On 2021-10-26 08:02:06 +0000, The Last Doctor said:
> On 25/10/2021 22:05, Your Name wrote:
>>
>> There's a massive difference between an original show casting different
>> genders / races, and an idiotic "reboot" that insists on gender /
>> race-swapping (and crowing about doing it) established characters
>> simply to appease the "Politically Correct' whiners and tick off studio
>> quotas.
>
> The thing about a reboot is - it's a reboot. These aren't "established
> characters", what you have is a set of templates that you can play with
> and change in order to engage the audience you want and to tell the
> stories you want to tell. And sometimes that will involve changes of
> gender, and it definitively should involve changes of race and WILL, if
> you have an open casting process and pick the best actor for the role.
> Imitating the original characters, keeping them in the same ethnic,
> social and mental positions, and telling the same stories, isn't a
> reboot - it's a continuation by other means.
The characters were established by the original. Changing them is
purely a case of appeasing "Politically Correct" whiners and quota
tick-boxing. It's also all one-way - changing these characters away
from being wite males (because as we all know, being a white male is
completely illegal these days). Get back to me when a new "Wonder
Woman" movie casts a male as the lead, when the "Fresh Prince" casts a
lead white male, etc.
> And telling stories and having "new" characters that a greater
> demographic finds relatable isn't "ticking off studio quotas" - it's
> reaching out to a larger potential audience.
Ah, that inane bollocks of an excuse.
> The crowing about it is, indeed, dumb and needs to go away - but half
> the time that's not what's happening.
It is what's happening. Advertising is constantly crowing about how
it's "the first" ... often when it actually isn't. For example, there
have been lots of TV shows with black characters or all black cast way
back on the 1970s and earlier, it's not something that suddenly started
happening in 2018 because morons with no knowledge of the past started
whining louder. :-\
> The studio just let everyone know who's been cast - then has to get
> defensive when reactionary dinosaurs go up in arms about it.
Because they moronically changed established characters to appease
"Politically Correct" whiners.
> I WANT sci-fi that women enjoy watching as well as men, where boys and
> girls; white, black, asian, and latino; gay and straight, bisexual,
> asexual, trans and non-binary; all have role models they can relate
> to. Not all in every show, not all in starring roles - but there. Why
> the hell not?
Real people will enojy the TV show / movie. Stoudi people who won't
watch isomething just because the lead isn't famale / gay / black /
disabled / etc. or because they have some mental health problem whereby
they have to "see themselves onscreen" are simply idiots not worth
bothering with.