Anal cancer is 46 times more common in people with HIV than in the general population
Gaylord Merryweather
Two presentations at the EACS Conference in Cologne investigating anal
cancer have found very different levels of the anal dysplasia (cellular
changes) that may lead to anal cancer in HIV-positive patients.
A study from Spain of men who had no previous history of HPV related
pathology found that 42% of those on antiretroviral therapy (ART) had some
degree of anal dysplasia, and no fewer than 59% of those not on ART.
This study found somewhat lower rates of dysplasia in patients taking
protease inhibitors (PIs), which backs up previous studies suggesting that
PIs have some activity against human papilloma virus (HPV), the causative
agent of anal dysplasia and cancer.
In contrast a study from Italy which looked at 205 male and female
patients (80% male) consecutively enrolled at a single clinic found a rate
of dysplasia of 11%.
It also found that there were high levels of infection with high risk-
types of HPV other than types 16 and 18, the ones for which vaccines have
been developed.
The study presented by Guillem Sirera of the Independent University of
Barcelona studied 269 male patients enrolled in a new cohort of gay men
called CARH-MEN. Notably, men with a documented previous history of anal
dysplasia were excluded from the cohort.
The men were stratified according to whether they were ARV-naive and, if
not, whether they had taken regimens containing PIs, NNRTIs, or both. Anal
biopsies were taken and tests for HPV infection, HPV genotype, and anal
cytology were performed.
Of the 269 men enrolled, 76% were treatment-experienced. Of these 205, 57
(28%) had only taken PI-containing regimens, 13% only NNRTI-containing
regimens, and 60% both.
There were very high rates of HPV infection, with 89% of the treatment-
naive men and 74% of those on ART infected. This difference in infection
rates was statistically significant. Only 65% of those who had ever taken
PIs were infected; this was significant in univariate analysis.
There was an extraordinarily high level of anal dysplasia in this group
with over 40% of treatment-experienced and 60% of treatment-naive men with
�anal precancerous lesions�. The rate in men who had taken PIs was 35% and
this was significantly different both from the drug-naive and from men who
had never taken PIs: the researchers calculated that PI treatment reduced
the odds of having dysplasia by 64%.
On the other hand, ever having taken a treatment interruption was
associated with a 75% increase in the odds of having dysplasia, and
treatment interruption was also associated with a 4.4-fold times greater
risk of infection with the most common cancer-causing variety of HPV, type
16, though being treatment-naive was not.
Dr Sirera, answering a question from the audience, said it was difficult
to say why the anal dysplasia rates in this study were so high, though men
at higher risk might be more motivated to volunteer for a cohort study.
Infection and dysplasia rates were lower in the second anal cancer study
presented. In this Dr Andrea de Luca and colleagues from the Gemelli
Polyclinic in Rome enrolled 189 consecutively-diagnosed patients. Patients
still had to consent to anal biopsies, but Dr de Luca commented that few
patients refused consent to be enrolled.
Of the group, 80% were men and 56% gay men. Fifty-three per cent of
patients had had receptive anal intercourse. Although a quarter had had an
AIDS diagnosis, their current CD4 count was 534 and CD4 nadir was not
especially low (204). At baseline 89% were on ART.
De Luca and colleagues performed similar infection and cytology tests but
also did genetic activation tests to look for the expression of the HPV
genes E6 and E7. When these are expressed they enhance the chances of
cancer and are usually expressed at much higher rates in HPV 16 and 18,
the two riskiest types and the ones covered by the Gardasil and Cervarix
vaccines.
Patients were re-tested a year later to measure progression or regression
of HPV infection and dysplasia.
As might be expected from a consecutive sample, this was a varied group
with 14% having had no sexual partners in the last year and 13% over 20
partners; 53% had never had receptive anal sex while 19% had had it with
over 100 partners.
Fifty-eight per cent of the group had evidence of HPV infection and 44%
had infection with multiple high-risk HPV types. Although the predominant
high-risk type was HPV 16, infection with three high-risk subtypes (31, 33
and 35) not covered by vaccines were found in around a quarter of patients
each.
In 90 (44%) of patients the HPV genetic activity could be measured and it
was found that cancer genes were active in nearly three-quarters of
patients with high-risk HPV. The genes expressed belonged to HPV 16 and
18, but also came from other subtypes: a third expressed cancer genes from
HPV 45 and 20% from HPV 35.
Although men had a greater risk of high-risk HPV and heterosexuals 62%
less, only previous AIDS was associated with infection in a multivariate
model. Infection did not appear to be related to the frequency of anal
intercourse. ART, unlike in the Spanish study, was not associated with
lower levels of HPV infection or dysplasia.
As we said above, 11% of patients infected by HPV (19 patients) had anal
dysplasia. Fifty-nine patients were followed-up after 12 months. The good
news is that new infections with HPV were outnumbered by patients who
became negative for infection, and progression of dysplasia was relatively
uncommon. Five patients who were HPV negative became positive while ten
who had been positive became negative. Seven patients developed new anal
dysplasia but two who had had dysplasia were normal at follow-up.
