- hi; in article, <jq2qlt$859$
2...@reader1.panix.com>,
tm...@panix.com "Tim McDaniel" enquired:
> ppint. at pplay <v$af$
pp...@i-m-t.demon.co.uk> wrote:
>
>>but scotland does have the reputation of being a bit behind in fashions
>
>The Renaissance started in Italy in the 1300s-1400s, and in Scotland
>next Wednesday (unless it's been rescheduled *again*).
- ah me, whatever became of the athens of the north ?
>
>> england had a tradition of names drawn from nature - indeed, two
>> traditions of this - but i don't believe the normans can have had,
>> by the time of the conquest; leastways, not for male christian names.
>
>I'd be interesting in knowing what you mean by this, and probably
>Brian Scott too, but maybe not others.
- i understand the anglo-saxons drew upon nature (inter alia)
for names, as did the by then anglo-danes above watling street;
but i don't recall reading of any such names amongst william's
invading army, nor amongst supporters he granted manors and the
right (and duty) to build castles to control the conquered realm.
this could be lack of knowledge on my part, and it could reflect
a difference in cultural habit amongst the invaders along class
divisions; but i don't believe the normans were (yet) so divided:
they were a pretty small minority in a land many times the size
of normandy, and so liable to be culturally pretty uniform.
- i don't know what their traditions would have been before they
settled (what was to become) the danelaw, but the great majority
of anglo-danes were farmers; likewise, i do not know those of
the norwegians who settled in these parts (north-wet england);
but they too reverted to farming the land, rather than replaced
the anglo-saxon and anglo-danish nobility, leaving a conquered
alien population doing the actual farming, and sometimes (often?)
overseeing it as stewards, too, as did the normans.
>
>> - how much the fall in "natural" names' popularity was a reflection
>> of the rising proportion of people's separation from life on the
>> farm and in small villages, i do not know
>
>Given that I am given to understand that flower names and herb names
>didn't become generally popular until the 1800s in England (or so I
>remember the introduction to Withycombe), I have doubts about the thesis.
- when did the urban population of england become self-re-
placing? not until well after the start of the industrial
revolution, i suspect; and until then, it was maintained by
(often forced, if not *enforced*) migration from the country-
side, with appropriate cultural traditions.
- love, ppint.
[drop the "v", and change the "f" to a "g", to email or cc.]
--
"The English country gentleman galloping after a fox -
the unspeakable in full pursuit of the uneatable."
_A Woman of No Importance_ - oscar wilde, 1893