

Jennifer Barber

unread,
Jan 23, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/23/99
to
In article <Pine.SV4.3.96.990123...@saltmine.radix.net>,
Dalila <dal...@radix.net> wrote:

>to hearing them both only on CD). Warlow is a lyric tenor (at least
>that's what he sang when he was with the Australian Opera) but one with a

Really? I've always been under the impression that he sang baritone with
the AO. And he's always called himself "a baritone with a bright top" in
all the interviews I've seen/read...and I should think he's well-trained
enough to know which he is!

jennifer

--
Uwe Kroeger page: http://www.mindspring.com/~jlbarber/kroeger.html
Elisabeth page: http://members.aol.com/jlbarber/eljen.html
"Ein Leben ohne Buecher waer' Tortur!"
--Michael Kunze, "Buecherlied", _Tanz der Vampire_

David Zack

unread,
Jan 24, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/24/99
to
>>to hearing them both only on CD). Warlow is a lyric tenor (at least
>>that's what he sang when he was with the Australian Opera) but one with a
>
>Really? I've always been under the impression that he sang baritone with
>the AO. And he's always called himself "a baritone with a bright top" in
>all the interviews I've seen/read...and I should think he's well-trained
>enough to know which he is!
>
>jennifer

I wasn't going to say anything, since this comes up all the time, but since
somebody else went first...

Warlow is a baritone. Listen to his solo albums and you'll hear his excellent
lower register. If you listen to "Stand Up and Fight" or "Were thine that
special face," there is no doubt. The man's a baritone.

Beyond that, Warlow has practically flawless technique! He knows how to
lighten his tone to sound more like a tenor as the song demands - which is why
is is often mistaken for a tenor. Most baritones who sing an A (those that
can) sing it with so much cover, that it is clearly "flipped". When Warlow
does it, you simply cannot tell. He knows how to almost completely disguise
his break (which is right about the G, where most high baritones and tenor
flip). And he knows how to change gears and sing in the proper style of the
song. For the contemporary material, he knows how to straight-tone, a trick
that most singers accomplish by doing potentially harmfull things, like using
throat muscles and not using enough air.

A lot can be learned from listening to Anthony Warlow albums.
David

HOSS

unread,
Jan 24, 1999, 3:00:00 AM1/24/99
to

Try "All I ask of you"
from Phantom of the opera

Ruth Hansen

unread,
Feb 1, 1999, 3:00:00 AM2/1/99
to
Yup, Billy's a baritone. Baritones get high notes, too -- they just
don't get MOSTLY high notes.

Ruth Hansen

On 19 Jan 1999 18:41:39 GMT, lily...@aol.com (LilysEye) wrotd:

>
>Dalila wrote:
>:Archy in SECRET GARDEN and Billy Bigelow in CAROUSEL are both :baritones,
>:not tenors.
>
>since when? If Billy were only a baritone, there's no way he could sing the
>end of "Soliliquey." and Archie would definitely have a hard time with such
>songs as "Lily's Eyes" and "Race You To the Top of the Mountain." Neville is
>the lower singing part of that show.
>
>Just my thoughts,
>
>Julie
>

Ruth Hansen
Chicago, IL
:::::::::

You can get farther with a kind word
and a two by four than you can
with just a kind word.

f...@pipeline.com

unread,
Feb 5, 1999, 3:00:00 AM2/5/99
to
song...@thewatercooler.com (Ruth Hansen) wrote:

>Yup, Billy's a baritone. Baritones get high notes, too -- they just
>don't get MOSTLY high notes.

>Ruth Hansen

>On 19 Jan 1999 18:41:39 GMT, lily...@aol.com (LilysEye) wrotd:

>>
>>Dalila wrote:
>>:Archy in SECRET GARDEN and Billy Bigelow in CAROUSEL are both :baritones,
>>:not tenors.

I feel that Archie is a baritenor. I invite any non baritenor to try
Lily's Eyes, it's a killer. The guy who played the role in my
production is definately a tenor (he also sang Joey in "Most Happy
Fella).
Monica

Christian L Wiktor

unread,
Feb 6, 1999, 3:00:00 AM2/6/99
to
So the big question is... has Mandy Patinkin ever played Billy Bigelow?

Yours,

Ann

Ruth Hansen (song...@thewatercooler.com) wrote:
: Yup, Billy's a baritone. Baritones get high notes, too -- they just
: don't get MOSTLY high notes.

: Ruth Hansen

: On 19 Jan 1999 18:41:39 GMT, lily...@aol.com (LilysEye) wrotd:

: >
: >Dalila wrote:
: >:Archy in SECRET GARDEN and Billy Bigelow in CAROUSEL are both :baritones,
: >:not tenors.

: >
: >since when? If Billy were only a baritone, there's no way he could sing the


: >end of "Soliliquey." and Archie would definitely have a hard time with such
: >songs as "Lily's Eyes" and "Race You To the Top of the Mountain." Neville is
: >the lower singing part of that show.
: >
: >Just my thoughts,
: >
: >Julie
: >

: Ruth Hansen
: Chicago, IL
: :::::::::

twomules

unread,
Feb 12, 1999, 3:00:00 AM2/12/99
to
Yes he has.

It was played on the radio about two years ago (might have been a special
recording) and he was SOOOO anguished! It was fabulous!!!

TM

Michelle McFee

unread,
Feb 12, 1999, 3:00:00 AM2/12/99
to Wendy Younker
Wendy Younker wrote:
>
> I've got the CD with him doing Soliloquy on it. It's just called Mandy
> Patinkin and its on CBS Records Label......

I have it, too, and believe me, he should have left SOLILOQUY to Patrick
Wilson... Billy Bigelow, Mandy ain't.

Wendy Younker

unread,
Feb 13, 1999, 3:00:00 AM2/13/99
to
0 new messages