Kurt Busiek <
ku...@busiek.com> wrote:
> On 2013-03-19 00:38:11 +0000, Moriarty <
blu...@ivillage.com> said:
>
>> On Mar 19, 11:22am, Will in New Haven
>> <
bill.re...@taylorandfrancis.com> wrote:
>>> On Mar 18, 7:01pm, lal_truckee <
lal_truc...@yahoo.com> wrote:
>>>
>>>> What Science Fiction features dogs?
>>>> (Leave out Fantasy, where the dogs are likely to be werewolfs or some
>>>> equally silly thing.)
>>>
>>>> There's Johann Braun's Thor in Heinlein's Tunnel in the Sky, plus dog
>>>> mention re the emigration gates. Heinlein also gives Lazarus dogs for
>>>> his wilderness emigration; he appears to think dogs are vital for emigrants.
>>>
>>>> I don't remember much about dogs joining man in most SF expansion
>>>> diasporas or the galactic civilizations that follow. Dogs seem to get
>>>> lost during the hand waving.
>>>> Where are the dogs?
>>>
>>>> (I haven't forgotten that Simak features dogs.)
>>>
>>> Well, some people think Pern is an SF setting and McAffery mentions
>>> "the canines" at times.
>>> Lots of dogs in post-apocolyptic fiction (fiction about people who
>>> can't spell?) which generally reads more like fantasy to me.
>>
>> Like "A Boy and His Dog"? Definitely more fantasy than science
>> fiction.
>
> Not definitely, no. Except when using the "it's not science fiction
> unless it's _hard_ science fiction" ruler, which eliminates most of
> what the genre was named to describe.
>
> It's set in the future, it's got psi-stuff that's meant as science, not
> magic, it's got radiation-created mutations -- what's not science
> fiction about it? Is DAMNATION ALLEY fantasy now, too?
>
> Anyway, someone's going to mention the graphic novel WE3, so I'll list that.
>
> There's a "space hound" in SIRENS OF TITAN, if "infundibulation"
> doesn't render it fantasy for not being realistic enough in its science.
>
> There's Lockjaw of the Inhumans in FANTASTIC FOUR, which is science
> fiction in that it invokes aliens and genetics to perform its fantastic
> stuff. Plus, Lockjaw's great, so he counts.
>
> Frank the Pug from the MEN IN BLACK movies is technically not a dog,
> but screw it, he's a dog.
>
> Kojak, from THE STAND. Which I suppose is fantasy/horror, but Kojak
> doesn't know that.
Wondering if Cujo fits...