Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

This week's BORG Episode on VOYAGER

11 views
Skip to first unread message

mojo

unread,
Feb 12, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/12/97
to


vinay nay pandey <vi...@linknet.net> wrote:

>BTW, if you could post updates from time to time about stuff on
>VOYAGER that would be worthy of seeing, we'd appreciate it. You can't
>really expect us to sit through their scripts, but we won't mind
>looking at pretty pictures.

FIRST let me say to everyone that I don't intend to try and hype
Voyager simply because we're doing FX for them now - I've been asked
about this so I'm going to comply, OK? So *please* no flames for this
post!!!

Anyway, yes, this week is the Borg and yes, Foundation has supplied
the visual FX, including a new Borg Cube.

FX aside, the script was very, very good and I anticipate it to be
perhaps the best show of the series (no, not just good for Voyager -
good for SF!).


MOJO

Jon Earle

unread,
Feb 12, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/12/97
to

mo...@foundation-i.com (mojo) wrote:

>FX aside, the script was very, very good and I anticipate it to be
>perhaps the best show of the series (no, not just good for Voyager -
>good for SF!).

FX aside, the script sucked! Those were Borg? Jeez.. they were no
more Borg than were the creatures in ST: FC. "We are a Collective,
composed of one mind. And this is our Queen." I half expected her,
at somepoint during the movie, to yell out in a Lisa Simpson voice "I
am the Borg Queen!"

The FX in this Borg ep, were not too shabby, and were the only
watchable parts of the show.

Puh-leeeze.


William Edward Woody

unread,
Feb 13, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/13/97
to

mo...@foundation-i.com (mojo) wrote:
> FX aside, the script was very, very good and I anticipate it to be
> perhaps the best show of the series (no, not just good for Voyager -
> good for SF!).

I have no doubts the effects probably look good.

But given a series with characters I don't care about, in a series
where the status quo must be more or less maintained at the end of
each episodic unit, God himself may not be capable of writing a script
good enough to surpass the average fourth-season Babylon 5 episode.

But then, Voyager doesn't have the advantage of characters that have
developed in front of our eyes over a few years (and who have grown
and changed, some radically). Nor does it have the advantage of an
overall story that is going somewhere, instead of floundering in space
70,000 light years from nowhere.

I just hope the Borg doesn't become to Star Trek what the Cylons
became to the Battlestar Galactica: a dependable 'baddie' the writers
could trot out from stage left to provide the antagonist to a story
they had little imagination to create from scratch.

Of course this is only my opinion.

- Bill

--
William Edward Woody - In Phase Consulting - wo...@alumni.caltech.edu
http://www.alumni.caltech.edu/~woody


Joshua Jasper

unread,
Feb 13, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/13/97
to rec-arts-sf-tv-b...@uunet.uu.net

In article <5dr1cp$e...@usenet79.supernews.com>,

mojo <mo...@foundation-i.com> wrote:
>
>
>vinay nay pandey <vi...@linknet.net> wrote:
>
>>BTW, if you could post updates from time to time about stuff on
>>VOYAGER that would be worthy of seeing, we'd appreciate it. You can't
>>really expect us to sit through their scripts, but we won't mind
>>looking at pretty pictures.
>
>FIRST let me say to everyone that I don't intend to try and hype
>Voyager simply because we're doing FX for them now - I've been asked
>about this so I'm going to comply, OK? So *please* no flames for this
>post!!!
>
>Anyway, yes, this week is the Borg and yes, Foundation has supplied
>the visual FX, including a new Borg Cube.
>
>FX aside, the script was very, very good and I anticipate it to be
>perhaps the best show of the series (no, not just good for Voyager -
>good for SF!).
>
Yeah, and it also had all the major problems in it 'fixed' by the
end of the ep. This is why I prefer B5 to ST. Not that for ST:V it was
bad, I agree, it was the best so far, it certainly beat the flying virus/
aliens rip off episode hands down ;)
Sinboy

Wookiee at the Helm!

unread,
Feb 13, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/13/97
to

On 13 Feb 1997, William Edward Woody wrote:

> I just hope the Borg doesn't become to Star Trek what the Cylons
> became to the Battlestar Galactica: a dependable 'baddie' the writers
> could trot out from stage left to provide the antagonist to a story
> they had little imagination to create from scratch.
>

Hey now!!! There was a reason for the Cylons showing up all the time in
Battlestar Galactica that was shown from the begining of the series. They
were programmed to hunt down and destroy all the humans. They took out a
huge chunk in the pilot episode, but a group escaped and was out in space
fleeing. a rag-tag fleet of them, if you will. Hence, being programmed to
kill all of the humans, the Cylons chased after them. Sure, that was
basically so that the dog-fights could use stock shots re-edited to make
them look like a new battle (same bad guys, same bad ships. On an aside,
They were robot/androids/biologically-challenged-beings, so why did it
take three of them to pilot those saucer ships? but I digress...). The
basic premise of BG was the escape from the Cylon's, and the search for
the lost 13th colony. That was always the premise of the show. So, while
it may not have been for the noblest of reason that they were set up so,
the Cylon's were a bit more then the standard bad guy to pull out when
the writers had no time/inclination to come up with a new one.

Now, the GI Joe cartoon had that problem. GI Joe, elite military
unit to fight against terrorism. ok, decent premise. But Cobra and
always Cobra?! did GI Joe destroy every other single terrorist ever while
recruiting even before the first miniseries? And, no other person ever
had terrorist inclinations, because the 'secret' GI Joe unit was so
powerful? or if they did, none had aspirations of power other then
climbing to the top in Cobra?

So, in conclusion, the Cylons were to BG what the Decepticons were
to the Transformers, where as your concern is more towards worrying that
the Borg will turn out to be the Cobra of ST:any/every series...

(Apologies now for this way off B5 topic digression, but I had to
defend the always misunderstood and much maligned Cylon's.)

Jason Snell

unread,
Feb 13, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/13/97
to

>Anyway, yes, this week is the Borg and yes, Foundation has supplied
>the visual FX, including a new Borg Cube.

Interesting.. I guess you did a good job, since it looked identical to the
ones seen in previous episodes.

>FX aside, the script was very, very good and I anticipate it to be
>perhaps the best show of the series (no, not just good for Voyager -
>good for SF!).

Oh, gee.. in Trek terms, it was a good story, but in continuity terms, it
was a washout.

In any event, it's nice to see Voyager taking a slight upturn in quality.
It's been a long, long night over there...

-jason

--
--
Jason Snell | http://www.etext.org/Zines/InterText/jason.html
jsn...@macuser.com | Senior Editor/Online, MacUser / Editor, InterText
jsn...@etext.org | Read TeeVee! http://search.intertext.com/teevee/


William Edward Woody

unread,
Feb 14, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/14/97
to

Wookiee at the Helm! <woo...@qni.com> wrote:
> On 13 Feb 1997, William Edward Woody wrote:
> > I just hope the Borg doesn't become to Star Trek what the Cylons
> > became to the Battlestar Galactica: a dependable 'baddie' the writers
> > could trot out from stage left to provide the antagonist to a story
> > they had little imagination to create from scratch.
>
> Hey now!!! There was a reason for the Cylons showing up all the time in
> Battlestar Galactica that was shown from the begining of the series. They
> were programmed to hunt down and destroy all the humans. ...

Yes, but it seemed that was because the human opposed the Cylons in the
last great war. Once the humans went well beyond Cylon-controlled space,
you'd think the Cylons would start thinning out, but noooooo.

I would have hoped Battlestar Galactica would have at least turned into
more of a "Wagon Train"--instead, we got the same episode every week,
with the only variations being exactly when the Cylons would show up,
and how.

> ... They took out a


> huge chunk in the pilot episode, but a group escaped and was out in space
> fleeing. a rag-tag fleet of them, if you will. Hence, being programmed to

> kill all of the humans, the Cylons chased after them. ...

But the Cylons never really 'chased' them--no matter how far away from
the 12 planets we got, no matter how far away from Cylon controlled
space we were, there was Yet Another Cylon depo, Yet Another Cylon-
controlled planet, Yet Another Cylon battlewaggon waiting around the
corner.

I did like the episode when they encountered the planet of humans
with the 'East' fighting the 'West', and we were never really certain
if we found a futuristic version of the Earth. I wished they did more
stuff like that and less stuff with the large stupid metalheads
intoning "by your command" before dying in a dogfight rerun...

> ... Sure, that was


> basically so that the dog-fights could use stock shots re-edited to make
> them look like a new battle (same bad guys, same bad ships. On an aside,
> They were robot/androids/biologically-challenged-beings, so why did it

> take three of them to pilot those saucer ships? but I digress...). ...

We actually got a boneheaded 'plot' explanation in one episode--it turns
out that the race who built the Cylon robots were trying to achieve
some form of 'perfection', and slowly replaced themselves with robots
who they considered a 'higher' form of evolution. (Makes me wonder how
a large, lumbering metal humanoid-shaped robot with a wrrring red eye
was 'superior', but I digress.)

The thing is, the race who built the robots only replaced biological
creatures with the biologically challenged, but as a one-to-one
replacement: they weren't constructed to directly interface with their
ship (for example), nor did they take a Cylon AI and put it into a
figher ship, because these were not biological 'replacements.'

(And besides, it made the networks happy by giving us a bad guy we
could kill on television without upsetting the censors who would not
allow humans or aliens to die en mass.)

> ... So, while


> it may not have been for the noblest of reason that they were set up so,
> the Cylon's were a bit more then the standard bad guy to pull out when
> the writers had no time/inclination to come up with a new one.

Bah. As we got farther and farther from the empire, it seemed an
act of laziness to have them encounter 'yet another outpost.' I could
almost see the writer's meeting: "hey, what do you want to do this week?"
"I dunno; maybe they find Yet Another Outpost?" "Oh, cool; I'll go
ahead and recycle the other four scripts where they encountered Yet
Another Outpost, and throw in a Plot Twist."


> (Apologies now for this way off B5 topic digression, but I had to
> defend the always misunderstood and much maligned Cylon's.)

Personally I thought of the lowly grunt Cylon metalheads as cute pets--
I wanted one when I was growing up. I thought it would be cool to have
a few hundred pounds of hokey-looking AI lumber around, wrrring that
cute little red light, saying "by your command" in that flat,
synthesized voice.

Now I write software for a living.

Oh, well; not quite my childhood dream, but close enough... :-)

gj...@lehigh.edu

unread,
Feb 14, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/14/97
to

In article <Pine.GSO.3.95.970213...@ultra.qni.com>, Wookiee at

the Helm! <woo...@qni.com> writes:
>On 13 Feb 1997, William Edward Woody wrote:
>
>> I just hope the Borg doesn't become to Star Trek what the Cylons
>> became to the Battlestar Galactica: a dependable 'baddie' the writers
>> could trot out from stage left to provide the antagonist to a story
>> they had little imagination to create from scratch.
>>
>
>Hey now!!! There was a reason for the Cylons showing up all the time in
>Battlestar Galactica that was shown from the begining of the series. They
>were programmed to hunt down and destroy all the humans. They took out a

>huge chunk in the pilot episode, but a group escaped and was out in space
>fleeing. a rag-tag fleet of them, if you will. Hence, being programmed to
>kill all of the humans, the Cylons chased after them. Sure, that was

>basically so that the dog-fights could use stock shots re-edited to make
>them look like a new battle (same bad guys, same bad ships. On an aside,
>They were robot/androids/biologically-challenged-beings, so why did it
>take three of them to pilot those saucer ships? but I digress...). The
>basic premise of BG was the escape from the Cylon's, and the search for
>the lost 13th colony. That was always the premise of the show. So, while

>it may not have been for the noblest of reason that they were set up so,
>the Cylon's were a bit more then the standard bad guy to pull out when
>the writers had no time/inclination to come up with a new one.
>
> Now, the GI Joe cartoon had that problem. GI Joe, elite military
>unit to fight against terrorism. ok, decent premise. But Cobra and
>always Cobra?! did GI Joe destroy every other single terrorist ever while

Hey wait! GI Joe troops or Cobra soldiers actually DESTROYING something!!
Come on. There aim was so bad they couldn't kill one person in endless years
of fighting. Of course, maybe I'm wrong, since both sides must have had
super-genetically engineered forces. How else do you explain how they could
have time to jump out of a tank before a missile going at Mach II could hit it
AND run far enough away to avoid shrapnel! :)


>recruiting even before the first miniseries? And, no other person ever
>had terrorist inclinations, because the 'secret' GI Joe unit was so
>powerful? or if they did, none had aspirations of power other then
>climbing to the top in Cobra?
>
> So, in conclusion, the Cylons were to BG what the Decepticons were
>to the Transformers, where as your concern is more towards worrying that
>the Borg will turn out to be the Cobra of ST:any/every series...

That's it!! That's what's going to happen now on B5. The AOL will have to
fight Unicron!!

>
> (Apologies now for this way off B5 topic digression, but I had to
>defend the always misunderstood and much maligned Cylon's.)
>
>
>

Greg

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| "In America, first you get de sugar, den |"All right Mulder. Who died this|
| you get de power, den you get de women!" |time?" |
| -Homer Simpson |-Dana Scully "The X-Files" |
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| "We're not the same. I'm an American. |"I've driven women to lesbianism |
| You're a sick asshole!" |before but never to an asylum!" |
| -DeFens "Falling Down" |-George Castanza |
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| "In America, first you get de sugar, den |"All right Mulder. Who died this|
| you get de power, den you get de women!" |time?" |
| -Homer Simpson |-Dana Scully "The X-Files" |
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| "We're not the same. I'm an American. |"I've driven women to lesbianism |
| You're a sick asshole!" |before but never to an asylum!" |

Mike Peake

unread,
Feb 14, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/14/97
to

Last week's Simpson's episode pointed out that adding new characters
to an established dynamic is a transparent grab for ratings.

And besides, the lead female 'borg' who befriended Chakotay said she
had been assimilated at Wolf 359, the big battle from "Best of Both
Worlds". Nonsense. That was a single Borg ship, which was destroyed at
the end of the second episode. And will someone please do the math
about how long it would take a Borg ship to travel from Federation
space to the Alpha Quadrant! I'll bet it's more than the specified
five years.

Who am I fooling, why the hell do I watch this remake of Gilligan's
Island anyway, esp. with B5 around? Someone please send the Narn Slap
On The Wrist Squad.

EMPeake

________

Specifications:

Source of Uncertainty/Stack Collision with Heap/Condemned to Freedom


This is not mind control-Think about it! --Shadoevision


Chuck Fullerton

unread,
Feb 14, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/14/97
to


EUREKA!!!!!!!
"Unity" kicked ASS!!!!!!!!!!
Imagine that! A Voyager episode that doesn't suck!
If every episode were this good, Voyager's problems would
be over. . .I'm glad I watched it!


<*>-CHUCK<*>


John & Linda VanSickle

unread,
Feb 14, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/14/97
to


mojo wrote:
>
> vinay nay pandey <vi...@linknet.net> wrote:
>
> >BTW, if you could post updates from time to time about stuff on
> >VOYAGER that would be worthy of seeing, we'd appreciate it. You can't
> >really expect us to sit through their scripts, but we won't mind
> >looking at pretty pictures.
>

> FX aside, the script was very, very good and I anticipate it to be
> perhaps the best show of the series (no, not just good for Voyager -
> good for SF!).

Uh, the plot had holes in it that we could drive the Vorlon planet killer
through. Like:

Why were the released draftees so eager to get back into the collective,
when ones like Hugh, born and raised in the collective, actually thought
freedom was really worth striving for?

Why was a Borg ship full of Federation-space draftees in the middle of
the Delta Quadrant? Did they just turn around and fly back?

Part way into the episode, we learn that a years-dead Borg corpse can be
revived. Why didn't Janeway immediately order all of them to be beamed
off and atomized?

Why didn't the Borg wannabes have Janeway beam down the equipment they wanted,
and then use it? It's not like they needed the whole ship for what they
wanted.

Why wasn't Janeway's answer to the wannabes thus: "We'll be glad to help you,
AFTER we've picked this ship clean."

NONE of the Ex-Borg wanted to go back to the Federation? Give me a break.

In short, it was a typical Voyager episode: Think up some nifty stuff,
and make darn sure that the most intelligent course of action nevers occurs
to any of the characters. Fortunately we saw very little of Neelix this
time around.

Regards,
John

--
"Is the power who is jealous of our prosperity, a proper power to govern
us?" -- Thomas Paine


John & Linda VanSickle vans...@erols.com


Barton Meeks

unread,
Feb 14, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/14/97
to

In article <woody-13029...@192.0.2.1>,
William Edward Woody <wo...@alumni.caltech.edu> wrote:

>Wookiee at the Helm! <woo...@qni.com> wrote:
>> On 13 Feb 1997, William Edward Woody wrote:
>> > I just hope the Borg doesn't become to Star Trek what the Cylons
>> > became to the Battlestar Galactica: a dependable 'baddie' the writers
>>
>> Hey now!!! There was a reason for the Cylons showing up all the time in
>> Battlestar Galactica that was shown from the beginning of the series. They
>> were programmed to hunt down and destroy all the humans. ...

>
>I would have hoped Battlestar Galactica would have at least turned into
>more of a "Wagon Train"--instead, we got the same episode every week,

Well, I never saw Wagon Train. But when I heard the premise of
Voyager, I hoped that it would be more like the original trek. It
seemed that TNG & DS9 had gotten a little too much Federation/Klingon
oriented, and I hoped that being away from all that would allow
Voyager to have some interesting, new stories. I haven't been too happy
with it so far. Possibly there are only so many stories, and I've
seen them already (but I don't think this is the case. I've NEVER seen
anything like B5 before!) Probably my disappointment has more to do
with the "safe franchise" mentality of trek, combined with becoming
recently getting hooked on B5.

B5: Stunning. Wonderful. Wish I had gotten hooked sooner. Wish I
could get friends/family interested in it.
TNG: At times, I was really into this show. Often entertaining,
sometimes excellent (but I didn't know about B5 then.)
DS9: Has its ups and downs. Some I really enjoy.
VOY: My original excitement for it faded. Quickly.
TOS: Wish it was repeating locally. But then again, I only really
time to keep up with one show now (the one this newsgroup is
about)

This is my first rastbm posting; sorry it is so far off topic. (But at
least I wasn't the one to bring up Battlestar Galactica or Wagon
Train!)
--
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Barton Meeks bme...@nortel.ca Raleigh, NC, USA

SGWM

unread,
Feb 14, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/14/97
to

vinay pandey <vi...@linknet.net> wrote:
>
>>BTW, if you could post updates from time to time about stuff on
>>VOYAGER that would be worthy of seeing, we'd appreciate it. You can't
>>really expect us to sit through their scripts, but we won't mind
>>looking at pretty pictures.

i.e. tell me about the FX, not the show as a whole.

On 12 Feb 1997 14:12:55 -0500, mo...@foundation-i.com (mojo) wrote:
>FIRST let me say to everyone that I don't intend to try and hype
>Voyager simply because we're doing FX for them now - I've been asked
>about this so I'm going to comply, OK? So *please* no flames for this
>post!!!

i.e. Mojo says he isn't plugging ST:V, he's only been asked about FX.

Minor comment about FX with no real revelations or discussion of
substance snipped for brevity . . .

>FX aside, the script was very, very good and I anticipate it to be
>perhaps the best show of the series (no, not just good for Voyager -
>good for SF!).

And then he goes on to plainly contradict his earlier statment 'I
don't intend to try and hype it' to unashamedly plug it instead of
talking about his realm of expertise, FX, which is what he was asked
to do.

Mojo, many of us don't watch ST:V because we did for too long in the
hope it would improve. It didn't and it hasn't. Your FX are great and
I think *very* highly of your work, but your obvious attempts to plug
ST:V and win viewers by reappearing here after at least a year's
abscence and only then after Foundation had 'left' the show makes it
all too obvious, IMO, you're only here to carry out a high profile PR
job for Foundation and "The Franchise". Please just stick to what
you're good at because these thinly veiled adverts for ST:V are
getting dull now. Please, just take the spam to sickbay and leave it
there, alongside the rest of the cheese.

However, I digress. I am interested in ST:V, if only for the FX. I'd
be very interested in hearing more about the FX as I'd imagine many
people here gave ST:V two and a bit seasons and gave up because of
it's irredeemably bad scripts, aimless characterisation and downright
dumbness (Threshold, Twisted, The 37's - I rest my case).

Seriously though, I'd love to hear more about the FX and the new
challenges posed by working in a very different environment to B5.
So, to be positive, tell us some more about the FX this time. How did
you texture map the new borg cube so it doesn't look like 6 flat
surfaces with pictures superimposed on them? It's an interesting FX
problem and one that I'd like to hear more about having seen it in a
B5 trailer. Looks pretty good from what I saw and I can't imagine it
would've been easy to construct even though it is 'just' a cube,
because of matching the texture of the surface to protrusions - like
drawing a bottle, the basic shape is trivial but the reflections are
difficult to represent.

So how about sharing your 'collective' wisdom with us on this subject?
It'd make far more interesting reading and might actually generate
some valid points of discussion.

All my opinions are my own.

--
Though much is taken, much abides; and though
We are not now that strength which in old days
Moved earth and heaven, that which we are, we are-
One equal temper of heroic hearts,
Made weak by time and fate, but strong in will
To strive, to seek, to find, and not to yield.

Alfred, Lord Tennyson


Brent Schmidt

unread,
Feb 14, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/14/97
to

John & Linda VanSickle wrote:

>
> mojo wrote:
> >
> > FX aside, the script was very, very good and I anticipate it to be
> > perhaps the best show of the series (no, not just good for Voyager -
> > good for SF!).

Me thinks you are overstating the episode just a bit. It was
acceptable, I wasn't yelling at the TV due to the inaccuraces, but it
was hardly stellar.

> Uh, the plot had holes in it that we could drive the Vorlon planet killer
> through. Like:
>

[snip]

You missed one plot hole. The woman character, whatever her name was,
said she was assimilated by the Borg at Wolf 359. But there was only
one Borg ship at Wolf 359 and it was destroyed, how did she get back to
the collective AND end up in the Delta Quadrant?

> In short, it was a typical Voyager episode: Think up some nifty stuff,
> and make darn sure that the most intelligent course of action nevers occurs
> to any of the characters. Fortunately we saw very little of Neelix this
> time around.
>
> Regards,
> John

Thank the Maker. I would sincerely love that show if they killed off
the "wacky" alien.
--
------------------------------------------------
Docking Bay 13 - http://www.mcs.net/~tvsbrent/
Brent Schmidt TVsB...@MCS.COM
------------------------------------------------


Chris Campbell

unread,
Feb 14, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/14/97
to

In article <woody-12029...@192.0.2.1>, wo...@alumni.caltech.edu (William Edward Woody) wrote:

>mo...@foundation-i.com (mojo) wrote:
>> FX aside, the script was very, very good and I anticipate it to be
>> perhaps the best show of the series (no, not just good for Voyager -
>> good for SF!).
>
>I have no doubts the effects probably look good.
>
>But given a series with characters I don't care about, in a series
>where the status quo must be more or less maintained at the end of
>each episodic unit, God himself may not be capable of writing a script
>good enough to surpass the average fourth-season Babylon 5 episode.
>
>But then, Voyager doesn't have the advantage of characters that have
>developed in front of our eyes over a few years (and who have grown
>and changed, some radically). Nor does it have the advantage of an
>overall story that is going somewhere, instead of floundering in space
>70,000 light years from nowhere.
>
>I just hope the Borg doesn't become to Star Trek what the Cylons
>became to the Battlestar Galactica: a dependable 'baddie' the writers
>could trot out from stage left to provide the antagonist to a story
>they had little imagination to create from scratch.

Geez, first everyone's yapping about the lack of Borg in the Delta Quadrant
(since that *is* where they came from) and now we get this. Sure, Voyager in
general is relatively poor, but this was a plotline that actually made sense.
They were bound to run into the Borg sooner or later; avoiding it would just
be silly.

Chris


Chris Campbell

unread,
Feb 14, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/14/97
to

In article <330401...@erols.com>, John & Linda VanSickle <vans...@erols.com> wrote:
>
>
>mojo wrote:

>>
>> vinay nay pandey <vi...@linknet.net> wrote:
>>
>> >BTW, if you could post updates from time to time about stuff on
>> >VOYAGER that would be worthy of seeing, we'd appreciate it. You can't
>> >really expect us to sit through their scripts, but we won't mind
>> >looking at pretty pictures.
>>
>> FX aside, the script was very, very good and I anticipate it to be
>> perhaps the best show of the series (no, not just good for Voyager -
>> good for SF!).
>
>Uh, the plot had holes in it that we could drive the Vorlon planet killer
>through. Like:
>
>Why were the released draftees so eager to get back into the collective,
>when ones like Hugh, born and raised in the collective, actually thought
>freedom was really worth striving for?

Uh, gee, maybe free thinkers have different ideas about what to do?

>Why was a Borg ship full of Federation-space draftees in the middle of
>the Delta Quadrant? Did they just turn around and fly back?

Well, the Borg are based in the Delta Quadrant; what, no one ever reports
back?

>Part way into the episode, we learn that a years-dead Borg corpse can be
>revived. Why didn't Janeway immediately order all of them to be beamed
>off and atomized?

Actually, the doctor said it was just a mechanical reflex. He never indicated
it was fully revived.

>Why didn't the Borg wannabes have Janeway beam down the equipment they wanted,
>and then use it? It's not like they needed the whole ship for what they
>wanted.

Because the equipment needed is a network throughout the ship. What, are you
gonna transfer the necessary systems, plus the power supply, plus the
infrastructure to support them? You might as well beam down the whole bloody
cube.

>Why wasn't Janeway's answer to the wannabes thus: "We'll be glad to help you,
>AFTER we've picked this ship clean."

Picked clean of what? Do they really want to dilly dally vaporizing 1100 Borg
and ensuring the ship won't pose a threat (good luck)?

>NONE of the Ex-Borg wanted to go back to the Federation? Give me a break.

Out of some 4 people? Why should they, necessarily? It's not like they can
exactly go back to their original lives, and it would take 67 years to get
there anyway. Better odds on the planet.

>In short, it was a typical Voyager episode: Think up some nifty stuff,
>and make darn sure that the most intelligent course of action nevers occurs
>to any of the characters. Fortunately we saw very little of Neelix this
>time around.

Actually, sounds more like typical ST bashing from here. It was a decent
episode, with a fairly novel idea and some good resolutions. Within the
constraints of Trek in general and Voyager in particular it was pretty damn
good. No, it's not B5 but not everything has to be.

Chris


Magick Man

unread,
Feb 15, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/15/97
to

: >Anyway, yes, this week is the Borg and yes, Foundation has supplied

: >the visual FX, including a new Borg Cube.


All right, here's something I must ask. It has bugged me
ever since the first series of TNG.

Whenever the Enterprise meets another ship, why are they
ALWAYS right-side-up with respect to each other? I don't
think I've ever seen an episode in which a working
vessel was at any other orientation.

Now, I came across Voyager the other night while channel-grazing.
I knew nothing about the episode and had not seen any trailers,
but I immediately knew that the Borg ship was disabled. Why?
Because it was tipped sideways! The silly thing was on an angle
in the viewscreen, so it was *obviously* not functioning.

I've heard devout Trekkies explain that the ship's viewer
automatically orients ship images to be right-side-up, to avoid
making the bridge crew disoriented. However, this explanation
conveniently ignores the fact that even the exterior shots
always show the ships' tops pointing in the same direction.
Not to mention that it ignores the shots of disabled ships
(like the Borg Cube), which are almost always slanted.

Once someone's given me a satisfactory answer to this question,
I can start asking why invisible ships *always* decloak in front
of the Enterprise, instead of behind it where the armament is
weaker. But I'll limit myself to one basic CGI flaw per week...

Magick Man

GM/S/CS d- s:->:-- a-- C++(++++) UU P+ L? E--- W+ N++
o++>++++ K? w(---) O? M--- V- PS+ PE Y+ PGP- t+(+++)*
5+++ X R+ tv+ b++++ DI+ D++ G+++ e++>++++ h! r++ y++

Charles J. Walther

unread,
Feb 15, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/15/97
to

Brent Schmidt wrote:
>

>
> > Uh, the plot had holes in it that we could drive the Vorlon planet killer through. Like:

Hey this is Voyager...you're expecting science fiction or something?
> >
>
> [snip]


>
>
> Fortunately we saw very little of Neelix this
> > time around.
> >

> > Regards,
> > John
>
> Thank the Maker. I would sincerely love that show if they killed off
> the "wacky" alien.
> --
> ------------------------------------------------
> Docking Bay 13 - http://www.mcs.net/~tvsbrent/
> Brent Schmidt TVsB...@MCS.COM
> ------------------------------------------------

I think that Neelix is to Voyager what Wesley Crusher (and his mother
for that fact) were to TNG. In short characters you love to think up new
ways to kill in the most gruesome manner.

Chuck


Annie Fox

unread,
Feb 15, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/15/97
to

Although it was not the best plot I've ever seen, it is
the best for VOYAGER. It also lends insight into how
the Borg collective was formed. Given the way the episode
was ended, given the way they sounded and behaved while in
that mini-semi-independent Borg collective, I can see how
a small proto-Borg community with good, peaceful intentions
can evolve into the Borg we see now.

I liked it. It's not B5, but it was passable.

-Peter


Chris Campbell

unread,
Feb 15, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/15/97
to


In article <5e3ebp$s...@linet06.li.net>, mag...@li.net (Magick Man)


<jsnell-1302...@js.macuser.zd.com> wrote:
>: >Anyway, yes, this week is the Borg and yes, Foundation has supplied
>: >the visual FX, including a new Borg Cube.
>
>
>All right, here's something I must ask. It has bugged me
>ever since the first series of TNG.
>
>Whenever the Enterprise meets another ship, why are they
>ALWAYS right-side-up with respect to each other? I don't
>think I've ever seen an episode in which a working
>vessel was at any other orientation.

I recalls seeing in several episodes ships which purposely orient themselves
so that they're on the same plane. It's probably to keep the crews from going
schizoid.

>Once someone's given me a satisfactory answer to this question,
>I can start asking why invisible ships *always* decloak in front
>of the Enterprise, instead of behind it where the armament is
>weaker. But I'll limit myself to one basic CGI flaw per week...

Typically, the ships decloaking are in a threat posture instead of an attack
posture. Decloaking behind the Enterprise (which actually, according to the
technical readouts and such, had pretty good armament to the rear) would be
interpreted as an attack and responded to as such. In fact, there have been a
couple of times when a ship did decloak to the rear of the Enterprise, and it
was always followed up with an attack.

The long and short of it is that the answer to both of your questions has to
do with making things easier on the viewers. We've been spoiled on B5 so we
think variations in such things would be cool; they make the average viewer's
(read: not SF junkie) head hurt.

Chris


William Edward Woody

unread,
Feb 15, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/15/97
to

In article <330524...@MCS.COM>, TVsB...@MCS.COM wrote:
> You missed one plot hole. The woman character, whatever her name was,
> said she was assimilated by the Borg at Wolf 359. But there was only
> one Borg ship at Wolf 359 and it was destroyed, how did she get back to
> the collective AND end up in the Delta Quadrant?

Maybe the Borg, while fighting the Federation at Wolf 359 managed to
assimilate a few ships before moving to Earth? And maybe those assimilated
ships slipped into a convenient 'space-time anomaly' which seems to
pop up like popcorn as the "plot device of the week" on Star Trek?

And maybe I like Babylon 5 because it doesn't resort to cheap tricks
to assure plot continuity, and require equipment failure to create
plot tension? After all, if I were the manufacturer of the transporter
pad in the various Enterprises to grace the big screen, I'd certainly
wouldn't expect to survive the lawsuits the Federation would file
against me.

(Oh, that's right--we killed all the lawyers, except for the ones
who work for the Federation's foreign affairs bureau.)

Diane L. Schirf

unread,
Feb 15, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/15/97
to

In article <5e50r5$6...@larch.cc.swarthmore.edu>,
f...@allspice.cs.swarthmore.edu (Annie Fox) wrote:

I thought it showed the potential Voyager's always had, but the writers
keep blowing.

--
Diane L. Schirf, introverted exhibitionist
sl...@aol.com | del...@mindspring.com | http://members.aol.com/slywy
Updated 4 February 1997 with a menage a trois photo! :)
Take the European IQ test at http://cech.cesnet.cz/IQ/IQ-test-e.html
"Who knows . . . what evil . . . llllllurks in the hearts of men? The *Shadows* know . . ."


William Edward Woody

unread,
Feb 15, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/15/97
to

In article <5e3ebp$s...@linet06.li.net>, mag...@li.net (Magick Man) wrote:
> All right, here's something I must ask. It has bugged me
> ever since the first series of TNG.

Actually, it's been around since the first few episodes of the
original Star Trek series.

> Whenever the Enterprise meets another ship, why are they
> ALWAYS right-side-up with respect to each other? I don't
> think I've ever seen an episode in which a working
> vessel was at any other orientation.

ROFL!

> Now, I came across Voyager the other night while channel-grazing.
> I knew nothing about the episode and had not seen any trailers,
> but I immediately knew that the Borg ship was disabled. Why?
> Because it was tipped sideways! The silly thing was on an angle
> in the viewscreen, so it was *obviously* not functioning.
>
> I've heard devout Trekkies explain that the ship's viewer
> automatically orients ship images to be right-side-up, to avoid

> making the bridge crew disoriented. ...

This begs another question, which I will pose:

How does the ship's viewscreen know that the ship is disabled?

If we presume that the viewscreen automatically rotates the view
to show ships upright, then shouldn't it always rotate the view
regardless of the status of the other ship?

And I won't even get into the question of how the viewscreen
knows what is 'up' with the other ship--after all, 'up' may
not be as trivial as looking for the bridge, or as irrelevant
as it is with the Borg cube.

> ... However, this explanation


> conveniently ignores the fact that even the exterior shots
> always show the ships' tops pointing in the same direction.

This is a common mistake, and I suspect it's made more by the
artists who are looking to recreate the 'battleships sailing
into battle or off into the distance' look, but in space.

Star Trek made that mistake (I always wondered why the equator
of the Death Star was always shown as horizontal from the
distance, even when we were from the viewpoint of X-wing
fighers flying towards it. After all, if I were flying a small
atmospheric ship in orbit, I'd either orient myself so that
my heat shield (presumably on the bottom of my ship, which
would be the first surface to hit the atmosphere when I fly back
to the planet) was facing towards the local star (like the
Space Shuttle does), or I would leave my orientation so that
'up' and 'down' was relative to the planet I was near.

The X-wing fighers did neither, instead orienting themselves in
an arbitrary orientation that matched the Death Star's equator--
even though this had nothing to do with the canyon they were going
to run down, or anything else in the story.

It was simply artistic license.

> Not to mention that it ignores the shots of disabled ships
> (like the Borg Cube), which are almost always slanted.

I think artists forget that Space is not the ocean. Perhaps
on an ocean a disabled ship would tilt over. But in space,
I would expect a damaged ship to rotate (due to outgassing
of important gasses/fluids), or to do something else equally
interesting.

But listing in a non-existant ocean seems silly.

> Once someone's given me a satisfactory answer to this question,
> I can start asking why invisible ships *always* decloak in front
> of the Enterprise, instead of behind it where the armament is
> weaker. But I'll limit myself to one basic CGI flaw per week...

Courtesy?

Paul Lozito

unread,
Feb 16, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/16/97
to

On 15 Feb 1997 10:16:09 -0500, mag...@li.net (Magick Man) wrote:

snip


>All right, here's something I must ask. It has bugged me
>ever since the first series of TNG.
>

>Whenever the Enterprise meets another ship, why are they
>ALWAYS right-side-up with respect to each other? I don't

snip again

>but I immediately knew that the Borg ship was disabled. Why?
>Because it was tipped sideways! The silly thing was on an angle
>in the viewscreen, so it was *obviously* not functioning.
>
>I've heard devout Trekkies explain that the ship's viewer
>automatically orients ship images to be right-side-up, to avoid

>making the bridge crew disoriented. However, this explanation


>conveniently ignores the fact that even the exterior shots
>always show the ships' tops pointing in the same direction.

>Not to mention that it ignores the shots of disabled ships
>(like the Borg Cube), which are almost always slanted.
>

>Once someone's given me a satisfactory answer to this question,
>I can start asking why invisible ships *always* decloak in front
>of the Enterprise, instead of behind it where the armament is
>weaker. But I'll limit myself to one basic CGI flaw per week...
>

>Magick Man

As far as orientation is concerned, you will find the reason in a
little known codicil of the Organean Peace Treaty that ordained that
all vessels must orient themselves in respect to the galactic plane.
It's been revealed that the Organeans were cousins of the Q, and so
were able to enforce this effect upon even the Borg.

De-cloak behind a ship? Gain the element of surprise? Whip the
Federation ships that can't for some lame-ass excuse of a treaty have
cloaking devices?. Sheesh, do you know where this kind of thinking
leads to?


* Paul Lozito
* Salvor...@msn.com
* plo...@hr.house.gov
*
* "Violence is the last refuge of the incompetent"

Harry McDow

unread,
Feb 16, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/16/97
to

Diane L. Schirf wrote:
>
> >I liked it. It's not B5, but it was passable.
> > -Peter
>
> I thought it showed the potential Voyager's always had, but the writers
> keep blowing.

One of the very few episodes that held my attention. Voyager has had so
many opportunities and [apparently] not taken them... I've almost given
up hope.

Harry

Gordon Glenn

unread,
Feb 16, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/16/97
to

William Edward Woody wrote:
>
> In article <5e3ebp$s...@linet06.li.net>, mag...@li.net (Magick Man) wrote:
> > All right, here's something I must ask. It has bugged me
> > ever since the first series of TNG.
>
> Actually, it's been around since the first few episodes of the
> original Star Trek series.
>
> > Whenever the Enterprise meets another ship, why are they
> > ALWAYS right-side-up with respect to each other? I don't
> > think I've ever seen an episode in which a working
> > vessel was at any other orientation.
>

I rather suspect that this is a matter of navigational convenience.
The Milky Way Galaxy, which we are in, is somewhat disc shaped. The
Star Ship has to navigate using an X/Y/Z coordinate and probably
uses certain references, such as the center of the galaxy, the edge,
and some other points to help with navigation. Certainly, it
would be helpful to keep the ship in a certain orientation to allow
the computers to reference these points (which begs the question
how they could do it in warp, but that would be another story!).
It may be that the federation and most other empires have a tacit
agreement that common points of reference and orientation will
be used in order to avoid making themselves hazards, etc. Not
a great explanation, but we will leave it to future star voyagers
to work out the details.

Boojiboy
--
Gordon A. Glenn aka Boojiboy -- gag...@ix.netcom.com
Likes: Sci-Fi, Star Trek, Star Wars, Babylon 5, X-Files, Stephen King
Video Game Systems Owned: Fairchild Channel F, Atari VCS/2600,
Atari 5200, Atari 7800, Intellivision II, Vectrex, Colecovision,
NES, SNES, SMS, Genesis, TurboDuo, 32X, 3DO, Jaguar... with more to
come!
Check out my web page devoted to Middle Aged Gamers at
http://www.netcom.com/~gaglenn/midgamer.html

In the real world I am a personal injury attorney in San Diego,
California.
Check out my law office web page at
http://www.netcom.com/~gaglenn/lawoffice.html

William Edward Woody

unread,
Feb 16, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/16/97
to

wo...@alumni.caltech.edu (William Edward Woody) wrote:
> Star Trek made that mistake (I always wondered why the equator
^^^^^^^^^

Oooops... Star <<Wars>>. Didn't mean to confuse one Billion-dollar
franchise with another. Just a simple typo.

Robert Denier

unread,
Feb 17, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/17/97
to


mojo <mo...@foundation-i.com> wrote in article
<5dr1cp$e...@usenet79.supernews.com>...


>
>
> vinay nay pandey <vi...@linknet.net> wrote:
>
> >BTW, if you could post updates from time to time about stuff on
> >VOYAGER that would be worthy of seeing, we'd appreciate it. You can't
> >really expect us to sit through their scripts, but we won't mind
> >looking at pretty pictures.


The problem with voyager is it has no continuity to speak of. Everything
is basically delt with in one episode. There is just not much you can do
with that. It also puzzles my why someone who found an intact borg ship
would attempt to leave it like they found it. There should be a star fleet
general order or something along the lines of if you find anything borg
blow it up.

Also it was amazing how many times some of the same "bad guys" kept showing
up to bug voyager. They are supposed to traveling at high warp almost
continuosly.

Perhaps the show would have greater potential if the crew had some larger
purpose other than traveling in a straight line home.

Another interesting idea would be to pick up some more hitchikers along the
way. Surely some of the planets they stop at will have people wanting to
see the galaxy (Or just get away from where they are.)

DS9 on the other hand is begining to show some potential, but that is more
or less because DS9 has more continuity than voyager and in some ways
better actors.

-robert

p.s. Of course nothing on telivision compares to B5. Perhaps it isn't
perfect, but it at least has aspirations for perfection.


john

unread,
Feb 17, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/17/97
to

William Edward Woody wrote:
>
> Maybe the Borg, while fighting the Federation at Wolf 359 managed to
> assimilate a few ships before moving to Earth? And maybe those assimilated
> ships slipped into a convenient 'space-time anomaly' which seems to
> pop up like popcorn as the "plot device of the week" on Star Trek?

So common in fact, that nobody on the bridge ever says 'how' when asked
to check for
the presence of said anomalies.

>
> And maybe I like Babylon 5 because it doesn't resort to cheap tricks
> to assure plot continuity, and require equipment failure to create
> plot tension? After all, if I were the manufacturer of the transporter
> pad in the various Enterprises to grace the big screen, I'd certainly
> wouldn't expect to survive the lawsuits the Federation would file
> against me.

How about the Holodeck(TM)? Tell me... if you knew that holodecks
malfunctioned as
frequently and catastrophically as do those in TNG, DS9, and Voyager,
would *you*
want to use one. Geez.

I remember catching part of one episode of B5 (1st season) at about
12:30am and
not being impressed. Didn't watch again until Season 3. Damn! All I can
say is that
if the makers of the DS9 and Voyagers could learn a little from JMS,
then they
wouldn't have to prey on the good nature of Trekkies.

OBcompliment:
1) The battle scene in TLN: phenomenal!


Peter J. Stewart

unread,
Feb 17, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/17/97
to rec-arts-sf-tv-b...@uunet.uu.net

Gordon Glenn (gag...@ix.netcom.com) wrote:

: William Edward Woody wrote:
: >
: > In article <5e3ebp$s...@linet06.li.net>, mag...@li.net (Magick Man) wrote:
: > > All right, here's something I must ask. It has bugged me
: > > ever since the first series of TNG.
: >
: > Actually, it's been around since the first few episodes of the
: > original Star Trek series.
: >
: > > Whenever the Enterprise meets another ship, why are they
: > > ALWAYS right-side-up with respect to each other? I don't
: > > think I've ever seen an episode in which a working
: > > vessel was at any other orientation.
: >

: I rather suspect that this is a matter of navigational convenience.
: The Milky Way Galaxy, which we are in, is somewhat disc shaped. The
: Star Ship has to navigate using an X/Y/Z coordinate and probably
: uses certain references, such as the center of the galaxy, the edge,
: and some other points to help with navigation. Certainly, it
: would be helpful to keep the ship in a certain orientation to allow
: the computers to reference these points (which begs the question
: how they could do it in warp, but that would be another story!).
: It may be that the federation and most other empires have a tacit
: agreement that common points of reference and orientation will
: be used in order to avoid making themselves hazards, etc. Not
: a great explanation, but we will leave it to future star voyagers
: to work out the details.

Also recall that despite the three-dimensional aspect of space, just about
all battles on SF TV and movies happen in a very two-dimensional manner. The
two notable exceptions in the Trek universe are when Kirk was battling Khan
in Star Trek II (in fact, using Khan's "two-dimensional" thinking against him
in the battle), and in the finale for ST:TNG when the Enterprise from the
future fried the Klingon ship.

Pete

--
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pete Stewart | "Violence is the last refuge of the incompetent"
ste...@bae.bellcore.com | - Salvor Hardin
------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Peter J. Stewart

unread,
Feb 17, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/17/97
to rec-arts-sf-tv-b...@uunet.uu.net

Magick Man (mag...@li.net) wrote:
: : >Anyway, yes, this week is the Borg and yes, Foundation has supplied
: : >the visual FX, including a new Borg Cube.

: All right, here's something I must ask. It has bugged me
: ever since the first series of TNG.

: Whenever the Enterprise meets another ship, why are they


: ALWAYS right-side-up with respect to each other? I don't
: think I've ever seen an episode in which a working
: vessel was at any other orientation.

: Now, I came across Voyager the other night while channel-grazing.


: I knew nothing about the episode and had not seen any trailers,

: but I immediately knew that the Borg ship was disabled. Why?


: Because it was tipped sideways! The silly thing was on an angle
: in the viewscreen, so it was *obviously* not functioning.

: I've heard devout Trekkies explain that the ship's viewer
: automatically orients ship images to be right-side-up, to avoid
: making the bridge crew disoriented. However, this explanation
: conveniently ignores the fact that even the exterior shots
: always show the ships' tops pointing in the same direction.
: Not to mention that it ignores the shots of disabled ships
: (like the Borg Cube), which are almost always slanted.

The reason for this has to do with the fact that TV writes to the lowest
common denominator education-wise in the audience. Unfortunately, the great
majority of people watching TV are going to react to a realistically-depicted
encounter with confusion, wondering what happened to make all the ships
all cockeyed with relation to each other. The reason the Borg cube was slanted
(as are all disabled vessels when encountered) is because that's what the
majority of the audience *expects* to see. Most people are very "grounded"
in their thinking and need these visual cues to understand what is going
on. While B5 is a much more intelligently-written show that seeks to break
from the mold of "writing down" to the audience, it still adopts this
convention as well to avoid confusion.

: Once someone's given me a satisfactory answer to this question,


: I can start asking why invisible ships *always* decloak in front
: of the Enterprise, instead of behind it where the armament is
: weaker. But I'll limit myself to one basic CGI flaw per week...

That one is a whole different discussion involving those two words that always
make me wince: dramatically appropriate :)

Timothy C. Eisele

unread,
Feb 17, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/17/97
to

Peter J. Stewart (pet...@netcom.com) wrote:
:
: The reason for this has to do with the fact that TV writes to the lowest

: common denominator education-wise in the audience. Unfortunately, the great
: majority of people watching TV are going to react to a realistically-depicted
: encounter with confusion, wondering what happened to make all the ships
: all cockeyed with relation to each other. The reason the Borg cube was slanted
: (as are all disabled vessels when encountered) is because that's what the
: majority of the audience *expects* to see. Most people are very "grounded"
: in their thinking and need these visual cues to understand what is going
: on. While B5 is a much more intelligently-written show that seeks to break
: from the mold of "writing down" to the audience, it still adopts this
: convention as well to avoid confusion.
:
Actually, there is a perfectly good way out of this, and has the advantage
that it is probably what would be done in a real ship, to boot: Design
the ships so that they are radially symmetric, and there is no preferred
"up" direction (or "up" is towards the nose, and "down" is towards
the tail). The Starfuries are tending this way, as are the EA destroyers,
but they aren't there yet. The smaller Vorlon vessels are pretty much
free of this problem, being more or less cylindrical.

Tim Eisele
tcei...@mtu.edu


Dan Wallach

unread,
Feb 17, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/17/97
to


In article <5e3ebp$s...@linet06.li.net>, Magick Man <mag...@li.net> wrote:
>Whenever the Enterprise meets another ship, why are they
>ALWAYS right-side-up with respect to each other? I don't
>think I've ever seen an episode in which a working
>vessel was at any other orientation.

The ST:TNG finale had Riker & the three-engined Enterprise (and
their Wave Motion Gun! -- oops, wrong show) attacking the bad-guy
Klingons from below.

ST:FC also had people walking on the bottom of the Enterprise, with
up and down conveniently swapped.

No other examples of non-planar Star Trek combat come immediately
to mind, but I'm sure they're out there, *somewhere*.


--
Dan Wallach Princeton University, Computer Science Department
dwal...@cs.princeton.edu http://www.cs.princeton.edu/~dwallach/ PGP Ready


William Edward Woody

unread,
Feb 17, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/17/97
to

In article <petranE5...@netcom.com>, ste...@bae.bellcore.com wrote:

> Gordon Glenn (gag...@ix.netcom.com) wrote:
> : I rather suspect that this is a matter of navigational convenience.
> : The Milky Way Galaxy, which we are in, is somewhat disc shaped. The
> : Star Ship has to navigate using an X/Y/Z coordinate and probably
> : uses certain references, such as the center of the galaxy, the edge,
> : and some other points to help with navigation. Certainly, it
> : would be helpful to keep the ship in a certain orientation to allow
> : the computers to reference these points (which begs the question
> : how they could do it in warp, but that would be another story!).

"It would be helpful to keep the ship in a certain orientation to
allow the computers to reference these points"--nonsense!

If the Voyager II probe can keep it's reference points without having
to constantly orient the probe to be 'right-side up' relative to
galactic north, and it's only using an 1802 microprocessor--which has
less computing power than a 20 dollar calculator nowadays, then why
should the supercomputers in the Star Trek universe not be able to
do the same thing?


> Also recall that despite the three-dimensional aspect of space, just about
> all battles on SF TV and movies happen in a very two-dimensional manner. The
> two notable exceptions in the Trek universe are when Kirk was battling Khan
> in Star Trek II (in fact, using Khan's "two-dimensional" thinking against him
> in the battle), and in the finale for ST:TNG when the Enterprise from the
> future fried the Klingon ship.

The battle in Star Trek II was more 2 1/2 dimensional--Khan used
ocean-surface tactics while Kirk used submarine tactics.

Nah, the best example of non-2D space battles in 'Trek was with the
television finale of ST:NG, when we see a Klingon cruser being blown to
bits from an Enterprise oriented flying 'up' from below. Now *that* was
a dramatic bit of special effects.

Gordon Glenn

unread,
Feb 17, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/17/97
to

William Edward Woody wrote:

SNIP!

>
> "It would be helpful to keep the ship in a certain orientation to
> allow the computers to reference these points"--nonsense!
>
> If the Voyager II probe can keep it's reference points without having
> to constantly orient the probe to be 'right-side up' relative to
> galactic north, and it's only using an 1802 microprocessor--which has
> less computing power than a 20 dollar calculator nowadays, then why
> should the supercomputers in the Star Trek universe not be able to
> do the same thing?

SNIP!

> - Bill
>
> --
> William Edward Woody - In Phase Consulting - wo...@alumni.caltech.edu
> http://www.alumni.caltech.edu/~woody

I think there is a *big* difference between a craft such as Voyager II
that has just one destination, compared to interstellar craft that
have to navigate multiple interstellar destinations "on the fly".
To create "maps", like in Star Trek -- Generations, they would need
to use a set of reference points in order to determine travel distance,
and to avoid previously mapped hazards.

Neely Stewart

unread,
Feb 17, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/17/97
to

>Perhaps the show would have greater potential if the crew had some larger
>purpose other than traveling in a straight line home.

Hypernauts had that potential. Aside from being a kid's show, the
premise was much more interesting -- and almost exactly what I
thought Voyager would be before it's premiere.

Neely


Marty T

unread,
Feb 18, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/18/97
to

mo...@foundation-i.com (mojo) wrote:

MO> FIRST let me say to everyone that I don't intend to try and
MO> hype Voyager simply because we're doing FX for them now


Then mo...@foundation-i.com (mojo) wrote:

MO> FX aside, the script was very, very good and I anticipate
MO> it to be perhaps the best show of the series (no, not just
MO> good for Voyager - good for SF!).

mojo, meet mojo.
___
X SLMR 2.1a X UPN: A TV Network for Urologists??? t


William Edward Woody

unread,
Feb 18, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/18/97
to

Gordon Glenn <gag...@ix.netcom.com> wrote:
> I think there is a *big* difference between a craft such as Voyager II
> that has just one destination, compared to interstellar craft that
> have to navigate multiple interstellar destinations "on the fly".
> To create "maps", like in Star Trek -- Generations, they would need
> to use a set of reference points in order to determine travel distance,
> and to avoid previously mapped hazards.

How more computationally difficult can that be? Find three known
reference points (beacons, stars, whatever), and calculate your
approximate location based on those references?

Certainly a computational system sophisticated enough to create a
holographic doctor by simulating the computations done in the human
brain can do a few more trig operations to account for the rotational
orientation of the ship...

Rasalom

unread,
Feb 18, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/18/97
to

The Just and Noble, John & Linda VanSickle <vans...@erols.com> had
this to say:

>Uh, the plot had holes in it that we could drive the Vorlon planet killer
>through. Like:

---- Snip ----

>Part way into the episode, we learn that a years-dead Borg corpse can be
>revived. Why didn't Janeway immediately order all of them to be beamed
>off and atomized?

A five years dead Borg corpse...

_Anything to report, Tuvok_?
_Yes, Captain. There's a horrible stench...
Captain! There's decomposing Borg everywhere_!

>In short, it was a typical Voyager episode: Think up some nifty stuff,
>and make darn sure that the most intelligent course of action nevers occurs

>to any of the characters. Fortunately we saw very little of Neelix this
>time around.

Don't forget that Commander C. took a bite out of one of the locally
grown veggies... Then dropped it back into the bin.

Typical Voyager

Rasalom
clar...@ix.netcom.com

Only an idiot fights a war on two fronts. Only the heir to the throne
in the kingdom of idiots would fight a war on twelve fronts.


Michael Fitzgerald

unread,
Feb 18, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/18/97
to

dwal...@CS.Princeton.EDU (Dan Wallach) wrote:


There was the battle scene at the end of ST:VI where the Bird-of-Prey
fired a torpedo that sailed "up" into the underside of the saucer
section of 1701-A, punching through to the top. Similar, but not
remotely as cool as the three-nacelled 1701-D in "All Good Things."

Michael Fitzgerald
maf...@indy.net

"One day, one night, Kobayashi Maru."

Chris Campbell

unread,
Feb 18, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/18/97
to

In article <3308E9...@erols.com>, Richard Bergstresser <rich...@erols.com>
<Pine.GSO.3.95.970213...@ultra.qni.com>
<petranE5...@netcom.com> wrote:
>Peter J. Stewart wrote:
>>
>> Battlestar Galactica, in my view, was a show that had great promise and
>> potential and was screwed up with bad plots, bad science, repetitive
>> stock footage, and a main antagonist that had to be the most laughable aliens
>> I've ever seen in my life. BG suffered from the common SF falacy that the
>> bad guys are always dumb and always have lousy aim.
>
>Similar to Star Wars Imperials, can't hit a damn thing. I was ROTFL when Obi
>Wan said the Jawa transport wasn't attacked by Sandpeople because the shots were too
>accurate and only Imperial Storm Troopers have that kind of precision. Yeah right, I guess
>they never practice on MOVING targets.

Having just seen the Sepcial Edition for the second time, I feel compelled to
point out that just about everybody seems to have terrible aim in Star Wars.
It seems to be a problem with blaster rifles, and I noticed that it carried
over nicely to Dark Forces. Obi Wan's comment was still kinda silly, but I
just wanted to point out that no one in any of the movies was a decent shot.

Chris


Tom Courtney

unread,
Feb 18, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/18/97
to

Hi folks,

Chris Campbell wrote:

> Having just seen the Sepcial Edition for the second time, I feel compelled to
> point out that just about everybody seems to have terrible aim in Star Wars.
> It seems to be a problem with blaster rifles, and I noticed that it carried
> over nicely to Dark Forces. Obi Wan's comment was still kinda silly, but I
> just wanted to point out that no one in any of the movies was a decent shot.

Not quite true. Solo is a pretty good shot. In The Empire Strikes Back,
when he walks into a room and suddenly meets Vader, without hesitating
he draws and fires - and would have obliterated Vader's chest had the
Force not been with him.

Tom Courtney


Gordon Glenn

unread,
Feb 18, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/18/97
to

I am talking in terms of our present capabilities. Obviously, you
could imagine anything. Warp engines are beyond our capabilities
and probably always will be. I suppose you could throw in needing
to calculate the 4th dimension to chart your navigation while in
warp, etc. Anyway, this is all speculation. It is unlikely that
any of us will ever live to see anything like a real interstellar
ship.

Gordon

Gordon Glenn

unread,
Feb 18, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/18/97
to

woog...@AOL.COM wrote:
>
> In article <33074C...@ix.netcom.com>, Gordon Glenn <gag...@ix.netcom.com> writes:

>
> >> In article <5e3ebp$s...@linet06.li.net>, mag...@li.net (Magick Man) wrote:
>
> >> > Whenever the Enterprise meets another ship, why are they
> >> > ALWAYS right-side-up with respect to each other? I don't
> >> > think I've ever seen an episode in which a working
> >> > vessel was at any other orientation.
>
> >I rather suspect that this is a matter of navigational convenience.
> >The Milky Way Galaxy, which we are in, is somewhat disc shaped. The
> >Star Ship has to navigate using an X/Y/Z coordinate and probably
> >uses certain references, such as the center of the galaxy, the edge,
> >and some other points to help with navigation. Certainly, it
> >would be helpful to keep the ship in a certain orientation to allow
> >the computers to reference these points (which begs the question
> >how they could do it in warp, but that would be another story!).
> >It may be that the federation and most other empires have a tacit
> >agreement that common points of reference and orientation will
> >be used in order to avoid making themselves hazards, etc. Not
> >a great explanation, but we will leave it to future star voyagers
> >to work out the details.
>
> Then wouldn't it be possible for one ship to be "right side up" and the other "up side down" in a first contact situation? And which way is "right side up"?
>
> The Woogazoid
> Homepage: members.aol.com/Woogazoid/woogie.htm

You are correct. Obviously there is no up or down in space. I
believe it would have made a great deal of sense, at least in
the new series to have shown ships meeting with different
orientations. But this is, after all, just television. And
they do this, just like they make "whooshing" noises as the
ships fly by (same problem with the Star Wars movies). It just
looks and sounds better, even if it makes no logical sense.
Hey! Why do you like chocolate better than spinach? Some
questions just can't be answered.

Richard Bergstresser

unread,
Feb 18, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/18/97
to

woog...@aol.com

unread,
Feb 18, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/18/97
to

Chris Campbell

unread,
Feb 19, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/19/97
to

<Sigh> Okay, you have some exceptional cases like Solo and Boba Fett, but
most of the characters on both sides are pretty pitiful shots. Even Solo was
pretty limp a good share of the time, particularly in SW (thinking of the
scene in the detention facility here where he shoots at a group of 5 troopers
for quite some time without hitting a one . . .)

Chris


Joshua Jasper

unread,
Feb 19, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/19/97
to rec-arts-sf-tv-b...@uunet.uu.net

In article <330A3A...@shore.net>, Tom Courtney <v...@shore.net> wrote:
>Hi folks,
>
>Chris Campbell wrote:
>
>> Having just seen the Sepcial Edition for the second time, I feel compelled to
>> point out that just about everybody seems to have terrible aim in Star Wars.
>> It seems to be a problem with blaster rifles, and I noticed that it carried
>> over nicely to Dark Forces. Obi Wan's comment was still kinda silly, but I
>> just wanted to point out that no one in any of the movies was a decent shot.
>
>Not quite true. Solo is a pretty good shot. In The Empire Strikes Back,
>when he walks into a room and suddenly meets Vader, without hesitating
>he draws and fires - and would have obliterated Vader's chest had the
>Force not been with him.
>
In Brian Daley's 'Han Solo' books, it's explained that Han is a
profesional gunfighter, among other things. He can speed-draw and hit a
target better than almost anyone. His reflexes are suposedly blindingly
fast.
Re, the stormtroopers acuracy, I think Kenobi meant shot
grouping, not how often they hit what they wanted to. Stormtroopers
attack from formation more often than not, possibly shootin while
stationary. Sand people would most likley attack from ambush, and hit
people from as many locations as possible.
Sinboy

gj...@lehigh.edu

unread,
Feb 19, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/19/97
to


In article <3308E9...@erols.com>, Richard Bergstresser <rich...@erols.com>

writes:

Actually, they're very precise... when they're not shooting at main characters.
The Storm Troopers completely wasted the defenders of Leia's ship at the
beginning of the movie.

Greg

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|"In America, first you get de sugar, den |"All right, Mulder. Who died this|
| you get de power, den you get de women!"| time?" |
| -Homer Simpson |-Dana Scully "The X-Files" |
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|"We're not the same. I'm an American. |"I've driven women to lesbianism |
| You're a sick asshole!" | before but never to an asylum!" |
|-DeFens "Falling Down" |-George Costanza |
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| "In America, first you get de sugar, den |"All right Mulder. Who died this|
| you get de power, den you get de women!" |time?" |
| -Homer Simpson |-Dana Scully "The X-Files" |
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| "We're not the same. I'm an American. |"I've driven women to lesbianism |
| You're a sick asshole!" |before but never to an asylum!" |


William Edward Woody

unread,
Feb 19, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/19/97
to

Gordon Glenn <gag...@ix.netcom.com> wrote:
> William Edward Woody wrote:
> >
> > Gordon Glenn <gag...@ix.netcom.com> wrote:
> > > I think there is a *big* difference between a craft such as Voyager II
> > > that has just one destination, compared to interstellar craft that
> > > have to navigate multiple interstellar destinations "on the fly".
> > > To create "maps", like in Star Trek -- Generations, they would need
> > > to use a set of reference points in order to determine travel distance,
> > > and to avoid previously mapped hazards.
> >
> > How more computationally difficult can that be? Find three known
> > reference points (beacons, stars, whatever), and calculate your
> > approximate location based on those references?
> >
> > Certainly a computational system sophisticated enough to create a
> > holographic doctor by simulating the computations done in the human
> > brain can do a few more trig operations to account for the rotational
> > orientation of the ship...
>
> I am talking in terms of our present capabilities. Obviously, you
> could imagine anything. Warp engines are beyond our capabilities
> and probably always will be. I suppose you could throw in needing
> to calculate the 4th dimension to chart your navigation while in
> warp, etc. Anyway, this is all speculation. It is unlikely that
> any of us will ever live to see anything like a real interstellar
> ship.

But for goodness sake, I'm talking about triangulating your position
irrespective of your orientation relative to galactic north. How
difficult can that be? So damned hard you *must* orient your ship
to galactic north because you can't deal with the computational
complexities of tilting your platform?

We do much more complex calculations every day to find the orbital
path of an unknown comet in order to derive it's orbital elements.

I just can't buy the notion that would have to maintain the
orientation of the Enterprise because we're too damned dumb to do
the extra handful of calculations necessary to deal with not being
oriented to galactic north!

Especially since, while we will probably not be on a starship in
our lifetime, we certainly can simulate the computational problem
finding our location in an aribitrary location in space would entail.

dhe...@polaris.attmail.com

unread,
Feb 19, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/19/97
to


In article <01bc1c91$91d39710$88fd9783@8088xt>, Robert Denier penned...


> Perhaps the show would have greater potential if the crew had some larger
> purpose other than traveling in a straight line home.
>
>

Well, considering in the original ST, they didn't even use a straight
line... I mean you might as well reword the opening monolog to say,
..."5 year mission to wander aimlessly around the galaxy, lay all the
alien females you can find and beat the crap out of anyone else..."

Don't get me wrong, I liked ST:O and have seen every ep more times than
I can count, but to imply that any variation on a theme actually *had* a
theme is stretching reality beyond the breaking point.

The whole idea of an SF TV show having a "purpose" other than providing
a backdrop against which individual stories could be played is still
kind of rare IME.

--
Dianne <*>

Maximillian Natzet

unread,
Feb 19, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/19/97
to


mag...@li.net writes:
> : >Anyway, yes, this week is the Borg and yes, Foundation has supplied
> : >the visual FX, including a new Borg Cube.
> All right, here's something I must ask. It has bugged me
> ever since the first series of TNG.
>

> Whenever the Enterprise meets another ship, why are they
> ALWAYS right-side-up with respect to each other? I don't
> think I've ever seen an episode in which a working
> vessel was at any other orientation.

While space may be 3D, any given star system or galaxy is
roughly a disk, therefore 2D. Its not too hard to imagine that
ships automatically orient themselves to the plane that defines
the center of system/galaxy.
--
Maximillian F Natzet, Combat Botanist
North American Combat Botany Institue
University of Virginia
Charlottesville, VA

David W. Knisely

unread,
Feb 19, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/19/97
to


I am not so much bothered by goofs in special effects than I am by real
goofs in writing, and Voyager has a lot of the latter. The Borg cube
ship in the Voyager episode was, according to one of the "survivors" the
same one which suvived the attack at Wolf 359. The problem is, that ship
self-destructed over Earth a short time later. At least JMS is a bit
more consistant about his writing. Long live B5!
--
David W. Knisely, KA0CZC email: dk8...@navix.net
Prairie Astronomy Club, Inc. http://www.4w.com/pac/

Attend the 4th annual NEBRASKA STAR PARTY, AUGUST 2-9th, 1997

BABYLON 5: Our last best hope for QUALITY science fiction.


Joel Konieczny

unread,
Feb 19, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/19/97
to


<big snip>


> : Once someone's given me a satisfactory answer to this question,
> : I can start asking why invisible ships *always* decloak in front
> : of the Enterprise, instead of behind it where the armament is
> : weaker. But I'll limit myself to one basic CGI flaw per week...

It's very simple, millions of years ago in the Star Trek universe, the
concept of military tactics was sucked out of the Star Trek universe in
some sort of the rampant space-time vortexes that inhabit that universe.

I've given up trying to figure out Star Trek combat in any kind of
military sense, the last even decent go at it was Star Trek II, and that
had it's problems too.

Beyond the 2-d nature of the fighting, which can be explained by
technical reasons (true 3-d combat is hard to do with models) and to
make things simple for the audience, there are hordes of other flaws.

First off, combat casualties. In nearly every combat sequence they take
a hit and someones panel explodes killing someone. Circuit Breakers?
Surge Protectors? For crying out loud, wear a helmet. I don't think
there has ever been anyone killed in a Star Trek combat sequence that
couldn't have been stopped by wearing some kind of armor. And before
anyone tells me armor wouldn't help, remember the DS9 episode with Tosk
and the hunters. The hunters were wearing some pretty nifty armor, that
stopped even full setting phasers. Surely the technologically mighty
federation could create something similar.

Or what about the Defiant? The federation builds this rather nifty
warship, and stops with one? They are having repeated Borg, Klingon,
Romulan, Maquis, and Dominion trouble, desperately need warships, and
they only build one of these things...(for that matter why is it the
only starship at the most important federation outpost?)

Well, enough of a tirade...believe me I can come up with more...(think
Picard Maneuver)...thank god Babylon 5 is rational (not to mention
consistent)

Joel Konieczny

Gordon Glenn

unread,
Feb 20, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/20/97
to

William Edward Woody wrote:

Snip!

> But for goodness sake, I'm talking about triangulating your position
> irrespective of your orientation relative to galactic north. How
> difficult can that be? So damned hard you *must* orient your ship
> to galactic north because you can't deal with the computational
> complexities of tilting your platform?
>
> We do much more complex calculations every day to find the orbital
> path of an unknown comet in order to derive it's orbital elements.
>
> I just can't buy the notion that would have to maintain the
> orientation of the Enterprise because we're too damned dumb to do
> the extra handful of calculations necessary to deal with not being
> oriented to galactic north!
>
> Especially since, while we will probably not be on a starship in
> our lifetime, we certainly can simulate the computational problem
> finding our location in an aribitrary location in space would entail.
>
> - Bill
>
> --
> William Edward Woody - In Phase Consulting - wo...@alumni.caltech.edu
> http://www.alumni.caltech.edu/~woody

I would not even think of debating in an area where I have no
expertise. This part of the thread dealt with trying to find an
explanation (other than mere convenience of 20th Century television
viewers) why the ships on Star Trek and most other movies and
tv shows, all seem to be right side up. For purposes of explaining
that phenomenon, assuming in that reality that ships never seem
to meet in any way but right side up, it is either a navigational
issue or a political solution. I am sure they would not care
the slightest over how an outside viewer may perceive what their
orientation is. Do you have a better explanation for this
right side up phenomenon, or are you just trying to impress
me with your computational knowledge?

William Edward Woody

unread,
Feb 20, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/20/97
to

Gordon Glenn <gag...@ix.netcom.com> wrote:
> I would not even think of debating in an area where I have no
> expertise. This part of the thread dealt with trying to find an
> explanation (other than mere convenience of 20th Century television
> viewers) why the ships on Star Trek and most other movies and
> tv shows, all seem to be right side up. For purposes of explaining
> that phenomenon, assuming in that reality that ships never seem
> to meet in any way but right side up, it is either a navigational
> issue or a political solution. I am sure they would not care
> the slightest over how an outside viewer may perceive what their
> orientation is. Do you have a better explanation for this
> right side up phenomenon, or are you just trying to impress
> me with your computational knowledge?

I am not trying to "impress" anyone.

I just think a 'political' solution seems terribly contrived,
given the fact that often Star Trek deal with races for whom we have
never had any contact before. (The Borg, for example.)

And I think the idea that we somehow need to orient our observation
platform (such as the Enterprise) to Galactic North because of
the navigational subsystem is unable to do the extra handfull of
calculations is just plain dumb.

No, I think the orientation is done simply because the special
effects artists on the show thinks it looks cool.

It's just like my comment about the X-Wing fighers from Star Wars
flying to meet the Death Star--in shots with the X-Wings in the
front and the plant below, they neither orient themselves with
the planet 'down' relative to the ship (as you would expect a
superstratospheric airplane to do after just emerging from the
planet's atmosphere), nor do they orient with 'down' towards the
local star (presuming that like the shuttle, their large heat absorber
is on the bottom of the craft).

No, they orient themselves in what is a very artistically dramatic--
and physically stupid--orientation.

I think there is no better reason than that: Star Trek ships meet
rightside up because the artist composes the shot that way, and
because the audience expects it that way.

no one of consequence

unread,
Feb 20, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/20/97
to

In article <330A3A...@shore.net>, Tom Courtney <v...@shore.net> wrote:
]Hi folks,
]
]Chris Campbell wrote:
]
]> Having just seen the Sepcial Edition for the second time, I feel compelled to
]> point out that just about everybody seems to have terrible aim in Star Wars.
]> It seems to be a problem with blaster rifles, and I noticed that it carried
]> over nicely to Dark Forces. Obi Wan's comment was still kinda silly, but I
]> just wanted to point out that no one in any of the movies was a decent shot.
]
]Not quite true. Solo is a pretty good shot. In The Empire Strikes Back,
]when he walks into a room and suddenly meets Vader, without hesitating
]he draws and fires - and would have obliterated Vader's chest had the
]Force not been with him.

Not to mention in RotJ when he blasted a Stormtrooper between the eyes in
the Forest Battle.

--
|Patrick Chester <*> ("VREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!") wol...@io.com|
|"Cannot run out of time. There is infinite time. You are finite. Zathras|
| is finite. This.. is wrong tool." -Zathras, "War Without End Part 2" |
|Wittier remarks always come to mind just after sending your article. |


David W. Johnson

unread,
Feb 21, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/21/97
to

Chris Campbell wrote:

>
> In article <330A3A...@shore.net>, v...@shore.net wrote:
> >Hi folks,
> >
> >Chris Campbell wrote:
> >
> >> Having just seen the Sepcial Edition for the second time, I feel compelled to
> >> point out that just about everybody seems to have terrible aim in Star Wars.
> >> It seems to be a problem with blaster rifles, and I noticed that it carried
> >> over nicely to Dark Forces. Obi Wan's comment was still kinda silly, but I
> >> just wanted to point out that no one in any of the movies was a decent shot.
> >
> >Not quite true. Solo is a pretty good shot. In The Empire Strikes Back,
> >when he walks into a room and suddenly meets Vader, without hesitating
> >he draws and fires - and would have obliterated Vader's chest had the
> >Force not been with him.
>
> <Sigh> Okay, you have some exceptional cases like Solo and Boba Fett, but
> most of the characters on both sides are pretty pitiful shots. Even Solo was
> pretty limp a good share of the time, particularly in SW (thinking of the
> scene in the detention facility here where he shoots at a group of 5 troopers
> for quite some time without hitting a one . . .)
>
> Chris
I thankfully don't have any personal experience with this, but from what
I've heard that in a real gunfight/battle, at anything beyond a few feet
a shooters accuracy drops a whole bunch. A huge adreniline rush,
combined with fear and confusion will throw almost anyones aim off by a
lot.
Dave J.


Gordon Glenn

unread,
Feb 21, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/21/97
to

William Edward Woody wrote:
>

SNIP!

> I think there is no better reason than that: Star Trek ships meet


> rightside up because the artist composes the shot that way, and
> because the audience expects it that way.
>
> - Bill
>
> --
> William Edward Woody - In Phase Consulting - wo...@alumni.caltech.edu
> http://www.alumni.caltech.edu/~woody

Well... there it is! And so we will never really know, in that
reality, why they do it. One person's guess is as good as the
other.

Chris Campbell

unread,
Feb 21, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/21/97
to

Hmmm, good point. I think you'd agree, then, that the much maligned Storm
Troopers aren't as terrible as we've been led to believe. :)

Chris


Kaite

unread,
Feb 21, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/21/97
to


thus spake:


>>Perhaps the show would have greater potential if the crew had some larger
>>purpose other than traveling in a straight line home.

>Hypernauts had that potential. Aside from being a kid's show, the


>premise was much more interesting -- and almost exactly what I
>thought Voyager would be before it's premiere.

>Neely

Yeah. I liked hypernauts, even though i'm more likely to watch a sci
fi show which airs late at noght than one Saturday morning. The
people developed more than Vpyager
************************************************
Eye are a riter. Eye read buks and eye remember wurds. Wurds r my
bizness. Eye have seen that wurd many, many times. Like in the
dikshonary. Eye read the dikshonary for funn. Eye likes wurds.
jms
**************************************
whit...@mulberry.com

Tom Courtney

unread,
Feb 21, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/21/97
to


Hi folks,

I don't think that helps. If our system is at all indicative, the
stellar plane generally doesn't line up with the galactic plane (it
might do so randomly.) Therefore, two ships entering a system and lining
themselves up with the stellar plane ought to be 50-50 to be upside-down
with respect to each other.

Tom Courtney


Richard Bergstresser

unread,
Feb 21, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/21/97
to


Tom Courtney wrote:
>
> Hi folks,
>
> Chris Campbell wrote:
>
> > Having just seen the Sepcial Edition for the second time, I feel compelled to
> > point out that just about everybody seems to have terrible aim in Star Wars.
> > It seems to be a problem with blaster rifles, and I noticed that it carried
> > over nicely to Dark Forces. Obi Wan's comment was still kinda silly, but I
> > just wanted to point out that no one in any of the movies was a decent shot.
>
> Not quite true. Solo is a pretty good shot. In The Empire Strikes Back,
> when he walks into a room and suddenly meets Vader, without hesitating
> he draws and fires - and would have obliterated Vader's chest had the
> Force not been with him.
>

It just amazing how he keeps hitting the Stormtrooper is A New Hope, despite pointing
his blaster at the ceilling. That Solo really is a great shot!


John & Linda VanSickle

unread,
Feb 21, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/21/97
to


Joshua Jasper wrote:


> In article <330A3A...@shore.net>, Tom Courtney <v...@shore.net> wrote:
> >Chris Campbell wrote:

> >> Having just seen the Sepcial Edition for the second time, I feel compelled to
> >> point out that just about everybody seems to have terrible aim in Star Wars.

> >Not quite true. Solo is a pretty good shot. In The Empire Strikes Back,


> >when he walks into a room and suddenly meets Vader, without hesitating
> >he draws and fires - and would have obliterated Vader's chest had the
> >Force not been with him.

> In Brian Daley's 'Han Solo' books, it's explained that Han is a


> profesional gunfighter, among other things. He can speed-draw and hit a
> target better than almost anyone. His reflexes are suposedly blindingly
> fast.
> Re, the stormtroopers acuracy, I think Kenobi meant shot
> grouping, not how often they hit what they wanted to. Stormtroopers
> attack from formation more often than not, possibly shootin while
> stationary. Sand people would most likley attack from ambush, and hit
> people from as many locations as possible.

Or it could have meant that Imperial Stormtroopers have a vague idea of the
vulnerabilities of the target, and try to aim for them, whereas the
sandpeople just blast away wildly.

Regards,
John

--
"Most self-described "pacifists" are not pacific; they simply assume false
colors. When the wind changes, they hoist the Jolly Roger." -- Robert
Heinlein

bbastabl

unread,
Feb 21, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/21/97
to


Chris Campbell (sank...@ix.netcom.com) wrote:
: In article <330A3A...@shore.net>, v...@shore.net wrote:
: >Hi folks,
: >


: >Chris Campbell wrote:
: >
: >> Having just seen the Sepcial Edition for the second time, I feel compelled to
: >> point out that just about everybody seems to have terrible aim in Star Wars.

: >> It seems to be a problem with blaster rifles, and I noticed that it carried


: >> over nicely to Dark Forces. Obi Wan's comment was still kinda silly, but I
: >> just wanted to point out that no one in any of the movies was a decent shot.

: >
: >Not quite true. Solo is a pretty good shot. In The Empire Strikes Back,


: >when he walks into a room and suddenly meets Vader, without hesitating
: >he draws and fires - and would have obliterated Vader's chest had the
: >Force not been with him.

: <Sigh> Okay, you have some exceptional cases like Solo and Boba Fett, but

: most of the characters on both sides are pretty pitiful shots. Even Solo was
: pretty limp a good share of the time, particularly in SW (thinking of the
: scene in the detention facility here where he shoots at a group of 5 troopers
: for quite some time without hitting a one . . .)

Hey, there's the point. Han nearly smokes Vader when he is shooting with
his own blaster pistol, which is presumably sighted properly, and is
fairly accurate -- why else would he have a 10x scope on it. <Grin> Yet,
give him a standard Stormtrooper blaster rifle, and he can't hit the broad
side of the Millenium Falcon. So, it's not that Stormtroopers are lousy
shots, it's just that Imperial procurement got a deal on rifles with
slightly variable barrel alignments. <Grin>

Later,
Brett Bastable Calgary, Alberta Canada
======================================================================
_The Death of the Ball Turret Gunner_; Randall Jarrell, 1945
From my mother's sleep I fell into the State
And I hunched in its belly till my wet fur froze.
Six miles from earth, loosed from its dream of life,
I woke to black flak and the nightmare fighters.
When I died they washed me out of the turret with a hose.


Maximillian Natzet

unread,
Feb 21, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/21/97
to


sank...@ix.netcom.com writes:
> Having just seen the Sepcial Edition for the second time, I feel compelled to
> point out that just about everybody seems to have terrible aim in Star Wars.
> It seems to be a problem with blaster rifles, and I noticed that it carried
> over nicely to Dark Forces. Obi Wan's comment was still kinda silly, but I
> just wanted to point out that no one in any of the movies was a decent shot.

Come now, you are much too hard on them. Han did make that
difficult, under the table shot at Gredo. That must have been
at least 4 feet at a stationary target.

Diane L. Schirf

unread,
Feb 21, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/21/97
to

>Chris Campbell wrote:
>>
>> In article <330A3A...@shore.net>, v...@shore.net wrote:
>> >Hi folks,
>> >
>> >Chris Campbell wrote:
>> >

>> >> Having just seen the Sepcial Edition for the second time, I feel
compelled to
>> >> point out that just about everybody seems to have terrible aim in
Star Wars.
>> >> It seems to be a problem with blaster rifles, and I noticed that it
carried
>> >> over nicely to Dark Forces. Obi Wan's comment was still kinda
silly, but I
>> >> just wanted to point out that no one in any of the movies was a
decent shot.
>> >

>> >Not quite true. Solo is a pretty good shot. In The Empire Strikes Back,
>> >when he walks into a room and suddenly meets Vader, without hesitating
>> >he draws and fires - and would have obliterated Vader's chest had the
>> >Force not been with him.
>>
>> <Sigh> Okay, you have some exceptional cases like Solo and Boba Fett, but
>> most of the characters on both sides are pretty pitiful shots. Even Solo was
>> pretty limp a good share of the time, particularly in SW (thinking of the
>> scene in the detention facility here where he shoots at a group of 5 troopers
>> for quite some time without hitting a one . . .)
>>

>> Chris
>I thankfully don't have any personal experience with this, but from what
>I've heard that in a real gunfight/battle, at anything beyond a few feet
>a shooters accuracy drops a whole bunch. A huge adreniline rush,
>combined with fear and confusion will throw almost anyones aim off by a
>lot.

Not to mention the weight/kick of the weapon.

--
Diane L. Schirf | sl...@aol.com | del...@mindspring.com | http://members.aol.com/slywy
Updated 4 February 1997 with a menage a trois photo! :)
Take the Digital City Emotion Detector at http://denver.digitalcity.com/cgi-bin/determinator
"Who knows . . . what evil . . . llllllurks in the hearts of men? The *Shadows* know . . ."


Chris Campbell

unread,
Feb 21, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/21/97
to

In article <330be...@news.nucleus.com>, bbas...@nucleus.com (bbastabl)
<5ee5l4$n...@dfw-ixnews8.ix.netcom.com> wrote:

>Chris Campbell (sank...@ix.netcom.com) wrote:
>: In article <330A3A...@shore.net>, v...@shore.net wrote:
>: >Not quite true. Solo is a pretty good shot. In The Empire Strikes Back,

>: >when he walks into a room and suddenly meets Vader, without hesitating
>: >he draws and fires - and would have obliterated Vader's chest had the
>: >Force not been with him.
>
>: <Sigh> Okay, you have some exceptional cases like Solo and Boba Fett, but
>: most of the characters on both sides are pretty pitiful shots. Even Solo was
>: pretty limp a good share of the time, particularly in SW (thinking of the
>: scene in the detention facility here where he shoots at a group of 5 troopers
>: for quite some time without hitting a one . . .)
>
>Hey, there's the point. Han nearly smokes Vader when he is shooting with
>his own blaster pistol, which is presumably sighted properly, and is
>fairly accurate -- why else would he have a 10x scope on it. <Grin> Yet,
>give him a standard Stormtrooper blaster rifle, and he can't hit the broad
>side of the Millenium Falcon. So, it's not that Stormtroopers are lousy
>shots, it's just that Imperial procurement got a deal on rifles with
>slightly variable barrel alignments. <Grin>

<Laughs> There ya go; probably the same corp who manufactures Tie Fighters.
:)

Chris


Chris Campbell

unread,
Feb 21, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/21/97
to

In article <E5y23...@murdoch.acc.Virginia.EDU>, Maximillian Natzet <mf...@watt.seas.virginia.edu> wrote:

>
>
>sank...@ix.netcom.com writes:
>> Having just seen the Sepcial Edition for the second time, I feel compelled to
>
>> point out that just about everybody seems to have terrible aim in Star Wars.
>
>> It seems to be a problem with blaster rifles, and I noticed that it carried
>> over nicely to Dark Forces. Obi Wan's comment was still kinda silly, but I
>> just wanted to point out that no one in any of the movies was a decent shot.
>
>Come now, you are much too hard on them. Han did make that
>difficult, under the table shot at Greedo. That must have been

>at least 4 feet at a stationary target.

Yes, but Greedo missed the same shot! It's all Han's super pistol, I'm
tellin' ya!

Chris


Tom Courtney

unread,
Feb 22, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/22/97
to

Hi folks,

bbastabl wrote:

> Hey, there's the point. Han nearly smokes Vader when he is shooting with
> his own blaster pistol, which is presumably sighted properly, and is
> fairly accurate -- why else would he have a 10x scope on it. <Grin> Yet,
> give him a standard Stormtrooper blaster rifle, and he can't hit the broad
> side of the Millenium Falcon. So, it's not that Stormtroopers are lousy
> shots, it's just that Imperial procurement got a deal on rifles with
> slightly variable barrel alignments. <Grin>

Vader wasn't shooting back. Presumably in the detention bay, Solo was
spending more of his resources staying covered, and less of it aiming.

The stormtrooper marksmanship is pretty understandable in this context.
It is pretty well known that the typical grunt might not even fire his
weapon when he could be safer lying low, and generally does not aim the
thing, because his individual chance of materially affecting the battle
by shooting is pretty low.

Typically in combat, the guys who have the heavy weapons (BAR, 50
caliber machine gun, etc.) do aim and fire, since their behavior does
seriously impact the result.

Tom Courtney


Daniel Pawtowski

unread,
Feb 22, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/22/97
to

In article <5ea4q9$5...@cnn.Princeton.EDU>,
Dan Wallach <dwal...@CS.Princeton.EDU> wrote:
>
>The ST:TNG finale had Riker & the three-engined Enterprise (and
>their Wave Motion Gun! -- oops, wrong show) attacking the bad-guy
>Klingons from below.

Unfortunately, that scene seems to have been done more as a show-off:
"Look at how powerful this ship is! It can maneuver like nothing
else before, it's got the muscle to pull VERTICAL CLIMBS!!!" Etc.

Daniel Pawtowski
dpaw...@vt.edu


K. C. Lee

unread,
Feb 22, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/22/97
to

William Edward Woody (wo...@alumni.caltech.edu) writes:

> I think there is no better reason than that: Star Trek ships meet
> rightside up because the artist composes the shot that way, and
> because the audience expects it that way.

It is more like 2D scripts written for 2D personalities in 2D space. ;)
The only things that don't seem to be 2D are the sexy outfits on the
females. ;) ;) ;)

> William Edward Woody - In Phase Consulting - wo...@alumni.caltech.edu
> http://www.alumni.caltech.edu/~woody

K. C. Lee


William Edward Woody

unread,
Feb 22, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/22/97
to

Gordon Glenn <gag...@ix.netcom.com> wrote:
> > I think there is no better reason than that: Star Trek ships meet
> > rightside up because the artist composes the shot that way, and
> > because the audience expects it that way.
>
> Well... there it is! And so we will never really know, in that
> reality, why they do it. One person's guess is as good as the
> other.

Are you _still_ suggesting that there may be a physical reason to
do things differently than what NASA does *right* *now*, either with
the shuttle, or with our space probes?

If you can think of one, I'm certain the Jet Propulsion Laboratory
would hire you in a hot second.

- Bill

--

Maximillian Natzet

unread,
Feb 23, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/23/97
to


wo...@alumni.caltech.edu writes:
> I just can't buy the notion that would have to maintain the
> orientation of the Enterprise because we're too damned dumb to do
> the extra handful of calculations necessary to deal with not being
> oriented to galactic north!

True, but I expect that its simply a convention to orient your
ship towards galactic north. Seems like a logical convention
to me.

What strikes me as odd is when the Enterprise goes into orbit
around a planet, it orbits on its side. Another logical
convention would be to orient the bottom of the ship towards
the planet. That way down would really be down. The way it is
now, Kirk/Picard/whoever shouldn't be saying "I'll beam down"
but rather "I'll beam over".

Diane L. Schirf

unread,
Feb 24, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/24/97
to

In article <E61uB...@murdoch.acc.Virginia.EDU>, Maximillian Natzet
<mf...@watt.seas.virginia.edu> wrote:

>What strikes me as odd is when the Enterprise goes into orbit
>around a planet, it orbits on its side. Another logical
>convention would be to orient the bottom of the ship towards
>the planet. That way down would really be down. The way it is
>now, Kirk/Picard/whoever shouldn't be saying "I'll beam down"
>but rather "I'll beam over".

That's a very good point and I'm still hurting myself that I didn't
think of it. But what they're really doing, though (I think), is orienting
their "north" to the planet's north, etc., if that makes sense.

William Edward Woody

unread,
Feb 24, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/24/97
to

In article <delenn-2402...@ip90.chicago3.il.pub-ip.psi.net>,

del...@mindspring.com (Diane L. Schirf) wrote:

> In article <E61uB...@murdoch.acc.Virginia.EDU>, Maximillian Natzet
> <mf...@watt.seas.virginia.edu> wrote:
>
> >What strikes me as odd is when the Enterprise goes into orbit
> >around a planet, it orbits on its side. Another logical
> >convention would be to orient the bottom of the ship towards
> >the planet. That way down would really be down. The way it is
> >now, Kirk/Picard/whoever shouldn't be saying "I'll beam down"
> >but rather "I'll beam over".
>
> That's a very good point and I'm still hurting myself that I didn't
> think of it. But what they're really doing, though (I think), is orienting
> their "north" to the planet's north, etc., if that makes sense.

But, have you noticed on the original Star Trek series, when the
Enterprise leaves orbit, it often does it with the ship's 'down'
pointed towards the planet?

I used to imagine the Enterprise rotating 90 degrees before leaving
planetary orbit--it just gave me a headache.

Jeff Lindstrom

unread,
Feb 25, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/25/97
to


In article <5e3ebp$s...@linet06.li.net>, mag...@li.net (Magick Man)
<jsnell-1302...@js.macuser.zd.com> wrote:

>Whenever the Enterprise meets another ship, why are they
>ALWAYS right-side-up with respect to each other? I don't
>think I've ever seen an episode in which a working
>vessel was at any other orientation.

I saw an episode where a Klingon vessel decloaked and rotated to the same
'up' orientation as the Enterprise. It was the episode where Picard was
selected as the arbiter of succession for the Chancellor of the High Command.

In the original series, the Enterprise was attacked from below a few times
(good angle for attack, too, as it provided the largest aspect).


Jeff


John & Linda VanSickle

unread,
Feb 26, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/26/97
to

Chris Campbell wrote:
>
> In article <330D35...@earthlink.net>, dwjo...@earthlink.net wrote:
> >Chris Campbell wrote:
> >>
> >> In article <330A3A...@shore.net>, v...@shore.net wrote:
> >> >Hi folks,
> >> >
> >> >Chris Campbell wrote:
> >> >
> >> >> Having just seen the Sepcial Edition for the second time, I feel compelled
> >> >> to point out that just about everybody seems to have terrible aim in Star
> >> >> Wars. It seems to be a problem with blaster rifles, and I noticed that it
> >> >> carried over nicely to Dark Forces. Obi Wan's comment was still kinda silly, but
> >> >> I just wanted to point out that no one in any of the movies was a decent
> >> >> shot.
> >> >
> >> >Not quite true. Solo is a pretty good shot. In The Empire Strikes Back,
> >> >when he walks into a room and suddenly meets Vader, without hesitating
> >> >he draws and fires - and would have obliterated Vader's chest had the
> >> >Force not been with him.
> >>
> >> <Sigh> Okay, you have some exceptional cases like Solo and Boba Fett, but
> >> most of the characters on both sides are pretty pitiful shots. Even Solo was
> >> pretty limp a good share of the time, particularly in SW (thinking of the
> >> scene in the detention facility here where he shoots at a group of 5 troopers
> >> for quite some time without hitting a one . . .)
> >>
> >> Chris
> >I thankfully don't have any personal experience with this, but from what
> >I've heard that in a real gunfight/battle, at anything beyond a few feet
> >a shooters accuracy drops a whole bunch. A huge adreniline rush,
> >combined with fear and confusion will throw almost anyones aim off by a
> >lot.
>
> Hmmm, good point. I think you'd agree, then, that the much maligned Storm
> Troopers aren't as terrible as we've been led to believe. :)

Now we can move on to a set of Bad Guys with even worse aim: The VC in any
of Chuck Norris' "Missing in Action" flicks. Chuckie, with an M-16 in one
hand and a buddy over the other shoulder, wades through the surf. All the
VC in the world are plugging away at him, missing with every shot. He turns
around, fires a couple times, one-handed, and six VC fall over from behind
their cover, dead. Right.

John & Linda VanSickle

unread,
Feb 26, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/26/97
to

Tom Courtney wrote:
>
> Hi folks,
>
> Maximillian Natzet wrote:
> >
> > mag...@li.net writes:
> > > : >Anyway, yes, this week is the Borg and yes, Foundation has supplied
> > > : >the visual FX, including a new Borg Cube.
> > > All right, here's something I must ask. It has bugged me
> > > ever since the first series of TNG.
> > >
> > > Whenever the Enterprise meets another ship, why are they
> > > ALWAYS right-side-up with respect to each other? I don't
> > > think I've ever seen an episode in which a working
> > > vessel was at any other orientation.
> >
> > While space may be 3D, any given star system or galaxy is
> > roughly a disk, therefore 2D. Its not too hard to imagine that
> > ships automatically orient themselves to the plane that defines
> > the center of system/galaxy.
> > --
> > Maximillian F Natzet, Combat Botanist
> > North American Combat Botany Institue
> > University of Virginia
> > Charlottesville, VA
>
> I don't think that helps. If our system is at all indicative, the
> stellar plane generally doesn't line up with the galactic plane (it
> might do so randomly.) Therefore, two ships entering a system and lining
> themselves up with the stellar plane ought to be 50-50 to be upside-down
> with respect to each other.

It could be that every system is defined with a "top" side, such that
viewing the system from this top side makes the planets appear to revolve
in a counter-clockwise motion (or clockwise, if the person who makes this
rules is left-handed).

Maximillian Natzet

unread,
Feb 27, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/27/97
to

John & Linda VanSickle writes:
> > Hmmm, good point. I think you'd agree, then, that the much maligned Storm
> > Troopers aren't as terrible as we've been led to believe. :)
>
> Now we can move on to a set of Bad Guys with even worse aim: The VC in any
> of Chuck Norris' "Missing in Action" flicks. Chuckie, with an M-16 in one
> hand and a buddy over the other shoulder, wades through the surf. All the
> VC in the world are plugging away at him, missing with every shot. He turns
> around, fires a couple times, one-handed, and six VC fall over from behind
> their cover, dead. Right.

Sticking with the Sci-Fi theme, can there be any more benign
enemy than the Cylons? These guys would hum such that they
could be heard for miles, couldn't hit the side of a barn, move
like an unexcited sloth and once you captured them, would do
everything you asked them to.

Anybody remember the episode where a wounded Starbuck and a
hand full of children lay seige to & capture a cylon fortress?
I think that after that, it might be time to invest in
recruiting new troops.

Richard Bergstresser

unread,
Feb 28, 1997, 3:00:00 AM2/28/97
to


Maximillian Natzet wrote:
>
> Sticking with the Sci-Fi theme, can there be any more benign
> enemy than the Cylons? These guys would hum such that they
> could be heard for miles, couldn't hit the side of a barn, move
> like an unexcited sloth and once you captured them, would do
> everything you asked them to.

Hey, Max! This would be a good time to move the Aliens discussion here.

For newcomers, the question is: Has there been good, accurate portrayals of military
in science fiction (esp. films and esp. soldiers).

Our vote was Aliens. Very well done. The point was also brought up that the Colonial
Space Marines could kick the butts of virtually any other military troops in sci-fi
(esp. Trek).

Comments welcome.

"Is this a stand up fight, or another Changeling hunt?"


Magick Man

unread,
Mar 2, 1997, 3:00:00 AM3/2/97
to

John & Linda VanSickle (vans...@erols.com) wrote:
: >
: > I don't think that helps. If our system is at all indicative, the

: > stellar plane generally doesn't line up with the galactic plane (it
: > might do so randomly.) Therefore, two ships entering a system and lining
: > themselves up with the stellar plane ought to be 50-50 to be upside-down
: > with respect to each other.

: It could be that every system is defined with a "top" side, such that
: viewing the system from this top side makes the planets appear to revolve
: in a counter-clockwise motion (or clockwise, if the person who makes this
: rules is left-handed).

So, all races in the univers are right-handed? If this were
reality (or even good fiction) I'd laugh at the idea, but
since since we're talking about Trek, it'll fit right in.

Magick Man


Maximillian Natzet

unread,
Mar 2, 1997, 3:00:00 AM3/2/97
to

A while back someone posted that a squad of US marines could
have defended DS9 against the invading Klingons, a comment I
completely agree with, btw. Rich & I sort of took it one step
further, trying to figure out who the best sci-fi troops for
such a mission would be.

There just wouldn't be much left of a Klingon Bath'leth waving
human wave assault:

[thundering roar]
[Shhhhh-click] "Sarge, have your men lay down suppressing fire
on beta squad's front. Beta squad, full auto, fire"
[16x 240 rounds per minute - 8mm HEAP caseless ammo]
[8x 30mm grenades]
[2x shoulder mounted smart mini-guns]
[the odd flamer]
[shhhh-click] "Cease fire, the area is secure"
[a pink mist settles slowly to the floor]

Rich & I were just talking about movie/TV sci-fi troops and
Starship troopers hasn't hit this media yet. Of course, I'm
not so sure that Heinlein's troopers would make good base
defense troops. Do you really want security grunts running
around with enough power to vaporize the station?


--
Maximillian F Natzet, Combat Botanist

North American Combat Botany Institute


University of Virginia Charlottesville, VA

http://watt.seas.Virginia.EDU/~mfn8j/

Joel Konieczny

unread,
Mar 3, 1997, 3:00:00 AM3/3/97
to


Richard Bergstresser wrote:
>
> Maximillian Natzet wrote:
> >
> > Sticking with the Sci-Fi theme, can there be any more benign
> > enemy than the Cylons? These guys would hum such that they
> > could be heard for miles, couldn't hit the side of a barn, move
> > like an unexcited sloth and once you captured them, would do
> > everything you asked them to.
>
> Hey, Max! This would be a good time to move the Aliens discussion here.
>
> For newcomers, the question is: Has there been good, accurate portrayals of military
> in science fiction (esp. films and esp. soldiers).
>
> Our vote was Aliens. Very well done. The point was also brought up that the Colonial
> Space Marines could kick the butts of virtually any other military troops in sci-fi
> (esp. Trek).
>

> Comments welcome.
>
> "Is this a stand up fight, or another Changeling hunt?"

I have to agree, the Colonial Marines would have to be the best so far.
Star Wars didn't do to bad a job either (at least in the larger
battles), with some real tactics in evidence (especially the Battles at
Hoth and Endor). Our own Babylon 5 shows some good stuff in some of the
space-battle sequences, and the few ground engagements (Severed Dreams
and where they killed Kosh II, just off the top of my head) showed some
tactical thinking (at the very least they wore some armor - that's a
step ahead of most sci-fi shows).

However for best military sci-fi film, I'm going to hold out for
Starship Troopers, if they do it right it'll make the Colonial Marines
look like Star Trek on a good day.

Waiting and hoping
Joel Konieczny
Joel Konieczny

Brian O'Reilly

unread,
Mar 3, 1997, 3:00:00 AM3/3/97
to

Joel Konieczny wrote:
>
> Richard Bergstresser wrote:
> >
> > Maximillian Natzet wrote:
> > >

> > Hey, Max! This would be a good time to move the Aliens discussion here.
> >
> > For newcomers, the question is: Has there been good, accurate portrayals of military
> > in science fiction (esp. films and esp. soldiers).
> >
> > Our vote was Aliens. Very well done. The point was also brought up that the Colonial
> > Space Marines could kick the butts of virtually any other military troops in sci-fi
> > (esp. Trek).
> >
> > Comments welcome.
> >
> > "Is this a stand up fight, or another Changeling hunt?"
> I have to agree, the Colonial Marines would have to be the best so far.

> However for best military sci-fi film, I'm going to hold out for
> Starship Troopers, if they do it right it'll make the Colonial Marines
> look like Star Trek on a good day.

Unfortunately we'll probably never see an accurate portrayal of great
Sci-Fi soldiery on a par with what you find in books. The Dorsai, Sauron
Supermen, Falkenberg's legion, Hammer's Slammers will probably never
be well portrayed. I'd be surprised if Starship Troopers manages to
retain the hard-core brutality of the book.

The Sci-Fi soldiers I most want to see on the big screen? Ender and
Dragon army.

Colonial Marines got their asses kicked. Aliens is full of bad military
moves. Of course you might argue that they were sent in only partially
briefed, but they didn't treat the whole area as a hot zone until it
was too late.

The best military Sci-Fi movie is IMHO Predator. The alien doesn't
really screw up and neither do the soldiers. Arnold wins with a
combination of luck and guts (of course they don't tell you that he
died a month later without his teeth and hair).


Stephen

unread,
Mar 3, 1997, 3:00:00 AM3/3/97
to

Joel Konieczny wrote:

> I have to agree, the Colonial Marines would have to be the best so far.

> Star Wars didn't do to bad a job either (at least in the larger
> battles), with some real tactics in evidence (especially the Battles at
> Hoth and Endor). Our own Babylon 5 shows some good stuff in some of the
> space-battle sequences, and the few ground engagements (Severed Dreams
> and where they killed Kosh II, just off the top of my head) showed some
> tactical thinking (at the very least they wore some armor - that's a
> step ahead of most sci-fi shows).

I like the storm-troopers best for the following reasons.

1. Fully sealed armor, with radio communications

Any trek/B5/colonial marine invasion force could easily be annihilated by turning an
area's gravity off and venting the hallway into space. Stormtroopers are the only
space-soldiers who would survive/ignore such a thing. In defence of the marines and
B5 invaders, there was no chance of losing gravity. Trek has no excuse.

2. Actual military organization

The imperial army acted like an army, which shouldn't be as rare as it is.

3. Possible excuse for poor aim in SW

When the MF is captured by the Death Star, Darth says that the princess may still be
of use. The heros are let go, the troopers may have had orders to miss! Keep in mind
that this was Darth's plan, so breaking this order ment apologizing to Darth Vader. I
would rather take a blaster shot to the head than fall on Darth Vader's "mercy".

> However for best military sci-fi film, I'm going to hold out for
> Starship Troopers, if they do it right it'll make the Colonial Marines
> look like Star Trek on a good day.

Stership Troopers was an awesome book, but I have heard bad rumors that the
battlesuits are not going to be in the movie. If the troopers have the armor, then
they will definately be the best, hands down. The colonial marines in Aliens were
cool, but they didn't have any weapons capable of touching the suits in Starship
Troopers. One nuclear warhead would have ruined the marines whole day.

Starship Troopers with the suits- The best by far.


Neely Stewart

unread,
Mar 4, 1997, 3:00:00 AM3/4/97
to

>I'd be surprised if Starship Troopers manages to
>retain the hard-core brutality of the book.


At least from the previews, Starship Troopers hired the
Shadows to play the bad guys -- and they're sporting nifty fashionable
green carapaces, not basic black.

The movie plot synopsis I found didn't make the movie very appealing,
but the visual of several thousand Green Shadows moving across
Captain Kirk's Desert Set was pretty awesome.

Neely


Nicholas C. Weaver

unread,
Mar 4, 1997, 3:00:00 AM3/4/97
to

In article <331AFD...@mail.sisna.com>,
Joel Konieczny <jo...@mail.sisna.com> wrote:

>Star Wars didn't do to bad a job either (at least in the larger
>battles), with some real tactics in evidence (especially the Battles at
>Hoth and Endor). Our own Babylon 5 shows some good stuff in some of the

Come on now. A legion of heavily armed crack Imperial troops
were slaughtered by a bunch of TEDDY BEARS! How competent can they
be?

--
Nicholas C. Weaver Ash C++ durbatuluk, ash C++ gimbatul,
nwe...@cs.berkeley.edu ash C++ thrakatuluk agh burzum-ishi krimpatul!
http://www.cs.berkeley.edu/~nweaver/ -Tolkien on C++
It is a tale, told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, .signifying nothing.


Chris Campbell

unread,
Mar 4, 1997, 3:00:00 AM3/4/97
to

In article <5fgcnn$4...@agate.berkeley.edu>, nwe...@hum.cs.Berkeley.EDU (Nicholas C. Weaver)
<E6AC1...@murdoch.acc.Virginia.EDU> <331709...@erols.com>
<331AFD...@mail.sisna.com> wrote:
>In article <331AFD...@mail.sisna.com>,
>Joel Konieczny <jo...@mail.sisna.com> wrote:
>
>>Star Wars didn't do to bad a job either (at least in the larger
>>battles), with some real tactics in evidence (especially the Battles at
>>Hoth and Endor). Our own Babylon 5 shows some good stuff in some of the
>
> Come on now. A legion of heavily armed crack Imperial troops
>were slaughtered by a bunch of TEDDY BEARS! How competent can they
>be?

And a rebel force (granted, a small rebel force) and a lotta booby traps and
vastly superior numbers. Even teddy bears can win when they outnumber you 100
to 1.

Chris


Bob Stout

unread,
Mar 4, 1997, 3:00:00 AM3/4/97
to

On 4 Mar 1997, Chris Campbell wrote:

> > Come on now. A legion of heavily armed crack Imperial troops
> >were slaughtered by a bunch of TEDDY BEARS! How competent can they
> >be?
>

> And a rebel force (granted, a small rebel force) and a lotta booby traps
> and vastly superior numbers. Even teddy bears can win when they
> outnumber you 100 to 1.

It's also worth noting that they were motivated teddy bears. The Imperial
Troopers would have been motivated by gung-ho unit pride and paychecks
alone.

-------------------------------------------------------------
MicroFirm: Down to the C in chips...
FidoNet 1:106/2000.6
Internet r...@brokersys.com
Home of SNIPPETS - Current release:
ftp.brokersys.com:/pub/snippets/snip9611.zip & snip9611.taz (.tar.Z)
http://www.brokersys.com/snippets/
juge.com:/c/snip9611.lzh
PDN nodes (SNIP9611.RAR) and SimTel mirror sites

Ben Trumbull

unread,
Mar 4, 1997, 3:00:00 AM3/4/97
to

In article <Pine.LNX.3.91.97030...@weck.brokersys.com>,
Bob Stout <r...@brokersys.com> wrote:

> > And a rebel force (granted, a small rebel force) and a lotta booby traps
> > and vastly superior numbers. Even teddy bears can win when they
> > outnumber you 100 to 1.
>
> It's also worth noting that they were motivated teddy bears. The Imperial
> Troopers would have been motivated by gung-ho unit pride and paychecks
> alone.

Yeah, but I think gung-ho unit pride counts for extra when you're fighting
teddy bears. How could the survivors ever look themselves in the mirror
? Suicide is the only option.

Also, for an elite troop, discipline was abyssal. Storm troopers ran off
in every direction ... no formation, no officer direction, it was chaos.
So lets see, we can run off in complete chaos into an unknown forest,
facing a force of indeterminant size, or we can whole up in our
unassailable bunker and follow our mission orders (keep rebel scum out).
Gee, tough call there. Can we say .. "scripted" ?

terminally curious,

Ben
___________________________________________________________________
Benjamin Trumbull
trum...@cs.yale.edu
Yale University
You can't be in hell; you can still read your e-mail


sla...@magi.com

unread,
Mar 4, 1997, 3:00:00 AM3/4/97
to

-=> Quoting Sec...@psu.edu to Unknown <=-

Se> Joel Konieczny wrote:

> I have to agree, the Colonial Marines would have to be the best so far.

> Star Wars didn't do to bad a job either (at least in the larger
> battles), with some real tactics in evidence (especially the Battles at
> Hoth and Endor). Our own Babylon 5 shows some good stuff in some of the

> space-battle sequences, and the few ground engagements (Severed Dreams
> and where they killed Kosh II, just off the top of my head) showed some
> tactical thinking (at the very least they wore some armor - that's a
> step ahead of most sci-fi shows).

Se> I like the storm-troopers best for the following reasons.

Se> 1. Fully sealed armor, with radio communications

Se> Any trek/B5/colonial marine invasion force could easily be annihilated
Se> by turning an area's gravity off and venting the hallway into space.
Greetings...

Hmmm, possible... But I wouldn't swear on the sealed idea...
They _have_ sealed versions... But it's quite likely they have some
life-support in there.

Se> 3. Possible excuse for poor aim in SW

What need of an excuse ??
a) Blasters are innacurate weapons by definition. (KN0B said so)
b) If you compare the volume of fire and the ratio of hits from Stormtroopers
to those of any other troops in any other show/movie those guys ain't so bad.
(Try the Elite chasing down the A-Team (-8

Remember that they are a crack military unit. They work best as a GROUP.
Individually, rebel super-heroes (the only people we see fighting against
them) may be better... And, hmmm, do you remember who they fight
against ?? A Skywalker and a guy who can outpilot TIE fighters in a CARGO
ship ?? Those comparison are not valid enough to dismiss their competence
in normal conditions..

So I did not scoff at the original mention "Only Imperial troops are so
precise" and actually watched them attack. Them guys in White are bad news.
Except against Jedi (-8

> However for best military sci-fi film, I'm going to hold out for
> Starship Troopers, if they do it right it'll make the Colonial Marines
> look like Star Trek on a good day.

Se> Stership Troopers was an awesome book, but I have heard bad rumors
Se> that the battlesuits are not going to be in the movie. If the

I have read. Philosophy + Powered armour. Philosophy has to disappear
(this is Hollyweird) and the Armour ain't there. Not a good start. )-8

Slarty

... Feeling suicidal? Then join Starfleet Security!
---
ş Blue Wave/QWK v2.11 ş

>> Slipstream Jet - The QWK solution for Usenets #UNREGISTERED

no one of consequence

unread,
Mar 4, 1997, 3:00:00 AM3/4/97
to

Nicholas C. Weaver <nwe...@hum.cs.Berkeley.EDU> wrote:
]Joel Konieczny <jo...@mail.sisna.com> wrote:
]
]>Star Wars didn't do to bad a job either (at least in the larger

]>battles), with some real tactics in evidence (especially the Battles at
]>Hoth and Endor). Our own Babylon 5 shows some good stuff in some of the
]
] Come on now. A legion of heavily armed crack Imperial troops

]were slaughtered by a bunch of TEDDY BEARS! How competent can they
]be?

Very competent. You obviously don't speak Ewok. Here is what that
battlecry of theirs translates to:

"THE SCRIPTWRITER IS ON OUR SIDE!!!"

Stormtroopers may be competent troops, but no one can stand against a
force the scriptwriter likes. :-)

--
|Patrick Chester <*> ("VREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!") wol...@io.com|
|"Cannot run out of time. There is infinite time. You are finite. Zathras|
| is finite. This.. is wrong tool." -Zathras, "War Without End Part 2" |
|Wittier remarks always come to mind just after sending your article. |


Tim Hodgson

unread,
Mar 5, 1997, 3:00:00 AM3/5/97
to

In article <331AFD...@mail.sisna.com>, Joel Konieczny
<jo...@mail.sisna.com> writes

>
>
>Richard Bergstresser wrote:
>>
>> Maximillian Natzet wrote:
>> >
>> > Sticking with the Sci-Fi theme, can there be any more benign
>> > enemy than the Cylons? These guys would hum such that they
>> > could be heard for miles, couldn't hit the side of a barn, move
>> > like an unexcited sloth and once you captured them, would do
>> > everything you asked them to.
>>
>> Hey, Max! This would be a good time to move the Aliens discussion here.
>>
>> For newcomers, the question is: Has there been good, accurate portrayals of
>military
>> in science fiction (esp. films and esp. soldiers).
>>
>> Our vote was Aliens. Very well done. The point was also brought up that the
>Colonial
>> Space Marines could kick the butts of virtually any other military troops in
>sci-fi
>> (esp. Trek).
>>
>> Comments welcome.
>>
>> "Is this a stand up fight, or another Changeling hunt?"
>I have to agree, the Colonial Marines would have to be the best so far.
>Star Wars didn't do to bad a job either (at least in the larger
>battles), with some real tactics in evidence (especially the Battles at
>Hoth and Endor). Our own Babylon 5 shows some good stuff in some of the
>space-battle sequences, and the few ground engagements (Severed Dreams
>and where they killed Kosh II, just off the top of my head) showed some
>tactical thinking (at the very least they wore some armor - that's a
>step ahead of most sci-fi shows).
>
>However for best military sci-fi film, I'm going to hold out for
>Starship Troopers, if they do it right it'll make the Colonial Marines
>look like Star Trek on a good day.
>
> Waiting and hoping
> Joel Konieczny
> Joel Konieczny
>
>
>
>
Starship Troopers my foot......for real fun try Joe Haldeman's "The
Forever War"....thoughtful sci-fi from a Vietnam vet. Want yet more
thrills read the same author's novel "Mindbridge" if you want
reasonably "good" bad guys.

Pit some Trek ships against the GSV's of the Iain Bainks "Culture"
novels and see how long their shields last ?

The list remains endless....
--
Tim Hodgson


Christopher L Tate

unread,
Mar 6, 1997, 3:00:00 AM3/6/97
to

Tim Hodgson (T...@palefire.demon.co.uk) wrote:
:
: Pit some Trek ships against the GSV's of the Iain Bainks "Culture"

: novels and see how long their shields last ?

Hey, no fair. After all, even the GSV _Quietly Confident_ could
probably fit the _Enterprise_-D into one of its general bays without
even having to shift one of its GCUs outside. :-)

[For folks who aren't familiar with Iain M. Banks's "Culture" novels,
a General Systems Vehicle is the basic "mothership" designation. The
_Quietly Confident_ is one of the earliest and smallest, at a mere
three-and-a-half kilometers long.]

--
Christopher Tate (Avara: Magaera) <*> ct...@world.std.com
http://world.std.com/~ctate/ <*> Finger for PGP public key
wear your inside out, dreaming of mercy....


Maximillian Natzet

unread,
Mar 6, 1997, 3:00:00 AM3/6/97
to


nwe...@hum.cs.Berkeley.EDU writes:
> Come on now. A legion of heavily armed crack Imperial troops
> were slaughtered by a bunch of TEDDY BEARS! How competent can they
> be?

They were supposed to be crack troops weren't they. A favorite
unit of the emporer's, right. I think that they got shafted by
low bid hardware and doctrine writers who were absent without
leave.

The battle on Hoth:
Given the choice, what would you use to assualt the Rebels:

a) Large, slow clumsy vehicles with the proverbial side of the
barn profile, with admittedly heavy guns but of limited
flexibility, no air support, bad air defense, no artillery, no
preparatory bombardment.

b) A flight of Tornados loaded with anti-personnel cluster
munitions escorted by a squadron of F-16 maxed for aid
superiority. The US first mechanized division with attached
air cavalry and corp artillery.

The battle on Endor
Given the choice, what would you use to defend against a rebel
assault:

a) Troops with helmets that allow no peripheral in close
quarters, semi-automatic weapons and apparently lack the
discipline to hold their position. Oh, yeah, add a couple
of vehicles which can be crushed by the odd swinging log.

b) Vietnam era US battalion with fully automatic weapons, better
vision, no aversion to digging little holes in the ground,
claymore mines, mortars and napalm on standby. Oh, and to even
things up, a few M-60 medium tanks with anti-personnel beehive
ammo, tanks which I daresay could withstand a falling log.

For some reason, most sci-fi writers account for massive
increases in technology in everything except ground combat.
Heinlein and Aliens are some of the few exceptions. (Our very
limited exposure to ground combat in B5 shows that JMS gave
some thought to this idea as well). However, in most cases,
the fictional troops seem vastly inferior to their modern
counterparts.

Mojo

unread,
Mar 6, 1997, 3:00:00 AM3/6/97
to

jea...@magmacom.com (Jon Earle) wrote:

>mo...@foundation-i.com (mojo) wrote:

>>FX aside, the script was very, very good and I anticipate it to be
>>perhaps the best show of the series (no, not just good for Voyager -
>>good for SF!).

>FX aside, the script sucked!

Actually, the script *was* very good. As anyone in TV or film will
tell you, sometimes the finished product can be better or worse than
the experience of reading the script. Often, mediocre B5 scripts
really sprang to life once they were on the air, and a few good
scripts were (in my opinion) somehow lost in the translation.

The script for "Unity" was excellent but the final broadcast was
certainly on the lackluster side.

Except for the FX! ;-)


MOJO

Joel Konieczny

unread,
Mar 7, 1997, 3:00:00 AM3/7/97
to

Nicholas C. Weaver wrote:
>
> In article <331AFD...@mail.sisna.com>,
> Joel Konieczny <jo...@mail.sisna.com> wrote:
>
> >Star Wars didn't do to bad a job either (at least in the larger
> >battles), with some real tactics in evidence (especially the Battles at
> >Hoth and Endor). Our own Babylon 5 shows some good stuff in some of the
>
> Come on now. A legion of heavily armed crack Imperial troops
> were slaughtered by a bunch of TEDDY BEARS! How competent can they
> be?

Actually I was thinking of the space part more than the land battle, but
even in the land battle I think the problem was less that they were
confused but more that they were over-confident, they ran off chasing
the pathetic little teddy bears and got slaughtered; but still, it was
crappy discipline, I guess every movie's entitled to one illogical
scene. (wow that was all one sentence...)
Joel Konieczny


Davis Wells

unread,
Mar 7, 1997, 3:00:00 AM3/7/97
to

trum...@cs.yale.edu (Ben Trumbull) wrote:

>terminally curious,

Scripted? Ha! They were thwarted by the Force! The notorious Yoda mind
scramble. They didn't have a chance. :)

Davis
What? What about The Lost Boys?

David W. Johnson

unread,
Mar 8, 1997, 3:00:00 AM3/8/97
to

David Hocking wrote:

>
> Tim Hodgson wrote:
> >
> > In article <331AFD...@mail.sisna.com>, Joel Konieczny
>
> > Starship Troopers my foot......for real fun try Joe Haldeman's "The
> > Forever War"....thoughtful sci-fi from a Vietnam vet. Want yet more
> > thrills read the same author's novel "Mindbridge" if you want
> > reasonably "good" bad guys.
> >
> > Pit some Trek ships against the GSV's of the Iain Bainks "Culture"
> > novels and see how long their shields last ?
> >
> > The list remains endless....
>
> To add to the endless list: John Steakely's "Armor" - an excellent book.
> It's just been re-released, go get it, I guarantee you'll like it.
>
> David
There's a book called "Legion of The Damned" (I've forgotten the authors
name) that has a pretty good portrayal of military sci-fi. If you like
space opera, the "Sten" series by Allen Cole and Chris Bunk is good too.
Dave J.


It is loading more messages.
0 new messages