Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Dan Brown's Rome

1 view
Skip to first unread message

Bo Lundin

unread,
Oct 14, 2004, 2:31:04 PM10/14/04
to

Being a long time both crime and Rome lover (and even author of a couple
of books on the subjects) I plunged into Dan Brown¹s ²Angels and
demons²with great anticipation. The author¹s note prefacing the text
claims that ²references to all works of art, tombs, tunnels, and
arcitecture in Rome are entirely factual (as are their exact locations).²
I beg to differ (page numbers refer to the Corgi Books pocket edition):
--
p.131: ²Michelangelos famed spiral staircase leading to the Museo
Vaticano² is in fact built by Guiseppe Momo in the 1930¹s.
p.151: The ²eight-foot spear with razor-sharp scyte² carried by the Swiss
Guard is ²rumored to have decapitated countless Muslim while defending the
Christian crusaders in the fifteenth century². The last crusade took place
in the fourteenth century and the Swiss Guard was founded in 1515.
p. 254: Pantheon named as ²the oldest Catholic church in Rome². Not true;
the pagan temple became a church in AD 609, several other churches are
older than that.
p.260: Pantheon is said to have ²one narrow entrance². The entrance is
about seven metres wide.
p. 263: There is no ²Piazza de la Concorde² in Rome. There is a Place de
la Concorde in Paris, however.
p. 270: ²La Tazza di Oro¹s outdoor café² does not exist, they serve their
excellent espresso only indoors. And the correct spelling is Tazza d¹Oro.
p.292: Santa Marie del Popolo lies in the northeast corner of Piazza del
Popolo, not in the southeast.
p. 316: ²This is the first altar of science!² Bernini carved the Habbakuk
and Angel statue 1656-61 and all the other sculptures mentioned as
Illuminati pointers several years, even decades, earlier. The first
pointer is the last one made! Besides, Galilei died in 1642 and must have
had quite a foresight to be able to write a verse with clues to works of
art created much later.
p.318: ²nobody else had contributed artwork to this chapel!² Not true.
Raphael designed and Lorenzetto executed the statue of Jonah, the bronze
bas-relief is by Lorenzetto, and so is David, the companion piece to
Bernini¹s Habbakuk.
p.329: ²because it¹s outside the walled city, Roman officials for
centuries have claimed it as a part of Rome.² . ²For centuries² is pure
nonsense. The controversy can only have been in effect from 1871 (when the
Italian forces entered Rome and the pope considered himself ²prisoner in
the Vatican² to 1929 when the concordat between Italy and the Vatican
defined the state.
330: The four stone disks surrounding the obelisk in Piazza San Pietro are
not bas-reliefs, they are simply flat stones, parts of the compass rose
araound the obelisk. p.334: ²Art historians knew the fountains marked the
exact geometric focal points of Bernini¹s elliptical piazza². Not true:
the focal points are marked by two red stone disks roughly halfway between
the obelisk and the fountains.
p.369: ²Nobody is allowed down there². Not true; tourist groups visit the
necropolis almost every day of the year. Even I have been there.
p. 374: ²Bernini had carved dozens of fountains in Rome, most of them in
front of churches.² The correct number is less than a dozen, most of them
not in front of churches.
p. 375: ²The Ecstacy of St Teresa, shortly after its unveiling, had been
moved from its original location inside the Vatican.² Downright lie. St
Teresa was commissioned for the sepulcral chapel in Santa Maria della
Vittoria where it still is. The sculpture was never rejected by Pope Urban
VIII for the simple reason that he died in 1644 and Bernini did the job in
1645-52.
p.394: ²The church is on Piazza Barberini². It¹s not. It¹s on Piazza San
Bernardo, half a kilometer uphill från Piazza Barberini.
²Twenty years agoŠcity planners had removed the obelisk and replaced it
with a small fountain called the Triton.² There has never been an obelisk
in Piazza Barberini, the Triton fountain in the center is hardly a small
one and it has been in place since 1643.
p. 441: ²According to the map, the spear was pointing west². The arrow ­
not a spear ­ held by the angel is pointing downward at Teresa¹s midriff.
Since the sculpture sits along the left side of the church wall, the arrow
would be pointing more or less to north/north west.
p. 451: ²The piazza was deserted². With a lot of restaurants along the
sides and three famous fountains in the middle, Piazza Navona simply can¹t
be deserted at 10.45 PM.
p.468: ²All of Rome spread out before him². Even at the top of the
obelisk¹s platform he would se no more than the houses surrounding the
square.
p.470: ²Langdon had little doubt that the angel and surrounding pentagonal
park were Bernini¹s doing as well.² Well, they¹re not. The park is modern,
the angel is by a Dutchman called Pieter Antoon Verschaffelt and from
1752, a century after Bernini.
p.478: ²He had heard of this tunnel many times². Il Passetto is hardly a
tunnel, but a covered gangway between Castel Sant¹Angelo and the Vatican.
The entrance at the castle side is from one of the bastions, not from the
castle itself. It was certainly never a ²secret escape route², being high
on very visible pillars along the streets all the way. These days there
are even guided tours along part of the Passetto.
p. 542: ²Cava Romana! The marble quarries north of the city were less than
three miles away.² Marble is quarried from mountains in the north of
Italy.
p. 557: If someone really would survive a drop from several thousand feet
and end up in the Tiber close to the Tiber island, he would first of all
bang into the bottom (not very deep here) and die. Secondly he would be
swept downstream very rapidly, the current is strong on both sides of the
island, and thus be impossible to reach in time for spectators on the
shore.
p. 558: ²Ever since the island had been used to quarantine the sick during
the Roman plague of A.D. 1656, it had been thought to have mystic healing
properties.² In fact those properties were supposed to be in full swing a
thousand years before that; there was a hospital on the island already in
293 B.C.
p.593: Brown is the first to claim that the ²Devil¹s Advocate²has anything
to do with Papal elections, officially credited by the church to rely on
divine inspiration. The Devil¹s Advocate (the job is now abolished by Pope
John Paul II) had to dig for dirt concerning people suggested for
beatification and canonisation. Since Papal elections are made by secret
voting it¹s rather hard to see where in the process a Devil¹s Advocate
could come in and air his findings.

These are remarks concerning only Dan Brown¹s treatment of a ²well
researched² (The Poisoned Pen) and ²Michelin-perfect ² (Publishers weekly)
Rome. I leave it to people with knowledge about antimatter, Vatican
hierarchy, the Illuminati and other cornerstones to have a look at ²Angels
and Demons² from their respective points of view.

Bo Lundin
Jury Magazine, Sweden

Message has been deleted
0 new messages