* Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet's Discussion Network *
The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet - Free!
Agreed. There really is "no going back," as the saying goes. But I don't see
why it would have to recapture the whole mood of the original series. I'd love
to see the return of all the people mentioned (with the exeption of Hope).
-=[ The BlakGard ]=-
"Somewhere there's danger;
somewhere there's injustice,
and somewhere else the tea is getting cold!"
>>How awesome would it be to have Karma, Sunspot,
>>Cannonball, Wolfsbane, and Dani all back together. Maybe after Magik's
>>limited
>>series, she could stop by too.
>
>Too awesome for Marvel's upper management to grasp apparently. I can understand
>the current X-Force team and their take on superheroism, that's fine. But
>Cannonball and Meltdown don't represent more 5% of the original New Mutants.
I hate to point it out to you, but Cannonball (Meltdown wasn't an
original New Mutant) represents exactly 20% of the original New
Mutants.
> I
>want all the lost-in-comic-limbo New Mutants back plus whoever isn't attached
>to X-Force now. Siryn, Karma, Magma, Wolfsbane, Warlock, Taki, Magik, Moonstar,
>the list goes on. Heck, even Hope from the cancelled Warlock series would be
>cool in the New Mutants.
Well, we'll just have to see what devious plans Rob Liefeld has...
Christian Henriksson
(ora...@hem.passagen.se)
--
"30 members of a small Mexican sect got into their heads that they
would get closer to God by inhaling butane gas in a small, well-
insulated room. They were right."
- Z magazine
What I want to know is if Rob Liefeld wants to do a New Mutans series so bad,
He sure as hell did. This fact is indisputable. He got rid of members, added
new members, and turned them into a military force.
>i think the series started to get away from what it was a little after
>magneto became headmaster. it was totally unbelievable and he
>was accepted way too quickly.
Unbelievable that Magneto could be their headmaster? Well, at the time it was
believable, because Magneto was for the most part a good guy back then. Was he
accepted? Not in the slightest. This is why the New Mutants did not respect his
authority and basically left.
>i think sean cassidy would have been a better choice or even moira.
Sean had a different philosophy back then. At the time, he was very much
against the whole concept of taking mutants in and training them. Moira would
have been possible, but I don't think she's much of a trainer.
>it seems like the real trouble sarted inbetween issues 56 n 57. Right
>after Amara left everyone changed drastically. Yana became a brat,
>rahn a whiner, dani a stick in the mud, sam was reduced to the dumb
>hick again, bobby the one dimentional macho punk. and warlock
>went from childlike and inquizative to goofy jar-jaresque comic
>releif.
Most of these personalities were in the characters from day one. Dani was
always a stick in the mud; Rahne whined; Bobby had a chip on his shoulder the
size of Galactus' ship; as for Warlock, it was a normal progression for the
character and the main reason why most people adored him. I don't remember Yana
being a brat... at least not anymore than the whole lot of them were brats.
>i think that by the time of the fallen angels lim. sam, dani, xain,
>and maybe amars should have been graduated to the x-men or
>left to go onto something else.
I do agree with you here. Perhaps if this did happen, the series would have
been more like its name: New Mutants. However, the basic premise of the series
was that there would never be a graduation, because Xavier did want them to die
as the X-Men were believed to have died fighting the Brood. This philosophy
continued too long, in my opinion.
>when Leifeld came on he at least gave them some sort of direction.
That's about the only thing that I will give Liefeld credit for.
>i think the problems really started because noone wants their
>characters to actually grow up and the muties did.
Agreed. I think most people are this way, unfortunately. I, on the other hand,
just wish they would grow up quicker!
Well, one obvious reason that would spring to mind is that that was
ten years ago and maybe he's changed his mind.
Paul O'Brien
THE X-AXIS REVIEWS - http://www.esoterica.demon.co.uk
Flowers: the practical alternative to capitalism, apparently.
> Most of these personalities were in the characters
> from day one. Dani was
> always a stick in the mud; Rahne whined; Bobby had a
> chip on his shoulder the
> size of Galactus' ship; as for Warlock, it was a
> normal progression for the
> character and the main reason why most people adored
> him. I don't remember Yana
> being a brat... at least not anymore than the whole
> lot of them were brats.
I don't know about that. In the very beginning, Dani was
rebellious, distrustful, proud and stubborn. That turned
into wildness and daring as she came to accept Xavier and
her teammates, and later she became a responsible and strong
co-leader. This is where it started to degenerate into being
a stick in the mud. Rahne didn't really whine so much as
have a conflict of interests most of the time, and a big
dose of empathy.
* Sent from AltaVista http://www.altavista.com Where you can also find related Web Pages, Images, Audios, Videos, News, and Shopping. Smart is Beautiful
>>i think sean cassidy would have been a better choice or even
moira.
>
>Sean had a different philosophy back then. At the time, he was
very much
>against the whole concept of taking mutants in and training
them. Moira would
>have been possible, but I don't think she's much of a trainer.
>
moira might not be much of a trainer but the muties didnt need
much more training. they needed alittle guidance. she could
have been an adviser and the other X-men could have provided the
actual training that the others still needed. magneto just
didnt work for me.
>>it seems like the real trouble sarted inbetween issues 56 n
57. Right
>>after Amara left everyone changed drastically. Yana became a
brat,
>>rahn a whiner, dani a stick in the mud, sam was reduced to the
dumb
>>hick again, bobby the one dimentional macho punk. and warlock
>>went from childlike and inquizative to goofy jar-jaresque comic
>>releif.
>
>Most of these personalities were in the characters from day
one. Dani was
>always a stick in the mud; Rahne whined; Bobby had a chip on
his shoulder the
>size of Galactus' ship; as for Warlock, it was a normal
progression for the
>character and the main reason why most people adored him. I
don't remember Yana
>being a brat... at least not anymore than the whole lot of them
were brats.
>
i think people took to lock because he was an innocent and
learning about the things around him. kind of like the whole
team when they first began. turning him into comic releif wasnt
natural it changed him into a child basically.
just my point. the whole team became brats. like most "kids on
television today. Yana acted like she was on 24-7 PMS. instead
of the cold frightened girl who had to keep her darkside in
chech she became a bitchy teen ager throwing temper tantrums and
egging on trouble. she seemed to delight in causing trouble.
like all the team as they became more stereotypical they lost
their cultural uniqueness. all there mannerisms and actions
became indistinguishable. yana was only in the us for about a
year or two. she spent 7 in the ussr and another 7 in limbo but
towards the end she became the typical girl next door. it
diminished her in a way. as it did the entire team.
I meant original as in the original series.
>Well, we'll just have to see what devious plans Rob Liefeld has...
Don't hold your breath.
-Drew
"What do the Republicans have to do with cancer?"
"Nothing. They just go where the evil is."
- Duckman
True. But a comeback of the old characters doesn't mean they have to be the
same. Heck, I would LOVE IT if they finally matured and joined the X-Men. But I
don't know if editorial would go for something like that. Enough regression,
let X-Force be the anti-X-Men and let the other lost New Mutants (who didn't
join X-Force or left) join the X-Men. I would actually like that better. And if
the photo of Magik from Millenial Visions is what I think it is, and it backs
up my new Magik theory, then there may be something to that. But I refuse to
share it until I have more proof.
>i loved the new muties but i think that if you try to recapture
>the mood of the original series by bringing the team back
>together youll fail.
How about "New Mutants: the lost episodes" ? These would be stories
that will take place "back in the day. " Or, they could be "what if"
style alternate reality stories. Or, it could have something to do
with Limbo. Or... well, hell, writers are imaginative. They could come
up with something.
What do you think? would it fly?
Clay
Probably only as a mini. I would much rather have the lost characters pulled
from the shelves and used again myself.
Uh? I never saw that part (not that it is that surprising,
conisdering what happened to her before she became a New Mutant).
Could you explain it some more?
Well, if I remember correctly, there were five members at the
beginning. And one of five IS 20%. Now if you count all the
characters who were members atone time or another, of course...
> << xains a nice generation girl lezzie (cool), >>
>
>Uh? I never saw that part (not that it is that surprising,
>conisdering what happened to her before she became a New Mutant).
>Could you explain it some more?
>
>* Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet's Discussion Network *
>The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet - Free!
I just asked this question in the "Where are they now, thread." And,
as someone recommended, went out and bought X-Force 75 today. She
shows up at this big party/Lalapalooza thing in the dessert with a
couple of lesbian friends. She's been living in SoHo. There's a couple
of hints that she's also a lesbian but... as someone else suggested...
Marvel probably wouldn't let the writers come out and say that.
Clay
I totally agree with you. A new NEW MUTANTS series shouldn't try to regress
the status quo of the characters nor delve on the cool storylines of the
past. I think that if the original NM are to be reformed there should be a
reason for that. Like when Dazzler was forced to remain in the X-Men for her
own safety. If the NM were being hunted, the safest bet would be to stick
together. And so much has hapened in the characters lives that it would be
like they were strangers again, and had to reconquer each others trust and
friendship again. This would make for some very cool stories. Imagine Rahne,
who comes from a very
rigig catholic (or whatnot) background, learning of Xian's sexual
orientation.
What I wouldn't like to see is a revisit to Illyana's Darkchylde side. When
she returns I would like her to be just a mutant. Even if the demon
sorceress part was what captured my attention way back when, I hope she has
lost that part during inferno. Because if she comes back a demon sorceross
we all know that whenever they run out of stories to tell, they will invent
a limbo story to throw at us. IMHO Limbo has the potential of a
phoenix storywise, so it has to be dealt with carefully coz we all know how
that one turned out.
What I would like to see is anything in Asgard. Maybe even the rematch for
Asgardian Wars. Enchantress never had her revenge for being completely
humiliated and left in Limbo at S'yms mercy ;)
I'd really like Weezies to write the book and Bret Blevins or Bill
Sienkiewickzs(sp) to pencill it.
Ricardo
> True. But a comeback of the old characters doesn't mean they have to be the
> same. Heck, I would LOVE IT if they finally matured and joined the X-Men.
You seem to equate 'maturing' with 'joining the X-Men'.
The New Mutants are already mature. They don't *want* to join the
X-Men.
Is Nightwing any less mature because he isn't in the JLA?
