> comedian Bill Maher took his passing as an opportunity to take a shot
> at fandom with an essay titled "Adulting":
Who the fuck is Bill Maher, had to look him up.
Man, is he bad at reasoning or what?
> "...the assumption everyone had back then, both the adults
> and the kids, was that comics were for kids, and when you
No assumption, most comic books simply were for kids "back then".
(Back then being 20 years ago!?)
Kids today (with responsible parents) still read kids comics.
That's not establishing that all comics are for children.
Comics for adults exist for much longer than 20 years.
Try a few centuries.
> grew up you moved on to big-boy books without the pictures.
Many books feature illustrations (from latin: enlightening),
because people actually like pictures. The absence of pictures is not
a sign of quality or maturity. (And what about the big girls?)
He tries to offend the people who disagree, so they don't see
how weak his argument is.
> But then twenty years or so ago, something happened adults
> decided they didn t have to give up kid stuff. And so they
Nice try again. Poor guy Maher is obviously no expert in contemporary
history or economics. The comic industry developed. Expanded its
audience. Gained customers. And hat about comic films like the original
Jungle Book from 1967? Art or not? O_o
> pretended comic books were actually sophisticated literature."
Silly. No need to pretend anything.
Some comics are sophisticated art, some are trash.
In the most restrictive sense they are not literature,
but neither is Beethoven's 8th symphony.
Again, he failed to make a point.
Any form of art uses a medium to transport its content.
To argue a certain medium (comics) could be exclusive to
a certain audience (children) is extremely idiotic.
Why do I rant about this?
Because Maher actually makes people dumber and more narrow-minded
with this kind of drivel. Its not even funny.
To me this habit of some comedians, commenters and debaters to replace
a valid line of argument with loose thinking and cheap or derisive jokes
is abhorrent. Make a good point and /then/ a joke, please.
/That/ helps to remember a point worthy of being remembered.
LL