THE MT VOID
Mt. Holz Science Fiction Society
11/27/20 -- Vol. 39, No. 22, Whole Number 2147
Co-Editor: Mark Leeper, mle...@optonline.net
Co-Editor: Evelyn Leeper, ele...@optonline.net
Sending Address: evelynchim...@gmail.com
All material is the opinion of the author and is copyrighted by the
author unless otherwise noted.
All comments sent or posted will be assumed authorized for
inclusion unless otherwise noted.
To subscribe or unsubscribe, send mail to ele...@optonline.net
The latest issue is at <http://www.leepers.us/mtvoid/latest.htm
An index with links to the issues of the MT VOID since 1986 is at
Science Fiction (and Other) Discussion Groups, Films,
Lectures, etc. (NJ)
My Picks for Turner Classic Movies in December (comments
by Mark R. Leeper)
Another Weird Animal Story (comments by Evelyn C. Leeper)
Not Another Weird Animal Story (comments by Evelyn C. Leeper)
NETWORK EFFECT by Martha Wells (audiobook review
by Joe Karpierz)
Leigh Brackett (letter of comment by Kip Williams)
STARGIRL (letters of comment by Paul Dormer, Kevin R,
and Tim Merrigan)
This Week's Reading (MEMOIRS OF MY LIFE AND WRITINGS
[Edward Gibbon]) (book comments by Evelyn C. Leeper)
TOPIC: Science Fiction (and Other) Discussion Groups, Films,
Lectures, etc. (NJ)
At the risk of stating the obvious, now that all the meetings are
Zoomed, you don't have to be in Old Bridge or Middletown or even
New Jersey to participate. So if we are discussing one of your
favorites, contact me at <ele...@optonline.net
> for Zoom
Both the Old Bridge and Middletown groups have (temporarily, we
hope) switched to Zoom meetings. For Middletown meetings,
participants need to watch the film on their own ahead of time as
well as reading the book.
December 3, 2020 (MTPL), 7:30PM: THE QUIET EARTH (1985) & novel
by Craig Harrison
January 7, 2021 (MTPL), 7:30PM: 1984 (1984) & novel
by George Orwell
[no film link yet; the disc is available from Netflix]
January 28, 2021 (OBPL), 7:00PM: I, ROBOT by Isaac Asimov
February 4, 2021 (MTPL), 7:30PM: THE PRESTIGE (2006) & novel
by Christopher Priest
TOPIC: My Picks for Turner Classic Movies in December (comments by
Mark R. Leeper)
I find it a bit odd that I am making positive comments about WORLD
WITHOUT END, a film with several bad points. It could tell us a
good deal about the early science fiction transitioning to more
recognizable modern science fiction films. But that still does not
make it a particularly notable film.
Hollywood's first science fiction time travel film (previous
attempts all used purely fantasy devices) is an updated but down-
scaled version of H. G. Wells' THE TIME MACHINE. Curiously enough,
it features an early performance by Rod Taylor who would become the
best-known time traveler in cinema a few years later in George
Pal's THE TIME MACHINE. A contemporary man is boosted into the
future where the descendents of us have evolved splitting into
troglodytes and effetes. t
The year is 1957 and a manned trip to Mars is engulfed in a
mysterious field that looks like fire superimposed over the ship on
the film. The ship's crew blacks out, and when they come to, they
discover they had traveled at a higher speed than their meters
could register. Having crash-landed while unconscious, they at
first assume they are on Mars. Earth gravity, oxygen in the air,
and trees somehow do not tip them off where they are. All too
slowly they realize the primitive planet on which they have landed
is Earth after a nuclear war. Civilization has split into two
groups. There are the feeble intellectuals who live below ground
and the mutated troglodytes who live above ground. The radiation
has also made them deformed, typically Cyclopes, for no reason ever
made clear. The intellectuals are in the process of dying out due
to some sort of genetic simpiness that afflicts only the men. In a
tasteful way, bearing in mind that this really is mostly a film for
a younger audience, the script implies that the astronauts are to
be used for breeding purposes. This is an idea that was "borrowed"
by Harlan Ellison in A Boy and His Dog. I wouldn't mention it, but
Ellison tended to point out when ideas are borrowed from him,
except he does it in a courtroom.
What follows is some fairly uninspired intrigue involving a murder.
The real killer is one of the men from this society who is jealous
of the attention the women pay to the humans from the 20th century.
He is dispensed with in a predictable way and the only effect he
had was to use up some screen time without advancing the real plot.
Eventually the astronauts are able to re-colonize the surface
through the magic of re-inventing the bazooka. The film seems to
imply that a bazooka is a very simple weapon. In fact, it is a
portable rocket launcher and you don't have to be a rocket
scientist to realize that to build a bazooka from scratch you
probably need a rocket scientist.
Much of the acting is on the serial level. In spite of the fact
that this was a wide-screen production and was intended to have a
really nice look, the product as clearly aimed at a younger
audience and the acting was no better than would be expected for a
children's film. The writing has its share of fluffs also. Lines
in the film include looking at Mars, seeing green and saying "if it
is grass, there is no reason why there couldn't be life on Mars."
Later, looking at the new planet, they repeat the error by walking
through obvious vegetation and saying "forest, brush, no sign of
life." Ideas of Einstein they attribute to another scientist, but
do say he was a successor of Einstein.
The director lavished care on the widescreen photography, but still
the look of the film is a bit tacky at times. The costumes of the
future males are lame' jackets and silly looking head-caps. The
women's costumes were designed by Vargas who for years did
cheesecake paintings for Playboy magazine. The costumes look like
they would have been sexy on paper but just don't work out when
implemented in cloth. Much the same can be said of the spiders
(though when I saw them as a kid they were pretty frightening).
The score by Leith Stevens (who had done Destination Moon, When
Worlds Collide, and War of the Worlds) is mediocre. Stevens had
done those for Paramount, but here he was working for Warner
The plot is heavily rooted in Einstein's Twin Paradox and while the
mysterious acceleration is never explained, it would have resulted
in an application of the "Twin Paradox" much as was shown. In
fact, this is the film I think of when I picture in my mind the
Twin Paradox. Unfortunately, I am more likely to picture
unrealistic looking giant spiders.
Regarded as a children's film this one isn't bad. It just does not
stand up to adult viewing. I rate it low +1 on the -4 to +4 scale.
Turner Classic Movies is running WORLD WITHOUT END on December 3,
11:30 AM. [-mrl]
TOPIC: Another Weird Animal Story (comments by Evelyn C. Leeper)
Scientists have discovered that platypuses are bio-fluorescent and
glow green under ultraviolet light:
This makes the platypus only the second green mammal (albeit on a
technicality). The other is the sloth, which is green because of
algae which grows in its fur, so I suppose that's a technicality
TOPIC: Not Another Weird Animal Story (comments by Evelyn C. Leeper)
The headline says it all: "Utah helicopter crew discovers
mysterious metal monolith deep in the desert".
TOPIC: NETWORK EFFECT by Martha Wells (copyright 2020, Recorded
Books, ASIN: B084QBWBSV, Length: 12 hrs and 48 mins, narrator Kevin
R. Free) (audiobook review by Joe Karpierz)
As a fan of science fiction, unless you've been living under a
rock, you've at least heard of the wildly successful "Murderbot
Diaries" by Martha Wells. The first four entries were novellas:
"All Systems Red", "Artificial Condition", "Rogue Protocol", and
"Exit Strategy", with "Artificial Condition" winning the Hugo for
Best Novella in 2018. There is no doubt that these were good
stories, and the Hugo Award was well deserved.
However, as the series continued on I began to feel that things
were going on a bit too long. In my review of "Exit Strategy", I
"But it should stop here. What I fear is going to happen is that
Wells will continue to write 'Murderbot' stories until people get
tired of them. There is no beginning, middle, and end to the
'Murderbot' story. Well, there was, but now it keeps going.
