I wanna know how many people believe the Doctor ever had sex with his
companions and exactly which ones.
I know this is a controversial subject and I think it would help if
we knew more about where people stand on this issue than just a "yes"
or "no" answer, so please reply if you can.
(I really want serious answers to this.)
>O.K. the first thing I wanna say is I'm not the troller, I'm a
>different person who's just using the same remailer and I hope I get
>some serious replies to this.
>
You know, after all the the posts Anonymous
has made, including the one where he claims
he's a regular poster just wanting to stir things
up, I really don't think you have a chance of
getting a reasoned answer to this.
Anonymous has basically shown that pro-moderates
are scowering. lying, senseless little pricks,
if he has shown anything at all...
"SEX? I've never heard of it! Now turn on that
sexual air supply, will ye?"
Anonymous <nob...@replay.com> wrote in article
<1998112219...@replay.com>...
> O.K. the first thing I wanna say is I'm not the troller, I'm a
> different person who's just using the same remailer and I hope I get
> some serious replies to this.
I'd have thought anyone who lurked here would have more sense than to use
that remailer if they didn't want to get told to fuck off.
But since all users of that remailer get the same thing (which is why
there's no point in killfiling it), I'll give the benefit of the doubt.
> I wanna know how many people believe the Doctor ever had sex with his
> companions and exactly which ones.
Undoubtedly the 4th Doc with Romana II.
There are plenty of old discussions on the subject in Deja News.
--
"Try some terrorism for hire; we'll blow shit up... It's more fun!"
> I wanna know how many people believe the Doctor ever had sex with his
> companions and exactly which ones.
>
Presumably so that you can sit in your sad lounge, watching a Who video,
bashing one out at the thought of it :)
>O.K. the first thing I wanna say is I'm not the troller, I'm a
>different person who's just using the same remailer and I hope I get
>some serious replies to this.
Yeah, right.
>I wanna know how many people believe the Doctor ever had sex with his
>companions and exactly which ones.
>
>I know this is a controversial subject and I think it would help if
>we knew more about where people stand on this issue than just a "yes"
>or "no" answer, so please reply if you can.
>
>(I really want serious answers to this.)
Twat. Kill-file.
Nick Cooper
["But it was here, it was all right here. There was a techno dance club...."
["Stan, you need to lay off the cough syrup, alright? Seriously, I'm worried
[about you, man!"
>Anonymous <nob...@replay.com> writes:
>
>
>
>>O.K. the first thing I wanna say is I'm not the troller, I'm a
>>different person who's just using the same remailer and I hope I get
>>some serious replies to this.
>>
>
>You know, after all the the posts Anonymous
>has made, including the one where he claims
>he's a regular poster just wanting to stir things
>up, I really don't think you have a chance of
>getting a reasoned answer to this.
>
>Anonymous has basically shown that pro-moderates
>are scowering. lying, senseless little pricks,
>if he has shown anything at all...
>
>"SEX? I've never heard of it! Now turn on that
>sexual air supply, will ye?"
Not going to offer to sell him some vid's, Azy?
>
> >I wanna know how many people believe the Doctor ever had sex with his
> >companions and exactly which ones.
> >
I don't know whether you're legit or not, but the answer is very simple:
none. They are friends, and nothing more. If this isn't obvious then I
think you've missed the point of the show entirely.
SV7
Carrot Juice! Carrot Juice!! Carrot Juice!!!
> Nick Cooper wrote:
>
> >
> > >I wanna know how many people believe the Doctor ever had sex with his
> > >companions and exactly which ones.
>
> I don't know whether you're legit or not, but the answer is very simple:
> none. They are friends, and nothing more. If this isn't obvious then I
> think you've missed the point of the show entirely.
I think a good case could be made for Romana though, regardless.
And I don't think I've missed the point of the show if I did think the
Doctor "had sex" or was attracted with some of his companions, as the
point of the show wasn't a half hour each week of the Doctor not getting
it on with his companions.
That said, since any conjecture about the Doctor having a relationship
with his companions would have to be based on the on-screen evidence it
might be difficult to make a case.
-Chris Rednour
_________________________________________________________________
gs0...@panther.gsu.edu http://www.gsu.edu/~gs06cjr/index.html
cred...@gpc.peachnet.edu
> On Tue, 24 Nov 1998, SV7 wrote:
>
> > Nick Cooper wrote:
> >
> > >
> > > >I wanna know how many people believe the Doctor ever had sex with his
> > > >companions and exactly which ones.
> >
> > I don't know whether you're legit or not, but the answer is very simple:
> > none. They are friends, and nothing more. If this isn't obvious then I
> > think you've missed the point of the show entirely.
>
> I think a good case could be made for Romana though, regardless.
>
> And I don't think I've missed the point of the show if I did think the
> Doctor "had sex" or was attracted with some of his companions, as the
> point of the show wasn't a half hour each week of the Doctor not getting
> it on with his companions.
>
> That said, since any conjecture about the Doctor having a relationship
> with his companions would have to be based on the on-screen evidence it
> might be difficult to make a case.
Unless of course you either have a very flexible definition for canon, or
believe that the show was an interpretation of the "real" adventures of
the Doctor.
At any rate I think its possible, but also think it probably wouldn't be
handled well either. But then, I'm and optimist. :)
I'd LIKE to think of The Doctor and Romana going at it (well, Baker and Ward
were briefly married after she left the show, but never mind about that now),
or The Doctor, Tegan and Nyssa. But it just won't fly with the storyline and
the characters' actions.
Hope this helps your research.
Doctor 5
> I seriously don't think so. Assuming that what you see on the screen is the
> 'real' interaction of the characters, it doesn't match. They just couldn't 'do
> it' and then go on about their business like nothing happened. They would
> either become closer, or become further apart. Sex changes people and their
> relationships, and it shows.
Very true.
>
>
> I'd LIKE to think of The Doctor and Romana going at it (well, Baker and Ward
> were briefly married after she left the show, but never mind about that now),
> or The Doctor, Tegan and Nyssa. But it just won't fly with the storyline and
> the characters' actions.
The Doctor, Tegan, & Nyssa?!?! I don't think so! But as for The Doctor &
Romana, I kind of think that maybe twords the end of her stay, maybe they did fool
around. And it was that fooling around that made her leave. As you say, sex
changes things. Maybe she decided they went to far. It seemed to me that in
Logopolis, The Doctor seemed to think it was his fault she left. I can't remember
if it was something he actually said, or if it was just they way he acted.
Of coarse, I doubt we'll even know for sure.
Dante Winter
The Man With No Sig
>Nick Cooper wrote:
>
>>
>> >I wanna know how many people believe the Doctor ever had sex with his
>> >companions and exactly which ones.
>> >
>
>
>I don't know whether you're legit or not, but the answer is very simple:
>none. They are friends, and nothing more. If this isn't obvious then I
>think you've missed the point of the show entirely.
Nice editing - thanks to attributing to me a question I didn't ask.
Please be more careful next time.
> I think a good case could be made for Romana though, regardless.
Do Time Lords have sex? I thought they reproduced artificially
in Looms or something, but since the Doctor's half human he
might be an exception but Romana isn't so she probably wouldn't
cooperate.
But people don't have sex just to procreate.
Mark Phippen
Perfect Timing - 35 stories, drabbles and poems celebrating 35 years of Doctor
Who and in aid of the Foundation for the Study of Infant Deaths. For more
information visit: http://drwho.shada.com/perfect-timing/
>>Do Time Lords have sex? I thought they reproduced artificially
>>in Looms or something
>
>But people don't have sex just to procreate.
Unless they're the most BORING race in the universe which we already
know the Time Lords are, yeah?
Reg
S/He's done the same to me, in that s/he attributed something someone
else had said to me, and then completely had a go at me about it. I
think SV7's probably a bit of a newbie who hasn't grasped the concept of
quoting chevrons.
ben w.
--
"I know only that I exist - everything else is just my opinion."
Read 'Lungbarrow.'
Well that's very much the point - and yet another possible reason for the
Doctor's departure from Gallifrey. It's possible to conclude, from what we
know, that Time Lords choose not to have sex - they certainly wouldn't do it
to procreate, since they can't (or have been led to believe they can't, it
seems they are now able to - or Leela and Andred's coupling is, anyway), and
they are the sot of culture that surpresses all feelings, closeness,
stickyness, etc. (but some individuals may well go rrogue in this area, like
Andred).
However, after his recent re-generation (well, after what happened when he
fell in love for the first time, in 'Human Nature,' and when he excised his
Gallifreyan up-bringing in 'Lungbarrow'), the Doctor, one would imagine, has
started - I find it hard to see any of previous companions as bed partners,
and it wouldn't gel with his characters as established. However, we can be
pretty much sure that he slept with Benny, so I'm guessing she's the first.
Sam's obviously a no-no. I wonder how Fitz'll turn out.
Mind you, suggesting that the Doctor hasn't had sex before 'Dying Days' does
rather scupper the idea that he and the Master were former lovers.
>
> Nice editing - thanks to attributing to me a question I didn't ask.
> Please be more careful next time.
>
Whoops! Sorry! (hangs head in shame a third time!)
>
> And I don't think I've missed the point of the show if I did think the
> Doctor "had sex" or was attracted with some of his companions, as the
> point of the show wasn't a half hour each week of the Doctor not getting
> it on with his companions.
Sorry! Getting a little self-righteous after that blasted Transit
thread! But you've cited the very reason why sex shouldn't be in the
books. Because WHO is not about sex and sexuality.
> I think SV7's probably a bit of a newbie who hasn't grasped the concept of
> quoting chevrons.
>
Yes, he is a bit of a newbie at this. Did I misquote you as well?
(Hangs head in shame for the fourth time) I just get a bit overzealous
with the delete key, that's all. Is there anyone else to whom I've
done this? An extended apology for you all if I have!
Who can be about anything surely? That's what I like about it, and why it's
about the only sci-fi/fantasy I watch/read.
SV7 <EAC4719.S...@ssu.edu> wrote
> Sorry! Getting a little self-righteous after that blasted Transit
> thread! But you've cited the very reason why sex shouldn't be in the
> books. Because WHO is not about sex and sexuality.
Who is about anything and everything - including sex and sexuality.
> Anonymous wrote in message <1998112904...@replay.com>...
> >Do Time Lords have sex? I thought they reproduced artificially
> >in Looms or something, but since the Doctor's half human he
> >might be an exception but Romana isn't so she probably wouldn't
> >cooperate.
Only the Eighth Doctor is half-human. It can not (should not) be applied
retroactively.
> But if Timelords don't have sex how did the half human Doctor come
> about in the first place ?
I think that this will be explained in one of the upcoming books.
> The Doctor, Tegan, & Nyssa?!?! I don't think so! But as for The
> Doctor & Romana, I kind of think that maybe twords the end of her
> stay, maybe they did fool around. And it was that fooling around that
> made her leave. As you say, sex changes things. Maybe she decided
> they went to far.
Romana, if you recall, was being summoned back to Gallifrey just before
they entered E-Space. If she had returned to normal space with the
Doctor, she would have had to either return to Gallifrey, or become a
renegade. That is why she left.
> It seemed to me that in Logopolis, The Doctor
> seemed to think it was his fault she left. I can't remember
> if it was something he actually said, or if it was just they way he
> acted.
The only thing that I saw in that was that he was sad that she was gone,
and that he missed her. I do not doubt that he had strong emotional
feelings for her, but there is no way you can tell from that whether
they actually did 'fool around'.
> Of coarse, I doubt we'll even know for sure.
Nor should we.
Fox Becker <zen_...@my-dejanews.com> wrote
> > >Do Time Lords have sex? I thought they reproduced artificially
> > >in Looms or something, but since the Doctor's half human he
> > >might be an exception but Romana isn't so she probably wouldn't
> > >cooperate.
>
> Only the Eighth Doctor is half-human. It can not (should not) be applied
> retroactively.
Oi, that isn't canon until July!
> Chris said:
>
> > I think a good case could be made for Romana though, regardless.
>
> Do Time Lords have sex? I thought they reproduced artificially
> in Looms or something, but since the Doctor's half human he
> might be an exception but Romana isn't so she probably wouldn't
> cooperate.
While the loom scenario may be true [depends on personal canon really] I
don't see why it'd affect Time-Lords ability to have sex, just to produce
children from such couplings between the male/females, regardless of what
you think of it. Currently humans have sex without wanting to
reproduce, its not that hard to extrapolate that another species couldn't
as well, particularly one that seems so human-like.
That's one of the nice things about the looms [and indeed many of the
ideas put forth in the books] is that they generally don't preclude other
events, in this case sex could be possible even with their introduction to
the mythos.
> Quences wrote:
>
> >>Do Time Lords have sex? I thought they reproduced artificially
> >>in Looms or something
> >
> >But people don't have sex just to procreate.
>
> Unless they're the most BORING race in the universe which we already
> know the Time Lords are, yeah?
But that just means that the Time Lords would have boring sex, not that
they wouldn't have sex! :)
> Yes, Timelords have sex, and yes, the Doctor and Romana were fucking like jack
> rabbits. Anyone who argues against that is either a moron or someone who can't
> get laid and so imagine the Doctor just DOESN'T, so suddenly they don't seem as
> big of losers as they really are.
Why does it seem a common assumption that "someone who can't get
laid" is a prude or against sex?
ObWHO: _Claws of Axos_ is an "appearances can be decieving" story.
>Who is about anything and everything - including sex and sexuality.
When it comes down to it, almost every aspect of human endeavour is
probably about sex and sexuality.
Look at the Trojan War - that was all about a couple of guys fighting
over a girl.
--
Mike
Mike Sivier wrote:
I *would* look at the Trojan War if... um, ah, um, ah, IT REALLY
HAPPENED.
Now, besides the imagining of a few Greek guys with too much time on
their hands, let's see if there was any sexual aspect to any of the
following:
World War II (German guy, pissed off at being crap artist, decides it's
the Jews' fault)
The National Lottery (Desperate government needs new way to tax poor)
Marilyn Manson (Sport-hating dweeb who got bullied at school decides to
get revenge on everybody by being as weedily shocking as possible)
The Scarlet Empress ('Mainstream' author, fresh from some bad reviews,
decides to condescend Who fans by deigning to write book that only he
would like)
Discuss. Or shot put if you prefer.
--
"Put him in the cur-ry!"
"I find it hard to see any of previous companions as bed partners,
and it wouldn't gel with his characters as established."
Why not? People do it all the time and are discrete about it
What I want to know is how he can't see any previous companions as sex
partners?
Because, Chris, they can't get laid, so they try to make sure no one else does
either, that way they don't seem like such losers. It's not that they're
against it, they're just bitter because they can't get it.
> Only the Eighth Doctor is half-human.
"I'm half-human - on my mother's side".
And presumably the earlier Doctors share the same mother as the Eighth,
so...
--
Nick Smale <http://www.smale.demon.co.uk>
Manchester, UK
> World War II (German guy, pissed off at being crap artist, decides it's
> the Jews' fault)
Scott's favourite Hitler fact (OT, but entirely true):
Hitler worked as a professional artists under contract to a particular
shop. For this shop he had to produce a certain number of paintings per
month. The shop then used them to display frames for sale! A special kind
of mediocrity - painting works so bland that they draw attention to the
frames.
> The Scarlet Empress ('Mainstream' author, fresh from some bad reviews,
> decides to condescend Who fans by deigning to write book that only he
> would like)
Unfair. It so happens I started Scarlet Empress this very morning, have
read the first three chapters, and think it's the best written DW novel
I've had the pleasure of perusing in many a long year.
Scott Andrews
Peace, Love and lugubriousness
>Fox Becker <zen_...@my-dejanews.com> wrote:
>> Only the Eighth Doctor is half-human.
>"I'm half-human - on my mother's side".
>And presumably the earlier Doctors share the same mother as the Eighth,
>so...
Oh no... I'm slipping into a time loop... I can feel it...
Who was it, used to announce what the most frequently occurring
threads were?
--
Mike
>Mike Sivier wrote:
>> "Dangermouse" <mas...@sol.co.ukDEATH-TO-SPAMMERS> wrote:
>>
>> >Who is about anything and everything - including sex and sexuality.
>>
>> When it comes down to it, almost every aspect of human endeavour is
>> probably about sex and sexuality.
>>
>> Look at the Trojan War - that was all about a couple of guys fighting
>> over a girl.
>I *would* look at the Trojan War if... um, ah, um, ah, IT REALLY
>HAPPENED.
Okay, okay! I was thinking about the Iliad but couldn't remember the
title (!). Earliest example of literature I could think of;
demonstrates the point that people have been doing such things, and
telling stories about them, since the dawn of time (whenever that
was).
>Now, besides the imagining of a few Greek guys with too much time on
>their hands, let's see if there was any sexual aspect to any of the
>following:
>World War II (German guy, pissed off at being crap artist, decides it's
>the Jews' fault)
Yeah - he only had one testicle so he felt inadequate.
>The National Lottery (Desperate government needs new way to tax poor)
A whole bunch of inadequates...
>Marilyn Manson (Sport-hating dweeb who got bullied at school decides to
>get revenge on everybody by being as weedily shocking as possible)
None whatsoever.
>The Scarlet Empress ('Mainstream' author, fresh from some bad reviews,
>decides to condescend Who fans by deigning to write book that only he
>would like)
There *is* a sexual aspect to this, but only if you prefer mature
women. :)
>Discuss. Or shot put if you prefer.
Female shot putters are the best.
--
Mike
My theory is that at every regeneration a new DNA pattern is formed
using the Timelord's more advanced Biodata. Now when the Eighth
Doctor was born his new DNA just happened to have Human genes in
the half that would have been supplied by his Mother.
This is because human genes were in the biodata template woven
from Lungbarrow's Loom.
--
///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
// Aidan Folkes : af6...@bristol.ac.uk www.folktest.demon.co.uk
"There are worlds out there where the sky is burning,the seas sleep,
and the rivers dream; people made of smoke, and cities made of song.
Somewhere there's danger; somewhere there's injustice, and somewhere
else the tea is getting cold! Come on Ace, we've got work to do!"
Nick Smale <n...@smale.demon.co.uk> wrote in article
<1djcn2r.y9t...@smale.demon.co.uk>...
> Fox Becker <zen_...@my-dejanews.com> wrote:
>
> > Only the Eighth Doctor is half-human.
>
> "I'm half-human - on my mother's side".
>
> And presumably the earlier Doctors share the same mother as the Eighth,
> so...
Heh heh heh...
> Nick Smale <n...@smale.demon.co.uk> wrote in article
>
> > Fox Becker <zen_...@my-dejanews.com> wrote:
> >
> > > Only the Eighth Doctor is half-human.
> >
> > "I'm half-human - on my mother's side".
> >
> > And presumably the earlier Doctors share the same mother as the Eighth,
> > so...
>
> Heh heh heh...
:-)
> Mr. Rednour,
>
> >
> > And I don't think I've missed the point of the show if I did think the
> > Doctor "had sex" or was attracted with some of his companions, as the
> > point of the show wasn't a half hour each week of the Doctor not getting
> > it on with his companions.
>
> Sorry! Getting a little self-righteous after that blasted Transit
> thread! But you've cited the very reason why sex shouldn't be in the
> books. Because WHO is not about sex and sexuality.
Well, I don't really agree, I think sex and sexuality can be in Doctor
Who, I just think there has to be a reason arising from the stories and
character that justify it. Obviously, since Doctor Who isn't a porn show
[sorry Charles] I doubt a plot where the Doctor and co. spend the novel
looking for the best sex on the planet Mobldbox would work...
But then a friend of mine complained to me a few years ago that everything
I wrote didn't have enough sex in it...[she never read the partially
written sequel to the novel I'd written [now long forgotten [and best
that way, since after re-reading it I'm really glad I never tried to
get it published!]] were there was more bed hopping than grasshopers in a
burning mattress factory and all justified by the plot and characters.].
But I digress...
> >Because WHO is not about sex and sexuality.
>
> Who can be about anything surely? That's what I like about it, and why it's
> about the only sci-fi/fantasy I watch/read.
If WHO can be about anything, then its about nothing in particular, so
playing semantics, I'm right. :)
My point is [as I believe it was I who wrote that line] that the focus of
WHO hasn't been sex or sexuality, but SF/Fantasy adventure stories with
continuing characters.
This doesn't preclude sex [or most of anything] being in the stories,
or indeed themes and allegorical stories that are about sex, but generally
doesn't mean that WHO has in the past tended to focus on sex as it main
reason to be.
But what about those who can't get laid and do accept sex in Doctor Who?
You are besmerching the already dubious reputation of the "laid-less".
I agree with this concept, that the sex must evolve from the
characters and plot, but in practice I just don't see how this can
logically happen given the evnts of your typical WHO story. I don't
know anymore. No one seems to agree with my Avengers-esque view of
WHO, so I should probably just stop banging away at this! Maybe I
really am a prude!
SV7
Carrot juice! Carrot Juice!! carrot Juice!!!
>
> Who can be about anything surely? That's what I like about it, and why it's
> about the only sci-fi/fantasy I watch/read.
>
True. But it HASN'T been about sex and sexuality, and I think
precedent is an awfully important guage of something's worth.
>>Why does it seem a common assumption that "someone who can't get
>>laid" is a prude or against sex?
>Because, Chris, they can't get laid, so they try to make sure no one else does
>either, that way they don't seem like such losers. It's not that they're
>against it, they're just bitter because they can't get it.
Just in case anyone buys into this... The first time the debate about a
sexual Doctor really flared up, during early '95 when the Segal project
was first getting underway, I was firmly convinced that it was a Bad Idea.
At the time, I'd been in a stable relationship for about three years, and
had had a couple of other fairly-long-term girlfriends in the two years
before that... in other words, the kind of love life which gets you
labeled a raging slut if you're a Doctor Who companion, but which
otherwise just seems fairly normal. So the "sexually deprived" argument
doesn't wash.
By the time the telemovie actually aired in May '96, and I saw that it
*was* possible to have the Doctor kiss someone without hitting the usual
Hollywood formula, Kate and I had become a couple -- but because of the
intercontinental thing, we'd managed to spend two weeks together in the
previous nine months. So perhaps you could make a case that not having
enough sex makes you *more* willing to see your heroes get a good snog in,
cause at least that means *someone*'s happy... :-)
Regards,
Jon Blum
--
jblum at access.digex.net
"Eep," said an I.
You can't get any, can you Chris?
That is an excelent point, Jon. I mean, just how much time had passed between
Ace leaving and the Telemovie anyway?
>Unless they're the most BORING race in the universe which we already
>know the Time Lords are, yeah?
>
I heard Sylvester McCoy say at a con years ago that the Time Lords have sex
very similarly to humans "except the way we do it it's much more fun."
I have it on tape
Rob Claffie - The Knights of the White Guardian
http://www.geocities.com/Area51/Rampart/2145/
I'm half-British. On my mother's side.
Did someone call? :)
I may revive it when the contract I'm working on at the moment is
finished and I have some free time again.
===========================================================================
The television critic, whatever his pretensions, does not labour in the
same vineyard as those he criticizes; his grapes are all sour.
--Frederic Raphael
SV7 <EAC4719.S...@ssu.edu> wrote
> True. But it HASN'T been about sex and sexuality, and I think
> precedent is an awfully important guage of something's worth.
"But Mister Wright - nobody's ever flown a powered flying machine before!"
"Oh, right; fuck it then, let's not bother"
>"Reg" <gosb...@ansonic.com.au> wrote:
>>But if Timelords don't have sex how did the half human Doctor come about in
>>the first place?
>Read 'Lungbarrow.'
Must...fight...temptation... ugh.... can't... stop... it...
You might as well cite the Peter Cushing films as proof the Doc is
half human, then back it up with passages from Peter David's Star Trek
novel Imzaldi....
life essence...slowly... disappearing... good... bye...
*slumps off to a cannonized death*
Anywho,
Lance Hall
_________________________________________________________________________
"What I'm saying here, in case you're a yotz who needs things codified simply
and directly, is that Doctor Who is the apex, the pinnacle, the tops,
the Louvre museum, the Colosseum, and other et cetera."
---Harlan Ellison
_________________________________________________________________________
Instant replay of Susan Ivanova "having sex" with the new ambassador on
Babylon 5.
> I have it on tape
Oo, Gallifreyan pornography?
-Glen Williams
bi...@vt.edu
http://www.slac.com/kallisti/
>On Tue, 01 Dec 1998 13:20:24 GMT, Mike Sivier wrote:
>>Oh no... I'm slipping into a time loop... I can feel it...
>>
>>Who was it, used to announce what the most frequently occurring
>>threads were?
>Did someone call? :)
>I may revive it when the contract I'm working on at the moment is
>finished and I have some free time again.
Only if you really want to...
My sole reason for mentioning it was that I saw us spinning back into
this never-ending loop of, "he's always been half-human" "Only since
his seventh regeneration".
If the truth is vague enough for people to be arguing over it, we
haven't seen enough evidence yet.
--
Mike
>SV7 <EAC4719.S...@ssu.edu> wrote
>> True. But it HASN'T been about sex and sexuality, and I think
>> precedent is an awfully important guage of something's worth.
>"But Mister Wright - nobody's ever flown a powered flying machine before!"
>"Oh, right; fuck it then, let's not bother"
Damn right. The only way I get to post to this newsgroup is by sitting
here in my cave and banging these rocks together.
--
Mike
I agree with you. We'll be prudes together.
Seriously, in the environments of "Dr. Who", any interesting story (i.e.
one that's worth telling) will probably preclude sexuality, since the TARDIS
crew will be strangers in a crisis situation, that has to be sorted out
before sex becomes a viable option again. Of course, as soon as the
situation is resolved, the Doctor and his companions troop off back to
the TARDIS and go somewhere else.
One gets the feeling that they may actually end up feeling rather
sexually frustrated sometimes. I think that's the real reason so many
of the Doctor's companions leave him (imagines a truly honest goodbye
scene on the subject) :->
Oliver Thornton
IYO - and I for one subscribe to the idea that, since sex and death are
implicit within every piece of fiction, it does already exist within 'Who.' If
that's not good enough, there's 'Happiness Patrol's allegorical homosexuality,
Ace's pubety, and more besides.
>and I think
>precedent is an awfully important guage of something's worth.
Then, any DW that has gone against precedent is worthless to you? That'd be
the series shafted, then.
True, and there have been many cases made for off-screen sex in the TARDIS,
but the Doctor's apparent total lack of interest in this area is indicative
IMO. His companions show signs of attraction, of love, etc., he never has -
not on a personal level. I've always seen him as loving everybody, unable to
limit his love for people in the way that we can (if you see what I mean -
clumsing phrasing here, I'm probably not getting my point across). The 'Human
Nature'/'Lungbarrow'/TVM idea, that he's learned, for the first time, how to
love in a different way and how pleasurable that cna be and the challenge for
the eigth Doctor is to retain his big love while exploring his small love too
(sorry, clumsy phrasing again) is so very, very appealing (and seems to be so
absolutely in keeping with how the Doctor has always seemed to be, how he has
always acted).
I could be witty and ask why you neccessarily assume that when I don't see
companions as "bed" partners I mean I don't see tham as "sex" partners, but
I'll actually explain that I meant to say "I don't see them as bed partners
for the Doctor." As for myself, I've covered this before, I'm sure (especially
in the Tegan and Turlough, early crushes area).
Would that help?
>life essence...slowly... disappearing... good... bye...
>
>*slumps off to a cannonized death*
Ha, I've told you all, it'll get you in the end. Repeat after me "there is no
canon, it is far too silly, there is no canon, it is far too silly, there is
no canon..."
Cave? What's a cave?
--
-Thad Doria
"This is Precious Roy, and I just robbed a bank in Egypt!"
Mike Sivier <mi...@wurzzz.demon.co.uk> wrote
> My sole reason for mentioning it was that I saw us spinning back into
> this never-ending loop of, "he's always been half-human" "Only since
> his seventh regeneration".
>
> If the truth is vague enough for people to be arguing over it, we
> haven't seen enough evidence yet.
And won't, until July.
G.C.G. Smith <ENG6...@leeds.ac.uk> wrote
> True, and there have been many cases made for off-screen sex in the
TARDIS,
> but the Doctor's apparent total lack of interest in this area is
indicative
> IMO. His companions show signs of attraction, of love, etc., he never has
-
> not on a personal level.
Somebody hasn't seen The Aztecs, The Green Death, etc...
: IYO - and I for one subscribe to the idea that, since sex and death are
: implicit within every piece of fiction, it does already exist within 'Who.' If
: that's not good enough, there's 'Happiness Patrol's allegorical homosexuality,
: Ace's pubety, and more besides.
I missed that, certainly!
You say that all fiction is about sex and death, implicitly, that
sexuality must be in Who. That seems to miss that it's already about
death, often quite explicitly - unless you mean the logical "and", in
which case, I would say that your initial statement is false.
Oliver Thornton
mon.co.uk> <01be1e03$8b5cc300$LocalHost@lgwujvnl>
Distribution:
Dangermouse (mas...@sol.co.ukDEATH-TO-SPAMMERS) wrote:
: Mike Sivier <mi...@wurzzz.demon.co.uk> wrote
: > My sole reason for mentioning it was that I saw us spinning back into
: > this never-ending loop of, "he's always been half-human" "Only since
: > his seventh regeneration".
: >
: > If the truth is vague enough for people to be arguing over it, we
: > haven't seen enough evidence yet.
: And won't, until July.
And when half of us decide we don't like where that evidence leads, there
will be a new argument over whether or not it's canonical. I am rapidly
becoming highly cynical about the options for persuading anybody of
anything they don't already believe on this ng.
Oliver Thornton
: True, and there have been many cases made for off-screen sex in the TARDIS,
: but the Doctor's apparent total lack of interest in this area is indicative
: IMO. His companions show signs of attraction, of love, etc., he never has -
: not on a personal level. I've always seen him as loving everybody, unable to
: limit his love for people in the way that we can (if you see what I mean -
: clumsing phrasing here, I'm probably not getting my point across). The 'Human
: Nature'/'Lungbarrow'/TVM idea, that he's learned, for the first time, how to
: love in a different way and how pleasurable that cna be and the challenge for
: the eigth Doctor is to retain his big love while exploring his small love too
: (sorry, clumsy phrasing again) is so very, very appealing (and seems to be so
: absolutely in keeping with how the Doctor has always seemed to be, how he has
: always acted).
You will never convince me that there wasn't *some* personal, one-to-one
attraction for Cameca ("The Aztecs"). That the Doctor has to leave in
order to get his companions home just adds to the poignancy of the
situation. When Cameca realises that the Doctor must go, it is really
quite touching.
The only reason I believe the Doctor so rarely involves himself with
others in a romantic way, is that to do so would almost always result in
the same kind of anguish and parting as that. With whom could the Doctor
share his passion? A human would die too soon, or yearn for a home. A
Time Lady would be too up-tight, or wouldn't understand (except perhaps
Romana). The Doctor as a gentleman couldn't take advantage as other
wandering folk have been known to do, nor could he involve himself with
those whom he has taken under his wing. He is de facto in loco parentis
for the majority of those, and feels the parental responsibility towards
them so that he could not feel that it would be anything but an abuse of
position to make advances, or to respond to those made.
The Doctor is in a very difficult position, and has so little time
anywhere to establish romantic relations that he very rarely has a
chance.
Hmmm. How about a UNIT story with a romance for the Doctor? Or a
reverse-roles of "Seeing I", that is, Sam seeking the Doctor, the Doctor
developing on his own, having (a) relationship(s) etc. until they find each
other again?
Oliver Thornton
(conspiritorial whisper)
They're shadows...
(/conspiritorial whisper)
-Erin (St.) ~Right Honourable RADW Babe of the Year~
President of Save Our Doctor: Television's Hero In Space
Proudly telling the Beeb to SOD THIS since 1997
"I'm on Aslan's side even if there isn't any Aslan to lead it. I'm
going to live as like a Narnian as I can even if there isn't any
Narnia." Puddleglum, _The Silver Chair_
Very interesting point. One might also see a reason in the fact that
the Doctor's regenerations are inconstant, resulting in sometimes
drastic changes in personality. That would admittedly make
relationships very difficult, especially considering that the Doctor
seems to regenerate pretty frequently compared to other Time Lords.
It's difficult to get romantically involved with someone knowing that a
week from now you could very likely wake up and try to strangle them.
At least, that would put a damper on *my* relationships.
-Glen Williams
bi...@vt.edu
http://www.slac.com/kallisti
OJ THORNTON <ojth...@bradford.ac.uk> wrote
> : > If the truth is vague enough for people to be arguing over it, we
> : > haven't seen enough evidence yet.
>
> : And won't, until July.
>
> And when half of us decide we don't like where that evidence leads, there
> will be a new argument over whether or not it's canonical.
Yep.
But I can't stop that any more than I could stop the sun from setting.
Ha Ha. Aren't you witty! :)
What's happening then?
Michael S. Tumilty <Tum...@email.msn.com> wrote
> Well, you see all those black figures dancing before your
> eyes?
>
> (conspiritorial whisper)
> They're shadows...
> (/conspiritorial whisper)
Don't say things like that aropund here - I'm *canon* in B5...
> Mr. Rednour,
> >
> > Well, I don't really agree, I think sex and sexuality can be in Doctor
> > Who, I just think there has to be a reason arising from the stories and
> > character that justify it.
>
> I agree with this concept, that the sex must evolve from the
> characters and plot, but in practice I just don't see how this can
> logically happen given the evnts of your typical WHO story.
Well, it could happen easily over a story that scope wise takes a few
weeks to happen. I think there could easily be time for a relationship to
begin and mature. A story that takes place over a couple of days seems to
me, to be pushing the envelope of believability.
> I don't
> know anymore. No one seems to agree with my Avengers-esque view of
> WHO, so I should probably just stop banging away at this! Maybe I
> really am a prude!
Well, I couldn't agree with it, because IIRC what you stated, I didn't
agree with your hypotheses about the AVENGERS.
-Chris Rednour
_________________________________________________________________
gs0...@panther.gsu.edu http://www.gsu.edu/~gs06cjr/index.html
cred...@gpc.peachnet.edu
> Chris Rednour <gs0...@panther.Gsu.EDU> wrote:
> >On 1 Dec 1998, MadDogG252 wrote:
> >
> >> Chris Rednour <gs0...@panther.Gsu.EDU> wrote:
> >> >On 30 Nov 1998, MadDogG252 wrote:
> >> >
> >> >> Yes, Timelords have sex, and yes, the Doctor and Romana were fucking
> >like
> >> >jack
> >> >> rabbits. Anyone who argues against that is either a moron or someone
> >who
> >> >can't
> >> >> get laid and so imagine the Doctor just DOESN'T, so suddenly they don't
> >> >seem as
> >> >> big of losers as they really are.
> >> >
> >> >Why does it seem a common assumption that "someone who can't get
> >> >laid" is a prude or against sex?
> >> >
> >> >ObWHO: _Claws of Axos_ is an "appearances can be decieving" story.
> >> >
> >> >-Chris Rednour
> >>
> >> Because, Chris, they can't get laid, so they try to make sure no one else
> >does
> >> either, that way they don't seem like such losers. It's not that they're
> >> against it, they're just bitter because they can't get it.
> >
> >
> >But what about those who can't get laid and do accept sex in Doctor Who?
> >You are besmerching the already dubious reputation of the "laid-less".
> >
> >-Chris Rednour
>
> You can't get any, can you Chris?
No, and I really don't want my reputation besmirched by tacking on
disliking sex in who because I'm bitter.
>I agree with this concept, that the sex must evolve from the
>characters and plot, but in practice I just don't see how this can
>logically happen given the evnts of your typical WHO story.
Facing danger and difficulty together can help to bring characters closer,
whether as friends or lovers. "The Green Death" is a good example from the
TV show, and "The Daleks" and "The Aztecs" have similar romantic elements,
as does "The Curse of Fenric".
We can do a bit more with the romance in the novels than the TV show could
- not just in terms of including more than a few chaste kisses, but in
terms of developing the relationships more fully. There's more time and
room to show a relationship developing.
--
Kate Blum Orman - "A broad too deep for the small screen"
kor...@laurel.ocs.mq.edu.au | http://www.ocs.mq.edu.au/~korman
Prompting SV7 to write:
>What's happening then?
Dangermouse will be publishing his first book. YAY!!!!!!!
SV7 <EAC4719.S...@ssu.edu> wrote in article
<3665C2...@ssu.edu>...
> Dangermouse,
> >
> > "But Mister Wright - nobody's ever flown a powered flying machine
before!"
> >
> > "Oh, right; fuck it then, let's not bother"
>
> Ha Ha. Aren't you witty! :)
I bow to the master of the snappy comeback...
SV7 <EAC4719.S...@ssu.edu> wrote in article
<3665C3...@ssu.edu>...
> Mr. Thornton,
> > : >
> > : > If the truth is vague enough for people to be arguing over it, we
> > : > haven't seen enough evidence yet.
> >
> > : And won't, until July.
> >
>
> What's happening then?
My book, with the evidence (well, as it were...) comes out.
You'll be delighted to know that there is no sex in it. But I suppose I
might import some especially to cheer you up.
OK. I'll bite. When and how did *this* happen?
--
Allen Robinson
Who's Doctor Who?
www.dwebs.net/~allenrob/whoshome.html
-----------== Posted via Deja News, The Discussion Network ==----------
http://www.dejanews.com/ Search, Read, Discuss, or Start Your Own
Um . . .no, actually it's his 9th book.
>> Mr. Rednour,
>> >
>> > Well, I don't really agree, I think sex and sexuality can be in Doctor
>> > Who, I just think there has to be a reason arising from the stories and
>> > character that justify it.
>>
>> I agree with this concept, that the sex must evolve from the
>> characters and plot, but in practice I just don't see how this can
>> logically happen given the evnts of your typical WHO story.
> Well, it could happen easily over a story that scope wise takes a few
> weeks to happen. I think there could easily be time for a relationship to
> begin and mature. A story that takes place over a couple of days seems to
> me, to be pushing the envelope of believability.
The time argument's bogus in the first place, people don't need to know
each other for a long time (even at all) to have sex.
How would that be witty?
>but I'll actually explain that I meant to say "I don't see them as bed
partners
>for the Doctor." As for myself, I've covered this before, I'm sure
>(especially
>in the Tegan and Turlough, early crushes area).
I see. You like to do it on the floor. Bed's too sqeaky. Head bord bangs up
against the wall. I got the same problem. But I'm sure the Doctor's trusty
sonic screwdriver could take care of those problems, and I see the Doctor as
more of a bed fellow.
---
At least it's not Menudo.
Maddogg
AHHHH! YOU STUPID SONOFABITCH! Lungbarrow is the worst piece of crap in the
universe. It's based on an obscure line from the five doctors and is
contradicted by most of the televised series.
>> You can't get any, can you Chris?
>
>No, and I really don't want my reputation besmirched by tacking on
>disliking sex in who because I'm bitter.
>
>-Chris Rednour
At least your honest, Chris. I gotta respect that.
We've done this before - and discusse how 'Aztecs' is purely down to
interpretation - the Doctor doesn't *seem* to be in love (attraction, sexual
love) in any tangiable way. As for 'Green Death' I can only say *what*??? If
you're talking about Jo, then I can only re-iterate points about friendship
and love on that level different to the level the eigth Doctor (and the
seventh, in 'Human Nature') is now capable of.
Anonymous <nob...@replay.com> wrote in article
<1998120302...@replay.com>...
> Anonymous:
> >
> >Dangermouse will be publishing his first book. YAY!!!!!!!
>
> Um . . .no, actually it's his 9th book.
10th.
Wages Of Sin in February is the 9th...
I don't expect to.
>That the Doctor has to leave in
>order to get his companions home just adds to the poignancy of the
>situation. When Cameca realises that the Doctor must go, it is really
>quite touching.
Oh, I can see that idea - and there can be no doubt that Cameca loves him.
I've said before (I think) that it's possible the Doctor has some feeling but
has trouble articulating and accepting them - this would develop what we know
about him from 'Lungbarrow.'
[snip]
>Hmmm. How about a UNIT story with a romance for the Doctor?
The third Doctor and Mike Yates? Hmm... It's certainly an idea.
Oh well, there goes that promising career in stand-up.