Dr de Luca commented that the high frequency of cancer-gene expression was
unexpected, and rare in HIV negative patients. His may explain why, as
another cohort study from Belgium reported (de Wit), anal cancer is 46
times more common in people with HIV than in the general population.
References
Sirera G et al. Highly active antiretroviral regimens on the prevalence of
anal human papilloma virus infection and anal pathology in HIV-infected
men. 12th European AIDS Conference, Cologne. Abstract P3/5. 2009.
De Luca A et al. Frequent detection of multiple, oncogene-expressing high-
risk HPV types in anal swabs from HIV-infected individuals: predictors and
associations with anal dysplasia. 12th European AIDS Conference, Cologne.
Abstract P3/1. 2009.
De Wit S et al. Characteristics of non-AIDS defining malignancies in the
HAART era: a clinico-epidemiological study. 12th European AIDS Conference,
Cologne. Abstract P3/2. 2009.
spi...@freenet.co.uk
I think people with HIV have far more pressing concerns than an increased
risk of cancer... like death in 10 years if the meds don't work, increased
ill health as that time approaches...
Oh, and "HIV" is not the "gay plague". There're far more straight people
infected with it than gay and have been for well over a decade.
--
| spi...@freenet.co.uk | Windows95 (noun): 32 bit extensions and a |
| | graphical shell for a 16 bit patch to an 8 bit |
| Andrew Halliwell BSc | operating system originally coded for a 4 bit |
| in |microprocessor, written by a 2 bit company, that|
| Computer Science | can't stand 1 bit of competition. |
James A. Donald
> Oh, and "HIV" is not the "gay plague". There're far more straight people
> infected with it than gay and have been for well over a decade.
There are very few cases of HIV being heterosexually transmitted
between one straight and the next.
The blood bank asks men "have you had sex, even once, with another man
since 1975?".
It does not ask women "did you get drunk and take the high school
football team up the ass every saturday night?"
It now appears that "heterosexual" AIDs in Africa is in fact
iatrogenic AIDS. When WHO gave clinics in Africa a large financial
incentive to find as many HIV cases as possible, it also inadvertently
gave them a large incentive to use the dirtiest needles possible.
spi...@freenet.co.uk
> On Mon, 14 Dec 2009 19:59:15 +0000, spi...@freenet.co.uk wrote:
>> Oh, and "HIV" is not the "gay plague". There're far more straight people
>> infected with it than gay and have been for well over a decade.
>
> There are very few cases of HIV being heterosexually transmitted
> between one straight and the next.
>
> The blood bank asks men "have you had sex, even once, with another man
> since 1975?".
That's because they're idiots, stuck in the 1980s when it WAS predominantly
a gay problem. Heterosexual males are just as promiscuous as Homosexual
males, and they didn't wear condoms where for most homosexuals that became a
standard practice very quickly.
> It does not ask women "did you get drunk and take the high school
> football team up the ass every saturday night?"
Doesn't matter what the blood transfusion services say. They're so tied up
in red tape it'd take years to change their rules.
James A. Donald
> > The blood bank asks men "have you had sex, even
> > once, with another man since 1975?".
> That's because they're idiots, stuck in the 1980s when
> it WAS predominantly a gay problem.
It still is a gay problem.
Genuine cases of sexual transmission between one
heterosexual and another are extremely rare, the vast
majority of such cases being women infected by males who
got aids in prison from another male.
> Heterosexual males are just as promiscuous as
> Homosexual males,
We do our best to be, but you know what the joke says.
> > It does not ask women "did you get drunk and take
> > the high school football team up the ass every
> > saturday night?"
> Doesn't matter what the blood transfusion services
> say.
Their decisions are life and death, and if made wrong,
they get in big trouble. So they have to speak the
truth, while everyone else can afford to lie.
And the truth is that AIDS is a gay disease, and anyone
who is not gay that gets it, has usually got it from a
gay. (For a lengthier and more accurate explanation of
risk factors, read your blood bank questionnaire)
spi...@freenet.co.uk
>> > The blood bank asks men "have you had sex, even
>> > once, with another man since 1975?".
>
> spi...@freenet.co.uk
>> That's because they're idiots, stuck in the 1980s when
>> it WAS predominantly a gay problem.
>
> It still is a gay problem.
It's an EVERYONE problem you dolt.
> Genuine cases of sexual transmission between one
> heterosexual and another are extremely rare
Bullshit, that kinda talk is not only utterly stupid, but fucking dangerous.
--
| spi...@freenet.co.uk | |
| Andrew Halliwell BSc | "The day Microsoft makes something that doesn't |
| in | suck is probably the day they start making |
| Computer science | vacuum cleaners" - Ernst Jan Plugge |