--
----------------------------------------------------------------------
| -- Samy Merchi | sam...@mash.yok.utu.fi | http://mash.yok.utu.fi |
| Reader & fan of superhero comics; writer of superhero fanfiction |
| Female supremacist; anarchist; personal pacifist; mass darwinist |
----------------------------------------------------------------------
> What I want to know is if Rob Liefeld wants to do a New Mutans series so bad,
> then why is it when he was on New Mutants he changed to series into something
> completely different??
Because he likes creating his own characters.
You seem to be under the impression that Liefeld's proposed NEW
MUTANTS series would feature any estabilished New Mutants.
> Imagine Rahne,
>who comes from a very
>rigig catholic (or whatnot) background, learning of Xian's sexual
>orientation.
Not that it's of world shaking importance or anything, but I do
remember in one of the early issues of New Mutants, Rhane mentioning
that she couldn't find a "Scots Presbyterian" church in Salem Center.
And her guardian was Reverend Craig rather than Father Craig, so
apparently she was raised protestant as opposed to catholic.
Clay
Not that its likely to happen, but Not Blevins, please,
never Blevins.
UGH. Do I have to explain it again? What is so hard to understand? I said
original as in the ORIGINAL SERIES of the New Mutants. Not the new Liefeld one
from Wolverine, or anything X-Force related. Ok?
Ayup. She's Scot's presbyterian.
--
Johan Gustafsson *** e98...@efd.lth.se
Are you a bad enough dude to rescue the President?
As a Western Isles girl with a fundamentalist Christian upbringing, I'd
always assumed she was meant to be Wee Free. (The Free Presbyterian
Church of Scotland, a borderline lunatic fringe sect which is still
very strong in some remote parts of the country.)
>On 25 May 2000 06:14:13 GMT, goro...@aol.com (Gorok190) wrote:
>
>>>>
>>>>I meant original as in the original series.
>>>>
>>>
>>>Well, if I remember correctly, there were five members at the
>>>beginning. And one of five IS 20%. Now if you count all the
>>>characters who were members atone time or another, of course...
>>
>>UGH. Do I have to explain it again? What is so hard to understand? I said
>>original as in the ORIGINAL SERIES of the New Mutants. Not the new Liefeld one
>>from Wolverine, or anything X-Force related. Ok?
>
>Well, okay. Let's count members of the New Mutants, from the Graphic
>Novel to #100, then. There were 17. Meltdown and Cannonball make up
>11.8% of all these members.
>
Just cuz I'm too lazy to count myself - did you include Magneto? and
Kitty?
jame
>>>
>>>I meant original as in the original series.
>>>
>>
>>Well, if I remember correctly, there were five members at the
>>beginning. And one of five IS 20%. Now if you count all the
>>characters who were members atone time or another, of course...
>
>UGH. Do I have to explain it again? What is so hard to understand? I said
>original as in the ORIGINAL SERIES of the New Mutants. Not the new Liefeld one
>from Wolverine, or anything X-Force related. Ok?
Well, okay. Let's count members of the New Mutants, from the Graphic
Novel to #100, then. There were 17. Meltdown and Cannonball make up
11.8% of all these members.
Christian Henriksson
> >I hate to point it out to you, but Cannonball (Meltdown wasn't an
> >original New Mutant) represents exactly 20% of the original New
> >Mutants.
> I meant original as in the original series.
Yes, but some of us hold that the original series ended shortly after
issue #50, long before Tabby and those other posers showed up. :)
--
/* Soleil */
> Probably only as a mini.
But we already had that: The Truth or Death LS. It sure didn't fly.
--
/* Soleil */
I Wolfsbane, Warlock, Karma, Skids, and others who have never really progressed
past their New Mutants stages. Those who never joined X-Force, thus never took
any standing on the issues in their more mature years.
>They don't *want* to join the
>X-Men.
How do you know this? As I said before, 11.8% of the ex-New Mutants who say
they don't want to join the X-Men don't speak for the rest.
Probably because NOTHING flew about that time. I very much doubt that it had to
do with the content or concept, but 1997 wasn't the best of years for Marvel
titles period. I don't think any of their different concepts outside their main
books did well at all.
Ok, but that's still a very nominal amount.
OK, let's try to make this clear. My question was: are you
counting the founding members only, or the full roster. It was
already clear to me that the New Mutants and X-Force were
different series, thanks a lot.
And your reference to that "new Liefeld one from Wolverine" isn't
really clear to me, since a)I tend to remember the storyline more
than the name of the arstist/writer and b)if there were two New
Mutants series, the French edition might not have signaled it.
In any case, it was quite difficult for me to get my hands on
comics back then, and the New Mutants weren't my favourite
serie anyway, so I only know fragments of the storyline.
>> jonnyprime <jonnyprim...@hotmail.com.invalid> writes:
>>> yeah im pretty sure Rahne was not catholic.
>>
>>Ayup. She's Scot's presbyterian.
>
>As a Western Isles girl with a fundamentalist Christian upbringing, I'd
>always assumed she was meant to be Wee Free. (The Free Presbyterian
>Church of Scotland, a borderline lunatic fringe sect which is still
>very strong in some remote parts of the country.)
>
>Paul O'Brien
I was curious about Rhane's religious background for a number of
reasons and I appreciate you posting this information. I'm currently
sifting through some usenet posts and articles relating to this Free
Church of Scotland (FPCoS) you mention, and I may be wrong, but it
appears my sources are telling me that the "Wee Free's" are actually a
faction which broke away from the FPCoS in the last decade. Since
Rhane left Scotland in the early/mid eighties... then I guess that
means she's not a Wee Free? Perhaps she was a member of the FPCoS
before the split?
On the other hand, I might be misunderstanding this stuff. The
information regarding the various splits between factions is all quite
confusing.
Clay
Not long ago, the X-Force gang hooked up with Skids. She was making a
nice life for herself and going to college. She made it very clear
that she had no interest in superheroing. She wanted to be normal. I'm
not positive but I believe Karma had the same feelings when they
hooked up with her at that festival. Wolfsbane won't be going anywhere
until Moira is cured of the Legacy Virus. As for Warlock, I have no
idea.
> >They don't *want* to join the
> >X-Men.
>
> How do you know this? As I said before, 11.8% of the ex-New Mutants
who say
> they don't want to join the X-Men don't speak for the rest.
They'd have to come up with some damn good reasons to get some of
these ex-New Mutants to join up. I'd like to see a few pop up but I
really don't think you could get them all back together to start a
team.
--
Bruins72 (the poster formerly known as Bigbear)
There are various microfactions which splinter every so often.
They are all equally laughable and irrelevant to anyone with half a
brain.
We're talking here about a church which excommunicated one of their
prominent members for attending the funeral of his best friend,
simply because it was a Catholic service. They are a complete
waste of brain cells from top to bottom, and an embarrassment to
the nation. I don't follow their factional squabbles pretty closely
because none of them have any opinions worth listening to.
>On Fri, 26 May 2000 00:48:16 +0200, Orange <ora...@hem.passagen.se>
>wrote:
>>Well, okay. Let's count members of the New Mutants, from the Graphic
>>Novel to #100, then. There were 17. Meltdown and Cannonball make up
>>11.8% of all these members.
>>
>Just cuz I'm too lazy to count myself - did you include Magneto? and
>Kitty?
Kitty was never really a member. Magneto, Cable and Professor X were
all excluded - they didn't fit the gang that Drew seemed to be talking
about.
Cannonball
Sunspot
Karma
Mirage
Wolfsbane
Magma
Magik
Cypher
Warlock
Rusty
Skids
Boom Boom
Rictor
"Domino" (I should have excluded her too, but I forgot)
Warpath
Feral
Shatterstar
these four never actually joined the muties. they were
introduced at the end of the run but they joined xforce only
Rusty
Skids
Boom Boom
Rictor
they werent official new muties either. they were the
exterminators. when they hooked up wtih the team the muties
were on the run and they all came together on the xfactor ship.
when cable took over they all were together but since he totally
changed the team from what they were i dont like calling them
the new mutants. they were xforce just not named. they were all
peers but not part of the team.
all of these later additions were hanging with the team while
the transition was going on
Agree with you there. And even so, Domino was never part of the team as that
was Copycat.
> Rusty
> Skids
> Boom Boom
> Rictor
>
> they werent official new muties either. they were the
> exterminators. when they hooked up wtih the team the muties
> were on the run and they all came together on the xfactor ship.
> when cable took over they all were together but since he totally
> changed the team from what they were i dont like calling them
> the new mutants. they were xforce just not named. they were all
> peers but not part of the team.
> all of these later additions were hanging with the team while
> the transition was going on
Dont agree with you there. OK, Skids and Rusty were never around, but Rictor
and Boom Boom were definitely part of the team. They went to Asgard with the
team, and behaved like one, rather than two. And Cable only changed the team
really when say, Wolfsbane and Rictor left.
MPierce
> I Wolfsbane, Warlock, Karma, Skids, and others who have never really progressed
> past their New Mutants stages. Those who never joined X-Force, thus never took
> any standing on the issues in their more mature years.
Wolfsbane has been a flipping *government agent*. Never progressed
beyond her NM stage? Whuh??
Can't comment on Warlock, but wouldn't be surprised to find out that
he was more mature in his solo series than during his NM days.
Karma was more mature in her first appearance than 90% of X-Men are
today. There is utterly no claim whatsoever you can make about Xi'an
being *immature*.
Skids wants to be left alone so she can go to college, which is a hell
of a lot more mature decision than parading around in skintight
materials with an isolated clique.
>>They don't *want* to join the X-Men.
> How do you know this? As I said before, 11.8% of the ex-New Mutants who say
> they don't want to join the X-Men don't speak for the rest.
If they wanted, don't you think they would've, I dunno, *showed up at
the X-Mansion* and said, "Hi, I'd like to join."
>
>jonnyprime <jonnyprim...@hotmail.com.invalid> wrote in message
>news:02ad0668...@usw-ex0103-086.remarq.com...
>>
>> >"Domino" (I should have excluded her too, but I forgot)
>> >Warpath
>> >Feral
>> >Shatterstar
>> >
>> Domino
>> Warpath
>> Feral
>> Shatterstar
>>
>> these four never actually joined the muties. they were
>> introduced at the end of the run but they joined xforce only
>
>Agree with you there.
I know, but Marvel themselves count these four as New Mutants.
>And even so, Domino was never part of the team as that
>was Copycat.
Do note my quotation marks.
Yeah, yeah I know. But the original poster was talking about what percentage
Cannonball made up of the new mutants. And jonnyprime and I were saying how
you cant count all the members as equal. They may be member.... but how many
were Members. You c?
MPierce
>
>Orange <ora...@hem.passagen.se> wrote in message
>news:eod0jskfngf9ighk5...@4ax.com...
>> On Sat, 27 May 2000 14:19:30 +0100, "Michael Pierce"
>> <mpi...@freenetname.co.uk> wrote:
>>
>> >
>> >jonnyprime <jonnyprim...@hotmail.com.invalid> wrote in message
>> >news:02ad0668...@usw-ex0103-086.remarq.com...
>> >> these four never actually joined the muties. they were
>> >> introduced at the end of the run but they joined xforce only
>> >
>> >Agree with you there.
>>
>> I know, but Marvel themselves count these four as New Mutants.
>>
>Yeah, yeah I know. But the original poster was talking about what percentage
>Cannonball made up of the new mutants. And jonnyprime and I were saying how
>you cant count all the members as equal. They may be member.... but how many
>were Members. You c?
Oh yeah. But you gotta draw the line somewhere, and mine was a bit
more inclusive. That's all.
No, cos Boomer was captured along with Sam, Firestar, Magma, Dani and Karma.
She may have just been in the wrong place, at the wrong time, cos she was
swimming with Cannonball, but she was still taken.
> the only
> ones i consider real new muties were the ones who wore the ol'
> black and yellow. the others are just wannabes. once the team
> got out of the training uniforms they werent in training any
> more. they graduated.
I think it is all about what the characters perceived. In X-Force #25,
Exodus comes to tell the team that Magneto will let his former students, the
New Mutants, on to Avalon. Exodus tells just Sunspot and Cannonball to come,
but Sam says that if the offer is open to all New Mutants, that means Rictor
and Boomer aswell.
As Cable, Feral, Shatterstar and Warpath were all there, this kinda shows
what is considered to be a New Mutant.
MPierce
Gosamyr was never considered a NewMutant
Bird Brain was atleast given a uniform
And Rictor and Boom Boom came way before Cable, and WERE New Mutants.
Do you not consider Cable, Dr Reyes, Maggott, Marrow, Psylocke, Dazzler,
Longshot and Thunderbird III X-Men, because they werent inducted by
Professor X?
Wolfsbane and Colossus werent members of Excalibur because they came to the
team only a few years before the cancellation?
I see your point that you might see their place on the team as coincidence,
but Rictor and Boom Boom's membership is different than say Trish Tilby's on
X-Men.
MPierce
>marvel may consider them all new muties but after a while you
>learn to not take everything marvels says as truth. if it doesnt
>fit their current plans theyll screw a once established fact
>into the ground and just make up a new explaniation. the whole
>amara nova roma thing is a good example. the way i see it the
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
>new mutant were a team of students learning at xaviers
<snipped rest>
Exactly. The way you see it. I don't question your view - in fact, I
more or less agree with it.
>I think it is all about what the characters perceived. In X-Force #25,
>Exodus comes to tell the team that Magneto will let his former students, the
>New Mutants, on to Avalon. Exodus tells just Sunspot and Cannonball to come,
>but Sam says that if the offer is open to all New Mutants, that means Rictor
>and Boomer aswell.
>
>As Cable, Feral, Shatterstar and Warpath were all there, this kinda shows
>what is considered to be a New Mutant.
Good example. I didn't remember that one, but of course you're right.
Well, at least it shows what the writer (that'd be Fabe, right?)
thought about who belonged in the NM.
yhe difference between the New mutants and the other teams were
they were a training group. they were in training at xaviers
for the purpose of learnig how to use their powes and after a
while uphold the ideals of xavier. the other teams had their
own agendas and and the members who joined their teams joined to
try and get those agendas met. excalibur wasnt set up by
xavier. they began to keep the "dream alive, then when the
other x-folks ame back they changed their mission to be
doogoders basically, the x-men are supposed to promate peaceful
coexistence between mutants and humans and combat evil mutants
that try to get in the way of that,policing other mutants, X-
force was supposed to actively seek out threats to the peace
and deal with them. the new mutants were students. if they were
still in existence at the time maggot and reyes should have been
put with them because they didnt have any practical fighting
experience or great control over their power. when psylock first
came to the mansion she had doubts if she should be an xman or
with the training group the new mutants. storm told her that she
belonged with the xmen because she was a warrior. i think that
dazzler should have been a new mutant. she needed more
training. the new mutants were supposedly a non combatant group.
in issue 76 cyclops said "x-factor was hoping to find the New
Mutants and invite them to join us...here on ship...
permenantly". probably with the hopes of continuing with xaviers
original intent. to teach. they were doing it with the
exterminators. when the xternminators first started to come
together they should have become the "new" new mutants and the
real new mutants should have became some thing more (x-force) so
the two groups intergrated. if you have to call them all new
mutants then the add ons were part of a version 2. like the all
new alll different X-Men. a completely new group. plus they
were hardly there before they got off to asgard, then x-factor
went into space. cable came and for his own agenda became their
leader. by the time all of this came about the new mutants as a
group were in name only. these people were x-force in
training, they just didnt have anything else to call themselves.
so while they were new mutants the real muties that made the
book what it was were gone. like the doomed youthful JLA of the
80's. they were the JLA but not the real JLA- and they were
punished for it. and as for tilby. she was a friend and ally but
thats it. boom-boom and rictor were more that that. they were
part of the team. i just dont consider that group the new
mutants proper, maybe the in between NM
Hee hee, I worked for a few years in stunts, so wearing skintight materials in
an isolated clique helped me pay for college. :D
--
So here I am, a male in the 00's where the women's movement has said that women
should have as much sex as they want, just like the men. Where they can be as
heartless, cruel, a player, a user ... just like men. Horray for progress.
[Jameson Stalanthas Yu, Shade and Sweet Water, mes amis and Edgerunners]
[Link at http://www-rcf.usc.edu/~jamesony -X- ICQ 10208399]
[Mutatis mutandis, strive to be humane, not human]
> wearing skintight materials in an isolated clique helped me pay
> for college.
Combined with your name of the day above, I'm not sure I wanted to
know that... ;)
I'm not so sure that I agree with this. Was fighting in Vietnam any less mature
than going to college? What about the Persian Gulf War? WWII? X-Men and X-Force
(just as Excalibur and X-Factor before them) are fighting a war that needs to
be fought (no, I'm not saying either of these wars needed to be fought --
that's too political of a topic for this newsgroup).
-=[ The BlakGard ]=-
"Somewhere there's danger;
somewhere there's injustice,
and somewhere else the tea is getting cold!"
> I'm not so sure that I agree with this. Was fighting in Vietnam any less mature
> than going to college? What about the Persian Gulf War? WWII? X-Men and X-Force
> (just as Excalibur and X-Factor before them) are fighting a war that needs to
> be fought
And making zero difference the way they go about it. If she wants to
fight the war, she should out herself as a mutant, educate herself
into a politician, and go up against Kelly in his own battlefield or
something.
The only thing the X-Men et al. have had any difference on is saving
the world. Now, admirable goal and all, but there are literally
hundreds, probably thousands of superheroes already out there.
Skids should go to college, get an education, ensure a livelihood for
herself, *then* if she wanted to, participate in either the war you
suggest by being a public and possibly politically active mutant, or
participate in the war against super-villains, which really isn't
going to have its result decided by the presence or absence of one
person.
"Ya gotta do, what ya gotta do." Futurama. :D
> i think its way mature that shes tried to become a whole person not just "skids"- the
> mutant.
Totally agree with you. By the way, what's her real name anyway. I keep thinking
Marie Blevins, but I think that' an inker or editor or something.
--
"The gun came up and accidentally shot itself." This is what Nathaniel Brazil
said
on a Ch 7 news interview this morning, 6/1. Goshfreakindangnabit!!!!! Of course
the kid-idiot didn't understand what happened if the dad-idiot thinks like this.
Sally Blevins
and if anyone's asking, it was Russell Collins for Rusty.
MPierce
Skids' real name is Sally Blevins I believe. The inker you're thinking
of is Marie Javins.
--Cypher, keeper of the Doug Ramsey flame
>Michael Pierce <mpi...@freenetname.co.uk> wrote in message
>news:8h6e87$coq$2...@gxsn.com...
>> idiots tout autour de moi de Designers <jame...@usc.edu> wrote in message
>> news:3936A0C3...@usc.edu...
>> > jonnyprime wrote:
>> > > people gotta do what they gotta do to ensure their own growth and sanity.
>> > "Ya gotta do, what ya gotta do." Futurama. :D
>> > > i think its way mature that shes tried to become a whole person not just "skids"- the
>> > > mutant.
>> > Totally agree with you. By the way, what's her real name anyway. I keep thinking
>> > Marie Blevins, but I think that' an inker or editor or something.
>> Sally Blevins
>> and if anyone's asking, it was Russell Collins for Rusty.
>Poor Rusty. Yet another senseless Mutie death. It's pretty amazing that
>the X-Men have had 1 fatality (Thunderbird, 2 with Phoenix) while the New
>Mutants have had 4 (Cypher, Warlock, Magik, Rusty).
Well, it does show up the point that the X-Men are "professionals"
while the New Mutants were just learning the ropes.
Much like the deaths of the Hellions (much as I hated it) showed how
dangerous the world was for kid mutants and how mutants had become
commoditised (as CC always apparently intended).
i think that for the x-peoples existence to be justifiable the
world has to be a dangerous place for mutants and that hasnt
been accurately shown. the death of the hellions was a waste
and horrid but it was a mutant on mutant crime and a mutant from
the future at that. it happened in a hidden location and if the
bodies were retreived pubically i doubt that the real reason of
what happened was told. it didnt affect the Real world at all. i
think that the real world of drugs and urban violence for
flatscans is more scary and dangerous than the anti mutant
setiment is for mutants. if the xmen are taking on this darker
attitude then there should be a reason for it. mutant lynchings
in the streets. anti mutant hate groups burning buildings and
promoting hate, actual hunting of mutants. this stuff is
supposedly going on but its hardly ever shown. and when it is
its done to exclamate a point then forgotten while the heroes
fight villans. with all the extremist mutant groups popping up
youd think therd be more visual details to make these
disgrunteled mutants more believable. you dont go out and join
a group thats considered outlaw without a good reason. show me
more fear and mistrust. make life a little more unbearable for
these people. and let it creep all through out the marvel
universe. the ff has mutants in its stable as do the avengers
and the warriors. the climate of hate and fear seems almost non
existent save for a few references from the mutants on how the
world hates them and how bad it is. the couple of pages in God
loves man kills? graphic novel that had kitty kicking the crap
outta the kid in stevies dance class was great. it showed real
reality based fear and bigotry.
well, thats not strictly true. If you are counting Rusty as a New Mutants,
then surely Revanche, Changeling and Joseph can all be counted too. So
that's actually 5 X-Men down.
None of those came back, whilst Warlock sorta has, and Magik probably will.
MPierce
True. Also, Magik didn't "die" (if she's dead, at all) while she was a New
Mutant either.
* Sent from AltaVista http://www.altavista.com Where you can also find related Web Pages, Images, Audios, Videos, News, and Shopping. Smart is Beautiful
As far as Warlock coming back to life, bite your tongue! That Douglock
thing is
not 'Lock, no matter how hard they tried to make him be.
--Cypher
PEACE
j
Then you didn't read WARLOCK, did you, I take it? Louise Simonson
basically picked up on all the little clues (including those she left)
that Doug was already on his way to become a techno-organic being by the
time of his death. In EXCALIBUR, when introduced (something Warren Ellis
ignored and Raab only got to at the end) Douglock is told that he is the
result of an amalgamation of the two without the memories. Once those
memories are restored, in WARLOCK, he's back to the same.
And with a new Illyana coming in September, the New Mutants have only lost
Rusty from their entire past rosters (and yes, at one point he is called a
mutie -- the Asgard period, if my memory serves me correctly). They've
also been betrayed once by Feral as a member of X-Force.
In contrast, the X-Men are doing much worse: they lost Changeling,
Thunderbird, Phoenix, Revanche and Joseph plus got tricked by Sabretooth.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Brian Fried bfr...@chat.carleton.ca Carleton U., Ottawa, Canada
----------------------------------------------------------------------
"What do you say? Will the human race be run in a day?
Or will someone save this planet we're playing on?"
Paul McCartney, 'Pipes Of Peace', 1983
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Nope. Defeated the Vulture. Thats about it.
> That being said, Revanche doesn't count at all,
Why not? Just cos everyone else forgets her?
> Changeling
> shouldn't count (much like I don't really count Xavier as an X-Man),
I know what you mean about Changeling, but he does count if you include
Professor X, and you dont so I see where you are coming from.
> but you
> definitely got me on (ugh) Joseph. Can't we just forget about him?
> Besides, if
> you noticed the pattern, the X-Men only killed people that just arrived
> (T-Bird)
> or were copies of a real member (Phoenix, Revance, Changeling, Joseph).
The
> NMs actually killed real, core members. Not that any of their deaths were
> well
> written ...
Yes, I agree with you there. However, I thought Illyana's and Cypher's
deaths were both written well.
> As far as Warlock coming back to life, bite your tongue! That Douglock
> thing is
> not 'Lock, no matter how hard they tried to make him be.
Oh dear. A disbeliever.
Yes, Warlock is Warlock. He is different from Douglock as now he has Dougs
memories.
MPierce
X-Force #56, IIRC. It was Warpath and Risque who came to the rescue.
MPierce
No. Youre thinking of the one where Rogue and Kitty (I think) save this
person from being attacked by this gang, thinking that the victim was a
mutant. However, he was a mutant hater, and the people attacking him were
pro-mutant.
It was a well thought out problem to the X-Men.
MPierce
It was UXM #196 and it was Rogue and Kitty. Very well written and
Rogue's comment later about not having stopped to help if they'd known
what the guy had been writing on the wall was both good
characterisation and good dialogue (from CC? Heaven forbid!).
Urggle ... I meant "... it was Rogue and Rachel."
> And with a new Illyana coming in September, the New Mutants have only lost
> Rusty from their entire past rosters (and yes, at one point he is called a
> mutie -- the Asgard period, if my memory serves me correctly). They've
> also been betrayed once by Feral as a member of X-Force.
>
Please elaborate on the new Magik. Even if this Warlock is the real thing,
he's not
Doug, so Cypher's still dead. Illyana is, at the moment, still (presumed)
dead.
> In contrast, the X-Men are doing much worse: they lost Changeling,
> Thunderbird, Phoenix, Revanche and Joseph plus got tricked by Sabretooth.
>
Changeling only counts if you count Prof. X (I don't). T-bird does.
Phoenix is
iffy (not a real person?, essence claimed by Rachel IIRC). Revanche was
never
a member of the X-Men, she tagged along with them very briefly. Joseph does
count, although I'm trying to forget him :) Did you miss my point on how
all the
X-Men characters were merely expendable copies of the real thing (Changeling
= Prof. X, Phoenix = Phoenix :), Revanche = Psylocke, Joseph = Magneto).
Some would even argue that, at the time, T-Bird was a copy of Wolverine.
--Cypher
> > That being said, Revanche doesn't count at all,
>
> Why not? Just cos everyone else forgets her?
>
Because she wasn't an X-Man. She stayed with them for a hot minute.
Show me where they call her a member. Maybe I just can't remember.
> > As far as Warlock coming back to life, bite your tongue! That Douglock
> > thing is
> > not 'Lock, no matter how hard they tried to make him be.
>
> Oh dear. A disbeliever.
> Yes, Warlock is Warlock. He is different from Douglock as now he has Dougs
> memories.
>
Granted, I didn't read Warlock, but does this "Warlock" have Warlock's
memories
as well? Does he say "self-friend"? Does Betsy know about this? What
about Sam,
Dani, and Bobby? I think Magnus would be very interested in speaking with
him, as
he was pretty hurt by Doug's death (and that part was also very well
written). On
second thought, maybe Doug's death was well written after all. I will
always question
the motivation, though.
--Cypher
Well the X-Men Alumni counts her. And she was on many missions.
> Granted, I didn't read Warlock, but does this "Warlock" have Warlock's
> memories
> as well? Does he say "self-friend"? Does Betsy know about this? What
> about Sam,
> Dani, and Bobby? I think Magnus would be very interested in speaking with
> him, as
> he was pretty hurt by Doug's death (and that part was also very well
> written). On
> second thought, maybe Doug's death was well written after all. I will
> always question
> the motivation, though.
So far Wolfsbane and Kitty have met Warlock, aswell as Magus.
And I suggest you buy it, if you are that big a fan of Warlock. It ended
quite short so its only 9 issues.
MPierce
Warlock had already been merging with Cypher too much by the time of
Cypher's death in THE NEW MUTANTS. This is clearly shown.
After Warlock was killed, Rahne sprinkled his ashes over Doug's.
Now, IIRC, when the Phalanx came to take the biological residue, it
reanimated all of the material there, Doug's and Warlock's. This explains
why Douglock had Warlock's species but Doug Ramsey's appearance.
However, when Kitty pressed Douglock, Douglock denied having Doug's memories.
Douglock was destroyed when he tried to access the implanted knowledge of
Legacy's cure in EXCALIBUR.
In "Rage Against The Machine," Douglock reasserts himself as Warlock,
merger of Doug and Warlock.
And yes, he was worried about the Magus. In Issue 9, the series' finale,
the two fought.
> Please elaborate on the new Magik. Even if this Warlock is the real thing,
> he's not Doug, so Cypher's still dead. Illyana is, at the moment, still (presumed)
> dead.
In September, "Black Sun" will be the event at Marvel. Set in Limbo
against Belasco, Polaris, Colossus, Storm, Wolverine, Shadowcat and
Nightcrawler will battle themselves over Illyana.
Now, according to reports in COMICS INTERNATIONAL, it looks like a new
teenage Illyana, not the original, will be coming out of this. As a result,
apparently, should the new DR. STRANGE mini-series being planned at Marvel
Knights not pan out, he may have a role in an upcoming MAGIK book.
> Douglock had Warlock's species
No. Douglock was a Phalanx. Warlock was a Technarch.
In article <39129bc0....@news.demon.co.uk>, Christian
Smith
<chri...@jasdigital.com> writes
Can someone quickly explain (I'm sure it has been covered
elsewhere on the group) what the link between this Warlock, the
original "Selfriends" Warlock, Doug Ramsey and Douglock is? Are
they all the same, different? How to the Phalanx come into it?
It's the original Warlock, with copied parts of Cypher's
personality added. But at the end of the day, it's Warlock.
The Phalanx... in an attempt to explain away the horrible mess
of past continuity here and reconcile the nineties Phalanx with
the eighties Technarch, Louise Simonson has retconned the
Phalanx by basically redefining them as anything infected by the
transmode virus and not consumed for food by the Technarch. The
Technarch regard the Phalanx as abominations. The Phalanx THINK
that they're on the same side as the Technarch and are
programmed to try and contact the Technarch for help. In fact,
this is a device to let the Technarch find and eradicate them.
(That was the point of the tower they were building in the
Phalanx Covenant.)
Warlock isn't a Phalanx, he's a Technarch. But having been
brought back from the dead as part of a Phalanx collective, he's
now regarded by his people as tainted.
Paul O'Brien
>Now, according to reports in COMICS INTERNATIONAL, it looks like a new
>teenage Illyana, not the original, will be coming out of this. As a result,
>apparently, should the new DR. STRANGE mini-series being planned at Marvel
>Knights not pan out, he may have a role in an upcoming MAGIK book.
Hmmm ... wouldn't it be cool (but unworkable, I guess, given we know
what happens later) if these X-Men become the alternate X-Men we saw
in UXM #160?
They're both the same character. Warlock was a Technarch who was
revived from the dead as part of a Phalanx collective. Since the
Technarch view the Phalanx as abominations, Warlock is now effectively
an outcast from his own race, who view him as contaminated - although
it's not like he was planning to go back there anyway.
This is all in the recent Warlock series, honestly.
Paul O'Brien
THE X-AXIS REVIEWS - http://www.esoterica.demon.co.uk
Flowers: the practical alternative to capitalism, apparently.