On Thursday, May 6, 2021 at 12:21:57 AM UTC-6, Kevrob wrote:
> You might get tagged as
> someone who thinks those descended from ancestors held as slaves are
> somehow inferior. It's perfectly alright to claim they still suffer from harms
> done to their ancestors, though. Don't let the cognitive dissonance hit too
> hard.
Cognitive dissonance is not required.
Acquired characteristics cannot be inherited, if you don't count
epigenetics.
When it is claimed that today's black people are suffering from
the legacy of slavery, it does not mean that slavery deformed
their ancestors, and by some mechanism is still deforming them
as well.
Certainly black people in America do exist, to some extent, as a
group with a culture, and this culture could indeed have flaws.
Some could date from slavery, others from the many years of
Jim Crow, and some could be the result of welfare policies that
discriminate against intact families.
But when it is claimed that black people today are still suffering
from the consequences of slavery, the main thing that is meant
has nothing to do with flaws in black culture. Instead, they're
talking about the fact th at black people tend to be _poor_. And
that's because, in a free-enterprise society, how well a child
does economically in life is very strongly influenced by the
financial position of his or her parents.
There are two ways to address this.
One would also benefit white people who are poor; turn the
country into something like Sweden, where the government
ensures that all children, rich or poor, get a quality education,
adequate nutrition, clean drinking water, and so on and so
forth.
Since American political culture is allergic to "socialism",
however (scare quotes used since a welfare state does not
require state ownership of the means of production),
reparations for slavery have been suggested as an
alternative.
After all, if property inheritance is regarded as legitimate,
then, since slavery is an act of aggression against those
enslaved, it is also a _theft_ of labor and its proceeds; and
of course restitution for a theft can be demanded if it has
not yet been recieved, no matter how many generations
have passed. With accrued interest.
John Savard