Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.

[ENT] Jammer's Review: "Affliction"

Skip to first unread message

Jamahl Epsicokhan

Mar 2, 2005, 7:54:21 AM3/2/05
Note: This review contains significant spoilers.

In brief: A solid outing that covers a good amount of ground, although the
cliffhanger concept seems a little unnecessary.

Plot description: When the Enterprise visits Earth for the launch of the
Columbia, Phlox is kidnapped and brought before the Klingons, who want him
to find a cure for a deadly outbreak.

Star Trek: Enterprise - "Affliction"

Airdate: 2/18/2005 (USA)
Teleplay by Mike Sussman
Story by Manny Coto
Directed by Michael Grossman

Review by Jamahl Epsicokhan
Rating out of 4: ***

"This is my daydream. *You* go away." -- Trip to T'Pol

One nice aspect of "Affliction" is that the varied story ideas allow the
episode to breathe. Often on this series, the focus is so narrowly put upon
a few key characters and situations that it's either success for their
specific arc, or bust. With "Affliction," there's a central plot line, yes,
but there are also enough other things going on and enough people involved
that we become interested in the characters and little details as well as
the plot they inhabit.

And it never hurts to get back to Earth, which itself opens the series up to
breathe a bit. The Enterprise has returned for the long-delayed launch of
the Columbia, where Trip has been transferred to serve as chief engineer.
Early in the episode, as he packs up to leave, T'Pol asks him if he's
leaving the ship because of her. The answer is obviously yes, but he tersely
tells her otherwise. What's a smitten man in this situation to do? I don't
know, but it is kind interesting to see that the not-credible hooking up of
these characters last season has now resulted in messy consequences. Let
this be a lesson to future Star Trek generations: Don't sleep with your
superior officer.

While on shore leave, Phlox and Hoshi are confronted on the street by
ominous men in hoods. There's a brief scuffle (in which Hoshi's martial arts
knowledge -- as suddenly/retroactively revealed in "Observer Effect" -- is
exploited), and Phlox is shot and carried away. An investigation into
Phlox's abduction is launched, beginning with interviews at the crime scene.
With a little tweaking and additional insistence, perhaps this could've
played as a teaser for "CSI: San Francisco 2154." Or maybe "Law & Order:
Starfleet Security Unit."

As the investigation begins to sprawl, we're taken into some familiar Star
Trek places. Hoshi's witnessing of the kidnapping doesn't turn up enough
conclusive facts, so Archer suggests T'Pol perform a mind-meld to help Hoshi
remember all the details. I guess this is like hypnosis, only better. When
T'Pol expresses concern over her ability to initiate a mind-meld, Archer
tells her, "I can walk you through it." I'm not sure what I think of that.
It certainly makes sense on a plot level, arising from the events of
"Kir'Shara," but do we really *want* the human teaching the Vulcan how to

The mind-meld produces a lead that has the Enterprise chasing a Rigellian
ship to a space station that the Enterprise crew finds destroyed by the time
they arrive. Destroyed by whom? Reed knows, but he's not saying.

On the other end of the plot, we already know that Phlox is in the hands of
the Klingons, who are forcing him to help one of their doctors, a man named
Antaak (John Schuck, not new to Klingon roles), research a cure to a deadly
contagion threatening the Klingon population. Refreshingly, Antaak is not
depicted as a villain but as a man of integrity -- in spite of his adherence
to accepted Klingon medical protocol, which permits the theft of data and
resources and the "euthanasia" of live Klingon test subjects (a brutal
notion played for mild laughs).

Through his search for a cure, Phlox learns that the outbreak began when the
Klingons attempted to create genetically enhanced subjects from embryos
discovered in the wreckage of the ship hijacked by the Augments (see "The
Augments"). In terms of self-reference without *literal* self-reference,
this will evidentially provide the explanation for the difference in
appearance between the TOS Klingons and the Klingons from the feature films
onward. The tie-in with the Augments arc is fairly clever.

Lt. Reed's investigation comprises the other major strand of the story, and
the most intriguing. He discovers Starfleet's security grid was down at
exactly the time of Phlox's kidnapping. When he tries to find out why, he's
contacted by a mysterious agent (Eric Pierpoint, of "Alien Nation" fame).
The show doesn't come out and say it, but this is clearly intended to be
some version of Section 31 (their uniforms apparently won't change during
the next 200 years; for the DS9 uninitiated, see "Inquisition").
Furthermore, Reed turns out to be a former Section agent. Because of the
plot involving Phlox's kidnapping, Reed is reactivated by the Section, and
ordered to thwart the Enterprise's investigation, for reasons we cannot yet
be certain of.

Reed's conflict makes for the show's best drama, because it involves loyalty
and betrayal. He's forced into hiding key evidence from Archer on the orders
of an organization that he was apparently affiliated with before Starfleet.
When he tells his Section contact that he's uncomfortable hiding things from
Archer, the response comes back, "I suggest you adjust your comfort level."
Eventually, a trail of clues leads T'Pol back through Reed's interference.
Archer dresses him down and has him thrown into the brig as a traitor, which
makes for some potent scenes.

Aboard the Columbia, Trip cracks the whip and tells the other engineers that
the ship's engines *will* be online and ready for launch within the week.
(He comes across as so inflexible that several engineers request transfers
off the ship.) This is before he even reports to the captain for duty. The
truth of these scenes are in the simple details of a man moving to a new
post, and especially in the quiet observation of Captain Hernandez (Ada
Maris), who seems to silently size Trip up while coming across as both
professional and friendly. Maris' subtle and internalized performance is one
of the show's highlights. Perhaps it's too early to say until we also see
the action side of her character in command, but Hernandez already seems
like a character that I could see as an anchor for its own series. Show me

In keeping with the show's effective "do a little bit of everything"
approach, there's also a bizarre daydream involving Trip and T'Pol, which
they both seem to share. The sharing goes even further: Hoshi has dreams of
Trip, evidently because something spilled over from the mind-meld.

Then there's the action, where human-looking Klingons board the Enterprise
and plant a computer virus, which has the effect of forcing the ship to
accelerate out of control. Although one of the Klingons is captured, the
MACOs still seem way too incompetent as security forces. As for the notion
of the ship speeding out of control: Do we really need this as a
cliffhanger, and isn't there something vaguely silly about it? (It begs
someone to shout out: "We're going too FAST! We're gonna BLOW!")

My biggest fear is that the interesting stuff here will be all too casually
reset in the follow-up. I'm speaking specifically of the fallout from Reed's
betrayal and Trip having transferred to the Columbia. It seems to me that
Reed can't remain in the brig forever, and we're not about to see Trip on an
ongoing, parallel "Star Trek: Columbia." Hopefully, however they resolve
these matters will be worthwhile.

Like many outings this season on Enterprise, "Affliction" is solid and
entertaining, but with no real signs of greatness. This, unfortunately,
limits my review to another where I basically say "here's what happened in
the episode" and "I mostly liked what I saw." Deep analysis or heavy thought
doesn't really seem to be required. Not that that's a problem.

Next week: The Enterprise keeps accelerating until it explodes. Okay,
probably not.

Copyright 2005, Jamahl Epsicokhan. All rights reserved.
Unauthorized reproduction or distribution of this article is prohibited.

Star Trek: Hypertext -
Jamahl Epsicokhan -

Moderated by Stijn Derudder
Article submissions:
Moderator contact:

0 new messages