There speaks a man (or woman) who hasn't read 'T8D,' or anything by Jeffrey
Archer. 'Lungbarrow's brilliance (in clearing up continuity errors in a new
and interesting way, in telling a fairly gripping story at the same time, in
winding-down the seventh Doctor and setting-up the eigth, in uniting the TVM
with the books and the TV series) speaks for itself IMO. It's certainly the
best fanwank out there (compare it to any anniversary story, 'Mawdryn Undead,'
UNIT stuff, etc.).
>It's based on an obscure line from the five doctors
And 'Planet of the Spiders' is based on an obscrue line from 'The Time
Monster' (OK, bad choice of defence perhaps, but what the hell).
>and is contradicted by most of the televised series.
Ha, try none of the TV series - go on, give me some evidence of contradiciton
that hasn't already been worked-through a dozen times on this ng.
>Mike Sivier <mi...@wurzzz.demon.co.uk> wrote
>> My sole reason for mentioning it was that I saw us spinning back into
>> this never-ending loop of, "he's always been half-human" "Only since
>> his seventh regeneration".
>>
>> If the truth is vague enough for people to be arguing over it, we
>> haven't seen enough evidence yet.
>And won't, until July.
... and IIRC, *that* idea sprang from a discussion of the topic on
this group a few months ago...
Not the idea for the book, the idea included in the book.
--
Mike
>In article <912607172.2596.5...@news.demon.co.uk>,
>Mike Sivier <mi...@wurzzz.demon.co.uk> wrote:
>>"Dangermouse" <mas...@sol.co.ukDEATH-TO-SPAMMERS> wrote:
>>
>>
>>
>>>SV7 <EAC4719.S...@ssu.edu> wrote
>>>> True. But it HASN'T been about sex and sexuality, and I think
>>>> precedent is an awfully important guage of something's worth.
>>
>>>"But Mister Wright - nobody's ever flown a powered flying machine before!"
>>
>>>"Oh, right; fuck it then, let's not bother"
>>
>>Damn right. The only way I get to post to this newsgroup is by sitting
>>here in my cave and banging these rocks together.
>>
>>--
>>Mike
>Cave? What's a cave?
It's what I live in when the tree is too cold.
--
Mike
>ENG6...@leeds.ac.uk (G.C.G. Smith) wrote:
>>>But if Timelords don't have sex how did the half human Doctor come about in
>>>the first place?
>>
>>Read 'Lungbarrow.'
>AHHHH! YOU STUPID SONOFABITCH! Lungbarrow is the worst piece of crap in the
>universe. It's based on an obscure line from the five doctors and is
>contradicted by most of the televised series.
Dunno about the rest of you, but if *I* was Gregg, being called a
stupid sonofabitch would've instantly swayed me to MadDog's point of
view.
--
Mike
Missed what?
>You say that all fiction is about sex and death, implicitly, that
>sexuality must be in Who. That seems to miss that it's already about
>death, often quite explicitly
No, that's missing the point - sex and death are implicit in everything
adult human culture produces, that's the theory. Explicit portrayals are
irrelevant. What this means is that sex is implicit in everything, therefore
not totally absent (its impossible for it to be totally absent), therefore any
explicit sex in new 'Who' is merely explicitly stating what was implicit but
not shown in the series. DW can be considered to be about sex and sexuality
because sex and sexuality are implicitly involved in any fictional discourse -
it could also be considered to be about sex and sexuality by its careful
avoidance of depicting them, but since that avoidance is mainly a product of
it being a kids' show I'm not sure that's a valid point.
> - unless you mean the logical "and", in
>which case, I would say that your initial statement is false.
I'm afraid to say I'm not sure what you mean by a "logical 'and'" - could you
elaborate (I assume this is a philosphical term?).
I won't even mention what he said in the Troll thread.
who...@my-dejanews.com wrote
> > Don't say things like that aropund here - I'm *canon* in B5...
>
> OK. I'll bite. When and how did *this* happen?
Ahahaahahahah. I'm a StarFury pilot... There's a listing somewhere in the
Security Manual, I think.
: >:IYO - and I for one subscribe to the idea that, since sex and death are
: >:implicit within every piece of fiction, it does already exist within 'Who.'
: >:If that's not good enough, there's 'Happiness Patrol's allegorical
: >:homosexuality, Ace's pubety, and more besides.
: >
: >I missed that, certainly!
: Missed what?
Allegorical homosexuality in "Happiness Patrol".
: >You say that all fiction is about sex and death, implicitly, that
: >sexuality must be in Who. That seems to miss that it's already about
: >death, often quite explicitly
: No, that's missing the point - sex and death are implicit in everything
: adult human culture produces, that's the theory. Explicit portrayals are
: irrelevant. What this means is that sex is implicit in everything, therefore
: not totally absent (its impossible for it to be totally absent),
: therefore any
: explicit sex in new 'Who' is merely explicitly stating what was implicit but
: not shown in the series. DW can be considered to be about sex and sexuality
You just said that what is explicit is not important.
: because sex and sexuality are implicitly involved in any fictional discourse -
: it could also be considered to be about sex and sexuality by its careful
: avoidance of depicting them, but since that avoidance is mainly a product of
: it being a kids' show I'm not sure that's a valid point.
: > - unless you mean the logical "and", in
: >which case, I would say that your initial statement is false.
: I'm afraid to say I'm not sure what you mean by a "logical 'and'" - could you
: elaborate (I assume this is a philosphical term?).
Logical "and" - in your example, "there is sexuality AND death implicit in
every fiction" says it is true both that "there is sexuality implicit in all
fiction." and "there is death implicit in all fiction."
i.e., every article of fiction contains BOTH implicit sex AND implicit
death. If either "implicit sex" or "implicit death" or both are absent in
any example of fiction, then your statement is false.
Oliver Thornton
Mike Sivier <mi...@wurzzz.demon.co.uk> wrote
> >And won't, until July.
>
> ... and IIRC, *that* idea sprang from a discussion of the topic on
> this group a few months ago...
>
> Not the idea for the book, the idea included in the book.
Or to be more precise, the idea of linking that idea to another idea that
was already in there.
Everybody following this?