People want to know what happened to the Murderbot after "Exit
Strategy". People *always* want to know what happens to their
favorite characters once a story is done, and they clamor for more.
More is not always better. Eventually the great stuff becomes good
stuff becomes mediocre stuff becomes bad or uninteresting stuff
(see Orson Scott Card's 'Ender' series--and yes, I have an 'Ender'
book on my stack waiting to be read and reviewed--and the 'Dune'
series (and I have three of those waiting to be read)).
"Stop now, so our memories of the Murderbot will be fond ones."
And, I was right. Well, at least in my opinion. Murderbot and a
bunch of folks are captured and taken *somewhere*. It really
doesn't matter where that somewhere is. The point is that the
story is a basic search and rescue tale, with an old friend being
involved. It turns out that the crew of said old friend's ship--
and if you're a fan of the series you can guess who that old friend
is--needed rescuing, as did the old friend. The story is that of
the rescuing and returning things back to normal.
I didn't give too much of the plot away in part because the plot
itself isn't really that new. I know that there are folks out
there that will say that there aren't very many, if any, new plots
anyway. Fair enough. But, quite frankly, I was bored. There was
nothing new or interesting here. This was just another "Murderbot"
adventure, much like every week we tune into a new "Doctor Who"
adventure. It may or may not be interesting, but it's a good story
with at least one familiar character that we know really well, and
we're comfortable with it and more or less happy unless it's a real
So, this isn't a real dud. It's a nice, well-written story. It's
got a couple of favorite characters who act the way we'd expect
them to act. Murderbot is still addicted to bad video, for
example. That's a comfortable thing for us to know and read--or,
in my case, listen to. Murderbot is, well, Murderbot. It has the
same aversion to human contact, the same addiction to bad videos,
the same feelings about humans that it has in the past. In short,
it's just another "Murderbot" story. It doesn't break any new
ground. And maybe it doesn't have to. Maybe that's the point.
Maybe "Murderbot" stories are comfort food, and everyone knows we
need comfort food (and yes, I will say it) in these unprecedented
times. And maybe that's okay. Maybe that's the point. But it's
just not enough for me.
I should be clear, though. It's well-written. It's a decent
story. But there's nothing new, nothing interesting. It's comfort
food. And if you're looking for comfort food, by all means, here
it is. If you're looking for something more out of Murderbot, this
Narrator Kevin R. Free's style isn't very dynamic. It's
serviceable, and gets the job done. I feel as if Free is a drone,
well, droning on. I would not go out of my way to listen to other
novels narrated by Free.
I know there's at least one more "Murderbot" novel coming out. As
a completist, and as someone who has come this far, I'm sure I'll
read it. Sadly, I'm not expecting much. [-jak]
TOPIC: Leigh Brackett (letter of comment by Kip Williams)
In response to Evelyn's comments on Leigh Brackett and THE LONG
GOODBYE in the 11/20/20 issue of the MT VOID, Kip Williams writes:
[Evelyn wrote,] "And for this we may have to blame Leigh Brackett,
who wrote the screenplay." [-ecl]
Oh, yes. I hate to 'blame' her for things, because she was a
lovely GoH at one of the 70s Denver cons I went to (MileHi or
Penulti), where they screened another movie she co-wrote with Jules
Furthman and William Faulkner, THE BIG SLEEP, and she announced
that she'd be writing the screenplay for the sequel to STAR WARS.
She authored the line "[F]ear makes stupid people do wicked
things," which has been so useful to me in recent years.
But damn, yeah. She was doing what she was asked for, which was a
certain take on Marlowe, and I respect her all over the place, but
what a horrid mess.
Elliot Gould, by the way, went a long way to redeeming himself (not
in general, but specifically in regard to Marlowe and Chandler)
with some fairly solid audiobooks of the novels and longer stories.
