When I returned _Penric's Progress_ to the library, I checked for
other Bujold. The computer turned up:
books I'd already read,
e-books (I can download a file all by *myself*, thank you very much),
audiobooks (I tried an audiobook novel once, and I'm eternally
grateful that I could go back and get the print version),
e-audiobooks, and
_Federations: Vast, Epic, Interstellar_.
I figured that if John Joseph Adams had chosen "Aftermaths", he must
have pretty good taste, so I took Federations.
At home, I sat down to read: the first story is an Orson Scott Card.
My first impulse was to skip it, but I gave it a chance and found that
it didn't have the usual OSC tics and tricks -- or maybe it's just
that it's been twenty or thirty years since I last read a Card and
didn't recognize them. "Mazer in Prison" is silly, but the silly is
sufficiently consistent and coherent that it was easy to take it
seriously for twenty-four pages.
My spouse, having run out of fiction, picked it up, found "Mazer"
unbearably boring, and skipped on to "Carthago Delenda Est". His
bookmark is three pages from the end, so I assume he hasn't formed an
opinion yet.
I just re-read the first paragraph of "Carthago", and hey! Now it
makes sense!
(I shall plow full speed ahead and damn the spoilers.)
"Carthago" is more of a puzzle than a story: you are supposed to
figure out what the situation is. Once figured out, it doesn't make a
lot of sense. Carthage is in our Oort cloud, and all the planets come
to us?
Or maybe they are all in our solar system, but there do seem to be
rather a lot of them, all at about the same stage of development. I
suppose a second reading might straighten it out, but once through
satisfies me.
The "planets" have been suckered into a four-hundred-year-truce -- the
message, to be so convincing, must have come from a god-like being --
and to keep the truce going, all these ambassadors are floating around
waiting for Godot. The ambassador cared for by the viewpoint
character is regularly "expired" and replaced by a clone. All the
other ambassadors come to a funeral party when an ambassador is
incinerated.
Another "planet" sent a generation ship with a disposable younger son
from the royal family; the story wasn't long enough to mention where
the royal ambassadors got royal wives.
Next story: "Life Suspension", L.E. Modesitt Jr. Spouse's bookmark
is well into this story; I haven't asked his opinion of "Carthago".
(The review took a while to write; Real Life (TM) etc.)
--
Joy Beeson
joy beeson at centurylink dot net
http://wlweather.net/PAGEJOY/