USA Radio-O Proposes older categories to the world

12 views
Skip to first unread message

Joseph Huberman

unread,
Jun 28, 2025, 9:53:50 PM6/28/25
to Radio USA, Bok-radio O
The Radio-O Committee had drafted a proposal to change the Region 1 rules to add the categories W75 and M80.  As you know, Region 1 rules are used for the World Champs.

I have sent the proposal (below) to as many leaders of the ARDF groups around the world as I could find.  If you have any international ARDF friends, please forward this to them.

Here is a link to the proposal if you prefer google docs

Joseph Huberman
image.png
.Proposal to Add W75 and M80 ARDF Categories 

American Radio Relay League (ARRL)
ARRL Radio Orienteering Committee

To the IARU Region 1 ARDF Working Group,

The ARRL Radio Orienteering Committee respectfully requests the addition of new age group categories W75 and M80 to our competitive framework. (Proposed changes to IARU Region 1 ARDF Rules 15.2, 20.7 and 28 are included below.)

Veteran ARDF athletes continue to train and compete actively, demonstrating a strong desire to participate in the sport they love. By embracing these new categories, we not only prioritize their well-being, we also acknowledge their dedication and commitment to amateur radio. In recent years, radio orienteering in the USA has grown significantly, thanks to the dedication of veterans. Their hard work has attracted youth to our sport. With these categories, we can provide these veterans with greater incentives to continue developing ARDF around the world.

Currently, athletes aged 75 and older (women) and 80 and older (men) are compelled to compete in the W65 and M70 categories, respectively. The competitors whose teams don’t have spaces in the W65 and M70 categories are unable to compete in the World Championships.  Competitors on teams with space in the W65 and M70 categories are undertaking courses and competing against significantly younger competitors on courses designed for the younger individuals. By competing in these more rigorous categories, our older participants are exposed to greater risk, not less.

We understand the Working Group's concerns regarding the safety of older participants, specifically the concern that introducing these categories might increase risk. But, in fact, the opposite is true. Establishing these new age groups will enhance safety, fairness, and increase the competitive opportunity for our most experienced competitors and allow the sport to retain their knowledge and ongoing contributions within the sporting community

Including these categories brings ARDF in line with other international sports.  IOF Orienteering events include these older categories.  The IOF masters orienteering categories require W85 and M85 as well as older categories when there are entrants in these categories. (IOF rule WMOC 5.9)  The USA has been including these categories in ARDF as well as our Orienteering National Ranking Events for years without problems.

Introducing W75 and M80 categories will allow for the creation of courses specifically tailored to the physical capabilities and competitive needs of these age groups, and can be accomplished with minimal additional work. This will enable organizers to design less demanding courses, potentially shorter in length, with less climb for these categories, thereby reducing the physical difficulty for these athletes. Furthermore, it will foster a more equitable competitive environment, allowing individuals to compete against peers of similar age and ability. This alignment is crucial for maintaining engagement and motivation among our long-standing participants as well as increasing organizers' revenue at our major events.

Thank you for considering this important matter. The addition of W75 and M80 categories will be a positive step forward for the sport, promoting both safety and fairness for our valued senior participants.

Sincerely,

ARRL Radio Orienteering Committee

Proposed changes to IARU Region 1 ARDF Rules to add categories W75 and M80

15.2  Categories

add…

Women (W)

Age 

Men (M) 

Age

W75

75 and older

M80

80 and older

20.7 Number of transmitters and course lengths assigned to particular categories:

Add …

Category 

number of transmitters 

effective course length

W75

2…3 + finish beacon

3…5km

M80

2…3 + finish beacon

3…5km

28. Transmitters arrangement

28.1 Classic competitions are organised on both the 3,5 MHz and 144 MHz bands simultaneously. Categories are divided into two groups: one group contains categories M19, M21, M40, W19 and W21, the other group contains categories M50, M60, M70, M80, W35, W45, W55 W65 and W75. On the first competition day, one group runs on the 3.5 MHz band and the other group on the 144 MHz band. On the second competition day, the bands are swapped.



Nadia Scharlau

unread,
Jun 29, 2025, 6:56:17 AM6/29/25
to Joseph Huberman, Radio USA, Bok-radio O
I want to suggest making the course length for women 3..4km (effective length). Currently, W55 has a distance of 4-6km, and W65 has a distance of 4-6km. However, because we do not run the same course, it means that W55 runs a maximum of 6km and W65 runs a maximum of 5km. As everybody knows, we do not run straight through the woods and add at least 1 km to the distance. 
Ruth, you will run the same course length as you run now. Is it not too much for you?

Nadia

On Jun 28, 2025, at 9:53 PM, Joseph Huberman <joseph....@gmail.com> wrote:

The Radio-O Committee had drafted a proposal to change the Region 1 rules to add the categories W75 and M80.  As you know, Region 1 rules are used for the World Champs.

I have sent the proposal (below) to as many leaders of the ARDF groups around the world as I could find.  If you have any international ARDF friends, please forward this to them.

Here is a link to the proposal if you prefer google docs

Joseph Huberman

--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Radio Orienteering USA" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to radio-o-usa...@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/radio-o-usa/CAO60M%3DiWrDdnpFmUx33913vg8329qQwKRBAoX5ZeqTh468kZJg%40mail.gmail.com.

Ruth Bromer

unread,
Jun 29, 2025, 7:05:14 AM6/29/25
to Nadia Scharlau, Joseph Huberman, Radio USA, Bok-radio O
Nadia,

I think your course length suggestion makes sense. That fits with what I'm seeing for a short Brown for W70+/M80+ in orienteering.

Ruth 

Joseph Huberman

unread,
Jun 29, 2025, 8:32:15 PM6/29/25
to Ruth Bromer, Nadia Scharlau, Radio USA, Bok-radio O
This suggestion should have been made prior to releasing the document.  In any case I maintained the shortening pattern that existed.  Who knows what the final decisions will be.

Joseph

================================
Joseph Huberman
904 Dorothea Drive
Raleigh, NC 27603

m. (919)610-1788

Charles Scharlau

unread,
Jun 30, 2025, 7:14:11 AM6/30/25
to Joseph Huberman, Ruth Bromer, Nadia Scharlau, Radio USA, Bok-radio O
If Region 1 adopts the recommendation of the ARRL, then they may make some changes to it. I think it is appropriate for its supporters to discuss tweaks to the proposal.
-Charles

Joseph Huberman

unread,
Jun 30, 2025, 8:26:46 AM6/30/25
to Charles Scharlau, Ruth Bromer, Nadia Scharlau, Radio USA, Bok-radio O
Yes, I agree. But let's not start controversy from within right at the start.  We need a united front if we hope to get this passed.
The proposal follows the pattern established in the current category standards.

image.png
       M80                  2...3                              3...5km
       W75                 2...3                              3...5km
Personally, I expect that the primary objections will be trying to add an additional course with the existing 5 transmitters, creating a category that won't have "enough" competition to make an award "valuable".

Joseph

================================
Joseph Huberman
904 Dorothea Drive
Raleigh, NC 27603

m. (919)610-1788

Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages