On 8/4/2017 10:40 PM, Jimmy Delach wrote:
> And if the Tampa Tribune were still in existence, they are the most
> hypocritical in how they manage their comics. They used a flawed
> readers' poll as an excuse to dump "Peanuts" in 2005 (more than five
> years into its' rerun phase) and in 2010, they dropped "Better/Worse"
> (and brought back "Shoe" to replace it on Sundays?!?!?). They dropped
> the Daily Doonesbury strips just as the Classic phase began
> (replacing it with "Rhymes With Orange") while continuing to run the
> new Sunday strips but yet they still carried "Get Fuzzy" which
> remained with the paper until its' May 2016 extinction. Whereas the
> Tampa Bay Times, the paper my family has subscribed to for years,
> remains loyal and still runs all four of the aforementioned rerun
> strips (I could personally do without "Fuzzy" but I don't want to be
> too hypocritical).
>
You can call it "loyal vs hypocritical" - I'd call dropping dead strips
(whether a reader poll said so or not) to be a reasonable approach, and
I'd call keeping them forever (again, reader poll or not) lazy.
I see no reason for Peanuts or FBOFW to still be in newspapers - Peanuts
ended over 17 years ago, and FBOFW (a significantly lesser strip IMO) 9
years ago - it's time to let them go and make space for the living.
Anyone who really still wants them can buy the books or read them online.
Many papers /have/ dropped Doonesbury dailies, but the Sundays are all
new, and I see no reason to drop those. Get Fuzzy is an odd case -
mostly reruns with occasional new. I'd think this has been going on
long enough that the syndicate should step in and either require more
new content or declare the strip officially in reruns. However (unlike
Darryl, who apparently has a bug up his butt over it) I don't think it
should be incumbent on (or even expected of) Darby to do so; I think the
syndicate should just require a significant amount of new content if the
strip is to be labeled "current", and should label it "classic"
otherwise - and let the papers decide if they want a "classic" strip.
(I'd personally prefer not, but like I said, I feel that way about
Peanuts, too.)