I used some honey Brooks leather tape to wrap the B115 bars on my Roadeo, and then removed it and used it to wrap the B135 bars on my Riv Road.
Now, the tape got used less than 100 miles on my Roadeo, so it's not like it was "worn in" or "worn out". The tape got a bit stretched around the brake levers, but it was able to re-stretch into place on the ever-so-slightly-different levers and bars on my Riv Road.
I've since re-done my Roadeo with another set of B135 bars (which came off my KOM, now with Jones Loops), and now the Roadeo is wearing Brooks synthetic leather. I probably only have 200 miles on this tape, so I can't speak to its longevity. It feels good, somewhere between Fizik or Deda synthetic and Brooks leather.
I also picked up some black Brooks leather tape for my cyclocross bike. That bike is currently wearing Lizardskins DSP tape, which has excellent grip (and is re-wrappable), but has terrible durability. The ramps have worn through down to the foam (like Steve P's scavengers). This is at about 1500 miles:

My friend had this same thing happen to his Lizardskins tape within 3 cyclocross races (no crashes, just wear).