- hi; in article, <k7r2fv$3st$
1...@dont-email.me>,
mste...@walkabout.empros.com "Michael Stemper" observed:
> "ppint. at pplay") writes:
>>
rja.ca...@excite.com "Robert Carnegie" s'a trompe:
>>>I'm trying to remember who's sentimental about cats in Middle-Earth.
>>
>> - no-one. i cannot recall even a walk-on part for a cat in
>> any of tolkien's fiction set in middle-earth.
>
>All that I can think of is that the song Frodo sang at the Prancing Pony
>included mention of a cat in a couple of verses. Oh, and one of the riddles
>(four-legs, three-legs, etc) that Bilbo asked Gollum featured one. Both of
>these were "mention" rather than "use". But, they do imply that cats were
>known in the Shire.
>
- indeed; and there was at least one - unnamed - referred to as
living in bree, which implies the existence of a breeding colony
there, and probably also in staddle, combe and archet, but this
does not provide any actual evidence of anyone in middle-earth's
being sentimental about cats. (- [a])
- which was the point in question, and that which i addressed.
- unless you claim the original comment concerned people in our
world who are, or were, sentimental about all those cats that
tolkien doesn't mention in harad, umbar, dol amroth, the grey
havens, bag end, hobbiton, frogmorton, fornost, tharbad, the
midgwater marshes, rivendell, moria, beorn's house, the elven-
king's halls, lake-town, lorien, fangorn, isengard, helm's deep,
meduseld, minas tirith, osgiliath, the dead marshes, minas morgul,
ithilien, the tower of cirith ungol, or the sammath naur.
at least some of which places are depicted as being sufficient-
ly warm for the comfort of cats, and liable to provide more than
enough prey species small animals in quantity to support a part
or wholly feral feline population, and some of which are shown
as being, or having been, inhabited by populations of seducible
sapients sympathetic to small, strokable, cute furry pest-killers.
- love, a ppint. as suspects jrrt may've preferred dogs to cats
[a] - though i don't doubt that a fair few bree-landers, at least,
are; nor that shire hobbits, though possibly not bucklanders,
do not also have some comfortably smug contented house-cats.
smeagol/gollum's recall implies that cats'd reached hobbits
fishing along the gladden river, though, as well as gondor
and umbar, from which north-west middle-earth presumably re-
ceived them - possibly one of harad's most welcome exports?
[drop the "v", and change the "f" to a "g", to email or cc.]
--
"The Wikipediasts want to believe that they're working on an
important project to collect and organize the knowledge of the ages,
and it offends them if it doesn't (yet) include a detailed history of the
Napoleonic Wars but does include a complete episode guide to Danger Mouse."
- Mike Schilling on rasfwr,ff 17:37 GMT 14/6/07 (6/14/07 for merkins)