I went in prepared to sneer at it, and all I can say is I didn't
sneer. I've only heard a couple of them, but will keep an ear out
for others. [-kw]
TOPIC: STARGIRL (letters of comment by Paul Dormer, Kevin R, and
In response to Dale Skran's comments on STARGIRL in the 06/19/20
issue of the MT VOID, Kip Williams writes:
By some accident, I just saw this post again in my message
archives. Since this was first posted, STARGIRL has turned up on
Amazon Prime in the UK and I watched the entire series, which was
For the record, Pat is Courtney's step-father not foster father,
having married Courtney's mum, and I thought Luke Wilson brought
just the right tone to the role.
However, the opening episode, where blonde cute Californian girl
moves to a new town, falls foul of a cheerleader, and is guided by
an older man into learning she is a superhero, did seem a bit of a
Buffy rip-off to me. [-pd]
Kevin R responds:
The "staff chose her" bit was not in the STARS AND S.T.R.I.P.E.
comic. Courtney was using the "Cosmic Converter Belt" she found in
Pat Dugan's stuff. It was an adaptation of Ted Knight's "Cosmic
Rod" from the second run of ALL-STAR COMICS and dates to the Jan-
Feb 1977 issue. #64.* Wally Wood art, which is why it looks so
much like the Dynabelt "Len Brown" wore with the Thunder Agents, as
DYNAMO. Sly Pemberton used it as the SSK, and he later adventured
as Skyman, but he was never "Starman." Courtney got the staff from
Jack when he retired. TV always changes stuff, and some of this
was treated differently from the comics on "Smallville" in seasons
Tim Merrigan replies:
In my experience, the canon of both the Marvel and DC universes is
extremely fluid, not only over time but simultaneously between
titles using the same characters, e.g. Batman and Detective Comics,
where there was no overlap between stories and details of the
Canon wasn't from either of those companies. Woody self-published
Sure, but after Stan and Jack got the kids hooked on continued
stories, DC followed suit, and the revivals of ALL-STAR were done
by ex-Marvel writers such as Gerry Conway and Roy Thomas. Roy
wrote entire story arcs to rationalize tiny bits of contradictory
back-story, inspiring one fan to introduce the term "retroactive
continuity," as reported on the letters page of ALL-STAR SQUADRON
"Qualified immuninity = vertual impunity."
.... and innterresting orrthoggraffy. [-kr]
TOPIC: This Week's Reading (book comments by Evelyn C. Leeper)
I have commented at length on Edward Gibbon's THE HISTORY OF THE
DECLINE AND FALL OF THE ROMAN EMPIRE, but I was recently listening
to John Sutherland talk about Gibbon in the Teaching Company (Great
Courses) course on "Classics of British Literature" and he quoted
from Gibbon's MEMOIRS OF MY LIFE AND WRITINGS: "After a sleepless
night, I trod, with a lofty step, the ruins of the Forum; each
memorable spot where Romulus stood, or Tully spoke, or Caesar fell,
was at once present to my eye; and several days of intoxication
were lost or enjoyed before I could descend to a cool and minute
Even assuming one grants Gibbon literary license to presume Romulus
to be a real person who stood where the legends claimed, Gibbon was
completely off the mark on Caesar. While the Senate building was
in the Forum (and its ruins still are), when Caesar was killed, the
Senate was meeting in the curia in Pompey's Theater, located in
Rome's Largo di Torre Argentina archaeological area. This was
because the old Senate house was being replaced by a new one,
ironically by Caesar and to be called the Curia Julia. Augustus
finished this new Senate house, which seems to be where Gibbon
places Caesar's death.
Gibbon also is a bit weak on Chinese history, writing, "... the
posterity of Confucius having maintained, above two thousand and
two hundred years, their peaceful honours and perpetual
succession." There were nine dynasties in that time, and it was
not always peaceful.
Gibbon would probably not think much of writing workshops: he did
not believe in having his friends read his manuscripts, and he also
thought his time spent at university was the most worthless time he
On a technical level, Gibbon defends his grouping events by nations
rather than chronologically. (In fact, I don't think he ever
includes any dates at all.) But he did bow to public opinion and
put his footnotes at the bottom of each page, rather than grouped
at the end of each volume. [-ecl]
Man is a dog's idea of what God should be.