Nothing But The Truth Test Pdf

0 views
Skip to first unread message

Mahmod Ohner

unread,
Aug 5, 2024, 9:39:57 AM8/5/24
to ransbrazobjoi
Nothingseemed to get rid of the headache though and it was a bit annoying. This went on for two weeks then suddenly the headache went. I felt a bit under the weather but nothing that I took seriously.

My whole family had to go through tests for TB. The children had a TB vaccine. When I left hospital, I had lost three and a half stone in weight and I suffered muscle wastage. I was very weak and awfully tired. I went back into hospital four more times for a week at a time.


I came to the end of my treatment in February 2022 after being on eight tablets a day for 12 months. I want to say a massive thank you to my GP and all the TB nurses and consultants who treated me. But the biggest thank you goes to my wife who nursed me through this terrible disease.


The site is secure.

The ensures that you are connecting to the official website and that any information you provide is encrypted and transmitted securely.


Background: In this age of evidence-based medicine, nothing is more important than the quality of laboratory tests. It is commonly thought that laboratory tests provide two-thirds to three-fourths of the information used for making medical decisions. If so, test results had better tell the truth about what is happening with our patients.


Methods: The age-old "truth standard" for the quality of evidence describes three dimensions that are important-a test should tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth. This three-dimensional model can be used to characterize the clinical and analytical reliability of laboratory tests and guide the translation of outcome criteria, or quality goals, into practical specifications for method performance.


Results: Clinical reliability, or medical usefulness, should assess the correctness of patient classifications based on stated test interpretation guidelines, taking into account the precision and accuracy of the laboratory method, and allowing for the known within-subject biologic variation and the QC needed to detect method instability. Analytical reliability should assess the correctness of a test result based on a stated error limit, taking into account the precision and accuracy of the method and allowing for the QC necessary to detect method instability. These assessments challenge the reliability of current tests for cholesterol, glucose, and glycated hemoglobin in the implementation of U.S. national clinical guidelines.


Conclusions: Evidence-based medicine must employ scientific methodology for translating test interpretation guidelines into practical, bench-level, operating specifications for the imprecision and inaccuracy allowable for a method and the QC necessary to detect method instability.


Before we even set foot in Forensic Polygraph Services Inc., Neil Myres promised to treat us like any other client. So when he retrieved us from the waiting room of his office, tucked into the first floor of a squat, brown brick building about 20 miles west of Detroit, there were no pleasantries.


A number of factors helped assuage Aleo's misgivings. First, since he had hired the polygrapher, the results were protected by attorney-client privilege. If they weren't favorable to the defense, presumably the report would never see the light of day. Also, no charges had yet been filed against the suspect. Aleo was preparing not for a trial in a court of law, but for a nongovernmental administrative hearing conducted by a national licensure organization that was seeking to strip the coach of his credentials.


As the coach was hooked up to equipment that measures an array of physiological reactions, he undoubtedly was nervous. Polygraph is an intrinsically intrusive process that elicits anxiety, apprehension, and unease even if you have nothing to hide.


Since its invention roughly a century ago, polygraph has been a lightning rod of controversy, alternately hailed as a critical law enforcement and even national security tool while simultaneously derided as junk science. As famed defense attorney F. Lee Bailey, who credits his first big break to his knowledge of "The Box," put it in the forward to the bookThe Lie Detector Man, "In some ways the polygraph technique exercises a pervasive influence over legal matters, and in other respects it is branded a bastard child."


So where does the truth lie? The search for it is one of life's most elusive pursuits. But in his case, Aleo thinks he found it. His client steadfastly maintained his innocence, and the results of his polygraph showed that, according to the examiner, he was 99 percent likely to be telling the truth. When Aleo submitted the test to the national licensure organization, which had revealed little about the evidence it had amassed, its reaction was swift.


"They produced a whole lot of stuff, including investigatory notes, that I had never seen before," he said. "Based on those notes, we were able to identify witnesses who contradicted things [the alleged victim] said. Had we not done the polygraph I don't think we would have gotten that."


