On Thu, 24 Jan 2013, Carter wrote:
> On 1/24/2013 1:53 PM, Michael A. Terrell wrote:
>
>> 2 Mhz is easier to shield than a lower frequency. You guys seem to
>> forget that I worked with RF for decades, where every leak had to be
>> found & fixed. Why do you think they invented copper tape with
>> conductive glue & feedthrough caps? :-)
>
> If you are building just one, no problem with the tape and caps, but if you
> are building several for sale, it sounds a little labor intensive.
>
Design is about overall results. Maybe it requires more effort, but maybe
it cuts things down in another area.
> Also, FWIW, it's not necessarily the trivial case to tame the RFI. Every time
> QST has done a review of switching power supplies, RFI across the HF spectrum
> has been a major consideration.
>
But they are lower in frequency, aren't they? A lot more harmonics, and
requring bigger filter coils to get the output clean.
I remember one review mentioned the switching supply could operate at 2
frequencies, which is an interesting thing. So if you are really bugged
by the signal, switch to the other frequency and hopefully it won't have a
harmonic on that frequency you are receiving. Actually kind of like those
"beat" switches on boomboxes and such, which are supposed to change the
bias oscillator in the tape deck in case a harmonic interferes with the
station you are listening to.
The reality is a lot of switching supplies don't really ahve much
shielding. In the early days when you'd start to see them in electronic
equipment, they'd be in their own shielding. Early VCRs that used them
had the power supply as a separate metal encased module, just like in
computers. But, look at more recent VCRs and the switching supply is
built on the main circuit board, the limits on radiated noise completely
depending on whether they really shield the plastic box of the vcr or not.
Or that LED desklamp I got at Ikea last year. It's great, I dumped a
bumch of halogen lamps for the LED lamps. But, the switching supply is
nice and small, and in a plastic box. I wouldn't expect it to be quiet
without any real shielding (and other switching AC adapters certainly seem
lacking in metal shielding).
In both cases, it's not that a lot of finicky work is needed, it's that
nobody bothered in the first place.
Michael