First thoughts on tGS WoT 12 **SPOILERS**
Sandwich
It's been a loooong time since I've posted here but I felt so excited
that I had to return! I'm sure that most of you have already read the
book in it's entirety by now (I for one am a slow reader) but I've
just finished the prologue and I wanted to put my two cents in that I
think Sanderson is going to be amazing. The amount of fulfillment we
got in the prologue was mind boggling!
Masema?! That was quick!
Anyway
whats everyone else thinking?
Scott Lurndal
How did Tam know who Morgase was; does that mean Perrin knows too?
Her reveal was a scene I looked forward too, but missed.
scott
guyan...@gmail.com
Tam used to be a soldier who fought for Andor and participated in the
battle at Dragonmount itself against the Aiel. He almost certainly
knows what Morgase used to look like. Perrin isn't likely to.
Scott Lurndal
>On Oct 30, 4:05=A0pm, sc...@slp53.sl.home (Scott Lurndal) wrote:
>> Sandwich <liam.w...@gmail.com> writes:
>> >Hi all,
>>
>> >It's been a loooong time since I've posted here but I felt so excited
>> >that I had to return! I'm sure that most of you have already read the
>> >book in it's entirety by now (I for one am a slow reader) but I've
>> >just finished the prologue and I wanted to put my two cents in that I
>> >think Sanderson is going to be amazing. The amount of fulfillment we
>> >got in the prologue was mind boggling!
>>
>> >Masema?! That was quick!
>>
>> >Anyway
>>
>> >whats everyone else thinking?
>>
>>
>> Her reveal was a scene I looked forward too, but missed.
>>
>> scott
>
>Tam used to be a soldier who fought for Andor and participated in the
>battle at Dragonmount itself against the Aiel. He almost certainly
>knows what Morgase used to look like. Perrin isn't likely to.
Considering that Tam was travelling with Perrin, why wouldn't Tam
tell him, or at least ask why the former Queen of Andor whom everyone
considers to be dead is travelling incognito with him?
scott
James Hammons
It was most likely Cadsuane. She travelled there to find Tam, and
recognized Morgase.
James Hammons
Rast
> whats everyone else thinking?
I've gotten through 20 chapters, but it's been rough going. Sanderson
keeps all the faults Jordan had, but adds new ones besides --
specifically, the prose is bland and bad. Plotwise, almost nothing has
happened; in this he's certainly faithful to Jordan. The Egwene passages
are especially tedious.
I do wish the Great Old Ones of rasfwrj would return to give us their
verdict on this book.
--
But my situation is not entirely desperate. The Flatlanders are, I
have learned, edible, with a taste something like very moist smoked
salmon. It takes quite a few of them to make a meal, but they are
plentiful, and they are easy to catch. - Rudy Rucker
fomu65
It assume it was Galad who pointed out his step mother. At one point
in the book, either Rand or Mat (can't remember whose PoV it was) had
one of their swirly colors episodes and saw Galad talking with Perrin.
This was prior to Cadsuane meeting up with Perrin's group.
maoltuile
Between Verin, (especially) Egwene and the Rand near the end, a lot of
great moments in this book. So many threads tied up, finally! The Mat
humour was laboured, and Perrin has become a character in a rut, but
the rest of it - oh, my.
James Hammons
I had forgotten about that. You are quite correct. I really can't
wait until Gawyn finds out and his whole little shitty attitude falls
down around him. I really wanted to like him when the series started,
but he just turned into a complete and total friggin idiot.
James Hammons
Scott Lurndal
>Sandwich wrote on Fri, 30 Oct 2009 05:43:15 -0700 (PDT):
>> whats everyone else thinking?
>
>I've gotten through 20 chapters, but it's been rough going. Sanderson
>keeps all the faults Jordan had, but adds new ones besides --
>specifically, the prose is bland and bad. Plotwise, almost nothing has
>happened; in this he's certainly faithful to Jordan. The Egwene passages
>are especially tedious.
Wow. This is the first negative review I've seen. Even Ms. Butler loved it.
scott
steveo
"Tony" <postmaster@[127.0.0.1]> wrote in message
news:hcf6jk$3um$1...@news.eternal-september.org...
> In rec.arts.sf.written.robert-jordan, Sandwich <liam...@gmail.com>
>
>>whats everyone else thinking?
>
> I
> read and then b) read the ones I never read because I lost the will to
> live
> before I can c) read the new one.
check out Leigh Butler's re-read at www.tor.com
steveo
steveo
"Scott Lurndal" <sc...@slp53.sl.home> wrote in message
news:IyIGm.5993$Xj3...@news.usenetserver.com...
The ugly truth is that the next book will have lots of Perrin and Elayne
since they were largely skipped in tGS. The reveal might be interesting,
but I might just have to skim over those chapters if there are too many
angsty Tallanvor/Morgase scenes...
steveo
steveo
"Rast" <ra...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:MPG.2556ba3a3...@news.eternal-september.org...
> Sandwich wrote on Fri, 30 Oct 2009 05:43:15 -0700 (PDT):
>> whats everyone else thinking?
>
> I've gotten through 20 chapters, but it's been rough going. Sanderson
> keeps all the faults Jordan had, but adds new ones besides --
> specifically, the prose is bland and bad. Plotwise, almost nothing has
> happened; in this he's certainly faithful to Jordan. The Egwene passages
> are especially tedious.
The Egwene scenes were the best in the book, IMO. They really seemed to be
well developed and moved along at a fast clip, with major conclusions and
advances made.
Mat was terribly caricatured, as was Cadsuane. Sanderson really failed with
these characters.
steveo
Tim Bruening
Scott Lurndal wrote:
Perhaps Tam met Morgase during the Aiel War.
Tim Bruening
James Hammons wrote:
Cadsuane: What are two Queens and the First of Mayene doing traveling with you,
Perrin?
Tim Bruening
Scott Lurndal wrote:
Elayne to Morgase: Thank the Light you are back! Now I can get off this
throne!
Morgase: No can do. I abdicated months ago in favor of you!
Elayne: Okay, I'll abdicate in favor of you!
Tim Bruening
steveo wrote:
IMHO, Rand should periodically Travel to Caemlyn so that he can boink Elayne
silly!
When they were in bed in Winter's Heart, why didn't they arrange a date for
him to visit with her?