"Am I going to tell you that polygraph's all things to all people at all times about all issues?" said Myres, president of the Michigan Association of Polygraph Examiners. "No. It's not a magic eight ball, it's not an Ouija board, it's not black magic voodoo science, it's straight-up forensic psycho-physiological detection of deception, which is a whole lot of long words, but in a nutshell it's personal knowledge."


In 1000 BC, the Chinese ordered accused liars to fill their mouths with a handful of dry rice. If it was still dry when they spit it out, they were guilty of fraud (the logic being that fear and anxiety are accompanied by decreased salivation). During the Middle Ages, the accused placed their hands in a cauldron of boiling water; if their skin was unscathed, they were deemed truthful.


A man named William Moulton Marston, whose own story took many twists and turns, including a stint at AU, picked up where Lombroso left off. A Harvard-trained psychologist and lawyer, Marston was commissioned by the US government to develop a method for questioning German prisoners during World War I. Although his systolic blood pressure test was only a slight improvement on Lombroso's glove, it would become the predecessor to the modern polygraph.


Marston landed a professorship at AU in 1922, teaching psycho-physiology and legal psychology. Fascinated by the theory that women are the more honest sex, he and his wife, Elizabeth, conducted a series of experiments in Hurst Hall that indicated men were less reliable jurors. "They were more careful, more conscientious, and gave much more impartial consideration to all the testimony than did the male jurors," he wrote.


His tenure at AU was brief. In 1923, Marston was fired after being arrested for fraud, although charges were later dropped. Like his time at AU, his appointments at Tufts, NYU, and Columbia never seemed to last more than a year. It's thought that his scandalous family life tarnished his reputation in academic circles. (Marston lived with both his wife and his mistress, Olive Byrne, Margaret Sanger's niece and aFamily Circle columnist.)


On November 25, 1920, James Frye shot and killed wealthy physician Robert Brown in the doctor's Washington, DC, home where he'd gathered with friends to celebrate Howard University's football victory. Seven months after the murder, when Frye was arrested on an unrelated robbery charge, he confessed to the killing. Shortly thereafter he withdrew his confession on the advice of his attorney, Richard Mattingly, a salesman by day and AU grad student by night. Marston was brought in to administer a polygraph; as he writes in his 1938 book,The Lie Detector Test: "No one could have been more surprised than myself to find that Frye's final story of innocence was entirely truthful!"


Despite dropping out of school in the sixth grade, Vollmer became one of the most influential figures in American policing. As chief of California's Berkeley Police Department he professionalized the force, recruiting college grads and requiring IQ tests. He was the first to put cops on bikes, in squad cars, and to equip those vehicles with a brand new technology: two-way radios. Vollmer also ushered in the era of forensic science.


In 1923, Vollmer's protg took on a pupil of his own. Leonarde Keeler was a psychology student, amateur magician, entrepreneur (he ran a snake "milking" farm, selling the venom for anti-bite serums), and Larson's foil. In his book The Lie Detectors, Northwestern University history professor Ken Alder calls Keeler and Larson "Vollmer's delinquent sons," each competing to control the future of the polygraph. It was a battle Keeler would ultimately win.


When Vollmer set eyes on Keeler's third-generation instrument, now called an emotograph, he said it looked like "a crazy conglomerate of wires, tubes, and old tomato cans." The machine was destroyed in a fire at Keeler's house in 1924; when it rose from the ashes, he renamed it the polygraph.


Eighty-two years after Keeler took the stand in the Badger State, polygraph evidence is banned in approximately 30 states according to Elizabeth Lippy, assistant director of the Stephen S. Weinstein Trial Advocacy Program at AU's Washington College of Law. Other states potentially allow polygraph evidence by stipulation if both the prosecution and the defense agree, and a few states allow it outright. New Mexico is the most liberal.


"There are anomalies. The only thing that is 100 percent is death, everything else is gray," Myres said. "[But] if I crack your knee with a rubber mallet you're going to get a reflex. I could tell you to keep it still and I'll give you a million bucks, but you're not keeping it still. That's physiological. Our central nervous system is split in half. We control the side that includes our words, so if we choose, we can be deceptive. But we can't control the autonomic side. Polygraphs are a blending of what you know and what you can't control."

3a8082e126
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages