I am gonna start with the good news: Matthew Williams' post on this forum about a 59 Clem Smith Jr on Craigslist Indianapolis helped me get a replacement bike within a week (green H-frame Clem). Yay! Thank you, Matthew and thank you, Josh in IN.
Sharing the below details in case someone comes across my stolen bike:
L-Style Clem Smith Jr., 59 cm, gray/silver frame (Serial A0A32CG0377) with mostly silver polished components: Jones H-Loop bar, Paul Love Letter levers, Crust/Nitto stem, White Industries crankset, Chromag Scarab pedals, Eno SS Hub, SON dynamo hub, Edelux headlight, Honjo fenders, Rene Herse front rack. Black components: Velocity Cliffhanger rims, Panaracer Gravel King tires, Yepp rear rack, Brooks B67.
Taken from my home in Brooklyn, NY, November 18, 2020.
Two different Clems but both so fun!