Refuting Wikipedia Misinformation about CQ

74 views
Skip to first unread message

David J. J. Ring, Jr.

unread,
Sep 8, 2023, 1:00:58 AM9/8/23
to Radio Officers Google Group
The Mystery of the Origin of CQ becomes clearer. We now have a citation from 1884 stating that CQ is "All Stations"and NOT "Seek You" or any of the revisionist nonsense from Wikipedia. CQ was never a solicitation outside of it's use in amateur radio. In commercial telegraphy it was always an address - "All Stations". The other related signal was "CP" which is a Restricted call - to Certain Stations only.  RCA's Sam Francisco Radio/KPH famously used this correctly when they sent out their nightly PX (Press) for Subscribers - it wasn't addressed to you unless you paid for a subscription!

Excellent, excellent find. Bill Burns Atlantic Cable Historian comes to the rescue!  https://atlantic-cable.com/ Absolutely brilliant research work.

I got the link in the the docx file you sent me to work and got this from that link in addition to what was in the docx file.  The link goes to The Telegraphist. Ed. by W. Lynd Volume I December 1883 to November 1884. 

The reference is on page 119.

The alphabet for Bain's printing was not like the one now in use for Morse. When the Electric Telegraph Company agreed to adopt the international alphabet, notice was given to CQ (all stations) to prepare for the change, and from a fixed date to abandon the one and adopt the other.

Bill Burns, your docx file converted to PDF is attached. What excellent work.

Those citations from the 19th Century clearly establish that CQ is a station call "To All Stations" even if they are mute on why "CQ" was chosen.  Maybe it has something to do with Berne Switzerland.

This most certainly refutes the historical negationism, a form of historical revisionism. Taking a new story and applying it to years ago history as if it was true. 

Wikipedia is now saying "CQ" came from "C'est qui" - French for "Who is it!" but of course this makes no sense if CQ is used as it is to mean "Calling All Stations" as it has been for over a  century. They also are saying that it means "Seek You!" which I blame the radio amateurs for because that's the way they use "CQ". As you can tell, I dislike historical revisionism.

Here's the misinformation from Wikipedia:  It's a mixture of true and falsehoods.  Just like those clever gremlins who propagate the Sovereign Citizen nonsense that the USA is a Corporation and that a gold fringed flag is an Admiralty Flag nonsense.

The CQ call was[2] originally used by landline telegraphy operators in the United Kingdom. French was, and still is, the official language for international postal services,[3] and the word sécurité was used to mean "safety" or "pay attention". It is still used in this sense in international telecommunications.[4][5] The letters CQ, when pronounced in French, resemble the first two syllables of sécurité, and were therefore used as shorthand for the word. It sounds also like the French "c'est qui?", which means "who's there?". In English-speaking countries, the origin of the abbreviation was popularly changed to the phrase "seek you" or, later, when used in the CQD distress call, "Calling all distress".

CQ was adopted by the Marconi Company in 1904 for use in wireless telegraphy by spark-gap transmitter, and was adopted internationally at the 1912 London International Radiotelegraph Convention, and is still used.[6]

A variant of the CQ call, CQD, was the first code used as a distress signal. It was proposed by the Marconi Company and adopted in 1904, but was replaced between 1906 and 1908 by the SOS code. When the Titanic sank in 1912, it initially transmitted the distress call "CQD DE MGY" (with "MGY" being the ship's call sign). Titanic's radio operator subsequently alternated between SOS and CQD calls afterwards.[

Bravo!

73
DR
N1EA

Virus-free.www.avast.com
Origins of CQ.pdf
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages