�jevind
1. Is it mentioned in LOTR? (Whether in a correct or incorrect edition
doesn't matter for the moment.)
Yes.
> OK - animal kingdom again.
> 1. Is it mentioned in LOTR? (Whether in a correct or incorrect edition
> doesn't matter for the moment.)
> Yes.
2. One or more living creatures?
Korppi.
> > OK - animal kingdom again.
> > 1. Is it mentioned in LOTR? (Whether in a correct or incorrect edition
> > doesn't matter for the moment.)
> > Yes.
>
> 2. One or more living creatures?
One.
Öjevind
> OK - animal kingdom again.
> 1. Is it mentioned in LOTR? (Whether in a correct or incorrect edition
> doesn't matter for the moment.)
> Yes.
> 2. One or more living creatures?
> One.
3. Speaking creature?
Br�n.
> > OK - animal kingdom again.
> > 1. Is it mentioned in LOTR? (Whether in a correct or incorrect edition
> > doesn't matter for the moment.)
> > Yes.
> > 2. One or more living creatures?
> > One.
>
> 3. Speaking creature?
Yes.
Öjevind
4. Does it have two legs (for walking)?
> > > > OK - animal kingdom again.
> > > > 1. Is it mentioned in LOTR? (Whether in a correct or incorrect edition
> > > > doesn't matter for the moment.)
> > > > Yes.
> > > > 2. One or more living creatures?
> > > > One.
> > > 3. Speaking creature?
> > Yes.
>
> 4. Does it have two legs (for walking)?
Yes.
Öjevind
does it sing?
--
tamf
(trying to be a little original)
> >>>>> OK - animal kingdom again.
> >>>>> 1. Is it mentioned in LOTR? (Whether in a correct or incorrect edition
> >>>>> doesn't matter for the moment.)
> >>>>> Yes.
> >>>>> 2. One or more living creatures?
> >>>>> One.
> >>>> 3. Speaking creature?
> >>> Yes.
> >> 4. Does it have two legs (for walking)?
> > Yes.
>
> 5. does it sing?
I think so.
Öjevind
6. Does it travel a lot during LotR (let's say more than Saruman or
Tom Bombadil)?
> > > >>>>> OK - animal kingdom again.
> > > >>>>> 1. Is it mentioned in LOTR? (Whether in a correct or incorrect edition
> > > >>>>> doesn't matter for the moment.)
> > > >>>>> Yes.
> > > >>>>> 2. One or more living creatures?
> > > >>>>> One.
> > > >>>> 3. Speaking creature?
> > > >>> Yes.
> > > >> 4. Does it have two legs (for walking)?
> > > > Yes.
> > > 5. does it sing?
> > I think so.
>
> 6. Does it travel a lot during LotR (let's say more than Saruman or
> Tom Bombadil)?
No.
Öjevind
> OK - animal kingdom again.
> 1. Is it mentioned in LOTR? (Whether in a correct or incorrect edition
> doesn't matter for the moment.)
> Yes.
> 2. One or more living creatures?
> One.
> 3. Speaking creature?
> Yes.
> 4. Does it have two legs (for walking)?
> Yes.
> 5. does it sing?
> I think so.
> 6. Does it travel a lot during LotR (let's say more than Saruman or
> Tom Bombadil)?
> No.
7. Is it among the Second-born of Il�vatar?
Cr�
> > OK - animal kingdom again.
> > 1. Is it mentioned in LOTR? (Whether in a correct or incorrect edition
> > doesn't matter for the moment.)
> > Yes.
> > 2. One or more living creatures?
> > One.
> > 3. Speaking creature?
> > Yes.
> > 4. Does it have two legs (for walking)?
> > Yes.
> > 5. does it sing?
> > I think so.
> > 6. Does it travel a lot during LotR (let's say more than Saruman or
> > Tom Bombadil)?
> > No.
>
> 7. Is it among the Second-born of Il vatar?
Yes.
Öjevind
> OK - animal kingdom again.
> 1. Is it mentioned in LOTR? (Whether in a correct or incorrect edition
> doesn't matter for the moment.)
> Yes.
> 2. One or more living creatures?
> One.
> 3. Speaking creature?
> Yes.
> 4. Does it have two legs (for walking)?
> Yes.
> 5. does it sing?
> I think so.
> 6. Does it travel a lot during LotR (let's say more than Saruman or
> Tom Bombadil)?
> No.
> 7. Is it among the Second-born of Il vatar?
> Yes.
8. Is it on the good side?
Marghvran.
> > OK - animal kingdom again.
> > 1. Is it mentioned in LOTR? (Whether in a correct or incorrect edition
> > doesn't matter for the moment.)
> > Yes.
> > 2. One or more living creatures?
> > One.
> > 3. Speaking creature?
> > Yes.
> > 4. Does it have two legs (for walking)?
> > Yes.
> > 5. does it sing?
> > I think so.
> > 6. Does it travel a lot during LotR (let's say more than Saruman or
> > Tom Bombadil)?
> > No.
> > 7. Is it among the Second-born of Il vatar?
> > Yes.
>
> 8. Is it on the good side?
Yes.
Öjevind
> OK - animal kingdom again.
> 1. Is it mentioned in LOTR? (Whether in a correct or incorrect edition
> doesn't matter for the moment.)
> Yes.
> 2. One or more living creatures?
> One.
> 3. Speaking creature?
> Yes.
> 4. Does it have two legs (for walking)?
> Yes.
> 5. does it sing?
> I think so.
> 6. Does it travel a lot during LotR (let's say more than Saruman or
> Tom Bombadil)?
> No.
> 7. Is it among the Second-born of Il vatar?
> Yes.
> 8. Is it on the good side?
> Yes.
9. Male?
Corb.
> > > > OK - animal kingdom again.
> > > > 1. Is it mentioned in LOTR? (Whether in a correct or incorrect edition
> > > > doesn't matter for the moment.)
> > > > Yes.
> > > > 2. One or more living creatures?
> > > > One.
> > > > 3. Speaking creature?
> > > > Yes.
> > > > 4. Does it have two legs (for walking)?
> > > > Yes.
> > > > 5. does it sing?
> > > > I think so.
> > > > 6. Does it travel a lot during LotR (let's say more than Saruman or
> > > > Tom Bombadil)?
> > > > No.
> > > > 7. Is it among the Second-born of Il vatar?
> > > > Yes.
> > > 8. Is it on the good side?
> > Yes.
(Raven asked:) 9. Male?
No.
10.. Would we find it in the Shire?
No
Öjevind
> OK - animal kingdom again.
> 1. Is it mentioned in LOTR? (Whether in a correct or incorrect edition
> doesn't matter for the moment.)
> Yes.
> 2. One or more living creatures?
> One.
> 3. Speaking creature?
> Yes.
> 4. Does it have two legs (for walking)?
> Yes.
> 5. does it sing?
> I think so.
> 6. Does it travel a lot during LotR (let's say more than Saruman or
> Tom Bombadil)?
> No.
> 7. Is it among the Second-born of Il vatar?
> Yes.
> 8. Is it on the good side?
> Yes.
> 9. Male?
> No.
> 10.. Would we find it in the Shire?
> No
11. Was she alive on the day that the Ring was destroyed?
Voron.
> > OK - animal kingdom again.
> > 1. Is it mentioned in LOTR? (Whether in a correct or incorrect edition
> > doesn't matter for the moment.)
> > Yes.
> > 2. One or more living creatures?
> > One.
> > 3. Speaking creature?
> > Yes.
> > 4. Does it have two legs (for walking)?
> > Yes.
> > 5. does it sing?
> > I think so.
> > 6. Does it travel a lot during LotR (let's say more than Saruman or
> > Tom Bombadil)?
> > No.
> > 7. Is it among the Second-born of Iluvatar?
> > Yes.
> > 8. Is it on the good side?
> > Yes.
> > 9. Male?
> > No.
> > 10.. Would we find it in the Shire?
> > No
>
> 11. Was she alive on the day that the Ring was destroyed?
Yes.
Öjevind
12. Was she a Gondorian?
Hr�fn.
Yes.
Öjevind
> > Yes.
12. Was she a Gondorian?
Yes.
13. Might she be Ioreth?
Yes! We have a winner! Over to you.
Öjevind
[snip]
>> Yes! We have a winner! Over to you.
>>
>> �jevind
>
> This time I tried a shot in the dark, instead of slowly approaching
> her ("Was she concerned with other people's health?" or "Was she
> talkative?"). There simply aren't too many women in LotR, and Ioreth
> is kind of memorable.
> I actually sent my posting before I saw Raven's question "Gondorian?"
Yes, once you had nailed down her sex it was easy going. The interesting
thing is how soon the question about her sex was asked. Meaning no
disrespect, the people here are most accomplished snuffflers.
�jevind